HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wissler

1,092 karma · joined March 13, 2012

"In [corporate] religions as in others, the heretic must be cast out not because of the probability that he is wrong but because of the possibility that he is right." - Edsger W. Dijkstra
submissionscomments
wissler··on Fukushima leak is 'much worse than we were led to believe'
I explicitly stated that a libertarian case could be made for regulating nuclear power, on the grounds that it constitutes a threat. Is there a reason you're choosing to ignore that fact?

"I reject the implication that government regulation is an attack of any kind."

It critically depends on the meaning of "regulation". If by "regulation" we mean "prove to us that your nuclear power is safe", then as I said, there can be a moral case for that, given the threat of meltdown. But if you mean "don't smoke that plant that's been growing on Earth for millions of years, and we'll send in a SWAT team if you disobey", then that kind of regulation is a crime against humanity.

So, you need to be clear here. Bandying about the term "regulation" is just not good enough.

wissler··on Fukushima leak is 'much worse than we were led to believe'
Whether most agree or disagree is irrelevant. It is immoral to attack someone who has not attacked or threatened you. It is likewise immoral to advocate attacking innocents. Take that how you will.

Nuclear power is a special case since it arguably represents a threat, even libertarians would argue that it should be "regulated", in the sense of being required to prove that it's safe. Part of proving safety is by being able to obtain private insurance from a reputable insurer, which is precisely contrary to the non-libertarian solution of just having the government say "just trust us, the nuclear power is fine, and besides, it helps us build nuclear weapons."

wissler··on Fukushima leak is 'much worse than we were led to believe'
I think you're confused.

Actually, you're just misinformed, e.g. read this:

http://www.cato.org/publications/policy-analysis/priceanders...

wissler··on Fukushima leak is 'much worse than we were led to believe'
"I think there are similarities between the nuclear power debate and the GMO debate. In both case, I think it's stupid to be fundamentally opposed to the technology/research itself. But in both case, the industry is so fucked up (lies, too close ties with control authority, ...) that I don't trust them at all."

If you look around you'll find a lot more examples than these two, and you'll trace the root cause as illegitimate use of government force, i.e. use or threat of violence for what is simply peaceful activity.

If someone threatens you with violence, "for your own good", you tend not to trust. But for some reason, when government does this very same thing, most people still trust it. It's like how children still trust parents even though the parents might restrain or even spank them (and this makes good evolutionary sense), but the difference is that the government is not your parent, it does not actually have a concern for you as an individual, it doesn't love you. It is a collection of strangers with their own agendas.

Somehow, government has figured out how to not only co-opt this evolutionary circuitry that was meant for trusting parents at a time when the child really doesn't know what's good for him, and what's more, extend this infantile frame of mind beyond childhood.

All of this recent NSA stuff is just getting toward the final consequences of allowing yourself to adopt such a childish frame of mind. The government has no more right to take a threatening or coercive action against innocent people than any stranger does.

wissler··on Bradley Manning's Post-Sentencing Statement
Lex malla, lex nulla.
wissler··on 'Sending a message': what the US and UK are attempting to do
When you were a child, would any of you have believed that one day in the early 21st century, you would wake up in a world where your own government spies on each and every single citizen...

A child with a proper education in history would not have been surprised. Nor would a child with a proper education think it was perfectly fine to have the institution of government so intrusively involved with the education of children.

wissler··on On Hyperloop
You're the one who can't use words properly. A "gap" is a generic term, an "airtight gap" is a type of "gap."

You're quibbling about words, you're on the wrong side of the quibble, and on top of all that, you're not even dealing with the main point I brought up.

Please tell me you're not a programmer.

wissler··on White House Had Advance Notice on Heathrow Detention
Consistency across scales of abstraction, amazingly rare...
wissler··on White House Had Advance Notice on Heathrow Detention
So, it's good to think differently than you and challenge your pre-existing assumptions, but just not regarding when to downvote? ;)
wissler··on White House Had Advance Notice on Heathrow Detention
The reason to downvote you is not because your rationale is necessarily "illogical", but because 1) it's speculation, and 2) it's better to spend your speculative effort defending and supporting the good guys than the bad guys.
wissler··on On Hyperloop
Your trifling quibbles don't matter. It doesn't matter what you call it or how you implement it, my original point stands. The Dr. is suffering from a lack of imagination.
wissler··on On Hyperloop
Because the tube must be maintained at a near-vacuum, it can't be "gaps" -- it would have to be expanding slip joints

