HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wilsonnb3

2,712 karma · joined August 7, 2018

submissionscomments
wilsonnb3··on Recall: Stealing everything you've ever typed or viewed on your own Windows PC
> I can't speak to all distros out there, but I've never seen a linux system force a restart in the middle of the day.

My point is that there isn’t a technical reason that prevents Linus distros, or any other OS, from restarting your computer whenever it feels like it.

By definition the OS has control of the hardware and software and thus whoever writes the OS inherits that control.

I completely agree that there are good reasons to not trust Microsoft and people who don’t should not be using Windows.

I just dislike the framing of this issue as a recent development rather than an inherent problem of running software you didn’t write.

wilsonnb3··on Linux May Be the Best Way to Avoid the AI Nightmare
> Do you remember when you could put your Mac to sleep, and when you woke it up a few days later, the battery would barely have dropped?

Has the author not used the m series Macs? Standby battery life is the best it has ever been in my time using laptops.

wilsonnb3··on Recall: Stealing everything you've ever typed or viewed on your own Windows PC
> Microsoft can access any file, install any software, change any setting, or remove any access at any time for any reason with no notice or indication to you that it happened. They can even just shutdown your device. Any device which works like that is not one under your control.

Having this power is inherent in making the OS. Whoever is the vendor of your particular Linux distribution has the same powers, it is just that you trust them not to use them (or, in a very small theoretical minority of cases, you’ve audited the code and binaries yourself).

So yes, you shouldn’t use an OS from a vendor you don’t trust, I agree completely.

I don’t understand why people are acting like this is earth shattering news though, this has always been the case since people started using software they didn’t write themselves.

wilsonnb3··on Recall: Stealing everything you've ever typed or viewed on your own Windows PC
Who do you anticipate forcing you to use a computer with this functionality?
wilsonnb3··on How Waymo outlasted the competition and made robo-taxis a real business
For the record Waymo taxis are not limited to highways in Phoenix, not sure about how they operate elsewhere.
wilsonnb3··on Google releases smart watch for kids
> Getting shot by a handgun is not like getting shot by AR-15. Even at the same caliber the muzzle velocity of a modern rifle makes the bullet that much deadlier.

Yeah I should have been more clear about my thoughts on this, my apologies.

Rifle rounds are unquestionably more deadly from a ballistic standpoint but at close range (25 yards or less, just for the sake of hypotheticals), before handgun round velocity falls off enough that they are ineffective, shot placement and how fast you can stop any bleeding matter much more than ballistics.

There aren’t many mass shooting events I can think off where it would have made a big difference if a pistol caliber had been used instead of a rifle caliber - it definitely would in cases like the Las Vegas concert though. That wasn’t an untrained teenager though so it might be outside of the scope of discussion anyways.

> I understand we're dealing with shades of gray here. It's about making a policy tradeoff between how many legitimate uses a weapon type has (for example home defense, farm use, hunting) and how many victims it claims.

Agreed and thank you for your very reasonable response.

wilsonnb3··on Google releases smart watch for kids
I hesitate to wade into these kinds of conversations but a lot of what you wrote is inaccurate.

Shotguns have a limited range compared to rifles but it’s still at least 50 yards so it isn’t going to matter. People hunt deer with them, they aren’t like shotguns in video games. They can also use removable magazines and be as easy to reload as any other semi automatic firearm.

There is not a single difference between a “sniper rifle” and a hunting rifle.

Handguns are not meaningfully less lethal than rifles against unarmed targets at close range. The mass shooting at Virginia tech was one of the worst and was done with handguns.

> Assault rifles are rifles designed for killing humans (as opposed to hunting rifles)

Every type of firearm was designed for killing people. Today’s “hunting rifle” was the standard issue infantry weapon in WWI and WWII. Russia is still arming some soldiers with what you would call a hunting rifle in Ukraine right now.

wilsonnb3··on Kino: Pro Video Camera
Yeah and you can still buy it for a one time $60 purchase if you want.
wilsonnb3··on Google releases smart watch for kids
You can (in fact, I think you have to) get the data plan straight from Google.

Lots of carriers, particularly cheaper MVNOs, don't support LTE watches and even less support the standalone Apple Watch setup.

So in that sense, it is convenient.

wilsonnb3··on Google releases smart watch for kids
It isn't an Android watch, fitbit has their own OS that works with both iOS and Android phones.

Only the Pixel watch uses android.

wilsonnb3··on Google releases smart watch for kids
I don't think it will change much, kids have been sorting themselves into pretend hierarchies based on the cool thing since the dawn of time.

We could send them all to school wearing a potato sack and some of the kids with the whole foods sack would make fun of the kids in the food lion sack.

wilsonnb3··on Google releases smart watch for kids
They've been making the fitbit ace for kids since 2018 and like the previous fitbit ace's, this is just a fitbit versa 4 with a slightly different UI.

