HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

woodandsteel

1,921 karma · joined January 8, 2016

submissionscomments
woodandsteel··on New Cobalt-free Li-ion battery reduces costs with similar design and performance
>One could equally argue that the fact we don't have a million mile battery already suggests that there may be intractible problems to solve.

That would be a good argument if batteries had been stuck for decades at a much lower limit. But the fact is their lifetime has been steadily increasing, and will reach a million miles within a few years at most.

woodandsteel··on Poorest Americans drink a lot more sugary drinks than the richest
You don't offer any other approach. So I am going to assume you probably think soda drinking is a good thing, but don't want to come right out and say it.
woodandsteel··on The Keynesian Revolution: A new biography of John Maynard Keynes
>We would still have had the Great Depression, and we would have gotten the political disaster then.

I hate to say it, but I have to admit you are probably right.

woodandsteel··on New Cobalt-free Li-ion battery reduces costs with similar design and performance
One of the many mistaken arguments of the fossil fuels forever crowd is that if there is anything wrong today with ff replacements, we can be absolutely certain technology will never in the future correct it.
woodandsteel··on Changing the way you sit could add years to your life
I think HN should have a rule that no paywalled link be published unless a way around the paywall is provided.
woodandsteel··on The Keynesian Revolution: A new biography of John Maynard Keynes
Your point that the French were taking the Realist position re: the German problem makes a whole lot of sense to me.

But what about Keynes idea that Europe as a whole was in economic ruin and it was necessary to rebuild it with economic aid or it would lead to political disaster. He seems to be to have been right about that.

woodandsteel··on The New Siberians
Whether or not the heat record is as extreme as presented, the fact is the arctic is getting warmer twice as fast as the world as a whole. And that is leading to huge changes, most notably permafrost melting, which has all sorts of consequences like destroying infrastructure on a massive scale.
woodandsteel··on The Khmer Rouge: Genocide in the Name of Utopia (2016)
Thank you for replying. I think a lot about these issues, but I haven't really talked with someone on the left about them.

Let me see if I understand what you are saying. First of all, I get the impression you are a democratic socialist. Is that right? And I take it part of the reason is that you see violent revolution as at least very often leading to oppressive regimes. On that I agree.

Ok, now that being the case, I say Chomsky should have predicted this for Cambodia, but he didn't. And that would seem to indicate that he disagreed with people like you on the idea that violent revolution leads to oppression.

And if that is true, then I think people on the democratic left who respond to Chomsky ought to make clear that he was wrong on the question of violent revolution and oppression. But I have read lots of things by leftists about Chomsky, and I don't think I have ever seen one that said that.

Maybe they are out there, but the left is sure not communicating this idea to people in the public who don't read leftist literature, but do run across lots of things by leftists in forums that reach a larger public.

So first let me ask you, am I right that Chomsky apparently disagrees with you on the strong connection between violent revolution and political oppression?

And if I am, would agree you that when the democratic left is communicating with the larger public about Chomsky, one of the things they should do is make clear that he is wrong about this? And if you disagree, then why not?

woodandsteel··on The Khmer Rouge: Genocide in the Name of Utopia (2016)
I started this discussion about Marxism-Leninism because I believe that Marxist-Leninist countries invariably turn brutal, for various reasons (and you seem to basically agree with me). That being the case, Chomsky should have assumed from the beginning that reports that Cambodia was brutal were probably accurate, and I assume he didn't because he has some mistaken ideological beliefs. And that being the case people should not be defending him.

I think this is part of a much larger problem. I think everyone should have an understanding of Marxism-Leninism and what is right or wrong about it. One of many reasons everyone needs to understand Marxism-Leninism is that China continues to be considerably influenced by it.

I am in my 70's, and it used to be a fair amount of the population had this understanding, but nowadays very few people do. This has happened partly because the left, both pro-and anti-communist, has basically stopped explaining it to people. One consequence is mistakenly defending people like Chomsky when they go wrong due to poor ideological understanding.

I think there are various reasons the left has stopped explaining Marxism-Leninism, but I think it is very unfortunate and am angry at them for this, and I take every opportunity to explain it, and in fact I am planning on someday writing an article on it.

Let me add it's nice to talk to someone who understands these issues far better than most people do.

woodandsteel··on Minimum wage workers cannot afford rent in any U.S. state
Oh you have to be kidding. I grew up in the 50's, and things are so much more difficult for young people today. If they are in the upper quarter of society they have to compete so much harder, and if they are below that they are so much less likely to have a good job, like the secure, union factory jobs that were so common. And besides that education has gotten vastly more expensive, and so has housing in much of the country, and also health care. And then there was the great recession of 2007. There are so many young people today who are doing worse than there parents.
woodandsteel··on The Khmer Rouge: Genocide in the Name of Utopia (2016)
Thank you for giving an answer. But you know, the original idea of Marxism was that the revolution would take place in the advanced industrial states, which have the greatest military power and so would not face this sort of threat.

