HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wolrah

2,854 karma · joined December 24, 2014

submissionscomments
wolrah··on Show HN: A USB-C LTE modem that gives my computer a phone line
There are SIP to cellular gateways which have historically been very popular in regions where landline to mobile calls cost money but mobile to mobile do not, but they mostly don't exist in the US market other than high-density devices mostly used by SMS spammers.

The only actual VoIP phone with a SIM card I'm aware of is the Yealink T74LTE which for a long time was exclusive to Verizon's business phone service but has recently become available for general purchase, those can support both SIM over LTE data and VoLTE (which is also basically SIP but over a prioritized channel).

wolrah··on Show HN: A USB-C LTE modem that gives my computer a phone line
> Will LTE continue to work when 6G rolls out in 3 years?

A significant change that came with LTE is the use of OFDM as the base of the air interface, which means that cellular providers no longer need to allocate large segments of spectrum to one protocol or another. Towers that were upgraded from 4G to 5G didn't need to disable 4G or consistently split their spectrum between the two they way they did when upgrading from 2G to 3G or 3G to 4G, they can dynamically allocate subchannels in each mode based on the immediate needs of their users.

It seems unlikely that whatever technologies come in the future will regress in this way, so there shouldn't be a need for a hard cutoff at any point and I'd expect LTE devices to keep working for many generations to come.

wolrah··on If IPv4 were land
> Only today we would have put everything behind something like NAT anyway because your devices would be getting hacked constantly.

So the security "provided by" common 1:many NAT comes from the fact that 1:many NAT inherently requires stateful connection tracking and by its nature traffic coming in from the "1" side without an associated connection or rule has nowhere to go, effectively denying any other traffic by default from the "1" side which is almost universally the untrusted side.

Do you know what else has stateful connection tracking and deny-by-default rules on untrusted interfaces? Every single firewall that's worth using or even was at one point worth using in a year starting with a "2".

So yes, in a world without NAT we'd still have stateful firewalls blocking unsolicited incoming traffic that had not been specifically allowed. Those who wish to host public services will still need to configure rules to allow that traffic in unsolicited but those rules will be simpler than NAT port forwards because there's no address translation involved. Anything else wanting to generate on demand temporary connections between systems will be able to do so simply by having each system perform a basic hole punch, sending traffic at the other at the same time with the same pair of ports, and expect it to work again in ways much simpler than what's necessary for reliably doing the same in a 1:many NAT environment.

1:many NAT makes nothing better, it only makes things worse. It's a bad thing and needs to go away as quickly as possible.

---

1:1 NAT is an entirely different beast, it can be entirely stateless and thus has no has no negative impact on most protocols that don't try to communicate address info in-band but also that statelessness means it doesn't inherently provide a firewall effect.

wolrah··on If IPv4 were land
You ignored the second half of that sentence:

> syncing data between computers you owned that all had publicly routable addresses is a much simpler problem.

In no way am I denying that people would like to solve the same problems easily. What I'm saying is that it would have been a much simpler problem requiring much less infrastructure. An application like SyncThing that works without any central infrastructure would have been an order of magnitude easier to implement in a world where every internet connected device had a unique routable address.

wolrah··on If IPv4 were land
> That's why Dropbox gained popularity in spite of, you know, the fact that we all can do it with FTP.

Dropbox gained popularity *BECAUSE IT MADE IT EASY TO DO THIS WHEN YOU'RE STUCK BEHIND NAT TRASH*. By the time it was even a thought in anyone's brain the internet had already been ruined by that garbage.

It would never have existed in a world without NAT because it wouldn't have been needed, syncing data between computers you owned that all had publicly routable addresses is a much simpler problem.

Every ISP that has CGNAT v4 without providing full v6 needs to be shut down. They are either incompetent or actively choosing to make their users' service less useful to restrict them and/or encourage "upgrades". Internet service has a public routable IP address, period.

wolrah··on MacBook Pro with PROLED XDR Display and Touch
That's not a justification for padding, it's a justification for scalable UI. A lot of those "classic" windows dialogs do not scale well on high DPI screens but they still work great with a mouse even if their scaling is ugly. The padding is just there for touch-friendliness.
wolrah··on Google has officially turned these Nest thermostats back into dumb thermostats
It was more of the point that WiFi devices allow that to happen because basically every consumer/smallbiz WiFi network can be assumed to support internet access and most buyers won't care.

