HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

woodandsteel

1,921 karma · joined January 8, 2016

submissionscomments
woodandsteel··on Police unions aren't “unions” in the traditional sense
I should have been clear that the idea about guns is what conservatives believe, not that I think it is correct.
woodandsteel··on Panasonic aims to boost energy density in Tesla batteries by 20%
Great but more important is how battery prices keep falling. Power density is already high enough that long range versions of the Model 3 can go 400 miles, which, with fast charging available when needed, is enough for the vast majority of auto owners.

The problem is that the battery pack that takes makes the cars too expensive to purchase for most people. But in a few more years falling prices will make ev's similar in sticker prices to comparable ice's. That plus much lower operating costs will cause ev sales to skyrocket.

woodandsteel··on Police unions aren't “unions” in the traditional sense
A key part of conservative political philosophy is a set of arguments that the people in governmental bureaucracies are invariable incompetent and act against the welfare of the larger society.

There is, however, one simple way to cure this problem. That is to give them guns and the right to use them in circumstances where ordinary citizens can't.

woodandsteel··on If language began in the hands, why did it ever leave?
Here's something else that seems to support the gesture-first hypothesis. A friend of mine worked in an institute for severely developmentally children. Many had little or no spoken linguistic ability, but most of them had a considerable ability to learn sign language. That makes me think gesturing came first.
woodandsteel··on If language began in the hands, why did it ever leave?
(9) Talking in a group. It seems to me with gestures you can understand only one person at a time. Though maybe deaf people who use sign language have a good way to handle this.
woodandsteel··on If language began in the hands, why did it ever leave?
Good point. Like suppose some men are coming back from a successful hunt, and each of them is using both hands to carry a limb cut off from a large animal.

Another case: when two people are swimming in deep water.

woodandsteel··on Wireheading done right: stay positive without going insane (2016)
The basic question here is the finitude of human existence. We have negative emotions because human beings are finite, ie are not immortal gods, and so are vulnerable to various types of harm, and negative emotions motivate us to take action to avoid or mitigate harm. Only a god could be happy all the time.
woodandsteel··on Why Do People Stay Poor? [pdf]
Oh, ok.
woodandsteel··on Airbus to build 'first interplanetary cargo ship'
Interesting, but the SpaceX Starship/Falcon Heavy, which will start flying in a few years, will be able to do this a thousand times better.
woodandsteel··on Why Do People Stay Poor? [pdf]
I have not read the article, but assume that their use of the term "poor" was carefully defined.
woodandsteel··on Why Do People Stay Poor? [pdf]
>Some people are poor because of their habits and inclinations and they just don't change those habits (for one reason or another), so they stay poor.

That's true. But often the reason they have those bad habits is they were taught them by the environment that, through no choice of their own, they were born in.

woodandsteel··on The Khmer Rouge: Genocide in the Name of Utopia (2016)
So it looks like I was wrong.

Thank you very much, that's just what I was looking for.

woodandsteel··on The Electric Car Atop Europe’s Sales Charts Isn’t a Tesla or VW
The Zoe has a short range in part because when it was first designed batteries were relatively low in power density and very high in prices. When batteries improved on both of these, the range was upgraded.

Battery density and prices are going to continue to improve, and so we can expect the Zoe will be upgraded in the future. And the battery progress means that larger and longer-range cars will become affordable to a broader public in Europe and elsewhere.

woodandsteel··on The Khmer Rouge: Genocide in the Name of Utopia (2016)
Ok, we agree that Leninism leads to oppression. My point is that, as far as I can tell, Chomsky doesn't agree, and the same is true of many on the left. And that this is why he took the position he did on Cambodia, and why so many defend him.

Let me say some about where I am coming from. I have been interested in these issues since the late 1950's. At the time the left was split over Stalin and the Soviet Union. Many of them said they were wonderful. Many others said they were terrible, and this was the inevitable result of leninist philosophy.

Later like with Solzinitzen, it became impossible to defend Stalin. So many on the left switched to arguing that leninism could turn out fine, and it had gone badly in this case because the leaders had fallen away from good communist principles. It seems to me that this is Chomsky's position, and many on the left who defend him.