But when that failed to happen Lenin switched to the idea of revolution in preindustrial nations, which would lack that military strength. He predicted this would be safe for Russia because imperialism had run out of options and would collapse in the great war, and then revolution in the advanced nations would take place and protect Russia. And then when that failed to happen he was stuck with socialism in one country, but decided to go ahead anyway, with the predictable result that it came under military threat first from the fascists and then the capitalist countries.

In the case of China and Cambodia, military threat was predictable from the beginning.

So what is your scenario? Is it to wait around for the revolution to finally takes place in the advanced nations? And what about Trotsky's argument that Democratic centralism inevitably leads to dictatorship?

Also, since you defended Chomsky, does he ever directly discuss Marxism-Leninism? My impression is that he is not one, and if that is the case why did he think that M-L regimes might turn out good?

woodandsteel··on The Khmer Rouge: Genocide in the Name of Utopia (2016)
Yes, they were. What I am saying is they were that because they were Marxist-Leninists. Pol Pot and Mao started out as Marxist-Leninists and that lead them to establish military dictatorships. That set of prior ideological ideas leads inevitably to that sort of situation.

One reason I think it is important to stress this is that defenders of Marxism-Leninism say that regimes like this went bad because they fell away from Marxist-Leninist values, which implies it could have gone better, but I say the ideology always leads to that result.

So let me ask you, do you disagree? Do you think it is possible for a Marxist-Leninist regime to turn out good?

woodandsteel··on Minimum wage workers cannot afford rent in any U.S. state
The promise of the free market economy is that the standard of living keeps improving over time, and that includes housing. For probably a majority of the population of the US, that has not been the case for a number of decades.
woodandsteel··on ARM licensing fee increase could drive some customers to competitors
So private equity is going to ruin yet another successful company?
woodandsteel··on The Khmer Rouge: Genocide in the Name of Utopia (2016)
What is your own overall view of the Khmer Rouge, and ditto Mao? And have your views changed over time?

Let me say where I am coming from here. The Khemer Rouge and Mao had in common certain ideas. They were for socialism, and they were for achieving it through violent revolution. They believed in the Leninist ideas of vanguardism and party centralization. And they believed that it was possible to take a preindustrial country directly to industrialization and then anarchistic socialism without first having to go through a liberal, capitalist phase.

I think these ideas are mistaken, and whenever they have been tried the result has been a horror. And it is for that reason the Pol Pot and Maoist regimes were so brutal. So my question to you is, what do you think of these ideas?

woodandsteel··on New Leaks of the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Nano
I would much rather someone made a laptop with a keyboard with sculptured keys and reasonably full key travel. I would be glad to lose a pound of lightness for that.
woodandsteel··on A Famous Harvard Professor Became a Target over His Tweets
Cancel culture people do not believe in freedom of speech. They do not believe in free and open debate.

The cancel culture people have a set of views on topics such as race. They further believe that every institution should have an elaborate, harshly enforced set of rules that forbids and punishes anyone who expresses contrary views.

My question to you is, do you believe it would be good for institutions to have such a set of rules?

woodandsteel··on How companies became addicted to debt
Thank you, that's a very interesting comment.
woodandsteel··on How companies became addicted to debt
This is a very informative article, but it has one major deficiency.

I have a general rule that when we are looking at something going bad in our country, one of the things to do is look at how the issue is handled in other countries, like are they doing it better or worse, and what can we learn from that that might help us decide what to do here.

With that in mind, the article should have covered how this whole corporate debt issue is handled in other countries. Are they doing better or worse? Perhaps someone who has some knowledge here could make a comment.

woodandsteel··on How companies became addicted to debt
From what I understand, the basic problem is this. The way things are supposed to work is corporations take their profits and divide them up in two ways. Part goes to paying the owners, like dividends to stockholders. Part goes in investing in the future, like research and building factories.

The problem is that for a long time a large proportion of companies have been paying out an increasing portion of their profits to pay off massive and ever increasing debts. They still keep paying profits to the owners, and so they have ever less left for investing in improving the company. That in turn means poor growth and being less competitive in world markets.

