HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

wvoq

49 karma · joined July 6, 2010

submissionscomments
wvoq··on Google reminds users to "Call Dad", makes users angry
> the OP on the ticket seems to have daddy issues.

Just bookmarking this for the next time someone insists that the folks on hacker news are an egalitarian bunch who would never tolerate casual sexism.

wvoq··on Student Loans and DOE S.W.A.T. Teams
Presumably so students will have no advance warning to flush their diplomas down the toilet.
wvoq··on Ask HN: Who is riding his weekend project straight to profitability?
It's not really as benign as you're insinuating it to be.
wvoq··on This is what it's like for an innocent man to spend thirty years in jail
First of all, I think you are conflating prior and posterior probabilities. P(brown skin | illegal) != P(illegal | brown skin). The standard for a police stop is reasonable suspicion. Do you think having brown skin in Arizona is reasonably suspicious?

But much more importantly, the statistical evidence (which you haven't shown) would only be a consideration if justice were a statistical property. But if justice were a statistical property, there should be no objection to giving police arbitrary discretion to make stops and searches, since statistically speaking it is overwhelmingly likely that a citizen chosen at random has committed some illegal act for which they have not yet been convicted. But somehow that reasoning does not seem as appealing when we are the ones staring down the barrel of it.

wvoq··on This is what it's like for an innocent man to spend thirty years in jail
Police are allowed to take into consideration factors like "race, color or national origin" when deciding whether to ask for your papers.
wvoq··on This is what it's like for an innocent man to spend thirty years in jail
You're aware that you live in a state where the police can stop you and ask for your papers if you're brown and speaking Spanish, right?
wvoq··on Space Stasis (Neal Stephenson)
When you describe rail and green energy projects as "uneconomical in the free market", are you intending to compare these projects to existing options for energy and transit like coal and cars+highways+oil?
wvoq··on How I Made It: Marissa Mayer, Google's champion of innovation and design
There was just a presumption of incompetence and an insinuation that Mayer's accomplishments are not _really_ accomplishments, without any given reason. The OP didn't state "Mayer must be incompetent because she's a woman", but that's not how sexism works--people perpetuate sexism by allowing sexist attitudes to color their judgments about the merits of individiuals, often subconsciously. Why do I think it is reasonable to ascribe sexist attitudes to the OP? Because the OP is willing to presume incompetence of an engineer a) without evidence ("I can picture it now...") and b) in the face of substantial evidence to the contrary (the alarming success of GOOG), when the only atypical characteristic of said engineer is that she's a woman.
wvoq··on How I Made It: Marissa Mayer, Google's champion of innovation and design
I can't help but notice that, with nothing in the way of demonstrable evidence, you are _presuming_ a female engineer to be incompetent and referring to her by her first name to boot. You're further implying that design is trivial work ("Okay, you can do the page layout, while we code"), subordinate to the real labor of coding. The general consensus I've surmised on HN is that design and UI are crucial for adoption; do you believe that Google's success was independent of the way that users used their product?

And if the public face of the world's most powerful search company has your imprint, isn't that _ipso facto_ evidence of merit? If design was in fact irrelevant, how could _any_ number of successful designs ever constitute evidence for the skill of the designer?

wvoq··on The Python Paradox
If you're trying to copy a non-trivial amount of code from a web page, you're doing it wrong. In 2010, I think sharing code over the internet is a solved problem.
wvoq··on ScienceLeaks
I am curious about your understanding of "the needs of the journals to make money". As I understand it, the purpose of an academic journal is to communicate new research. For about 300 years, a published print journal was about the most reasonable method of accomplishing this. Printing and shipping cost money, so a subscription model was a natural means of recuperating costs. Historically, academic journals were non-profit enterprises, and stipends were rare for the academic work involved, viz: writing, refereeing, editing, &c. Since a non-profit journal loses money on each print copy it has to produce, why shouldn't they reduce physical circulation by converting to an open-access model? The only people who stand to lose from a norm of open access are the for-profit publishing houses. Their influence on academic publishing, on the whole, has not exactly been encouraging so far.

If we can find a more efficient way to communicate research (perhaps some kind of global network of computers might do the trick?), then we should do that. We ought take no more consideration of the needs of the journals than we should for the needs of the buggy-whip makers.

wvoq··on ScienceLeaks
A data point: I have actually tried this. As a student at No Name State, I often found myself travelling to nearby Prestigious Research University for books and journals which weren't in circulation at NNS. PRU only had reciprocity agreements with other PRUs, so I couldn't ILL materials or check them out in person with my NNS card. Indeed, without a PRU ID I couldn't even enter the library except at certain designated hours, for reasons that had no discernible relation to crowding or public safety.

PRU did offer a private membership, but its annual circulation fee was in the hundreds of dollars. It was 2008, and one of the richest universities in the country wanted to charge a student--who was already enrolled in NNS down the street, hardly any kind of flight risk--the equivalent of 20 hours of labor for the privilege of reading books.

Now PRU has one of the worst academic cultures I've ever experienced or heard of, and I would be glad to learn that the state of public access to academic libraries is not so dire in general. It remains, though, that it is not always so trivially easy to do academic work at university libraries, even if you're already in "the academy".

wvoq··on The Anthropology of Hackers
Do you just not believe that there should be such a thing as anthropology?
wvoq··on A letter to my students
Cost disease.
wvoq··on ASK HN: How to be a better programmer?
>For example, if you know Java, you won't get a lot out of learning Java

Sound advice.

wvoq··on [dead]
You understand that you're assuming everyone here is a straight man, right?
← PreviousPage 2 of 2