HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wissler

1,092 karma · joined March 13, 2012

"In [corporate] religions as in others, the heretic must be cast out not because of the probability that he is wrong but because of the possibility that he is right." - Edsger W. Dijkstra
submissionscomments
wissler··on Behind the scenes of the Pirate Bay trial
So, what is to be done?

At root this is a philosophical problem, coming down to what people believe is true or false, good or bad. Now, many people will instinctively react very negatively to this remark -- see my last paragraph.

The US was never on a very firm philosophical base, but it was on an improved philosophical base. The thing is, while this may get an improved government going, unless you fix the philosophy of the culture, it's going to degrade over time.

Our problem is that our institutions, which are funded and therefore controlled by government, do not permit the right kinds of philosophy to flourish, and they promote the wrong kinds.

wissler··on My Father's "Eviscerated" work - Son of J.R.R. Tolkien finally speaks out
I have a hard time seeing how the work was "eviscerated" -- last I checked I could still buy the actual work, i.e. Tolkien's books (which I'm sure got a bump in popularity from the movies).
wissler··on Life and Career Lessons – 2012
It sure is a mistake to label them that way, but that's how they are usually labelled, so making his point this way really makes the point best: it may cause some reflection by the masses who really mislabel. Emphasis on "may".
wissler··on A year without caffeine
If the Mountain Dew was not diet, I'd expect the sugar to make a huge impact on whether you could stay awake.
wissler··on The USPTO Would Like to Partner with the Software Community
Don't sanction the insanity. It would be better that the situation become so dire and painful that the populace wakes up than that software developers actually help make the software patent system appear as if it is reasonable and can "work" in the long run.
wissler··on America's Real Criminal Element: Lead
It's not a market failure, it's a governmental failure, for this reason: if you spew poison into the atmosphere (it was known long before then that lead was poisonous), you should be expected to have to pay for the damages caused. But these companies knew they could get away with it with impunity, and they did. So, it was a governmental failure in the first place, and failure was piled on failure by not addressing the root cause and by increasing the cost of doing business for everyone just because some criminal company notices that the government won't actually punish them.
wissler··on Time to toss the floss
Note: this article is about a substitute for flossing, not simply stopping flossing.
wissler··on Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison
Most laws are intellectually dishonest. Creating a legal code that is so big that it's impossible to know what it is and thus, to be able follow it, is intellectually dishonest. Really, the fundamental basis of our legal system is intellectually dishonest.
wissler··on Basecamp Breeze - Private Email Mailing Lists from 37signals
I thought your statements were insightful and relevant. Some of the the time the HN community is right that somebody is being gratuitously critical or missing the point, but rest of the time they are just touchy and don't want to hear any good criticism.

Apologizing for their unreasonableness only encourages it.

wissler··on Basecamp Breeze - Private Email Mailing Lists from 37signals
For heaven's sake, don't apologize for giving an honest opinion. If we had to apologize every time someone in the world found something to get offended by then half our speech would be apologies for the other half.
wissler··on We Need More Operating Systems
In order to transcend the modern operating system we need to transcend the modern programming language paradigms.
wissler··on Half the Facts You Know Are Probably Wrong
It's not that widely held bogus views turn out to be wrong by accident or from some congenital defect in human reasoning.

Issac Newton's physics, while not applying to all possible contexts, still holds as correct over a vast range, and that's because it's properly identifying an aspect of Nature's behavior, and it did so due to Newton's extreme methodological diligence. Some of these other "facts" that get overturned likely did not adhere to Newton's Rules of Reasoning, or had some other flaw that led people to jump to conclusions prematurely.

Of course, it's exceedingly unpopular to point out that we should learn why we make mistakes and then strive to not make them by scrutinizing the source of the error and adopting better methods. Most people are amenable to having their mistakes pointed out, but are extremely offended if you try to point out that the way they are arriving at conclusions is mistaken. It's as if most people don't want to believe that yes, there is a difference between wisdom and foolishness, and instead want to believe that the highest form of foolishness is in fact to believe in wisdom.

wissler··on Will the New Ethanol Blend Tank My Ride?
To save the environment, we need to use fuel that destroys cars prematurely. Makes sense.
wissler··on Why Workers Are Losing the War Against Machines
E.g., we can't even increase fish farming productivity without massive political interference:

http://www.nature.com/news/transgenic-fish-wins-us-regulator...

wissler··on Why Workers Are Losing the War Against Machines
Those figures by "economists" are woefully, comically limited, they only consider natural resources as determined by current limits of politics and technology, but in fact the whole solar system is rich with natural resources, just waiting for people who actually have imagination (and liberty from the punks who listen to those economists) to begin to capture.
wissler··on Amazon Book Reviews Deleted in Purge Aimed at Manipulation
With so many people willing to contribute reviews, I see no reason to allow either anonymous reviews or reviews from people who have no direct familiarity with the product. Can there be some value from these two sources? Perhaps. But there's a lot more noise generated than value.
wissler··on Why Workers Are Losing the War Against Machines
It's not useful to just say you disagree. You ought to say why.