Well you're doing to me what the Dr. is doing to Musk. Obviously they'd have to be airtight, but there would indeed be gaps between the sections. Jesus.

wissler··on On Hyperloop
I am no expert on such things, but it seems to me that Dr. Drang has a very basic misunderstanding or lack of imagination. He seems to assume that Musk intended for each section of tube to physically be touching, when instead Musk intended to leave gaps between, to account for the expansion.
wissler··on On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs
It's not economic at all, it's political (whether it is intentional or not is a different question). In evidence is all the violence that is brought to bear in sustaining the current economic status quo (i.e. the piles of regulations and laws).
wissler··on Why does this Java program terminate despite appearing that it shouldn't?
Side question: with $12M of equipment, wouldn't it make sense to have an independent limiter of some kind to prevent damage? Is there something about this equipment that makes that greater than $12M in difficulty? Because relying on having no bugs just so your hardware isn't destroyed seems like a bad idea...
wissler··on How Your Brain Becomes Addicted to Caffeine
Why quit cold turkey and invite suffering, when all you have to do is reduce your intake over time?
wissler··on SWAT-Team Nation: The Militarization of the U.S. Police
Exactly -- the police screw up and the judges let them off the hook, while if a citizen makes an equivalent error he's convicted of murder and sent away for life.
wissler··on Lavabit abruptly shuts down
People aren't using the first amendment while they can -- and by that I mean that they 1) do not engage each other on politics nearly enough; 2) when they do, they are generally not very honest or rational.

In short -- on average and with exceptions, we deserve what we are getting.

wissler··on Keep Your Identity Small (2009)
He's right that people think they can have an opinion on politics or religion without actually knowing anything, but this is something they are taught to believe in school and church. It's a result of widespread poor upbringing and education, it's not an issue of "keeping your identity small".
wissler··on IRS manual detailed DEA's use of hidden intel evidence
1) What does that have to do with the subject at hand?

2) Citation?

wissler··on IRS manual detailed DEA's use of hidden intel evidence
"He that would make his own liberty secure, must guard even his enemy from oppression; for if he violates this duty, he establishes a precedent that will reach to himself." -- Thomas Paine
wissler··on How to Convince Investors
This is a really fantastic essay, but I was disappointed by this:

The people who are really good at acting formidable often solve this problem by giving investors the impression that while no investors have committed yet, several are about to. This is arguably a permissible tactic.

By engaging in this tactic, you are working to make foolish behavior on the part of the investor successful, which then leads to the very climate that makes the dishonesty so tempting in the first place. It's a vicious cycle.

Why not stick to the "always be 100% honest" approach? This will reform the investor climate over the long-term if the best startups consistently use it, and after all, these best startups are the target of your essay.

I recognize you didn't recommend this approach. But I think you should go one step further and not claim it is arguably acceptable.

wissler··on Can You Keep Your Integrity?
My my, what an unpatriotic attitude.
wissler··on The myth of America's missing software engineers
The trouble with this is that no centralized analysis can determine what "qualified" actually means; only an individual employer can determine that. So if they say there are no qualified engineers then that's the end of discussion.

Having more intelligent people in the US is a good thing.

wissler··on U.S. directs agents to cover up program used to investigate Americans
At some point people need to wake up enough such that they recognize the equivalence of being surprised and being naive, which is an important reason they've trusted government to its own devices for far too long.
wissler··on The world is socialist
I don't see the point of your question. What you consent to is what you consent to. You can consent to just one pizza or you can consent to a succession, it's up to you.
wissler··on Open letter to Sal Khan
It's a good suggestion but his evident premise that "licensed teachers" uniformly do better is either extremely naive or speaks to an agenda on his part.
wissler··on The world is socialist
Well first of all you didn't point any fundamental flaw in reasoning; you engaged in it yourself. Second of all this is just pure ad hominem. On top of that you've failed to respond to the point at hand, i.e. my underscoring of your fallacious mode of reasoning, namely that you can't rationally reject a general method on the grounds that the method didn't spell out all applications for you.
wissler··on The world is socialist
This is actually a very deep question.

To oversimplify, yes, the difference is that you've consented to the rules. Imagine you and your friends decide to order a pizza and agree to vote on the toppings. That's fine. But it's not fine for a friend to force you to pay for the pizza when you didn't agree to do so.

wissler··on The world is socialist
HOA's can be formed based on a premise that democratic procedures govern the creation/modification of new rules.
← PreviousPage 4 of 18Next →