HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wonderzombie

967 karma · joined June 2, 2010

submissionscomments
wonderzombie··on Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002)
other (non-bullied) politicians

Is this how people are co-opting the term "bullied" now? To describe criticism of prominent people in public life? C'mon. Condoleeza Rice served in two presidential administrations. She is not some ingenue who accidentally stumbled into the spotlight.

wonderzombie··on Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002)
...which are all rational ways for people to optimize their time. And lo, it works sometimes.

So what you're really saying is that even though this is a fairly well-optimized use of people's time and effort, it's illegitimate because people aren't sweating for it. This is HN— if you leveled a similar complaint at a CEO, startup, or corporation, you'd be criticized for implying they're lazy rather than rational.

Don't get me wrong; I don't love slacktivism, either. I suspect it has an opportunity cost. I tentatively agree that it's a proxy for more substantive protest. However, I submit that this is because people don't otherwise feel empowered. If you believe any sort of activism is low percentage, then why not choose the route that is the least amount of effort?

wonderzombie··on Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002)
Why wouldn't people take action which has even a small percentage of success when it requires negligible effort and little time? It seems utterly rational to me.

Likewise, moderate physical exertion (read: effort and time) for a low percentage play is a more dubious proposition. There's a fixed amount of time in a day and you simply can't get more of it; you can only optimize.

I'm not saying people don't jump on bandwagons or whatever. I think outrage & anger are in some sense addictive and cyclical on their own. (Whether they are "legitimate" in any given case is orthogonal IMO.) And I'm sort of with you in spirit, as I gather you're basically criticizing slacktivism.

But if you're trying to set a bar for "real" activism, it's best to keep the above in mind, particularly when people feel otherwise disempowered.

wonderzombie··on Internal Apple document: FY'14 Planning Offsite
I can barely use my Moto X one-handed (e.g. standing on a bus). I must be one of the only people on the planet who a) does this and/or b) does not have monstrously large hands. :P
wonderzombie··on Brendan Eich, We’ve Failed You. I’m Sorry.
We failed him? How overwrought can you get?

He wasn't incarcerated, executed, sued, or tried for a crime. He lost his job. As we're all fond of implying here, there's no right to employment, let alone the right to be a CEO.

Don't hide behind "meritocracy" and "tolerance" to defend morally repugnant ideals. You demean those words and yourself. You reveal your lack of understanding of what an open and free society means when it comes to the more vulnerable, less privileged members of same.

wonderzombie··on The Next Mission
"Keeping marriage as it's been" is a post-hoc rationalization, to attempt to disconnect the anti-gay-marriage crowd from a religious argument. Go read the Bible that's used to justify this crap and write up a compare/contrast.
wonderzombie··on The Next Mission
Good grief. You do far more harm to your position by invoking a practice part of a century-long campaign of terror against a racial minority.

Free speech doesn't mean freedom from criticism. It means the opposite, actually. And we as a society have decided some views are socially unacceptable. Anti-homosexual bigotry has been added to the list, along with pro-slavery or violence against women. Those are topics which are really just not up for debate anymore— we are in theory an egalitarian society, where plurality takes precedence over someone's right to (e.g.) express negative views, esp about minorities.

wonderzombie··on The Next Mission
Um, how could his actions not suggest intolerance? He contributed money to a campaign which essentially persecutes a minority. In what universe is that not bigoted? "He didn't mean it" is a ridiculously flimsy defense.
wonderzombie··on The Next Mission
Social censure is the most powerful way to adjust norms. You're much more likely to listen to a friend calling you out on something than anyone else. And it sends signals to other people with a similar bent, suggesting that certain behavior is no longer acceptable.

Here's the thing that you're forgetting: the targets of (e.g.) hateful rhetoric feel better when bigots are dismissed from polite society. Some bigots may become more radicalized, but many become demoralized or may even think twice about it (see above). However, when fewer people are allowed to propagate bigoted views in society, society overall is a better place. The whole point is to make society more inclusive. I care less about marginalizing people with abhorrent views than marginalizing different ethnicities, lifestyle choices, and genetic predispositions.

"Wait until they die" suggests a bootstrapping problem: why would children of bigots feel any different unless they had a reason to? If you only wait for bigots to die out instead of marginalizing them, bigotry is normalized over generations. You have to interrupt that cycle.

wonderzombie··on The Next Mission
The "BS" in "BS religious reasons" is the tell. There are huge swaths of the Bible the religious set is happy to set aside when it's convenient. Go read Leviticus for a start.

It says more about Christians than it does about gay people or even the Bible that they're fixated on homosexuality.

wonderzombie··on The Next Mission
It's not about "winning." It's about what kind of world we want to live in. Evidently enough people don't want to live in a world where a bigot is the CEO of an organization that ostensibly espouses freedom and equality.

I use the word bigot advisedly. Anything else is sugar-coating the motivations and rationale of the anti-gay-marriage crowd— there is no basis for it which does not rest on a religious argument, in theory or in practice. And you can't actively oppose deny someone else's civil rights and claim it's not personal, or whatever.

wonderzombie··on The Next Mission
Lynching? Please. There's no legal right to be a CEO. Nobody's bringing this guy up in front of a congressional committee. He exercised his constitutional right to donate money, and everyone else exercised their constitutional right to criticize a public figure.

You'll see truly scary comments anywhere and everywhere on the Internet. If you judge every movement by its most extreme, unhinged elements, then there are exactly zero sane or wholesome movements.

wonderzombie··on Mozilla employees tell Brendan Eich he needs to “step down”
And yet the US, EU, et al, still sent their Olympic teams to Sochi. I remember hearing something about how companies are usually pretty happy when people call for a boycott because it means it's a vocal minority and nothing organized.

I don't really see how this is relevant except for a tit-for-tat comparison b/w Russia and the US, which is kinda pointless.

wonderzombie··on Mozilla employees tell Brendan Eich he needs to “step down”
Um, it's wrong, but only because of the particulars of this example, in that the board is probably racist. And to close the loop on your example, it would be open season on the board once public opinion caught up with them.

I think you're presupposing that principles are interchangeable and I don't accept that. I believe in some inherent human rights, and the merits of this particular issue are incredibly relevant. The gentleman in question made a substantial monetary contribution aimed at denying a collection of people a set of privileges.

The reasons for why society ought to privilege views like his over the rights of other people are flimsy at best; it's just a lousy idea given that the basis is wholly religious. Substitute something interracial marriage if you prefer. The fact is that some views are not just immoral in the face of society's avowed principles but unsound as well.

wonderzombie··on Mozilla employees tell Brendan Eich he needs to “step down”
I don't accept this as "redefining marriage." For one thing, the definition has changed throughout history. "Redefining" is a talking point engineered by bigots when the fact is that gay marriage affects straight marriage not a whit. It's orthogonal.

Straight folks just want an exclusive right to define it, and on that basis deny that right to other people. Well, sorry, but nobody ought to have that exclusive right, especially when it's little more than a fig leaf to deny privileges to a group of people. We all know the real reason. It's religious, which just doesn't hold any water, and everybody knows that.

And your remedy is "separate but equal." Non-starter.

wonderzombie··on Mozilla employees tell Brendan Eich he needs to “step down”
There're any number of reasons why someone might visit those countries. When you put up $1K towards a political campaign whose raison d'etre is to deny gay people the right to marry, it's rather well defined what the expectation is.

I don't understand what charities have to do with this, though. Surely there are charities which would be morally objectionable. If he'd donated to a charity with similar aims to the Prop 8 campaign, I imagine it would change people's opinions rather little. Or how about a charity which campaigned against interracial marriage?

wonderzombie··on Mozilla employees tell Brendan Eich he needs to “step down”
He expressed his views publicly. They are subject to public criticism. It's absurd to characterize any form of criticism, especially something relatively mild as this, as a witch-hunt.

Anti-gay bigotry is socially unacceptable. Honestly anyone who thought about it at length ought to have realized we were heading in this direction. And the bar for denying an entire category of people's rights out to be relatively high, personal religious beliefs or not.

He might not have personally expressed bigotry, sure. But putting up $1K to a cause is almost worse, given that it's one of the more efficacious ways to support a cause. That cause happened to be in favor of denying civil rights.

wonderzombie··on Inclusiveness at Mozilla
Here in the US we're in the middle of a debate about what views are socially acceptable and which are not. The tide is turning against views and policies which disadvantage gays as a category of people simply because they are gay.

Thus it's not a question of whether someone's sub-human but whether or not we, as a society, find those views acceptable. Pro-slavery or nakedly white supremacist views fall into a similar category. I believe anti-gay bigotry is drifting towards that axis. While those views are protected, that's orthogonal to whether they're subject to criticism.

Also, "tea party" or "pro-NSA" or "anti-NASA" are not really classes of people, considering they're elective categories.

Honestly I am not very sympathetic. Substitute any other form of prejudice and "I don't demand perfect agreement" starts to sound more and more like apologism for bigotry. I'm sure that's not your intention but the contours are similar.

wonderzombie··on Neovim
Of all the reasons to keep Vim, Vimscript is the one I'd least expect to see on a list! The obtuse nature of Vimscript and clunky Ruby/Python interop are, IMHO, a huge wart on an otherwise fantastic editor.
wonderzombie··on Ask HN: Why isn't Erlang more popular?
"Do you really decide whether you'd learn a language by looking at its website?"

Kind of! Irrespective of Erlang's site, a well-maintained, informative, and newbie friendly website is often a signal. Maybe it's not a very accurate signal. But it's a signal which suggests that, for lack of a better term, the community exists and has its act together.

There are enough other things to occupy programmers' time. People adopt heuristics like these — "how professional/modern does the website look?" — as a way to save time.

wonderzombie··on Women Outnumber Men For The First Time In Berkeley’s Intro To Computer Science
Did you research this, or are you relying on casual observation? There's going to be heavy selection bias here if you're in the software industry but not involved in traditionally female-dominated professions.

Anyway, if the shoe were on the other foot, as a male feminist I would be in favor of getting more men coding.

wonderzombie··on Gmail is a Usability Nightmare
> (If I'm wrong about being unable to migrate the data, please let me know.)

IMAP has been supported since '07. Takeout support was added last December.

Exporting contacts to CSV has been supported for as long as I can remember, though I cannot find a citation.

wonderzombie··on 1 in 4 Americans Don't Know Earth Orbits the Sun. Yes, Really.
What worries me more is people who believe the world is going to end in their lifetimes. How can we plan for the long-term future, as a species, with that kind of worldview?
wonderzombie··on After 15 months, Windows 8 has sold 100 million fewer copies than Windows 7 did
Thanks for those numbers.

So they're the numerator, right? Then what's the denominator? It seems like that's tough to figure out. But I want to say something like, how many PCs were sold up until the release, and with what OSen?

I don't have an answer. I'm just curious because it's an interesting debate.

wonderzombie··on Male, female or custom? Facebook adds options for users to self-identify
With respect, I think the disconnect for you is that you're trying to generalize across a rather diverse group. There's nothing inherent to the definition of not-gender-binary that suggests "and prefers not to identify publicly" in principle.

If you imagine that gender's not a binary, then you could imagine how "trans$foo" is itself a gender. From there, some people prefer to keep it a secret. Some people prefer to make it public. A lot of times it's a matter of personal safety or privacy, but some people prefer to make their presence known.

Consider it as the cousin to coming out as gay if you like. If more folks realize that they know LGBTQ folks, eventually it's no big deal. This is well underway for LGB but not TQ.

wonderzombie··on Male, female or custom? Facebook adds options for users to self-identify
It's not sad because "frighteningly representative" is purely subjective. I don't even know where to start disagreeing with you because you've failed to say anything about how.

If you believe in the right of self-determination, what's the fucking difference how someone self-identifies?

wonderzombie··on Male, female or custom? Facebook adds options for users to self-identify
Unless you intend to go around feeling up people's crotches -- which, even setting aside the absurdity, is an incomplete solution -- it's probably a lot simpler to just call people what they want to be called.

Do you also refuse to use nicknames because they're different from their legal names? What about Internet handles?

wonderzombie··on Oh, you still use Wordpress for your blog? That's adorable.
It looks great, but I don't have nor do I want to pay extra for a VPS just so I can install Node, of all things.

Contrariwise my host supports installing Wordpress with a single click. The End.

This post is just more tech hipsterism. I say this as someone who does indulge in PHP bashing from time to time, and who would like to switch from Wordpress.

wonderzombie··on Disingenuous Basterds: The oligarchs’ campaign to depict their critics as Nazis
"evade one's own accountability for one's relative lack of success does not." — this is it, in a nutshell.

Those who earned deserve it. Those who didn't done. How do you know whether someone earned their success? Well, they're successful. Calvinism, just world fallacy, circular logic, and on and on.

wonderzombie··on This is What it's Like to Be a Woman at a Bitcoin Meetup
Who's suggesting you need to police everybody? Think of it like being an ally or a spotter, not an enforcer or inquisitor.
← PreviousPage 2 of 16Next →