HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wonder_er

1,322 karma · joined March 21, 2016

https://josh.works/
submissionscomments
wonder_er··on Bollards: Why and What
fixed most of 'em. Thanks. For sure posted a draft, hadn't expected prime time like this, but turns out someone follows me via rss!
wonder_er··on Bollards: Why and What
what a good find, thanks for the link! I opened it up, looked around, imagined the conditions that led to the photo I put in the article!
wonder_er··on Bollards: Why and What
holy cow this is amaaaaazing, u/ellipsis753. My god. I want the t-shirt, I love the love for bell bollards, I obviously had a photo of one in the post but i didn't know there was so much love for them!!!!! I <3 this
wonder_er··on Bollards: Why and What
I was under the influence of _deep_ rage at American traffic planners and municipal 'engineers' who commit themselves, deeply, to dehumanizing decisions, and then spend meaningful effort preventing OTHERS from tending to the spaces that they use.

It's one thing to be useless at your job. It's another thing to punch down at others trying to make their way through the world.

When I talk to professional planners, they're always so cute. "Wow, Josh, you're so interested in this domain, why don't you get into planning?"

I always say:

If you were as good at your job as you claim to be, I wouldn't need to spend my precious time trying to fix your shit. When the websites and services _I_ maintain go down, I don't expect _you_ to show up at a public meeting to 'give input' on what needs to be done. I fucking fix the thing that's broken, and until then, everyone's justifiably annoyed that the service is non-performant.

I expect minimum levels of safety and adequacy from the mobility network I use, for myself, my child, those I love, and indeed people I've never met.

I don't manage to hide my contempt for the professionals actively involved in permitting the death of tens of thousands of people _every year_.

But obviously, _obviously_, you don't have to read it.

wonder_er··on Bollards: Why and What
saaaaame
wonder_er··on Bollards: Why and What
loooool this is gold. Author of the post, here, I love this.

> Like, they would love nothing more than for some master race of pickup truck bros to upload their brains into anthropomorphic cars, discard their primitive flesh, and then run over all the remaining meatbags that refused to join in.

:party:

wonder_er··on Bollards: Why and What
> In fact, it strikes me that "places where you shouldn't try and park a car because your car would probably be hit by a car" would make a pretty decent heuristic for places to start.

Spot on. I'd LOVE to start with bollards, here.

(author of the post. You're picking up exactly what I'm saying. TY.)

wonder_er··on Bollards: Why and What
> we make an active choice to create danger and then a second choice not to mitigate the danger.

Precisely! This is why I keep suggesting charges of criminal negligence against city engineers, along side stripping them of sovereign immunity.

> Oh no, Josh, it sounds like you want someone to be responsible for the decisions they make!

Yes, yes I do.

(I wrote the article. You very correctly perceive that two-step choice. make it dangers, keep it dangerous.)

wonder_er··on Bollards: Why and What
I feel seen. (Author here.)

Indeed, the cost of bollards is _dramatically_ lower than 'not bollards'.

Also, a one time spend for permanent safety, for years or decades. It's a slam dunk.

wonder_er··on Bollards: Why and What
author here. Thanks for the gracious words. Yes, I'm foundationally attacking the entire way the discipline is practiced, I'm not _trying_ to do it politely, _and_ the critiques are possibly fairly leveled. :)
wonder_er··on Bollards: Why and What
exaaaaaactly. this, all the way. (i wrote the bollard post.)

> It's actually much crazier, but you will find it hard to believe.

I kept having this experience, as professional, licensed engineers would tell me, with their whole mouth, and a straight face, things like "we cannot protect pedestrians because it might hurt a car."

Me:

Who _the fuck_ do you think drives the cars?

The false dichotomy in america between 'pedestrians' and 'cars' is entirely downstream of the class-based ethnic cleansing ushered in by municipal planning agencies in the 1920s-1960s. They couldn't say "we don't want black people here", but they could say "we want only the kinds of people who drive cars _here_".

wonder_er··on Bollards: Why and What
I've been following the world bollard account for ages, love them with my whole soul.

I'm weighing _installing a bollard_ against _a person or building or both being destroyed by a regular and routine mistake_.

Bollards are hilariously cheap compared to every single other option, including "doing nothing except cleaning up the damage".

FWIW, I hate the corrugated steel barriers you mention, and they're not cheaper than bollards (if you're at all judicious and thoughtful about the bollard design and installation).

As another commenter mentioned, at the bottom of a post, there's a photo of 'strong' bollards, mid-installation, at the bottom of the post.

Why do you say that it's ironic that I link to the world bollard association?

wonder_er··on Bollards: Why and What
author of the post here, this is exactly right. There's zero 'structural empathy' towards non-car-drivers. It's always been that way in America, though, as soon as municipal planners figured out they could use federal highway money to run highways through ethnic neighborhoods full of 'those people', and could destroy those neighborhoods. The danger was the point.

That 'lack of empathy' has killed literally tens of thousands of children, as their parents plead before local municipal planners to do something, anything, to cause their kids to not die.

The planners say "meh, don't know don't care, but I'll sleep fine tonight."

wonder_er··on Bollards: Why and What
I do desired them for their _objective_ incompetence. Among serious traffic people, globally, american traffic planners are regarded as children in a corner eating play dough.

I have plenty of nuance, here you go:

- https://zoningverydifferentthanours.substack.com - https://josh.works/issues-in-golden - https://josh.works/parking-in-golden - https://josh.works/about-roundabouts

I could go on. Do you want to start with Donald Shoup's [The High Cost of Free Parking](https://www.amazon.com/High-Cost-Parking-Updated-Edition/dp/...) or my friend Alain Bertraud's beautiful book about urban _economics_ as the right frame of analysis for managing shared city resources: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/39644188-order-without-d...

There's a deep and intimate relationship between american zoning laws, american mobility regimes, and the american ethnic cleansing of all non-whites: https://josh.works/full-copy-of-1922-atlanta-zone-plan

Tell me more about my lack of nuance. You might be right, fwiw, but it might kinda be the point. I'm not interested in a message of "your opposition of ethnic cleansing is _insufficiently nuanced_.", though it is slightly humorous.

wonder_er··on Bollards: Why and What
> The author writes as if people who work in this space are not smart.

That's correct. I write as if they are not smart, because the other option is that _they are willfully malicious and committed to maintaining a status quo that is not in accordance with any other ethical framework that you and I routinely validate_.

> I’m pretty sure everyone realizes bollards saves lives

No, american municipal "planners" and "engineers" (the people who claim special authority over, and knowledge about, mobility networks) routinely state that bollards are dangerous and _kill people_, because a properly engineered and placed bollard would completely destroy a car, if the car hit it at any speed.

Basically, I'm ranting because the people who say "there can be no bollard here" justify their decision with "because it would function as a bollard, creating a 'shadow' or 'eddy' of safety behind it, but at the cost of being able to stop a car, and what if the vehicle driver was inconvenienced or annoyed?"

I'm not suggesting miles of bollards, I'm suggesting that every intersection have two bollards on each corner, pointing towards the street in such a way that if you are standing in the vicinity of the corner, you could be positioned relative to passing vehicle traffic with a bollard between you and it.

If there is money to pour concrete and place rebar in the ground, there is money to reshape some of the metal so it protrudes from the concrete instead of being _exclusively_ embedded within it.

Also, youre "who will pay for it" is simply opposing the energy of anyone trying to create safety. It's not welcome. You're straw-manning me, I didn't say 'miles of bollards', I'm saying 'that bollards exist should be professionally relevant to anyone who claims special knowledge of roads and cars, and it's dedignifying to pretend that they don't know better.'

wonder_er··on Bollards: Why and What
Author here. You got the exact message I was trying to convey. Thank you.
wonder_er··on Bollards: Why and What
author here. Didn't find out until just a few minutes ago that this recent, random, draft post ended up on the HN front page. Huzzah.

> My biggest question is: is the author arguing that there should be spaced bollards along literally every sidewalk in the country/world, and around all edges of every parking lot?

