2,631 karma · joined July 5, 2010
In other words, superintelligence often referred to as AGI might either be months away or just VC-Money induced cult-speak many fall victim to.
It doesn’t matter because the only certainty is that it’s not here now, and neither tomorrow etc.
"15% of a distressed key industry player" is a completely different ballgame than being an actual SOE, with insane amounts of subsidies let alone absense of any red-tape for these party-run corporations, and a market that forces foreign car manufacturers to set-up shop as a "joint-venture" were the "joint" is more akin to being sucked out, never allowed to be more than 49% owned by the foreign company and a general impossibility (unless you do some HK trickery) to transfer any profits made in China out of China.
What you are doing is not just intellectual dishonest, not just whataboutism, it is comparing apples with oranges.
Edit: And we haven'T even begun discussing the glaringly state promoted IP-theft.
But what annoys me the most about the article is this constant praise of „China Speed“, Cost-Advantages and Love of the Free Market, as if not every single Chinese Automaker, including its Suppliers down to the tiniest screw is a State owned entity, massively subsidized and in general part of a rigged market.
This is not to take from the accomplishments of the Chinese, but a major part of the last 30+ years of development is just massive screwing and exploiting the western open market and its companies. Yeah, we’ve not forgotten the droves of people blatantly stealing IP on every trade show imaginable and a state completely absent from enforcing IP when ever another Chinese car is dropped to the market that looks 100% like a Benz, Porsche or Land Rover.
> It's a cool legal structure
No it’s not cool at all that you have to double down on the Byzantine-ness to get a reasonable amount of taxation, „investsbility“ and limited liability. Especially for digital products.
> eating your cake and having it too
This is so typical of our country, the passive aggressive condemnation of founders as greedy, and selfish to even desire fewer taxes and limited liability.
Well if in a couple of years all the German Blue Chips will celebrate their bicentennials, while all the moonshots are LLM-oneshotted outside of Germany, not even talking about „normal“ incorporations: who is going to finance our vast welfare state? Speaking about
> eating your cake and having it too
The thought of all that regulatory hassle you have to go through in Germany compared to those superniche ideas you would try out in our AI days, makes me weep [1].
I wonder if the gap we‘ve already saw in the last 20 years between EU and US in terms of tech success stories is just the tip of the iceberg of what’s to come.
[1] notary costs (every visit ~400€ like changing your address or business scope), registry costs (also for every address and business scope change), hiring a tax attorney to produce compliant balance sheets (2,000 - 3,000 € /year), multiple types of yearly, quarterly, and monthly tax filings (tax attorney 150-300€/ month), different taxes which will be collected federally and locally, mandatory membership in Commerce Chambers (~350€/year), legal requirement to have a „business bank account“ (here at least today there are some startups making this easier and somewhat cheaper), mandatory membership at a trade-coop (yes it costs money), public health insurers in your neck nagging you to find some legal trap you stumbled into to extract bankrupting amounts of premiums from you, same with the state pension program. And just because you close down, it doesn’t just stop (you have operate the GmbH for years after before it gets deleted, so you pay money for years after still). Then there is the Exit Tax, which on the rare case you were successful locks you into Germany forever (unless again you pay professionals insane amounts of money).
So this leaves you and your kindergarten-Management-slash-Single-parent-CRM vibe coding idea easily with effectively 500-1000 €/month just to deal with red tape.
But it’s not just the money, each of these points I listed are just sources of endless amounts of paperwork with people/Organisations that know they don’t have to respect you or care about you at all to extract money from you.
And no, UG is not helping at all because still exactly the same GmbH red tape applies. And I am 65% certain the proposed EU Incs will - in Germany - be not exempt from this.
And while Vienna or Stockholm are often cited as Utopias, the citees often intentionally leave out the negative side effects (ie. Waiting-times of years, housing black markets, etc) that are eventually coming full circle to the thing they were proposed as a solution against. Just with much less transparency.
There have been social housing projects that paint a more nuanced picture, eg Hamburg-Steilshoop, where a giant block (for EU standards) has been erected in the 1970s and was basically divided into three sections: one to be run by existing housing coops, one by owner occupants, and one by the city. Needless to say that those parts run by the city were quickly becoming a prime example of a German „banlieue“ while the other parts became a prime example for those eager to dismiss any criticisms.
Opened the page, first entry: „white supremacist dogwhistle“
One can’t make this much diversity and humaneness up.