And even worse when the economy goes through a bad period, many thousands of companies can no longer pay their huge debts and go bankrupt, with great damage to the economy.

woodandsteel··on Cutlet: A Japanese to Romaji Converter in Python
I'm an American and a few years ago I started getting into Japanese musicians (Senri Kawaguchi, Kanade Sato, Yoyoka Soma, Rie Suzaku, Juna Serita and others). This got me into reading a little about how the Japanese write and it's crazy.

They have four different systems. There is Kangi which is from Chinese. There are two different systems that are phonetic but based on syllables rather than single sounds. And finally they use the Roman script like we do. It must be really hard on the elementary school kids who are trying to learn this all.

woodandsteel··on The World Can’t Take Much More Shale Gas
Thank you.

I think HN should have a rule that no paywalled link be published without including an alternative.

woodandsteel··on How to become a Bayesian (2016)
Thank you for the explanation.
woodandsteel··on Tesla’s Stock Keeps Going Up
History shows again and again that where there is a major technological transformation in an industry, some or all of the incumbents fail to make the change, and some of the major powers afterwards are new companies.

Also, Tesla is getting pretty good at manufacturing, and steadily getting better. It is turning out many more cars than it did a few years ago, and has good profit margins. It has also learned to build factories and get them into production much faster than any of the old companies can.

And no, it is not a commodity race-to-the-bottom when the technology is continually improving at a rapid pace. Someday it will be, but that is decades from now.

So instead of trying to figure out why Toyota will clobber Tesla, you should be trying to guess which companies today are doing a good job of positioning themselves for the big change, and which are not. Among the old companies, VW is doing a great job, Toyota is so far so-so.

You know, that sort of "we are the biggest so we can't fail" mentality is the key reason companies fail to make big technology transitions.

woodandsteel··on Japan's Love of Face Masks
I first learned about this when I saw a youtube video of a music performance at a mall, and some of the people walking by were wearing face masks. Some commenters asked what was going on, and other commenters explained how the Japanese love to wear them. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xDAjGv5Cwc
woodandsteel··on Facebook boycott leaders ‘disappointed’ after meeting with Zuckerberg, Sandberg
The thing you have to keep in mind about corporations is that, unlike human beings, they lack consciences, at least most of them. They may say they have them, but for various reasons this is usually not at all true.

As a consequence, corporations do whatever will maximize their size and profitability, and are entirely indifferent as to whether what they do is good or bad for the society as a whole.

Now in the case of Facebook that means following policies that at least in some very important ways are quite bad for the world. That is the very nature of its business model. Furthermore I can't think of any way external pressure or governmental laws could seriously change that, so we need to be looking for alternatives.

woodandsteel··on How to become a Bayesian (2016)
About 40 years ago I was reading a business mathematics book and ran across a section that, as I recall, started out with a basic probabilities equation and derived the basic Bayesian equation in one step.

Am I remembering this right? If so could someone post it?

woodandsteel··on Tesla’s Stock Keeps Going Up
Tesla's price seems crazy, but it's not. In the coming few years the market for ev's is going to skyrocket, and the market for ice's is going to start to collapse.

There are several reasons this will happen. For one, global climate change will continue to get worse, so governments are going to keep pushing harder promoting ev's. Secondly, the number of available public charging stations is going to continue to go up. Thirdly people will become more familiar with ev's and realize a lot the ideas about them they have been fed by ice promoters are false.

Finally there is cost. Ev's are already cheaper in overall operating expense. In the next few years falling battery prices will start to make them as cheap in sticker price.

So there is a technological revolution coming. In the last year or so many of the legacy auto manufacturers have realize this, and have gone into high gear working on ev's. A flood of new models is coming onto the market.

The problem is demand is going to outrun production for many years, partly due to battery shortages, and so the companies like Tesla that have lots of ev production place are going to prosper, and those that don't are going to go out of business.

Beyond that, Tesla is also in solar and energy storage, and it is about to get into li-ion cell production. Now there is no way to be sure how things are going to go, but Tesla is clearly one of the companies to bet on.

woodandsteel··on Walmart’s Amazon Prime competitor will launch in July
For many years I shopped once a month at the local Walmart, mostly groceries.

Now we have the coronavirus. There is no home delivery from the store. I would like to do pickup from there, but almost nothing I would buy is available for that. I would have to shop in person, and I am not going to do that.

So I buy all that food elsewhere, even though it costs more. They are losing a lot of money on me, and don't seem to care.

woodandsteel··on Tesla’s SA big battery just got 50% bigger after goals thanks to Autobidder
Right. Because these utilities have, as Ruban says, "political and budget power" they are fat and happy, and don't bother with engineering innovation.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →