805 karma · joined September 5, 2010
PhD Student Social Science of the Internet at Oxford (topic attainment of Critical Mass)
Homepage: http://wybowiersma.net
It should not be too hard to imagine 'implementing' it in a different way.
Such as through a specific law that required giving users access to the source code (and other freedoms, possibly extending to derivative works) if a certain piece of software were marked as Open Source (or for all software, as Stallman would probably prefer it).
(yes this might make Open Source software a less attractive alternative, as it would be competing against free as in a free lunch, but as the market-landscape would be changed in favor of FOSS production models as well, by this, and FOSS has certain benefits even if produced for a fee (ability to hire competing firms for implementing fixes and modifications), there are good reasons to assume FOSS would still flourish)
It keeps surprising me how otherwise intelligent/educated people don't see this option...
1) Moore's law holds across worlds. 2) People/beings will, for various reasons (historic, sociological, experimenting, play) want to simulate another world (at a social/molecular/submolecular, etc level). 3) If they simulate one, they'll likely do more. 4) Ergo, there will be more simulated worlds than real ones. 5) Therefore we are more likely to live in a simulated world/universe than in a first order one.
http://www.simulation-argument.com/
Think about this when you unplug something in the future...
Until that time agent-based modeling is the best we have :)
A sure formula for success. Bye Nokia & MS...
Sorry to be nitpicking... :)
It misses the point that people with college educations can start businesses, or raise the quality of production even in jobs with lower requirements.
At worst/best the unrest in Tunesia stemmed from people with a good education being more used to critical thinking, and standing up against an undemocratic government because of that.
Adaptation of OZYMANDIAS: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ozymandias
MUBARAK
I met a traveller from an antique land \\ Who said: Two vast and trunkless legs of stone \\ Stand in the desert. Near them, on the sand, \\ Half sunk, a shattered visage lies, whose frown \\ And wrinkled lip, and sneer of cold command \\ Tell that its sculptor well those passions read \\ Which yet survive, stamped on these lifeless things, \\ The hand that mocked them and the heart that fed. \\ And on the pedestal these words appear: \\ "My name is Mubarak, king of kings: \\ Look on my works, ye Mighty, and despair!" \\ Nothing beside remains. Round the decay \\ Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare \\ The lone and level sands stretch far away.
0) It is harder to raise money for FOSS, especially in the startup-phase (so if competing endeavors are closed, they will have the financial edge, which could be an important disadvantage if you're doing something innovative...).
A) If it is a centralized Affero GPLed app:
1) There is a barrier to installation on local/development machines (try getting your first time hesitant developer to install MySQL, ruby and a host of gems). A barrier that is smaller / nonexistent for desktop software, because to use it at all, you have to install it.
2) There is a barrier to updates, a fix somebody applied to his local copy still has to be checked and deployed to the server(s) before he even can use it (if it is a feature relying on his data on the production-server).
B) If it is a GPLed P2P web-app:
1) There are critical mass issues for updates of social functionality (how to get most people to to update? and how to coordinate different version). If updates are automated or even go through a package manager, you're back at A2.
2) The required architecture will be much more complicated compared to centralized apps with the same functionality (at least while the centralized app is small enough to run on one server / cluster).
Not that it is absolutely impossible, but I tried (option A, a forum/wiki-type app) and was, to say the least, not wildly successful :) (though we/I did get a decent app completed, and I'm doing fine otherwise) (could just be the things I was building, ymmv): http://foundation.logilogi.org/
Oh, and naturally, for social networks it is even harder, as there is an additional critical mass effect in the network itself (not useful as long as most of your friends are still hanging out on FB, and unlike us programmers / geeks, they generally don't care that much about code and FOSS-freedoms, and at best mildly about data-freedoms. They are mostly happy about not having to worry about software and updates at all...).
http://islington.the-hub.net/public/
(and they have multiple locations, including two in the Bay Area: http://bayarea.the-hub.net/public/)
(and yes, transparency is a good thing in general, as long as no severe overriding concerns are present)
But secondly, as set out in the article, their aim seems to be a semi-transparent paywall, that will allow people to read a few articles before triggering a payment requirement.
Will people buy into this?
But in either case it seems a fortunate move towards much-needed standardization of torrent RSSes :)
(the beauty of improvement through competition...)
(disclaimer, I'm taking the university route myself)
And better than having paginated comments, as noted here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2132568
In that as citizens they should support politicians that take 419/spam/fraud issues seriously?
Were there no collective responsibility, then all arguments of the kind that the West owes/owed something to Africa for its colonial misdeeds, would even be less valid (as hardly anyone involved with that is around any more...).
(and just to clarify, I do think the West owes something to Africa, but collective responsibility can't go one way only. Being responsible, and building a reputation for it, is as important for nations as it is for businesses, teams and individual employees)
I made such a thing for C++ years ago. It adds a header and a footer to your pure C++ build-script, compiles it, and then runs it (compiling your program). It also included extension libraries that did some more advanced things, such as detect local dependencies, but still was very toy-like and unpolished. I never advertised it widely, especially after I started to use Ruby instead of C++ for the project it was related to.
Still, the basic idea of including the build-system in source-form with ones code might be interesting to some people... at least makes it easy to fix, deliver, and extend.
http://sourceforge.net/project/shownotes.php?release_id=3730... (unix / linux only)
Not, maybe in terms of falsely blocked sites, but certainly in terms of having fewer false positives (e.g. spam/useless pages) in the search results.
Mom & pop users (and even more advanced searchers, such as students looking for book-reviews, or torrents) might very well forgive them the few false blocks for this.
Zittrain in his 'The Future of the Internet and How to Stop It' already wrote about this trade-off in terms of spam being made possible by the generativity of the internet, and people increasingly preferring controlled environments over those full of virusses and spam (wonder why apple's locked down devices are so popular?).
Of course this has big downsides too, and even is bad in my opinion. But Blekko, by allowing people to create their own slashtags (categories, much more flexible and quick than Googles domain search) and google/yahoo/bing always being only one click away, might have arrived at a good middle-ground...
Imho Blekko might very well be able to beat Google at their own game. Give them a try, or at least sometimes when google doesn't do it for you, I'd say...