Yes, their frontpage overall seems normal and you probably meant well, but that this is their first entry is just hilarious.
Don’t mistake your curiosity for everyone else’s
With all that being said, I still think that overreliance on tourism is bad for a place in principle. Those places fossilize, the wealth of tourists overwhelmes local culture, it will create wrong incentives, draw in junk vendors, pick-pocketers, and AirBnB vultures making life more miserable for the locals. One can also be certain that the local hospitality operators will try to pass the least possible amount to locals by finding even cheaper employees from god knows where.
Till this day I remember this fondly as it gave me so much ease of control of the application’s many complex states. Especially when I nowadays deal with all sorts of false-prophets in forms of hooks and what ever reactive primitive du-jour (don’t get Me wrong they are 80% of the time the better choice, it’s just that they don’t scale).
What’s today’s version of complex state management in Angular-Land?
Nothing, absolutely nothing do we have to adjust to America, neither up or downwards.
That being said, and as much as I think Mamdani is an Ideologue, taxing second, unoccupied homes sounds absolutely reasonable (at least if they aren't rented out). Expect all kinds of shenanigans to circumvent this, but still.
I'm sure many of those tokens are gone by now. While the Poles I've worked with are on average very capable and driven, there is also the bigger picture: That they have a national ambition.
Can only guess, but it seems they know that Poland must outperform its biggest two neighbours (DE & RUS) in order to retain their freedom. Given the current state of these neighbours this fear may seem to be blown out of propotions, but history is the better guide here.
Given that ambition I would guess the population is less devided on economic and trade issues, specifically with regards to Europe/International. The need to join the Euro is certainly less present there and in hindsight might be another part of Poland's success.
Poland tries to be a serious nation at least. Which can't be said about Germany and its self-inflicted demise on almost every measruable front, ie the woke mind virus.
Fun fact: German IT magazine Heise in light of the sluggish German job market recently published an article about moving abroad for jobs, ie. to Poland https://www.heise.de/ratgeber/Auswandern-nach-Polen-Was-ITle...
Don’t know why but this has so many upvotes, so I want to be clear: by „social sciences“ I‘ve meant the toxic „science“ disseminating from US social sciences departments colloquially referred to as „Wokeness“ which intra-US might be shrugged off as coping mechanism for mentally ill Ivy League members, but outside the US just comes down to outright cultural imperialism.
Furthermore at current projections, the speed at which MAGA is imploding, those who still make the migration won’t be the ones fleeing „persecution“ but rather „market forces“
This is in part to blame on that book, but also on the socioeconomic class that is omnipresent in our publisher‘s editing boards. As study after study has shown German journalists are 4 times as likely to vote for the Greens as the normal population.
> We decide something, then put it in the room and wait some time to see what happens. If there is no big shouting and no uprisings, because most do not understand what it is about, then we continue - step by step until there is no turning back. – Jean Claude Juncker, then President of the EU Commission
They will try this again. And again. And again. They will never stop.
They are not your friends.
And I would argue also that this scarcity of ability was already a problem for the last 100 years. The whole iterative process of ideation (ie. designing, sketching) gets so much less intuitive, if one has to pull out a ruler first, or boot up his machine.
While I can't say whether Bauhaus and subsequent modern styles are to blame, with their reductionist philosophies, or rather the lack of ability of the professionals driving "style" into that direction, it surely does rhyme with the general population's perception of modern architecture being faceless, and indistinguishable, boxes.
After all, none of our modern building's first designs consist of strokes that came from the rich muscle memory of a human arm. At best they came from arms with almost none.
The state of affairs is so bitter, often the buildings perceived to be the most creative ones of this era are most often results of letting some `Math.random()` on a PC do the drawing.
If I had to count one positive thing about being a graffiti "artist" since youth it's that you constantly practicing shapes and the perceived emotional impacts of even tiniest adjustments all embedded in your muscle memory. Once you gained that skill, no design tool can beat that ideation process. Not with a stylus, not with ai. Even the ms between a stylus's input until it appears on-screen are blocking you, the misalignment of the stylus's tip to where the drawn line appears, let alone the seconds++ an AI takes to turn your prompt into an image.
In dev-speak, removing hand-drawing from the skill set of architects entirely is as if you were deliberately removing HMR from your local web dev-setup.
I would thus argue the opposite: Architects badly need to draw more!
So like instead of hiring by merit doing it via DEI?