But you seem to be a lot more familiar with Chomsky than I am. So let me ask you, what is his position on leninism?

woodandsteel··on A Dark Consensus About Screens and Kids Begins to Emerge in Silicon Valley
This is behind a paywall and so I can't read it.

I think HN should have a rule that any link that is behind a paywall cannot be posted unless a way around the paywall is provided.

woodandsteel··on The Khmer Rouge: Genocide in the Name of Utopia (2016)
Leninism has always lead to great oppression. But that doesn't mean that the people who supported it understood that. Lot of bright, well-meaning people have philosophical, political and religious beliefs that are very wrong. Also, remember, we are not just talking about Lenin's own motives and beliefs, but many if not most of the thousands of party members who supported Leninism. Most of them were sincere idealists (which is why Stalin got rid of them all in the Moscow purge trials).T

I strongly disagree that only the bourgeoisie would be opposed. Leninist revolutions take place in preindustrialized societies. That is because Lenin believed that peasants were naturally cooperative and so would eagerly adopt socialism (he got this from the Russian philosophy of narodnikism).

But that is simply mistaken. Peasants are deeply conservative and traditional, including being completely embedded in extended kinship networks, raised to value life as a farmer, and extremely religious.

Communism in a preindustrial society means tearing that whole culture completely apart, and that requires enormous state violence. Yes, a lot of them got fooled by propaganda for a while, especially before the revolution was over, but many more in Russia were never won over, and many of the ones who had supported it changed their minds once they saw it in practice.

And in fact I have read that once the Communists came to power in Russia, Lenin regularly denounced, in private, the peasants for their resistance.

So what I am saying is that leninists are generally well-meaning, intelligent people who sincerely believe it will lead to a socialist paradise, but leninism's ideas, when you try to put them in practice in a preindustrial society invariably lead to massive state violence.

woodandsteel··on How you 'attach' to people may explain a lot about your inner life
The reason that the article doesn't go into that sort of thing is it was written for the general public. I am not expert in this area. I do know that over the years I have read a great many articles for the general public that refer to scientific study of infant-mother interaction. If you are seriously interested, do some research and read up about it.

Let me add that, I do understand that people in the therapy field often make claims that are unsupported by scientific research, and so I can understand that you are suspicious in this case. But this field is different, there is lots of sound research.

woodandsteel··on Siberian heatwave of 2020 almost impossible without climate change
Not just pipelines, but roads, foundations of buildings, storage tanks, and so on. And don't forget that oil prices are low and will get lower as the world transitions to renewable energy, so there is no money to pay for fixing all this.

Putin bet the economy on fossil fuel extraction, and as a consequence Russia is basically screwed over the long run.

woodandsteel··on How you 'attach' to people may explain a lot about your inner life
Very detailed observation, in particular using video tapes.
woodandsteel··on How you 'attach' to people may explain a lot about your inner life
The question here is infant and child psychology, and for that you need direct observation. Freud didn't do this, and he came up with an infant psychology that in key ways was simply wrong. The same is true of Lacan. Klein was a step in the direction.

Part of the problem is that the needed scientific methods did not exist. But in recent decades they have been developed, and so we now have a vastly better understanding. And that in turn has enormous implications for psychotherapy.

As to neuropsychology, I am not familiar with that field, so my question is what does it have to say about infant psychology.

woodandsteel··on How you 'attach' to people may explain a lot about your inner life
Peer relations are very important. But from what I recall, that book doesn't really address what the article is about, partly because many of the developments took place after it was written.

And by the way, are you saying that, if you were a man married to a woman and you had children, you wouldn't be bothered if she was insensitive or abusive with them, because it would have no long-term effects on their personalities?

woodandsteel··on How you 'attach' to people may explain a lot about your inner life
That's quite true. However, the article doesn't describe parents as such, it describes the actually style of parenting that took place, whatever were the reasons things went that way rather than another.
woodandsteel··on How you 'attach' to people may explain a lot about your inner life
Yes, you might call this the psychoanalytic idea of transference. However, the psychoanalytic understanding of infant psychology, and the infant-mother relationship, is radically different from the one presented here. Furthermore, Freud developed his ideas in this area by a very indirect method, and before any real scientific investigation had been done. In recent decades a great deal of research has now been done, and it has made clear the Freudian view was quite mistaken.
woodandsteel··on How you 'attach' to people may explain a lot about your inner life
As the article makes clear, it is not just general good feelings, but the specific, back-and-forth interactions between the therapist and the patient.
woodandsteel··on How you 'attach' to people may explain a lot about your inner life
I have worked in psychotherapy research. One way the possibility you raise is dealt with is by comparing what goes on in successful therapy with what goes on in unsuccessful therapy.
woodandsteel··on The Khmer Rouge: Genocide in the Name of Utopia (2016)
Part 2 (sorry, the order is fouled up here)

Ok, with respect to your views, I think I can narrow it down to a single question. I said that Marxism-Leninism has goals that can be achieved only through a great deal of violence against the population, and as a consequence whenever Marxist-Leninists come to power, this is what they practice.

That means that even if a Marxist-Leninist party came to power that was headed by a basically good person, and was not threatened externally, it would still behave quite oppressively toward its population.

My question is, do you agree that due to the nature of its basic goals, Marxist-Leninist regimes must be so oppressive?

woodandsteel··on The Khmer Rouge: Genocide in the Name of Utopia (2016)
Ok, I'm back. I've been thinking about this, and I think it would be best if I presented my own ideas in a more organized form, and then said what I think you are saying, and ask some questions.

So here is how I look at things To start out, dictatorships vary greatly in how cruel and oppressive they are. And how oppressive they are is greatly determined by whether or not they are ideological. The non-ideological dictatorships are often less violent, while the ones that are ideologically revolutionary invariably are very oppressive.

The reason is they have different sorts of goals. Non-ideological dictators just want to stay in power and make use of the state for their own benefit. To achieve this they only need to eliminate and suppress any political opposition, through means such as jail, execution, and controlling the media. The rest of the society they leave as it is.

On the other hand, revolutionary ideological dictatorships want to radically change the whole culture and society, top to bottom. The problem is that invariably a large portion of the population is opposed to this, to the bottom of their souls.

So the regime has to resort to extreme measures, like endless propaganda, and violence such as execution, imprisonment, labor camps, and starvation, and aimed at large portions of the public. The idea is to eliminate opponents (Stalin: "Man is a problem. No man, no problem") and terrorizing everyone else.

Now Marxism-Leninism is such a radical philosophy, and so whenever Marxist-Leninists come to power, they invariably resort to all these extreme measures. Yes it matters that they come to power generally through violent revolution. And yes it matters that they face military threats. But the heart of the matter is that they have ideological goals that can only be achieved by great violence against their people.

And this means that the personality of the leader, like Lenin's ambition, is not what is key here. A leader who was basically a good person but believed in Marxism-Leninism would still have to follow similar policies. Most radical Islamic terrorists for instance, sincerely want to do what they think is good for the world, the problem is their ideology and what it clearly requires.

One more point. Marxist-Leninist regimes differ in how extreme their ideologies are, and that considerably effects how violent they are.

Now I apply all that to the case of the Pol Pot regime, and it was Marxist-Leninist, and so I think one could have predicted with certainty from the begining that it would be violent. And it had an extreme form of Marxism-Leninism, so one would expect it to be very high in violence.

End part 1

woodandsteel··on The Khmer Rouge: Genocide in the Name of Utopia (2016)
That's good to know.
woodandsteel··on SpaceX successfully catches both fairing for the first time
That was the original plan. But according to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vulcan_Centaur they went ahead without funding it, though they may some time in the future. So for now Vulcan is going to have a disposable first stage, just like all the other old-time space rockets.
woodandsteel··on The Khmer Rouge: Genocide in the Name of Utopia (2016)
Sorry I haven't responded. I've been busy. I plan to respond tomorrow
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →