HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wutbrodo

8,628 karma · joined March 27, 2012

submissionscomments
wutbrodo··on Cinema’s greatest scene: ‘Casablanca’ and ‘La Marseillaise’ (2015)
> it seems irrelevant to predict the results of hypothetical ones.

It's probably not difficult to understand, by analogy to things that you might be passionate about. I have zero interest in professional sports, but it's clear to me that hypotheticals like this are a way to motivate deeper structural thinking about your perception of the quality and strategy of given teams. You already have an intimate understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of your team in the context of their modern competitors. The thought experiment of pitting them against the challenge of historical teams can easily deepen your understanding of them.

Hell, you don't even need the idea of "fun" to explain this. The concept of a thought experiment is widely, almost universally useful. I might have a blindspot due to working in research, but it's my impression that modeling hypotheticals that are impossible is a fundamental skill for creative work.

wutbrodo··on Glassdoor not so anonymous
Sure, I agree there's an incentive force pushing scores up. I was responding to a comment asking what possible countervailing force could push scores towards accuracy. The answer is pretty obvious, as the yelp reductio ad absurdum shows.
wutbrodo··on An installation-art company called META (or Meta.is) is suing Meta (or meta.com)
Yea, but the IG complaints are more of a moral panic than anything else, and don't come from any of the actual users. Though you're right that that feeds into the overall brand.
wutbrodo··on Tell HN: Salesforce has globally revoked Slack's holiday shutdown benefit
I find it completely plausible that some people would prefer limited PTO. My comment specifies the maximalist criticisms, which can't imagine unlimited PTO as anything but a scam.

Ive seen this a million and one times since I started working in tech, including my nontech friends being blown away by the perks of Google and concluding that they must work me like a dog (I worked a hard 35 hrs/wk at the time).

wutbrodo··on ML is not that good at predicting consumers' choices
I don't understand your comment or how it's remotely relevant to the thread. Is this just a non sequitur Luddite rant about the very existence of new tech?
wutbrodo··on Ask HN: What is the job market like for niche languages (Nim, Crystal)?
I strongly disagree. It's very visible when someone is trying to write (eg) Python in C++ or vice versa, in a way that can substantially harm readability.
wutbrodo··on ML is not that good at predicting consumers' choices
This is more of a product problem than a technological one. I don't think the issue is lack of imagination, but hostility from consumers.

There are a million and one cases where a pdocut could be 10x better with 10% more effort from me,and where that tradeoff is more than worth it (hell, it's why I use Linux). But the average consumer is aggressively turned off by having to do any "work", and the type of person hanging out on Hacker News is very high-percentile for wanting to put a nonzero amount of work into optimizing this type of thing.

wutbrodo··on Tell HN: Salesforce has globally revoked Slack's holiday shutdown benefit
Yup, this is my experience too. The maximalist complaints about unlimited PTO being a scam seem to be a mix of:

a) sour grapes

b) people being unwilling to admit that they prefer paternalism instead of being capable of making their own decisions about how to balance work and life

(FWIW for me, making my own decision looks like "4-5 wks per year, not including a handful of ad-hoc 3-day weekends throughout the yr")

wutbrodo··on Tell HN: Salesforce has globally revoked Slack's holiday shutdown benefit
FWIW, people confidently disclaiming that this is always and necessarily how unlimited PTO works are wrong (which should be obvious....). I worked at a company that was extremely intense and deadline-driven and unlimited PTO was pretty great. In the almost 4 years I was there, I took an avg of 5 wks/yr, not counting the scattered 3-4 day weekends I took throughout the year. Hell, I think there was even a policy where managers would ping employees who took less than X days/yr (this happened to me during one of the lockdown years).
wutbrodo··on An installation-art company called META (or Meta.is) is suing Meta (or meta.com)
Whatsapp is overwhelmingly popular, no? I'd guess much more so than Oculus.

And anecdotally, IG users seem to feel very positively about it in a way that isn't true for fb or Twitter users. Most of the handwringing about IG that I've seen comes from commentators

wutbrodo··on Glassdoor not so anonymous
The foundation of the site's usefulness is that the ratings have some signal. The value of job listings to a Glassdoor user is that they're from companies that Glassdoor rates as positive: an undifferentiated mass of ratings would be a completely useless site. The idea that they have no incentive to improve discriminativity (at the expense of company rating) proves way too much.