So I wouldn't worry them killing these ala the spotify car thing.

wilsonnb3··on Giving Windows total recall of everything a user does is a privacy minefield
> If something like this (with negligible enough compute/storage impacts) could be implemented locally, I would probably buy into it

It is implemented locally

wilsonnb3··on Windows Recall sounds like a privacy nightmare
AMD and Intel powered "Copilot+" PCs are coming in the near future, it is only ARM specific for a little while.
wilsonnb3··on Windows Recall sounds like a privacy nightmare
Should we throw out the browser history too then? And whatever logging your router might be doing.

And probably ban the software you can already install to monitor someone's computer activity.

Isn't this argument just the classic "think of the children" dressed up in new clothes?

wilsonnb3··on Windows Recall sounds like a privacy nightmare
> Microsoft controls this entire process. They could easily send copies back to "the mothership" like they probably already do with the processed results

Microsoft controls the whole operating system, they can already do whatever they want with your data. They could be sending screenshots back to the mother ship already.

I can understand why people may not trust them but they already have the keys to the kingdom. This new feature isn't any more or less private than Windows already is.

wilsonnb3··on Microsoft Paint's new AI image generator builds on your brushstrokes
Microsoft dictates what their software can generate, much in the same way they dictate what colors you can use in paint and what font sizes you can use in word.

You can still generate as much porn or whatever it is you want to generate using other software.

wilsonnb3··on Windows Recall sounds like a privacy nightmare
I do live a charmed life by those standards but my point is that it isn't a privacy issue at all to me.

Storage and processing happens on your device and it is encrypted, so I don't see how this feature makes my information less private at all.

It seems like the actual issue people have is that they don't trust Microsoft or they don't trust the government/people/everyone.

Which is fine and understandable, it just isn't related to privacy.

wilsonnb3··on Windows Recall sounds like a privacy nightmare
You bring up a good point about making previously ephemeral activities recorded, I can see why people would take issue with that.
wilsonnb3··on Windows Recall sounds like a privacy nightmare
Thanks for coming up with a specific scenario for me.

I do agree that the outcomes in this case might be worse than an alternate universe without the recall feature.

That said, if someone steals my laptop and can log in, I am already pretty fucked. There are so many other ways they could get this or other information, from email, calendars, etc.

wilsonnb3··on Windows Recall sounds like a privacy nightmare
Isn't this just a general argument against closed source software and nothing specific about this recall feature?

If you don't trust Microsoft then yeah I can see why you wouldn't want this feature but you probably aren't using Windows in that case anyways, so it is a moot point.

wilsonnb3··on Windows Recall sounds like a privacy nightmare
Just depends on whether you trust Microsoft or not, and I already mentioned in my comment that I understand concerns about the on device part potentially changing in the future.
wilsonnb3··on Windows Recall sounds like a privacy nightmare
Please do go on, I am curious - what exactly is the threat you are seeing here?
wilsonnb3··on Windows Recall sounds like a privacy nightmare
What else should not be allowed because of it possibly being abused?

Should I not be allowed to use a password manager because it would be problematic if my roommate or one night stand copied it?

This isn't fundamentally different to any other feature.

wilsonnb3··on Windows Recall sounds like a privacy nightmare
10th, 11th, or 12th depending on how you count.

It's also the third one that is just called "surface pro", along with the firs generation and fifth generation devices.

wilsonnb3··on Windows Recall sounds like a privacy nightmare
> Strange that Microsoft is getting into hardware again, you'd think they'd have learned their lesson by now

They've been making surface devices for a decade, I am not sure what you mean by "again".

As for performance, there is a reason the feature is limited to laptops with 16 gigs of RAM or more and a dedicated NPU of a certain speed. I dont think there will be performance issues when they are controlling the hardware spec that tightly.

wilsonnb3··on Windows Recall sounds like a privacy nightmare
I don't understand why people have such a big privacy issue with this. It all happens on your device.

I understand being concerned about Microsoft using it to target ads or moving it off device in the future But the four scenarios laid out in the article don't seem like a problem.

> You're using a public computer

> You're using a work computer

> You're using a shared family computer without a password protected profile

> Your computer gets stolen

You shouldn't expect privacy on public or work computers. For all you know, they could already be doing this.

Ditto for a PC where you share an account with other people.

And if your laptop is stolen and they have your passwords, you're fucked anyways.

wilsonnb3··on Microsoft Phi-3 Cookbook
no it doesn't, at least not according to the specs https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/surface/devices/surface-lapt...

The Surface Pro has an OLED config now, which costs more, but the laptop and standard pro are still LCD.

wilsonnb3··on Introducing Copilot+ PCs
> Legacy software is why we still use windows. There is nothing better about windows than say, Fedora.

Except, of course, the legacy software support.

wilsonnb3··on Introducing Copilot+ PCs
Lenovo has been selling a Qualcomm laptop, the Thinkpad x13s, for several years already with questionable at best Linux support so I wouldn't expect the new ones to be much better.
← PreviousPage 8 of 32Next →