The easiest way to avoid that problem is to just skip retail WiFi devices altogether because having WiFi basically always means assuming internet connectivity which is not far from mandatory cloud bullshit.

wolrah··on Google has officially turned these Nest thermostats back into dumb thermostats
Matter only sort of solves it because a lot of Matter devices (most in my personal experience) use WiFi and often intentionally neuter their Matter support to "encourage" you to use their app and/or cloud integration with a major voice assistant.

I have a pair of Govee ceiling lights that have a RGB+CCT primary downward facing light and an addressable RGB accent ring. The ARGB ring only exists in their app. As far as both their Matter support and their official API are concerned these units have a single element which is the downward light, the ARGB ring is not controllable from any third-party systems.

If these were using Zigbee, Z-Wave, or Matter over Thread they wouldn't be able to do this but because they use WiFi they can.

I'm going to be opening one up soonish to see how hard it'll be to just replace the controller with one running WLED (or even reprogram the controller already in it).

wolrah··on Google has officially turned these Nest thermostats back into dumb thermostats
One of many reasons I prefer home automation hardware that uses ZigBee, Z-Wave, or Thread over using WiFi. If it uses WiFi it almost always wants to connect to or worse requires a cloud, where the dedicated home automation network tech is basically the polar opposite and requires that it work entire directly locally or with a local hub.

Other major reason being that "IoT" devices usually have the shittiest WiFi radios that usually don't even support 5 GHz and almost never support WiFi 6/7 modes where they aren't wasting a ton of airtime on their low-bandwidth communication.

wolrah··on VMMouse for NT 3.x: QEMU/VMware mouse integration driver
Mouse "works" but it will require that the VM "capture" the mouse pointer and often doesn't move the same way it would on the host because the VM is having to translate the messages it's receiving from the host OS in to emulation of a classic PS/2 mouse.

A VM integration driver allows the host to just pass through to the guest the absolute position of the pointer over the virtualized display and the button/scroll events which allows it to not need to be captured and movement feels natural to the host system.

Newer guest OSes that support USB HID can generally support an absolute input mode which was intended for drawing tablets and it'll work well enough, but it's a bit of a hack and requires updating the USB descriptor any time the display resolution changes to keep them in sync so a VM integration driver is still nice to have.

wolrah··on eMudhra to exit global SSL/TLS certificate business
As Wayne points out later in the thread, it's because those who are paying attention already know the answers but the questions are specifically designed to both confirm that eMudhra actually understands what they've done wrong and are willing to publicly acknowledge it, which is a critical factor in how an incident will affect trust going forward.

Obviously in this case eMudhra has decided they don't want the responsibility anymore which I actually respect to some extent.

wolrah··on eMudhra to exit global SSL/TLS certificate business
> Is the Mozilla bugtracker usually a / the Go to party for these issues? Or just a coincidence in this case?

Yes, because of the project's open nature the Mozilla CA program Bugzilla and their dev-security-policy mailing list have become the de facto public discussion point for TLS-related issues.

wolrah··on Plex laid off the whole player team
The actual thread the post being referenced is in is about Dolby Vision and HDR10 playback on Apple devices, so I can see where a rant might come out I guess...

edit: Yup just saw GP's reply and they clearly have opinions about HDR.

wolrah··on Your MCU likely escaped the eMudhra intermediate CA compromise
> sometimes due to real constraints

IMO this should always be pushed back against, because it's not a valid excuse. If the hardware is too constrained to support appropriate security then that hardware is not appropriate for the application (or no longer appropriate for the application, as the story often goes).

wolrah··on What If Video Games Came on VHS? One Modder Is Finding Out
The element of limited choice between multiple tracks makes me think of the Viewmaster Interactive Vision which implemented a much more limited version of the concept.
wolrah··on Wine ported to OpenBSD
There was a whole era of mid '90s Microsoft games where they were still competing with "Exit to DOS to get the best game experience" so they went out of their way to make sure you were aware you were running in Windows while playing their games. Aside from the early Age of Empires games I also recall the "Madness" family of racing games had different takes on the same idea from a variety of different developers. I actually just reinstalled Monster Truck Madness 1 the other day and have been working my way through trying to bodge it in to being an acceptable experience for this exact reason. The game itself runs fine but the UI does a lot of weird things that may have worked on Windows 9x with a low-res CRT but are very annoying on a modern system.
wolrah··on Plex vulnerabilities being exploited in the wild to drop a cryptominer
Did you miss the point about working on random devices? That's the key to why I use Plex at all. If I have to install and set up a VPN client on it I'd just use Jellyfin because at that point I've limited myself to only my devices.

