324 karma · joined September 3, 2010
until 1900: A dollar represented a weight of gold and silver 1900: $20.67 / oz gold 1933: $35 / oz gold (internationally only, domestically it was just a piece of paper) 1971: (outside of the 70 year range) USD represents only the full faith and credit of the USG
So observing that a coke cost a nickel throughout that period is interesting - but the dollar isn't really a static denominator of value over time that it might appear to be. Certainly using basket of goods is necessary after 1971 because since 1971 a dollar is nothing more than an idea in people's heads. It has no guaranteed exchangability for something (real) from the currency issuer, it's value is only derived from what other people are willing to exchange it for that day.
The fixed price syrup story is interesting though - just goes to show how a different mindset on the inflation risks of the currency were back then.
Interesting. I've asked my grandma how she saved given she was in the USD=42oz period but her response was we never had enough to save (postwar period really). My mum would rather believe a nobel prize winner rather than me :) As with evertthing, views on these matters depend on ones life experience.
>> impossible to do at the volume I need
Ha! a good problem to have!
>>if trading stopped tomorrow, it could not settle and there would be huge defaults
Exactly right! but if you trade in comex futures then you are still trading in paper - albeit paper gold. When the musical chairs stop then those holding the real physical metal will be ok imho. I don't want to be a christian missionary trying to convert but you may find the concept of freegold and the fofoa blog worth a read. In a nutshell, freegold is about thinking through the transition when the USD/paper gold market collapses and looking at what the giant players (central banks) are doing. If you subscribe to that theory then there are some good arguments why there would be no tax on gold in the future (a black market would arise to ship the gold to any region where it is not taxed). YMMV.
Some history for you: A USD until 1971 represented a thing. It was redeemable for a specific weight of gold. After Nixon shock it become a concept. It is now only backed by the 'idea' that someone will exchange their goods or services in the future for the paper you hold - or the full faith and credit of the USG if you prefer. The value of the USD is only in the prices placed on the goods. If someone refuses to trade an item with you for your USD then what value is the dollar? If you also read up on Triffin's Dilemma, you will understand why the US must run a perpetual trade deficit - to provide lubricating dollars for world trade. So there are many many many more dollars in circulation than can lay claim to physical goods in this world. Eventually all paper money returns to its intrinsic value (Voltaire!). When it happens to the USD, it's going to be a doozy!
Agree on your criticism of my loose word of the term saves. I don't agree with your reasons on why people don't buy gold though - most would have no idea what spread is and how it works. From my experience of trying to convince my friends and family to save something in gold - they just find the idea totally foreign of buying a metal that doesn't earn income...even if said income is not keeping up with inflation.
Interesting perspective on the boxes. I only have one so don't know about increasing/decreasing availability - I know there is a waiting list for the ones at my bank in the city. I find the price very reasonable for the value I obtain from it (150/year).
So what are your thoughts on storing that apartment cash then? I am a goldbug but am interested in other thoughts on preservation of purchasing power.
As an aside I wonder what percentage of the population had boxes back then - compared to now. I mean no one I know has them now - almost everyone saves in currency/stocks etc.
Why so anti gold then if you are aware of the perils of saving in currency. Silverbug? :)
2) Coins from a reputable mint are pretty easy. The tungsten forgeries are only cost effective for the bigger bars
3) If you purchase coins then they can be redeemed for the currency of the day at under the radar levels. I don't see why I should pay tax when trying to preserve purchasing power of my savings.
Money wasn't meant to be saved. Earn and pay your bills in the monetary plane. Save your surplus production in the physical plane.
I'd recommend you read some FOFOA http://fofoa.blogspot.com.au/2010/07/debtors-and-savers.html (and all the rest.) If nothing else it will help you see the money system in a different light.
Remember there are three functions of money
1) Unit of account 2) Medium of exchange 3) Store of value
Currency is not a good store of value - it can be printed at will. It does store value over a short time frame but if you were given a box from 1930 that inside held somones life savings from 1930 - would you wish it to be in USDs or gold? Hint: USDs is the wrong answer! Currency is an excellent medium of exchange. You can buy food at the supermarket with it. Just don't save your surplus wealth in it.
Gold is used as a store of value instead of orange juice concentrate since it has historical value, it is fungible, divisible and inert (ie: it won't spoil). Also you are not impinging on the economy by hoarding it as a store of value since it has relatively little utility otherwise.
If you think gold is not valuable because you cannot excahnge it for food, then ask yourself why the US Government banned its ownership in 1933 for citizens and why the Euro has it as its number one asset on its consolidated financial statement - above all currencies - including USD http://www.ecb.int/press/pr/wfs/2011/html/fs110706.en.html
surprised at all the 'no this is actually quote ok' arguments. you can't print value out of thin air. you only print volume which taxes the holders of existing USD.
"Bitcoin does not have a central bank capable of printing and lending bitcoins"
>>I rather think thats the point. Lending is inflationary.
"Built in Deflation"
>> God knows how the computer industry makes money when if i hold my $$$ just a little longer, i can buy an even better machine.
"For Bitcoin to work as a currency, it would have to act as a predictable store of value"
>>No, currency does not have to store value. The USD is a terrible store of value. Gold is a store of value. Govt paper is not.
" That's called a bank run, and for obvious reasons we want to avoid them."
>> um - I'm not an expert on bitcoin but there are no banks i thought. your money is in your e-wallet. you dont need a bank to keep your money away from theives. there are no banks with fractional reserve lending that are fragile to a run on deposits
This guy is dunning kruger at its best.
Imagine a puddle waking up one morning and thinking, 'This is an interesting world I find myself in, an interesting hole I find myself in, fits me rather neatly, doesn't it? In fact it fits me staggeringly well, must have been made to have me in it!' This is such a powerful idea that as the sun rises in the sky and the air heats up and as, gradually, the puddle gets smaller and smaller, it's still frantically hanging on to the notion that everything's going to be alright, because this world was meant to have him in it, was built to have him in it; so the moment he disappears catches him rather by surprise. I think this may be something we need to be on the watch out for.'