Absolutely not, not even close.

I'm suggesting that wherever there are cars parking while pointed at buildings, considering them as you would a loaded gun. If you don't feel comfortable with them pointed at your building, being willing to drive _through_ the thing, if the vehicle operator makes a mistake, _add a bollard or a large rock or a strong art installation or anything that keeps the vehicle from being able to drive into the building_.

I'm further condemning the entire American transportation planning industry that _expends effort to prevent individuals from adding safety to their own paths, routes, commuting habits_.

It's interesting that you go straight to costs, which makes me think you don't viscerally feel the danger _you_ are routinely exposed to by unprotected exposure to cars. Otherwise, you'd get it.

That said, the costs of _not_ doing anything are well-established. Entire industries exist to prevent occasional bad things from happening, and their ethical standing is sound. Insurance of all kinds, fire extinguishers, fire detectors, fire suppression systems, seat belts, air bags, guard rails, term life insurance plans, cargo insurance, and more.

It's also ugly, however, to see car parts and oils and fuels sprayed about an intersection. It's also ugly to see the human carnage that cars leave behind them. I don't like seeing the insides of a body on the outside, spread across the ground.

wonder_er··on SpaceX seeks permission to dump treated wastewater into Texas bay
The public input blocking improvement is a feature, not a bug.

Think about who had the permission to vote, when voting was first deemed as a way to impact the world.

'the public' means 'americans' which means 'the norms of white people'. Colonialism, supremacy, violence, the carceral state. (Pardon the redundancy)

American traffic planners use 'the public' has justification for the continued oppression of poor and minority people, via highways and refusal of services that would actually help the real public.

Texas still has in its municipal governments and public populations, enough people that are disappointed by the end of slavery, that often enough the political will is indistinguishable from that of slaveholders.

It's a feature, not a bug.

wonder_er··on America's advanced manufacturing problem and how to fix it
when two people are playing a game, and one of them is willing to use violence, it's quite a bit harder for the other person to not use violence as well.

The US uses violence and coercion as a matter of fact, continuously, in every way, shape, and form.

If you tried to 'play' with the US from a position of mutuality and co-creation... you get colonized and cleansed and westernized.

wonder_er··on America's advanced manufacturing problem and how to fix it
"America" is so hideously crippled by the heavy duty ethnic cleansing and regimes of social control baked into land use laws and transportation/mobility networks that 'advanced' problems are not even eligible to be solved.

Sorta a 'do not pass go, do not collect $200, until {x} is solved' situation.

If a city still has parking minimums on the books, I evaluate all involved parties as utterly unserious, pseudo-scientific religious zealots.

Do you think the American south, in the era of chattel slavery, could solve 'advanced manufacturing problems'? NO! of course not! So why does anyone think 'america' could solve an advanced problem?

Meh. I shouldn't be surprised by the article, though. The authors probably think the USA isn't a backwater country that is 'on top' only via a willingness to use economic and actual violence to achieve all aims.

wonder_er··on Scientists of Chinese descent leaving the US at an accelerating pace
the us immigration system is deeply dehumanizing. The presumptions, control, classism, the authoritarian language, the implication that access to some perfect garden is being granted, that the lucky recipient will never want to leave...

it's like some performative piece of propaganda, that you' must participate in, enthusiastically, in order to get the reward. (permission from the state to enter "it's" borders.)

at a prior company, a coworker was a young, single, pakistani male. the company was remote-first, did company meetups twice a year. About 30 or 40 people, maybe.

Anyway, every time he entered the USA, we'd lament together about the litany of indignities he'd suffer at the hands of various authorities. It was sort of like filling out a bingo card.

I did a lot of apologizing, and explaining how xenophobia has been baked deeply into american institutions.

wonder_er··on Scientists of Chinese descent leaving the US at an accelerating pace
yeah. for a few years, but especially recently, every time I re-enter the USA, I cannot help but think, for a long time, how it feels like such decline is so visible everywhere.