Also of course friends/family. The most technologically useless people I know can operate Plex and can access my collection with basically no support necessary.

wolrah··on An Apology
"No Problems" isn't exactly a comparison.

Apple's network has the majority of iOS and iPadOS devices on the planet tracking for it.

Google's network has whatever subset of Android devices are running a new enough version of the OS and have opted in tracking for it.

Tile's network has whatever subset of both iOS and Android devices where the device owner either has/had or is close with someone who has/had a Tile device, installed the app, hasn't uninstalled it, and the app hasn't had its permissions revoked automatically due to lack of use.

It's just not comparable. Tiles are fine around the house or in densely populated areas where you can generally assume someone with the app is going to be nearby pretty regularly, but if you lose your keys on a hiking trail and someone else picks them up so they're not wherever your phone last saw them you're probably not getting any updated info any time soon.

wolrah··on Plex vulnerabilities being exploited in the wild to drop a cryptominer
> This is terrifying. Who runs things like this open to the outside?

Probably the majority of people with a Plex Pass subscription and most Plex users in general.

As far as I see it, Plex's primary purpose is to allow people who have extensive collections of legally obtained digital media to conveniently access it and share access to their friends and family on pretty much any random device from anywhere in the world.

All my home media devices run Kodi, they run Jellyfin, they run all sorts of fully open stuff, but when I travel Plex wins because it runs on basically anything that can stream video and I can sign in to it in seconds without needing to connect a VPN or enter my password on someone else's device.

wolrah··on An Apology
I bought my partner a few of those years ago before Google had even announced an intent to get in to the tracker market, and they work great for an individual looking to find their keys in the house, but as far as tracking things in the real world they're significantly less useful because their tracking network is basically only other Tile users who have the app installed and haven't let its permissions expire.

A tag like this is only as strong as its network, and Apple absolutely dominates that with Google a distant second and Samsung still pretending they have a chance in third. Tile isn't even in the competition.

wolrah··on Tesla Roadster
> Mobileye is no longer a Tesla supplier because Tesla insourced their ADAS.

Mobileye is no longer a Tesla supplier because Tesla wouldn't stop using their tech in ways they did not approve of, turning back all the safety limits to allow the public to do things Mobileye knew were unsafe. Mobileye publicly called them out, saying that Tesla was "going to hurt the interests of [Mobileye] and hurt the interests of an entire industry, if a company of our reputation will continue to be associated with this type of pushing the envelope in terms of safety".

This is one of the reasons why S/X ADAS performance famously got significantly worse in late 2016 with HW2, they had of course been working on their own tech but because they'd already built their brand around ADAS they felt compelled to put it out unfinished when they no longer had the Mobileye system to sell.

wolrah··on It took me nine years to hack my Xbox 360
> I’ll bite: the PS3 controller sux!

It doesn't suck, but it certainly isn't the best and I've always found the Playstation stans' insistence on it being the greatest possible design to be hilarious because we know exactly how it came to be.

The SNES controller is pretty universally agreed to be great and has more or less defined the standard layout for digital gamepads since then. Given the history between Sony and Microsoft I don't think anyone disputes that the original digital PSX pad is basically a legally-distinct evolution of the SNES pad, made mostly better other than the then-patent-encumbered D-pad. It's a top tier digital input device and allowed for a very easy transition for 2D franchises established on the SNES.

When the N64 however it became immediately clear that 3D gameplay really benefitted from analog inputs, and Sony was caught with their pants down having barely even launched a full size analog joystick at that point. The Dual Analog was quickly put together by slapping two analog sticks on to the standard PSX gamepad in the least disruptive way possible, which was a perfectly fine solution for the time but absolutely not the way to get the best analog controls.

Then they freaking stuck with it instead of designing a controller optimized primarily for 3D play. To this day the Playstation platform has a controller that is derived from one of the best 2D digital gamepads ever to exist but where 3D analog support remains more or less bolted on to the bottom.

Again, it's not terrible, but I find it hilarious how many people insist it's peak controller design overall when it's more of a historical accident.