Eg by that logic, Yelp would have no incentive to allow bad reviews. Hell, they could just be a listing site that puts "5 stars (10,000 reviews)" next to every listing.

wutbrodo··on People with low BMI aren't more active, they are just less hungry, 'run hotter'
I wouldn't describe myself as actively adapting my tastes: I just ate better and eventually noticed my preferences shifting. I assume it's some combination of my brain getting more sensitive to the stimulus (of eg sugar), my gut changing, and my better diet reducing cravings.
wutbrodo··on People with low BMI aren't more active, they are just less hungry, 'run hotter'
> That's a weird judgement to throw in the midst.

Sorry, I wasn't implying anything by this. Just absent-minded phrasing.

> people have to accept that their preferences aren't always and possibly not ever going to align with healthy eating.

Sure, I think it's possible some people can't make it through the transition to healthier preferences. That doesn't suggest that the original claim in the thread is correct.

The comment you originally responded to claimed that convexfunction was "restating" the claim that weight loss is pure effortful discomfort (from the top of the thread). Your response was that you doubt that healthy food can taste as good as junk food[1]. In the comment I responded directly to, you say that having cheesecake occasionally is evidence that a healthy person eating less cheesecake comes from conscious healthy effort.

These claims are what I'm pushing back against. I use way less willpower on food now than when I was a junkier eater[2].

[1] Note that the issue here might be that your definition of weight-loss-promoting foods is askew. Steak is a pretty reasonable part of a weight-loss diet, as long as you're not mindless about the quantity. As with the cheesecake example, eating the right amount of steak is a way more pleasant experience than eating too much.

[2] though thankfully never as bad as the avg US upper-middle-class diet

wutbrodo··on People with low BMI aren't more active, they are just less hungry, 'run hotter'
> you're making the decision to NOT have cheesecake when you only kind of feel like it.

Chiming in as someone whom the GP comment resonates with: the point here is that you literally come to enjoy it less. The natural amount that you would eat isn't constrained entirely by health choices. I find finishing a single slice of cheesecake to be overwhelming: a second one would be actively unpleasant.

If you were following your assumptions here to their conclusions, you would conclude that people who eat unhealthily would eat cheesecake 24/7 if it weren't for conscious health choices. This is trivially untrue, no?

The original claim was that losing weight requires constant extra discomfort, and GP's (and my) claim is that this is false: you can move yourself (with initial discomfort) to an equilibrium that's more comfortable _and_ healthier than the status quo.

I feel the discomfort of constraining myself much less often now than I did when I ate like you. This is again trivial: if your preferences are aligned with healthy eating, you need to push against them less.

wutbrodo··on People with low BMI aren't more active, they are just less hungry, 'run hotter'
He said that he eats fewer _stereotypically_ high-reward foods because he eats other high-reward foods. How do you interpret that as equivalent to "continually decreasing comfort"?

The pt is that the reward function isn't static, and you can move yourself to an equilibrium with as much utility/comfort that is much healthier.

This has been my experience too. Eg, I'm almost a little grossed out by the proportion of refined carbs on the plates of some of my friends: not only is it unhealthy, it's the most boring part of the meal (to my palate)! And my habituation to sugar has gotten low enough that things taste much sweeter to me than they do to most people.

If anything, this has _increased_ the reward I get from eating, since their unfettered preferences need to be consciously constrained by awareness of their health, while mine line up pretty well.

wutbrodo··on Manhattan rents cross $5k threshold for first time
I've only ever heard the claim made in reference to other large cities, not suburban, rural, or exurban parts of the country.

Its trivially true that dense urban environments are going to have different baseline patterns of crime

It also seems pretty clear to me that this is the context OP was speaking in, given that almost everything else he described are features of big cities.

wutbrodo··on Uber used Greyball fake app to evade police across Europe
> New York is one of the best, but still shitty by EU standards.

If we're talking about concrete things like throughput, the MTA is one of only a few systems with round-the-clock operation, and I don't think anywhere else matches its scale and reach.

