2,232 karma · joined October 8, 2013
hn (at) rtoip (dot) com
It is a lot of land occupied by a very recource hungry industry and less efficient industry e.g. you need 100x more water to make animal protein when compared to plant protein. We use 25% of our freshwater consumption for animal protein production - not even mentioning other recourses. With a growing number of people on the planet, efficiency is key.
The challenges in the alt.ag. sector lie in the development of mass production technology. From the side of the market, consumers need an extra benefit (animal cruelty free products are not enough) in order to be converting. Outside of the startups, the time to maturity is hypothesized to be 5-15 years.
Tyson is a very forward looking company, very much worried about the future of protein food supply. I had the pleasure of meeting some of their folks, and at least the top level very well outlined the problems we are going to face.
Current business model in the sector is focused on high volume production with strong attrition, little regard to animal ethics (low regulations) and consolidation among manufacturers.
Just the numbers make me shudder:
* Livestock produces 18% of greenhouse emissions
* Feed animals occupy 70% of arable land on our planet.
With the classic animal protein supply chain being almost max'ed out in terms of capacity (and energy+matter conversion effiency), we have some grim perspectives here.
Disclaimer: I work in the alt tag tech startup sector.
Disclaimer: Have seen both the IT/CS and biotech side of things.
What are your reference points here? Would love to hear other recommendations of yours.
* With a of noteworthy/critical tech sector
I still run a MS OS from time to time: Windows 7, for some legacy software, well confined in a virtual box.
Linux is an alternative the days, both for individuals and companies.
DrRacket seems to be a refreshing alternative.
In Poland it is still called Małpa, which means monkey.
"Kim Jong Un, Chairman of the Workers' Party of Korea, Chairman of the State Affairs Commission of the DPRK and Supreme Commander of the Korean People's Army, visited the Sohae Space Centre to inspect the ground jet test of a new type high-power engine of a carrier rocket for the geo-stationary satellite."
It sounds really hilarious, but it reminds me of the soviet era in the Warsaw Pact member states. Poor citizens. We are so lucky to have a degree of control over our supreme leadership..
I am a big fan of this technology [1], and still hope that it will be more wide spread among citizens in a secure form. Like freedom of speech, information security is definitely an important pillar of the modern state and empowers citizens. Unfortunately, all attempts to introduce it to the masses and get it right from the security point of view have failed so far.
It is a tough balancing act to get right [2]: freedom, convenience, safety - you seemingly can only have two of them.
[1] e.g. in the form of https://www.gnupg.org/
[2] https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2010/11/dan_geer_on_c...
There are many startup endeavours that aim to use tech for the better of our ecosystem e.g. all the startups affiliated with the New Harvest Community (http://new-harvest.org).
This question is spot on. We have this planet, our habitat, in our hands. Overexploition of natural recources can bring our ecosystem in dire straits, and us with it. We can loose so much. About time to use technology to change this. And about time to change out behaviour en masse.
1) A PhD is a very personal experience, but hard work is the common denominator.
2) The article is off - very much because there is a multitude of outcomes when it comes to personal development during a PhD.
We are still far away from the comprehension of state, or even computuation in living tissue. The technology underlying silicium based computers is quite primitive compared to biologics. Certainly - these are interesting thoughts in theory - but for the sake of science communications with the general public I am very careful in what context and what way I would articulate these concepts.
Animal welfare, and the health of ecosystems, is definitely another minefield of a discussion.
Don't forget, human brains are squishy, too, and there are many more of them!
Sarcasm off
Not sure if your comment meant to be provocative, or if you just did not think through the ethical considerations of your statement. In fact, I am not sure how well protected octupus as a species are, since they lack a spine.
The cold war was messed up in so many ways. It reminds me these developments.
The type of people that advocate such nationalistic projects in favour of international, peaceful and reasonable exploitation should be removed from power.
Panel on Conservation through Technology, New Harvest Conference.
[2] www.pembient.com, http://twitter.com/pembient; Biotech Startup.
> So all the rest (economic devastation, EU disintegration, counterproductive attitudes) might be exactly [...]
I doubt that one can draw a straight line from the outcome of the referendum to a fatalistic, self destructive attitude of the population of the UK. There are many factors at play here - protest votes against the political establishment, general abstinence, phobia against EU bureaucracy, nationalistic tendencies et cetera. I am not in the picture here, since I have never lived long enough in the UK to understand the tendencies at hand.
> perhaps democracy isn't really your preferred form of government.
I will not comment on that apart from the remark that every form of human government has its suboptimal characteristics. Democracy is not such a bad solution - apart from the fact when it fails.
All in all, again, the EU will survive the BREXIT, albeit it will take damage. The UK might not.
On the other hand, what if the electorate did not vote out of protest, was misinformed by the politicians or media, or simply not educated enough to make the proper choice? Apart from the shocking failure of an established western democracy to make a good economical and political choice, what are the consequences at stake here?
For our startup, for instance, it means that we considered dropping potential R&D partners from the UK. For the UK economy, the consequences might be devastating.
In general, I am all for removing UK's special privileges, and their counterproductive attitude towards the EU. But I also do not want to see them go. The EU would loose a member state, and the UK might desintegrate (Northern Ireland and Scotland sure want to stay in the EU!).
In a way, a clean way to do it would to be a call for elections, and a proper mandate - either to stay in, or stay out. But that might not happen, considering the nature of the political game.
I agree about the reasons to worry, and to have a proper discussion. Things tend to get out of hand sometimes when it comes to media.
As such, there is a lot of fuss and hot air about things that will possibly not materialize. Not to mention all those speculative business affairs..
Could you point me to some of these essays? I would like to have a look at them.