HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wilsonnb

404 karma · joined January 8, 2018

submissionscomments
wilsonnb··on Sci Hub repository torrents of scientific papers
At the end of the day, researchers need some way to decide which papers they should read and which they shouldn't. There are too many papers coming out for anyone to read them all. The fact that prestigious journals have a vested interest in not printing crap papers is a helpful filter when deciding what to read.

I still think there should be some reform in this area but the journals do provide some value at the moment.

wilsonnb··on Getting 1Password 7 ready for the Mac App Store
There was plenty of demand for a "1password cloud" as you call it. It's one of my favorite features.

I like that I don't need a Dropbox, Google Drive, iCloud, OneDrive, etc. subscription for 1Password to work. It's convenient.

wilsonnb··on Getting 1Password 7 ready for the Mac App Store
It's become a big thing because it's convenient. Every time I sign into 1Password on any of my devices, all of my passwords are there. I don't need an account with Google, Dropbox, or Microsoft for it to work and I don't need to do any manual setup. It "just works", which is exactly what the average person wants their software to do.

Manually dealing with files is a sign of poor software design for simple use cases, in my opinion. I quite like the iOS model that abstracts the idea of a filesystem away from the user because the user never cared about the file system anyways. They just had to deal with it to do whatever they really wanted to do.

wilsonnb··on Google de-emphasizes 'Don't Be Evil' motto in its code of conduct
You can't just declare that humans have a right to know if they are talking to another human or a machine. That's just restating what you already said. You have to justify why humans should have that right.
wilsonnb··on Jim Black's Steve Jobs Story
Jobs was not deeply technical.

If I remember correctly, Steve Jobs got hired at Atari because he showed them a board for some arcade game that Steve Wozniak had designed and conveniently forgot to tell them that he didn't actually design the thing.

I also think I read that Steve Jobs lied to Woz about how much Atari paid him for it so he could cheat Woz out of the money.

I'm pretty sure I read about this in a book called "The Ultimate History of Video Games". [1]

[1] https://www.amazon.com/Ultimate-History-Video-Games-Pokemon/...

wilsonnb··on GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU
The Equifax breach was already illegal - I assume you mean you think that websites shouldn't keep user information to prevent future data breaches.

This is a bad solution to that problem. So many people's data was stolen that preventing future data from being stolen isn't the most important thing we should be doing. Last I heard it was 150 million people - that's enough that it no longer really matters to the average person if their data is leaked in the future because there's such a high change it already has.

The real solution is to change our systems so that data leaks aren't a big deal. If people didn't ask for a 9 digit number to identify me, as if that's a reasonable thing to keep secret, then it wouldn't matter if everyone in the world knew it. That's the problem with data breaches like this. That's what we should be fixing in response to it.

wilsonnb··on GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU
The laws you talk about are, I think, laws about stalking. I'm not aware of any laws that apply to that kind of thing if it happens on a massive scale. Singling someone out is an important part of stalking.

Keeping detailed information about everyone that enters your store isn't illegal, as far as I know. Especially not information that is gained from observation (what color shirt they're wearing, their IP address) and information that is submitted willingly (their name given for a reservation at a restaurant, their username).

wilsonnb··on GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU
Yes, you should be able to do that, unless you are reasonably certain that the information might be used to commit credit card fraud/identity theft.

If you think they might be used illegally, I believe there are already laws to charge you with that relate to facilitating a crime.

If you don't think they will be used illegally, then what's the harm in selling them to someone else?

wilsonnb··on GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU
I wasn't trying to say it was - I was simply saying that when you base an argument on free speech, you don't have to explain why free speech is a good thing because it's generally accepted by everyone to be a good thing.

In this case, a lot of people base their argument on a fundamental right to privacy which is not generally accepted by everyone and therefore it has to be explained because it's an important part of the discussion.

wilsonnb··on GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU
Well whoever took the picture is the one that holds the copyright usually so it's more or less that person's data.

Pictures probably aren't a good example because they are covered by intellectual property laws.

wilsonnb··on GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU
It can be a privacy violation but the idea of a fundamental right to privacy is not universally supported like free speech.