The fact is that matter is virtually unlimited, and it is not against the laws of physics that we can transform matter into more useful kinds, that we can deploy various means of collecting energy from the sun (even extraterrestrial), that we can learn how to fuse hydrogen, etc.

Edit: I guess you sort of did indicate why you disagreed, but referring to "Club of Rome" is just argument from authority, and anyway their study flies in the face of common sense. We know the Earth is brimming over with energy and resources, that the main difficulty is collecting and transforming them. This is a technological problem not a fundamentally unresolvable problem.

wissler··on Why Workers Are Losing the War Against Machines
Natural resources are virtually unlimited, at least for the current size of the human race. We're only just scratching the surface of the resources available on Earth, and there's a whole solar system we have access to. The only issue is the technology required to transform these resources into something useful, and the "permission" to create and deploy such technology.
wissler··on Why Workers Are Losing the War Against Machines
The root problem is that instead of being able to appropriate resources from nature and produce what we need as individuals directly, we've been corralled into a setup where we have to get permission from government to appropriate and transform raw materials. This is a completely artificial man-made problem, due to various forms of fiat property, one important class being patents, another being government-granted permission for resource extraction (but this is not exhaustive).

It wasn't always so. Early man could claim and transform resources as he needed. Now we are required, on pain of death really (if we try to disobey we will be arrested, if we don't comply with the arrest we will be shot), to either plug into the existing economic structures -- or to starve to death.

wissler··on Congress Is Quietly Abandoning the 5th Amendment
"He that would make his own liberty secure must guard even his enemy from oppression; for if he violates this duty he establishes a precedent that will reach to himself."--Thomas Paine
wissler··on Milton Friedman's Thermostat
This is a subset of David Hume's analysis of causality, see his "An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding."
wissler··on Killed by Homeopathy
You can do a bit better than just trusting it by educating yourself and seeking second or third opinions on treatment.

Medicine isn't a special case, it's just part of the human condition that we haven't fully crossed the threshold from acting like apes to acting like truly civilized people. What makes this worse is when people get all proud of how much we have accomplished, without recognizing how far we yet must go.

wissler··on Killed by Homeopathy
However real medicine has gotten a lot better.

It hasn't gotten better enough. Homeopathy is, in a certain sense, propaganda for modern medicine, because instead of people contrasting modern medicine with what it could and should be, they compare it to something that's obviously worse, and then they feel pleased with themselves for being so smart and become complacent about further improving modern medicine.

wissler··on Killed by Homeopathy
Homeopathy has never kept anyone alive.

I'm sure there are cases where it did, e.g. by virtue of offering something benign in place of something in the mainstream that might have killed.

People are comforted by the thought that modern medicine has completely transcended the barbarity of its own past, but doctors are humans and, on average, are subject to the same kinds of irrationality as everyone else is, and if you're unlucky enough to have to get up close to modern medicine and if you pay attention, you'll see the barbarism very clearly.

wissler··on SpaceX Awarded Two EELV-Class Missions from the United States Air Force
I'm going to guess that you're not privy to their production scalability plans.

The first one is the hardest.

wissler··on 'Everyone in US under virtual surveillance' - NSA whistleblower
Almost everyone is distracted from the main point:

"A declaration of rights is not a creation of them, nor a donation of them. It is a manifest of the principle by which they exist, followed by a detail of what the rights are; for every civil right has a natural right for its foundation, and it includes the principle of a reciprocal guarantee of those rights from man to man. As, therefore, it is impossible to discover any origin of rights otherwise than in the origin of man, it consequently follows, that rights appertain to man in right of his existence only, and must therefore be equal to every man."-- Thomas Paine

wissler··on Julian Assange: Cryptographic Call to Arms
Insightful. ;)

Yes, I was surprised by his responses, I thought his initial remark was great, but people mean quite different things by those lofty abstractions.

wissler··on Julian Assange: Cryptographic Call to Arms
I don't think the principles are common knowledge. Of course they matter.
wissler··on Julian Assange: Cryptographic Call to Arms
Insightful. I'm curious as to what you think are the basic human rights and the principles of the Enlightenment.
wissler··on Tor exit node operator raided in Austria
Also, if you feel the best way to make your point is to Godwin the topic, it's time to take a step back.

What pure unmitigated bullshit. Read this article:

http://www.salon.com/2010/07/01/godwin

I never said anonymous speech wasn't important so I don't know whose arguments you think you're addressing.

← PreviousPage 9 of 18Next →