Your tacit premise is: "Since you didn't show me how to solve every problem, then your general solution is false." This is like blaming calculus for not having worked out all possible calculus problems.
1,092 karma · joined March 13, 2012
Your tacit premise is: "Since you didn't show me how to solve every problem, then your general solution is false." This is like blaming calculus for not having worked out all possible calculus problems.
Coming at it from the utilitarian point of view (for sake of argument -- I am not a utilitarian[1]), does it really need to be argued that every humane person should naturally wish to respect individual consent to the fullest extent possible? The only remaining question should be to determine to what extent this is possible. Is there a way to get the road clearing paid for without violating the consent of those who don't care if it's cleared or not?
It turns out that we can form systems whereby this is possible. For example, take a home owners association (HOA). It violates no consent to have contracts that stipulate that you must pay a yearly fee (or "tax") to join the HOA. So there you go, the snowplowing problem is solved, all without any violation of consent.
If you're creative, it turns out that you can solve all of these dilemmas, without resorting to government fiat, which of course can only be implemented by being willing to point a gun at your neighbor's head. No humane person would prefer this, ergo actually humane people would seek more creative solutions.
But on a deeper level, your response equivocates between two entirely different things, i.e. giving an opinion on a board vs. paying for something.
My problem with the OP's opinion wasn't that he was giving his opinion, it was that his opinion was completely arbitrary. Why is it wrong to ask for donations of 1/2 salary for a year? Maybe the OP is jealous, but certainly he has no good reason.
On the other hand, this mail application seems to have good grounds for existing, and their method of funding is just a simple use of the market -- people choosing to buy something if they want it. There's nothing arbitrary about it at all.
People will look at the app for themselves, decide whether it's a good value proposition for them or not. Nobody needs your bitching and moaning; if you don't like it, don't pay anything.
You're just demoralizing people for the sake of it. I'm disgusted that yours is the top ranked comment.
I also never said that "opinionated design is stupid".
Perhaps you could rephrase your question in such a way that you aren't presuming to speak for me.
JSON is code because I use it as code. It's not your business to tell me it's not code -- you haven't seen how I'm using it. And don't go chirping that I should only do things your way, it's none of your god damned business what I'm using it for.
Further, if JSON was really only data, then it's an incredibly stupid way to store data, given that it has a human-readable syntax that the computer can only deal with after it's been parsed. As data, it's bloated and inefficient. To the extent that JSON is a good format, it's code. To the extent that it's data, it's not a good format.
This is horrific design reasoning. It's an authoritarian, presumptuous, "punish everyone in the classroom because one child misbehaves" mentality.
Comments would be useful in JSON because comments are useful in code, and JSON is code. For example, I might have a config file that I'm typing in that I want to leave a documentation trail for.
Don't tell me I can do a silly thing like redefine a field, as if it's "neat". It's an abomination that I have to resort to such things. And guess what: by resorting to such things I can still do precisely what Crockford claims he was trying to prevent. So his rationale is not only insulting to one's intelligence, it's sheer stupidity.
Quite a generalization, but just because you are touchy doesn't mean everyone is.
The problem is when people are taught in an authoritarian manner, and then they run into places that method breaks down, and so throw the baby out with the bathwater. As you have done.
But you make a good point. I think this approach can still work though.
- Rotate the cipher based on the current day/time, or rotate it based on the previous use.
- You could prime the next password each time you successfully login. So e.g. every time you login, you offer 3 additional letters in "clear mode", but then have to give them back in cipher mode.
I think I'd go with the last one.
The worst part about all this is that it requires custom programming.
- Figure out how to add a text filter between DragonDictate and your system.
- Program the filter to look for a special sequence, e.g. "cipher_mode"
- When in cipher mode, feed characters through a simple cipher. E.g. A -> C, B -> D, etc. No passerby is going to be able to figure out what you're doing.
- When the filter sees "cipher_mode" again then it stops filtering.
Being a creative type does not necessarily mean being an engineer.
This strategy will not work at the higher levels of a largish company, ultimately for reasons that would be politically incorrect to point out.
Theories attempt to explain why things happen as they do, observations are statements that something has or has not happened."
You are very confused. The observation is that it appears as if the Sun is moving across the sky. The theory is that that's because the Earth is rotating.
You should be able to work out the rest for yourself.
It's not only presumptuous to say "if someone's not rich, they must not be smart enough to invest", it's a self-fulfilling kind of thing, isn't it?
Nothing prevents people from gambling in Vegas. So clearly these laws are not about protecting fools from their own foolishness. No, the laws are about only one thing: making sure that the people who are in charge of the economic system, stay in charge. And it's not just these SEC laws, there are a wide variety of laws that secure the elite from competition by the peasants.
Whenever someone claims they're keeping you from doing something for your own good, who pretends to be your parent, they really are your master.
Sure it is.
You are not only confused about that, but you're also incredibly arrogant (in that you think you discern dishonest motives with such sparse evidence).
I.e., you are a very confused person.
Also, read Newton's Rules of reasoning for a better example of a philosophy that's successfully been at the base of science.