The filth of the stations are a legitimate complaint...but given that my primary interest is my transit system moving me from place to place, I'd take it over the majority of EU systems in a heartbeat.

wutbrodo··on Covid learning loss has been a global disaster
> which puts them at the same level as their global peers who went through the same thing.

What are you talking about? The headline says learning loss is a _global_ disaster. Who are the "global peers" of a population that consists of all the world's children?

wutbrodo··on SSD will fail at 40k power-on hours (2021)
Derp you are correct, sorry. Hopefully my comment is still useful for anyone who didn't know they needed smartmontools
wutbrodo··on SSD will fail at 40k power-on hours (2021)
Just FYI for anyone for whom this didn't work by default: I needed to use the --all flag with smartctl (and install smartmontools if you don't have it).
wutbrodo··on Elon’s Out
And in the example the parent comment gave: RUDY Guiliani was a US Attorney and the Associate Attorney General (third highest position in the DoJ).
wutbrodo··on Are We Wayland Yet?
Oh, wow, didn't expect it to be that straightforward haha
wutbrodo··on A billion pounds of California almonds stranded at ports amid drought
I agree, desalinization is another counterargument to the carrying capacity argument. An effectively inexhaustible source of water means that the tradeoff is primarily against economic activity, which sharply cuts against doomerist claims of land that simply can't sustain 40 million people. There are environmental costs to consider, but that's also (more?) true of temperature control in the 99% of the US that's less temperate than CA's primary population centers.
wutbrodo··on Ask HN: Why do you use a VPN?
Wow, that's wild. I'm aware that speech norms are very different in Europe vs the US. Without making any normative claims about which one is better, it's just very alien to me.
wutbrodo··on Are We Wayland Yet?
I have my qualms about Wayland, but this dashboard is quite obviously not directed at you? I don't see any suggestion that everyone should switch over now that there are a small handful of compatible apps per category.

But for someone like me, all the software I use is completely fungible except for the browser and DE, and my recent switch to Wayland could've used precisely this dashboard.

The real complaint here is that the dashboard is inaccurate, at the very least by omission. The checkbox elides the level of stability implied by "support", for software as central as Chrome

wutbrodo··on Are We Wayland Yet?
What is your blocker?I'm curious because I recently switched to swaywm to fix some screen tearing, and I'm still figuring out how ready it is for primetime. It mostly works fine, but I'm getting occasional bugs with critical software like Chrome/Brave. It's giving me a very uncomfortable Ubuntu-in-2007 feeling.

It's a testament to desktop Linux's improvement that I haven't felt that way in a decade, and have a much higher stability bar than I do for Windows or my limited Mac usage. But having my browser processes freeze once a week is well below the standards I've come to enjoy, and I'm wondering if I should just switch back to X and deal with the minor graphics hiccups.

wutbrodo··on Ask HN: Why do you use a VPN?
This was my first thought when reading OP's post. A big chunk of VPN usage is almost by definition for "nefarious" purposes. But the pt is that trusting government to reliably and morally define "nefarious" for you is incredibly foolish.
wutbrodo··on Ask HN: Why do you use a VPN?
> Or, if I want to watch Russian State controlled news, why does my government get to block it?

Woah, is this a real example? Where do you live?

wutbrodo··on A billion pounds of California almonds stranded at ports amid drought
My favorite stat from a previous drought was that the water used for _exported almonds alone_ is equivalent to the water used for Los Angeles and San Francisco.

It's ludicrous to me that people use the drought to claim that CA is in the process of hitting the limits of its population carrying capacity when we have such a pants-on-head idiotic allocation of water. As a spherical-cow thought experiment, if _banning the export of almonds_ would allow building another LA and SF, "does CA have enough water for its population" is not the right question to be asking.

wutbrodo··on With no fuel and no cash, Sri Lanka grinds to a halt
This is a very naive view of how the food economy works. It's not some Edenic paradise where everyone maintains a homestead. It's an Asian country in 2022. There are plenty of people in the countryside; though it's questionable that they can automatically feed themselves off the land).

But 25% of the population lives in Colombo alone, in a population density double that of New York City's.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →