HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

x3blah

104 karma · joined April 30, 2020

submissionscomments
x3blah··on What the heck happened with .org?
In the short history of the Internet so far, domain names originally were free. Many of the early .com(mmercial) names, e.g., bbn.com, dec.com, etc., were registered for free. Some TLDs were non-commercial for a long time, e.g., Educase I think only began charging fees for .edu around 2006.

For me, the question remains why do user have to pay for domain names.

Users once had to pay for SSL certificates but it seems like Let's Encrypt found a way to work around that.

Why can't the same be done for domain names.

One could argue the "legitimacy" of LE certs is directly connected to, or even dependent upon, the "legitimacy" of the applicant's domain name registration. An ICANN-approved domain name registration is required to obtain a LE cert. Wonder why LE does not operate a domain name registry.

x3blah··on Thank you for helping us increase our bandwidth
Archive.org works surprisingly well as a general purpose web proxy. Just prefix the URL, e.g., http://example.com, with https://web.archive.org/save/, e.g., https://web.archive.org/save/http://example.com

The aesthetic intrusiveness of the archive.org header and footer are minimal since I use a text-only browser that has no Javascript engine.

Sometimes I get "This url is not available on the live web or can not be archived." However this happens for only a surprisingly small minority of websites.

Rarely I find that /save is unsuccessful in which case I can still find past copies using something like

   curl -o 1.txt "https://web.archive.org/cdx/search/cdx?url=http://www.example.net&fl=timestamp,original" ;
   sed -i '/^[12][0-9]* h/!d;/^[12][0-9]* h/{s/^/http:\/\/web.archive.org\/web\//;s/ /\//;s/\r//;}' 1.txt
The limitation with past copies versus /save is that archive.org will not usually crawl past page one on websites with many successive pages, e.g., http://example.com/?page=2, http://example.com/?page=3, etc.

Has anyone ever considered mirroring archive.org, or parts of it, to other geographic locations.

Could this be done. Why or why not.

x3blah··on Pi-hole 5.0
Looks like they fixed the issue.

The above is no longer needed to avoid the Sucuri interstitial page.

x3blah··on Air travel is going to be very bad, for a very long time
"This state of affairs is a consequence of the usual culprit: advertising. Society/the media needs to develop a new business model, and fast."

Isn't this also the "business model" of Google, Facebook and hundreds of thousands of other "tech companies" and websites that aspire to generate revenue by catering to advertisers.

x3blah··on Why is the stock market rallying when the economy is so bad?
"Goldman Sachs Group Inc. analysts have been tracking varied measures such as gas demand, Starbucks mobile application downloads and traffic in restaurants as measured on the reservation website OpenTable for signs of a recovery."

OpenTable data

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vRbPuAyJy74U...

x3blah··on Pi-hole 5.0
"Javascript is required. Please enable javascript before you are allowed to see this page."

Required to read the text of the announcement. No. Required to make donations via Stripe. Yes.

RSS does not require Javascript. Looks like the full text announcement.

https://pi-hole.net/feed/

Alternatively:

   echo 159.203.180.3 pi-hole.net >> /etc/hosts
x3blah··on How to disable the built-in Windows 10 ads
"For me, Windows 10 is where I felt like I was no longer in control of my computer."

If Microsoft cannot not stop Windows computers from becoming controlled by a botnet, the logical solution is to create their own. Well, that is what it looks like.

Big tech companies will tell users that they will "protect" them from this, that and the other thing (including protecting users from themselves), but they cannot protect users from the company. Obviously, showing ads demonstrates that the user, what Microsoft knows about her, is now a "product". Nevertheless, it is fair to ask why any user would prefer to control their own computer 100% instead of letting Microsoft control it for them. It is possible that, outside of HN commenters and voters, most Windows users are ambivalent.

I can remember when Windows had no way to access the internet, only local area networks. It was much faster. Why not temporarily bring down the interface to the internet gateway when it is not needed, or just delete the default gateway from the routing table. For example, if one is only using a program that does not need internet access, e.g., a word processor, spreadsheet, dictionary, calculator, etc., there is no need to have a connection to the internet. A script could be used to automate this procedure. This way the user has some control over when Microsoft can install updates, send telemetry data, etc., i.e., when the company can "take control". When the user is done with her offline work or game playing, she can bring up the interface or re-add the default gateway and let Microsoft have control.

x3blah··on AWS EC2 General Price Cut

   220 pan.alephnull.com dictd 1.12.1/rf on Linux 4.4.0-1-amd64 <auth.mime> <114924196.15062.1589085014@pan.alephnull.com>
   150 15 definitions retrieved
   151 "Extortion" gcide "The Collaborative International Dictionary of English v.0.48"
   Extortion \Ex*tor"tion\, n. [F. extorsion.]
      1. The act of extorting; the act or practice of wresting
         anything from a person by force, by threats, or by any
         undue exercise of power; undue exaction; overcharge.
         [1913 Webster]
   
      2. (Law) The offense committed by an officer who corruptly
         claims and takes, as his fee, money, or other thing of
         value, that is not due, or more than is due, or before it
         is due. --Abbott.
         [1913 Webster]
   
      3. That which is extorted or exacted by force.
   
      Syn: Oppression; rapacity; exaction; overcharge.
           [1913 Webster]
   .
   151 "extortion" wn "WordNet (r) 3.0 (2006)"
   extortion
       n 1: an exorbitant charge
       2: unjust exaction (as by the misuse of authority); "the
          extortion by dishonest officials of fees for performing their
          sworn duty"
       3: the felonious act of extorting money (as by threats of
          violence)
   .

"an exhorbitant charge"
x3blah··on Rebuilding our tech stack for the new facebook.com
Under the document-like school of thought, less "engineers" would need to be employed. Also, less computing resources would be required on both the client side. Money, not to mention time, could be saved.

Perhaps application-like school of thought probably allows for more user manipulation. metrics and tracking.

x3blah··on Rebuilding our tech stack for the new facebook.com
Does the compensation of those "engineers" reflect that they have "failed"? Perhaps there is another way to evaluate the work, not from the perspective of the user waiting in front of a screen. Do not forget that the money to pay the salaries of those who do this work does not come from users.
x3blah··on The Original Cookie specification from 1997 was GDPR compliant (2019)
"This also applies to other things, like browser-fingerprinting, or how Google will now try to identify people using machine learning without actually using cookies."

Even if only a User-Agent string is sent from a "browser" that has no Javascript engine and does no CSS processing or auto-loading of any resources, the online ad services folks, not to mention the "web security" folks, will still try to create a "fingerprint".

There are companies whose entire business is dependent on a demand for lists/databases of user agent strings. For example,

https://deviceatlas.com/

https://51degrees.com/

https://www.scientiamobile.com/

Fingerprinting based on user agent seems like a rather easy problem to solve. Aside from not sending the header or every user sending the same one, one idea is to keep changing the string.

The following is from a file called "mosaic-spoof-agents" and dates back to at least 1996.

   #
   # Agent Spoofing -- Who will you be today?
   #
   # "I don't think [t]he[y]'ll be too keen" -- Originally from Monty Python, run
   #                                            into the ground by Tommy Reilly
   #
   # NOTE! There is a hard limit of 50 agents! Mosaic will not read anymore!
   #
   # This file should be located in your HOME directory under the filename:
   #   .mosaic-spoof-agents
   #
   # This file consists of lines that begin with a # (comment), a - (a seperator
   #  for the sub-menu off options), a + (this is special...it denotes that the
   #  agent following it [no spaces] should be the default agent to use) and
   #  anything else (considered an agent spoof line).
   #
   -  This is a seperator...as long as the first thing is a dash
   #  This is a comment line
   #
   # This is the "example" agent. If you don't like it...comment it out.
   #   if you want it to be your default, put a + infront of it.
   #
   Bond_James_Bond/007 (BMW; Z3 Roadster)  DOHC_inline_16-valve_4-cylinder
   Gandalf/White (Shadowfax; Wind)  White_Staff
   Elric/Emperor_of_Melnibone (Hellsword; StormBringer - Devourer of Souls)
https://github.blog/2010-03-08-ncsa-mosaic-on-github/

https://github.com/alandipert/ncsa-mosaic

One could argue that the original "netiquette" was to change one's user agent string. At least we can see it was contempleted by authors of Mosaic.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mosaic_(web_browser)

Today tech companies will argue that any user agent string is an abberration from what they expect then "something is wrong". Users might get blocked or they might be alerted their "browser is not supported" and/or be advised to "upgrade". They might receive a "security" warning that someone logged in to their account. All based on simply changing the user agent string. The assumption today is that no netizen would ever do that.

Today, browsers allow changing the user agent string using some "toolbar" or "console" but if the name given to it is any indication, this is only meant for "developers", not "dumb [users]", to borrow from the infamous Zuckerberg quote.

One of the authors of Mosaic is now a Silicon Valley VC who posts on HN.

The "Who do you want to be today?" is probably a play on the Windows 95 slogan "Where do you want to go today?" A web browser was a new thing in Windows back then, the web being an idea Gates was not easily sold on, and I always thought the slogan seemed to suggest someone thought web access would be a selling point to users.

x3blah··on Cross-signing and end-to-end encryption by default
Only one appears to allow for E2E without the help of a third party. If person A and person B are technically capable and want to run their own servers and use their own clients, without involving a third party, then Matrix appears to allow for that. With Signal E2E is only available if persons A and B involved Signal in the process, including using Signal's software. Matrix appears to be just a protocol. Theoretically, there is no need for users to involve the Matrix organisation in their E2E communications.

Signal: - cannot run own server - writing clients discouraged; centralised control preferred

Matrix: + can run own server + writing clients encouraged

Ideally, what persons A and B might want is a protocol that allows for peer-to-peer connections without passing traffic through the third party. The server might be merely a point of rendezvous to enable one person to discover the network address of the other. For example, person A contacts person B's rendezvous server for person B's address, port, etc. Then person A makes direct connection to person B. Once that peer-to-peer connection is established there is no more need for the server. No traffic passes through it. It could even be shut down.

x3blah··on No cookie consent walls, scrolling isn’t consent, says EU data protection body
"If more browsers were still User Agents in the literal sense, maybe we wouldn't have needed this legislation."

s/browsers/popular &/

There are browsers and other clients that are still User-Agents in the literal sense but they are not the popular ones.

The popular browsers measure their success by market share, not qualitative measures.

That is why Firefox tries to stay more or less in lock step with the leading browser on features.

This is not done out of fear of being inferior by some qualitative measure but out of fear of losing market share.

x3blah··on Ad blocking with Raspberry Pi and Pi-hole
I do not do recursive lookups at home. I store the DNS data I need in custom zone files. Once I have the data stored, this is faster than recursive lookups, especially with tinydns listening on localhost. djbdns works great for me year after year. I would never use MaraDNS.
x3blah··on Ad blocking with Raspberry Pi and Pi-hole
I am a djbdns user. I also use nsd and unbound. I do not use "upstream" third party DNS, such as 9.9.9.9. Surprised to hear that anyone still uses MaraDNS.

What I am curious about are these massive blocklists. Does anyone actually read through them. Does it make sense to block 60,000 hosts when only, say 100 or even 1000, ever stand a chance of being accessed by a user's computer -- due to the user's particular usage habits.

x3blah··on YouTube Without JavaScript
Correction: firefox ./0.html should be firefox ./0.htm
x3blah··on Popcorn Time repository unavailable due to DMCA takedown
http://web.archive.org/web/20190402223528/https://github.com...

Looks like this was a fork from https://github.com/butterproject/butter-desktop which is still up

x3blah··on Ad blocking with Raspberry Pi and Pi-hole
Watching videos with Javascript turned off, there are no ads.

Google tries to force users to turn on JavaScript by needlessly making the YouTube website "require" JS to be turned on to play videos.

However it is easy to play the videos without using JavaScript using just basic HTML.

Example

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23076239

x3blah··on Ad blocking with Raspberry Pi and Pi-hole
Will you test the efficiency of the block list.

For example, given a block list of 60,000 how many hosts on the list did your computer actually try to access. Have you ever read through one of those massive blocklists.

I use a whitelist rather than a blocklist. Similar to a firewall, I block everything by default. Then carefully choose what I allow.

This way I can see exactly what hosts I actually need to access. Makes it easy to see attempts to access ad servers, trackers, phone home, etc.

x3blah··on Bye, Amazon
http://web.archive.org/web/20200409045004/https://www.oann.c...

CNBC interview with Smalls

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=15HUGc7R8hw

x3blah··on Systemd, ten years later: a historical and technical retrospective
Sounds more like the problem is with the packages and a general lack of quality control with respect to the userland than with GNU init. Perhaps that is why BSD projects, which do have some quality control over userland, can still use BSD init.
x3blah··on Judge approves Facebook's settlement with FTC over ‘stunning’ privacy violations
The ideal post then might be a link to the ruling itself:

https://epic.org/privacy/facebook/epic2019-challenge/US-v-Fa...

Through an FOIA request, EPIC found there were over 29,000 outstanding complaints to the FTC against Facebook since the 2012 Consent Order.

https://epic.org/privacy/facebook/epic2019-challenge/

x3blah··on Judge approves Facebook's settlement with FTC over ‘stunning’ privacy violations
"Old newspapers could only dream of the kind of advertising revenue that sites like this probably have."

Actually they are struggling for ad revenue hence all the third party crud in their web pages.

Many of them allege that companies like Facebook and Google have "stolen" their ad revenue. Some complained of Craigslist taking away their classified ads business.

Old newspapers, particularly local ones, are going out of business thanks to competition from ad-supported websites that operate as middlemen for news delivered via internet, not to mention the impact of Covid-19.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decline_of_newspapers

https://www.poynter.org/business-work/2020/here-are-the-news...

x3blah··on Judge approves Facebook's settlement with FTC over ‘stunning’ privacy violations
Compare HN title with actual titles given by the author/publisher:

"og:title" content="Federal Judge Stunned by Facebook's `Unscrupulous' Violation of the Law, Warns of Much Deeper Problems"

<title>Judge Timothy Kelly Stunned by Facebook's Violation of Law

One could argue the HN title suggests the important point of the news story is that the settlement was accepted despite "stunning" privacy violations.

One could argue the author's titles suggest the important point of the news story is that a federal judge was "stunned" by Facebook's violations when approving the FTC settlement.

x3blah··on Gemini – A new, collaboratively designed internet protocol
Incidentally, "Netscum" is a reference to Netscape Communications Corporation. They introduced SSL. This company was founded to commercialise a web browser, called NCSA Mosaic, that was originally co-written by venture capitalist Marc Andreesen of a16z.com as part of an academic project at U. of Illinois. The name "Mosaic" refers to its support for a variety of internet protocols, not all of them web-based. Netscum code-named their derivative browser "Mozilla", marketed under names like "Navigator" and "Communicator".

Fearing the growth of the web, Microsoft acquired rights to use the NCSA Mosaic code and produced a derivative browser called "Internet Explorer", which they included as part of Windows.

As web use grew, Mozilla Foundation, who inherited rights to publish the Netscape source code, added a "search box" to their derivative browser called "Firefox" and started directing search queries to Google, receiving large payouts in return. Mozilla Corporation was formed.

Google later hired developers from Mozilla to write another derivative browser called "Chrome".

x3blah··on Pricing Your Product
A better title might be "Pricing Your Service" since the overwhleming majority of examples cited are services, not products.
x3blah··on Gemini – A new, collaboratively designed internet protocol
"Given another 10 years of experimentation, I could 100% imagine WWW being seen as corporate, commercial and professional space."

Excerpt below is from the file /scripts/web included with the original netcat in 1995.

   #! /bin/sh
   ## The web sucks.  It is a mighty dismal kludge built out of a thousand
   ## tiny dismal kludges all band-aided together, and now these bottom-line
   ## clueless pinheads who never heard of "TCP handshake" want to run
   ## *commerce* over the damn thing.  Ye godz.  Welcome to TV of the next
   ## century -- six million channels of worthless shit to choose from, and
   ## about as much security as today's cable industry!
   ##
   ## Having grown mightily tired of pain in the ass browsers, I decided
   ## to build the minimalist client.  It doesn't handle POST, just GETs, but
   ## the majority of cgi forms handlers apparently ignore the method anyway.
   ## A distinct advantage is that it *doesn't* pass on any other information
   ## to the server, like Referer: or info about your local machine such as
   ## Netscum tries to!
   ##
   ## Since the first version, this has become the *almost*-minimalist client,
   ## but it saves a lot of typing now.  And with netcat as its backend, it's
   ## totally the balls.  Don't have netcat?  Get it here in /src/hacks!
   ## _H* 950824, updated 951009 et seq.
   ##
FWIW, I still use original nc and similar TCP clients to "interact" with the www. Works great.

Not fan of SSL, now TLS, which was in fact created to facilitate commercial use of the www, or "e-commerce", in 1990's.

As an ongoing experiment in a different protocol/space, I run CurveCP on home LAN.

x3blah··on Crypto Fund II
a16z is "all about" spending other people's money.

The "time to build" nonsense was about spending taxpayer's money. That is, telling the American government how to spend it.

Consider that a16z and its clients probably do not pay much taxes. Certainly they pay less than people who cannot afford the same level of profesional services required to reduce their tax burden to the same extent.

If America builds infrastructure and better educational systems, a16z and their clients will benefit, along with the folks who actually paid for it. Whether those benefits would be disproportional in favor of a16z and its clients is left as a question for the reader.

x3blah··on The Open Web Is Dying
The cost of hardware, with few exceptions, e.g., Apple, and the price paid by consumers for it, continues to fall. This has been the trend for at least the past forty years.
x3blah··on The Open Web Is Dying
"Anyone remember when Netscape was a browser monopoly?"

I remember when Andreesen wanted to commercially license Netscape Navigator to companies.

I remember when Microsoft perceived the web as a threat and wanted to act as the gateway to it.

I remember when Google was just a search engine and had no business model.

Perhaps the lesson is that there really is no money to be made from consumers, including corporations, for being the "gateway to the web". Rather, the money is in manipulating or selling out those consumers for the benefit of third parties. The money is to be made from third parties, not consumers. Whomever is the gateway is in the best position to do that.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2