If it is a fundamental right, how far does it go? Should I be able to sue you for watching me walk in a public place? Photographing me? Video taping me? What about a privately owned but still public place?

There are a lot of questions here that I think people tend to skip over about users owning information about them and being able to control it.

wilsonnb··on GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU
Why not? I have yet to see anyone arguing for data protection legislation actually give a reason that they think a users data belongs to the user.
wilsonnb··on Michael Pollan reluctantly embraces the 'new science' of psychedelics
There's nothing wrong with "playing with your own hypothesis-space" as you put it, but it's stupid to believe in something without any proof that it might be true.

It's fine to think "what if god created the universe" or "what if we're living inside a giant space beaver" or "what if there is another fundamental force responsible for consciousness that we can't measure" but unless you actually have some evidence or reasoning that points in that direction, they are all stupid theories compared to materialism which actually fits into the current scientific world view pretty well.

wilsonnb··on An Alphabet X concept from 2016 is an unsettling vision of social engineering
A better reason not to fear the singularity is because it a science fiction concept that's connections to the real world are tenuous at best.

Anyways, I think the fear most people have is either that the AI would be far better at doing these bad things to humans than humans are (which you allude to in your comment), or they always envision themselves on the "good guys" side in human vs human conflict and don't have that comfort when it comes to AI vs human conflict.

Those fears seem valid to me if you believe in the underlying premise.

wilsonnb··on An Alphabet X concept from 2016 is an unsettling vision of social engineering
I really don't care if I'm talking to a person or a robot. Anonymous social interactions that are required to achieve an unrelated goal are a waste of time. I truly believe that my time is not worth talking to a human to set up an appointment that could have been set up in much less time if I could interact with a computer instead, nor is that worth anyone else's time.

In many cases, I'm never going to see the person I'm talking to. We won't discuss anything other than the details of the appointment I want to schedule. For all intents and purposes they are no different than a computer to me.

I understand why people would want to keep meaningful anonymous social interactions, like conversing with strangers on a bus (or on the internet!), around but I fail to see why anyone cares if we get rid of meaningless ones.

wilsonnb··on College May Not Be Worth It Anymore
To be fair, this is from the opinion section. It's not news. Most of the articles you are talking about are probably opinion pieces as well.

I do think they should do more to differentiate between news and opinion pieces.

wilsonnb··on Ask HN: Tips on coping with my quarter-life crisis
I don't see why death should have no bearing on the decision if the risk of death in each situation is different.
wilsonnb··on US cell carriers are selling access to real-time phone location data
At that point, what's to stop them from forcing me to present myself at the interrogation booth anyways? Does it matter if they have data "proving" that I've done something wrong, or if they just make it up?
wilsonnb··on US cell carriers are selling access to real-time phone location data
I guess my view of the situation is that the massive collection of data only becomes a problem in situations where we can absolutely not trust our government, and if things get that bad then we have much bigger problems than the government having a lot of data about us. At that point they don't need evidence of wrongdoing to drag people into the street and shoot them, so it doesn't matter to me if they have it.
wilsonnb··on Musk, Zuckerberg, Bezos, and Ethically Iffy ‘Philanthropy'
I'm not sure I understand what you mean. I do understand people incorporating their friends and family into their identity but I'm not sure how that logic would extend to people that don't exist (yet).

What you're saying seems to be an explanation of why people care about the future. I'm looking more for an argument about why people should care about the future.

I hope that makes sense. Regardless, I've enjoyed your comments to so far. I appreciate you taking the time to write them.

wilsonnb··on Musk, Zuckerberg, Bezos, and Ethically Iffy ‘Philanthropy'
I do value my own life, because it already exists. I also value other life that also exists. I do not value future life that does not exist. Future life and current life seem very different to me.

Putting your billions towards the long view seems to require you not putting your billions towards the short view. The short view is the one that affects those who are already alive so that seems like a better option to me.

wilsonnb··on Ask HN: Tips on coping with my quarter-life crisis
I mean, more young people probably die skiing than sitting in an office.
wilsonnb··on Ask HN: Tips on coping with my quarter-life crisis
I'm only 23 but I think about leaving the tech field every day. I have also been depressed (not sure if I would say clinically depressed, but depressed) for a while now.

The only advice I have to give is that most bad things aren't as bad as we think they will be and most good things aren't as good as we think they will be.

You'll find plenty of reasons to become a ski instructor and plenty of reasons to take a 9-5 job, along with even more reasons not to do both. If you can find a way to relieve the pressure of making the "right" choice, it will be easier to make a good choice. Which, realistically, is probably either!

I'm not sure if that will help but I really hope that you enjoy your life, regardless of what you decide.

wilsonnb··on Musk, Zuckerberg, Bezos, and Ethically Iffy ‘Philanthropy'
I think that the idea of technology saving us from our inherent natural tendencies is nice to think about but ultimately naive.
wilsonnb··on Musk, Zuckerberg, Bezos, and Ethically Iffy ‘Philanthropy'
Conversely, why should I care about the trillions of people here after I die? Why should I care if humanity dies in it's birthplace or spreads across the universe like a virus?

To me, a future with a trillion happy people is not better than a future with a million happy people just because there are more happy people. Life has no inherent value that makes me consider it worth spreading.

wilsonnb··on Senate votes to reinstate net neutrality
The difference here is that you are guessing as to what might happen.

We know that some people without access to medical care will die. You're saying it's okay to gamble those people's lives on the chance that future lives might be saved. Obviously a balance between spending on research and health care must be struck so this isn't a black and white issue but you would need to put forth a pretty convincing argument that a lack of net neutrality would prevent us from saving billions for me to buy that.

For the record, I do not support single issue voting at all. There is no issue that outweighs the others.

I also think the idea that someone who was going to vote based on a single issue would choose something as trivial as net neutrality is particularly ridiculous when there are so many other issues where life hangs in the balance.

wilsonnb··on Senate votes to reinstate net neutrality
Some people's ideas of what's important are stupid. Everyone has the right to an opinion but that doesn't mean we should treat every opinion as equal.

If someone was going to vote on the single issue of whether or not we should make it illegal to have more than 17,000,000 butterflies in a room smaller than 100'x100' I would have no problem telling them that their pet issue is stupid and there are other things they should care about more.

I don't see why that principle shouldn't hold for other issues. Obviously net neutrality is something we should be concerned about but a single issue voter says it's the only thing we should be concerned about. That's just not true.

If we elect a government who reinstates net neutrality and proceeds to immediately launch a nuclear missile at Moscow, will the 20 minutes that half of the US population got to enjoy net neutrality matter?

wilsonnb··on Senate votes to reinstate net neutrality
I'm not a foreigner and I think the comment you're responding to is spot on.

Are we just supposed to pretend that all issues are equal? People aren't going to die because the nets aren't neutral. People are going to die based on our health care policy, whether we go to war, whether we can prevent nuclear proliferation.

The author of the comment you call patronizing made no statement on whether or not he's happy that people are involved in the political process. I know I'm happy about it, but I also think single issue voting on net neutrality is stupid. These views are not linked.

In summary, net neutrality is important but there are more important issues in America at the moment. It's not patronizing to point that out.

wilsonnb··on US cell carriers are selling access to real-time phone location data
It's possible that they care about the aggregated data and not about the individual data.
wilsonnb··on US cell carriers are selling access to real-time phone location data
I'm not the person you're asking this question to, but I thought I'd reply anyways.

No, it doesn't really bother me. Why would anyone care that I get up around 7AM on weekdays, drive to work around 9, stay there until 5, and then drive home?

On weekends they will see me going to Target and the grocery store. Sometimes another store. Sometimes I go to visit my family in another city.

I really don't care if people have that information. Many people (not me) post that information freely on Facebook, Instagram, or Twitter.

There are some future situations in which I might care that I am being tracked. If that were the case, it's highly unlikely I would bring a phone with me.

Would I prefer not to be tracked? Probably. Does it bother me that I am being tracked? Nope.

I suspect these views line up with the majority of people in the US.

← PreviousPage 3 of 11Next →