It feels quite dispiriting. I'm not sure I'd go to china as my first choice, especially as I don't speak mandarin or cantonese, but I'd _love_ to leave the USA. There's many great options I'd consider. Maybe in a year or two, I'll be hailing from outside the USA!

wonder_er··on Boston mayor announces residential conversion program for office buildings
part of the reason this is so bad in the USA is indeed what OP named, the concept of 'legibility', as explained in 'seeing like a state'.

In the case of the USA, though, another 'lens' on the legibility is that overall the people making the laws were neurotically concerned with keeping black people away from white people and enforcing segregation.

'separating uses' was a good way to also 'separate users', and a little barely-that-creative law-writing lets someone keep black people quite removed from the white people.

I found a document from 1922 that is upstream of all american zoning codes - it's what got ratified in Euclid v. Ambler circa 1926.

It's explicit goal was:

"To maintain harmonious relations between the races, care has been given to ensure adequate separation between the two, with room to grow without encroaching on the other"

The race-based zoning designations are gold:

"R1 - white, R2 - colored, R3 - undecided"

Here's a deep link straight to that portion of the document: https://josh.works/full-copy-of-1922-atlanta-zone-plan#race-...

Oh, it also says:

"The ordinary two or three story store and dwelling building is not a desirable type of construction from a public stand point. The regulations as applied will tend to reduce the number of flats that would otherwise be located over stores."

So - there it is. The goal of American zoning was, in part, to eliminate 'the ordinary two or three story store and dwelling building'.

wonder_er··on Ask HN: Could you share your personal blog here?
ooooh, sorry, no, it's gone.

I had a whole thing happening around becoming a bold lead climber by becoming an amazing lead belayer.

It was great! I've helped many, many people become very safe, very confident sport climbers. Watching them 'climb through the grades' is enjoyable for all parties.

wonder_er··on Ask HN: Could you share your personal blog here?
https://josh.works/blog

Oh, boy, it's a random collection of things.

Here's a smattering of posts about:

- climbing: https://josh.works/climbing/2016/05/29/on-boldness-in-climbi...

- went to the top of HN, changing your mac address: https://josh.works/shell-script-basics-change-mac-address

- how to write a letter of recommendation for yourself: https://josh.works/how-to-write-a-letter-of-recommendation-f...

i've found SO MANY wonderful personal blogs here on HN. I even built a little web scraping thing a long time ago to scrape these links from the top-level comments: https://random-hn-blog.herokuapp.com/

Heroku shut it down, but I'm gonna see if i can bring it back online in like 30 seconds...

wonder_er··on Ignoring boys' emotional needs fuels public health risks
My only credibility to make a reliable book recommendation on this topic:

1. Have experienced some of what's discussed

2. Has historically read quite a lot

The following book, and others by the author, have proven to be the most efficient filter for 'compressing' sometimes challenging life experience into something manageable:

'The Tao of Fully Feeling: Harvesting Forgiveness Out of Blame', by Pete Walker.

https://www.amazon.com/Tao-Fully-Feeling-Harvesting-Forgiven...

wonder_er··on Presence of airborne microplastics in human lung tissue
Great question. I think because plastic and rubber are both petrolium byproducts, the 'shreds' of both are bad.

I googled, found: > Current tires consist of 19% natural rubber and 24% synthetic polymers (plastics), as well as metal and other materials.

So tires have both rubber and plastics. both are bad, and both get ejected into the environment at a horrific rate. :(

wonder_er··on Presence of airborne microplastics in human lung tissue
Tire rubber is a huuuuge source of airborne microplastics.
wonder_er··on uBlock Origin 1.50.0
whoa. Thank you! Just enabled this for my ublock extension. Don't see a difference yet, but I'm psyched for any chance to up my ublock usage.
wonder_er··on uBlock Origin 1.50.0
couldn't agree more.

I put together an explainer about how to use it to _rapidly_ (and usually permanently) delete nearly any part of public websites.

When I see friends on many websites now, it makes my heart ache.

https://josh.works/take-back-your-attention

← PreviousPage 3 of 15Next →