If I'm playing SNES emulators, I reach for my PS3 gamepad. If I'm playing 3D games, I reach for my Xbox One gamepad. I only ever play 3D games with PS controllers when they're exclusive to PS platforms that aren't yet emulated

wolrah··on The Haunted Toys R Us
That's pretty common, a lot of older phone systems will literally have a line input where you can hook up a looping music player, Muzak receiver, a radio (illegal but common anyways), or whatever else to provide the hold music feed and for the most part if the business has overhead audio they'll want to use that as their hold music as well.
wolrah··on Publishers Killed the Paperback, Then Blamed Readers
When I was in school my backpack had to carry not only hardcover books for all my classes but also the associated notebooks and/or binders that the class all too often required us to keep as part of our grade. It often weighed enough that I needed to effectively do a squat to get in and out of my seat on the school bus.

I can think of one time in my adult life that my backpack has been anywhere close to that full, which was a weekend trip to New York City where I was testing whether I could get away with not needing to navigate the transit system with a large bag (it worked but didn't really feel worth the effort). A hardcover would be no issue to fit in any normal situation.

That said, when I travel I carry an e-reader and usually pick up a car magazine at the airport newsstand. My physical books stay at home.

wolrah··on Triple-A Minesweeper
Though there definitely is a lot of slop out there (even before that term gained a new meaning) I think it's hard to argue that there are so many more high quality games now than there ever were before just because it's so much easier to develop and distribute them.

Also don't rose-colored-glasses older games either, there was a lot of absolute trash. Bargain bins existed for a reason. That said just because a game is bad doesn't mean it isn't still fun in some way, even if for its brokenness. There's an entire genre of games these days where the basic principle is "if you find a bug, but it's funny, it's now a feature".

wolrah··on Triple-A Minesweeper
Also there are a lot more high-quality games available now, for a lot less money. In the '80s and '90s you might spend $50-100 on a bad game and you'd play it anyways because you couldn't return it. Even if you could, your local game store only stocked so many things.

Now if you're paying full price for a game you've at least had the ability to read reviews and you know it's going to be half price in a year but you want it now. You also have tens of thousands of other games to pick from in basically any genre you want, accessible more or less on demand.

wolrah··on PS5 Relapse Exploit
I just fired up my Deck and it's Settings > Security which seems like a pretty obvious place. I have mine set to trigger a lock screen on wake/power and if desktop mode is requested, which are the only two options on that entire page.
wolrah··on Nissan's third generation e-POWER powertrain
I'm from the flat parts of the US midwest. Interesting stuff can be hundreds of miles away. There is absolutely a culture of cramming the family in to the car or RV the moment a long weekend starts and driving late in to the night to reach the destination, getting a day or two there, then hauling ass to get home in time to be back to work/school the next day.

That said, I also daily drive an EV and have no trouble road tripping it. I'm older, I can't just drive 500 miles only stopping for gas and restrooms like I used to, so a 15 minute stop every 1:45 or so is no big deal.

Back when I had a gas car it was a Fiesta ST, which is a great daily driver but a terrible road trip car, so I was already in the habit of renting a car if I was going to be on the road for longer than 8ish hours. This car is more comfortable so I probably won't rent if I'm not in a hurry, but if I feel the need to knock out 1000 miles as quickly as possible the option will always remain.

wolrah··on Nissan's third generation e-POWER powertrain
> Just a normal weekend trip to the beach or mountains (200-ish miles from the Triangle of NC either way) would mean I’d have to limit myself to hotels/Airbnbs with a charger.

I bought an EV just under a year ago and because I park literally right next to my electrical panel I figured I'd probably end up installing a 40 amp EVSE within a few weeks. Here we are, again nearly a year later, and I'm still using the standard 120v L1 cable the car came with because it's plenty. The only time I'm getting below 50% are on road trips where fast chargers are easy to come by.

As a matter of fact the last two vacation rental homes I've stayed in have been in North Carolina, one on Topsail Beach and one near Black Mountain. The one near Black Mountain actually had a 14-50 outlet outside intended for RVs or EV charging but both had plenty of 5-20s outside where I could have easily plugged in my portable cord to easily cover the driving we did in the area, and even if they didn't with 240ish miles of range and a variety of fast chargers in the nearest decent size city 10-15 miles away it's not really a concern.

wolrah··on PS5 Relapse Exploit
It's definitely deck-specific (or maybe Big Picture specific), neither my desktops nor laptops have ever asked for a PIN nor would I want them to.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →