HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xantronix

619 karma · joined November 14, 2014

an online presence is a liability
submissionscomments
xantronix··on Miasma: A tool to trap AI web scrapers in an endless poison pit
You do raise an interesting point. The poison fountains would probably be more effective if their outputs more closely resembled whatever the most popular problem spaces are at any given point.
xantronix··on Miasma: A tool to trap AI web scrapers in an endless poison pit
The README.md specifically states how to allow for nice robots to proceed unhindered. The people behind these efforts, I would imagine, don't particularly care about their sites' reputations in the cases people use LLMs for search.
xantronix··on LinkedIn uses 2.4 GB RAM across two tabs
That's the sort of question a reasonable person would ask. To answer this correctly, you need to occupy the mind of a madman. Now, we've got a boatload of KPIs to optimise or our necks are on the chopping block!
xantronix··on LinkedIn uses 2.4 GB RAM across two tabs
Actually I think I'll play mean, specifically _because_ I want to be radioactive to investors and private equity. I sincerely believe there is a better way to exist and work without being beholden to a system that incentivises quarterly thinking at the cost of everything else.
xantronix··on LinkedIn uses 2.4 GB RAM across two tabs
The greatest value I see in LinkedIn is that it's one of the best places you can have PvP encounters with delusional C-suites making ridiculous claims in a world economy-defining hype bubble. Do I particularly think I am doing anything to change their minds? No, but I figure if enough people saw, at least some class consciousness could be built enough to resist some of their most inane excesses.
xantronix··on A single-file C allocator with explicit heaps and tuning knobs
Brother. What is up with the Makefile rule 'test'? I don't mean to be harsh but is this performance art?

Edit: Homie. Why is bench.sh fetching external resources? Call me old fashioned, but it would be nice if when I cloned the repository (and checked out any submodules that may exist), I've got everything I need, right there.

xantronix··on Everything old is new again: memory optimization
The point is a bit moot. The compiler is the one place where it's okay to be a little spendy, because you're not compiling each time you need to execute the program.
xantronix··on Is anybody else bored of talking about AI?
Yeah I don't think humans were meant to create things faster than they could understand them, but, here we are
xantronix··on I'm OK being left behind, thanks
Are you budgeting time to allow people to properly evaluate LLMs and possibly struggle with them? This is not the sort of new tool whose utility is universally immediately obvious to all builders and craftsmen out there. Are you willing to pay down the likely debt of some individual contributors never clicking with this, or being outright resentful to towards the technology or the mandates? There is a LOT of self-selecting bias from LLM proponents assuming everybody else is willing or able to travel the same path as them.
xantronix··on Wayland set the Linux Desktop back by 10 years?
Wayland can never be an adequate replacement for X11R6, despite its stated purpose, because its design fundamentally chases specifying a protocol for heterogeneous implementations of, what I suspect to be one thing: Apple's WindowServer. In specifying Wayland, focusing on compositing, while expecting major projects already committed to standards built atop the X Window System like XDND, ICCCM, et cetera, to band together to do the same for Wayland a priori, clearly hasn't worked out for reasons that seem self-evident to me. If there was one single dominant ecosystem of desktop environmens built on one dominant UI toolkit from which all others sprung, sure, this could work, but this is simply not the reality. On top of this, with the realities of the second-system problem, it seems clear to me the Wayland steering committee set out on an impossible task.

But man, with a few million bucks, a couple years development time, and a small, dedicated team, maybe somebody out there could make their own little slice of heaven.

xantronix··on Ask HN: How is AI-assisted coding going for you professionally?
It's a multifaceted principled stand I take for reasons I do not wish to get into on HN. There are more than enough people I can associate with who feel similarly to me outside of work and HN that I will not feel particularly compelled to use LLMs anytime soon. I cannot say this will remain the case forever, however, I just don't experience FOMO about these things.

As it stands today, I accomplish tasks at the speed of understanding, and that's with my "ancient" tooling.

xantronix··on The “small web” is bigger than you might think
I have noticed that when I encounter an HTTP-only web site, I know I am in for a pleasant, calm, well-curated experience, and I mean that without a hint of irony.

I don't have a lot to say about the technical discussion here, other than "TLS null cipher could be fine but also a lot more infrastructure than desirable", which could subvert your intent here.

Maybe we should normalise TOR usage before it becomes a surefire signal to the FBI to raid one's home.

xantronix··on Ask HN: How is AI-assisted coding going for you professionally?
Before the advent of widespread LLM usage, and more particularly, before LLM-using coworkers began submitting large PRs against codebases I am the primary maintainer of, my velocity had never been greater.

I do not like the current culture around LLMs. I do not use LLMs, I shall continue to resist any peer pressure to use them, much as I have resisted IDEs in favour of CLI tooling, vim, tmux and the like. I feel my output is incredibly devalued compared to the before times.

On the one hand, my passion for personal projects has never been greater. It helps me feel as though I am bettering myself, pushing the boundaries of my capabilities without resorting to LLM usage. However, I no longer release my code openly.

On the other hand, on top of building resentment towards being treated even more interchangeably than before, I resent the asymmetry of my LLM-using peers submitting large pull requests I am obliged to review, on codebases I have never touched before, applications I have never had the occasion to use; my team is managed in such a way that everybody is more or less working on independent projects, due to pressures to deliver at a much faster pace.

I really wish the fervour would die down for the sake of my own sanity.

xantronix··on Ask HN: How is AI-assisted coding going for you professionally?
In the Lord's name we pray: Infinite. Growth. Forever.

Amen.

xantronix··on Ask HN: How is AI-assisted coding going for you professionally?
This feels similar to the slow encroachment of devops onto everything. We're making so much shit nowadays that there is nobody left but developers to shepherd things into production, with all the extra responsibility and none of the extra pay commensurate with being a sysadmin too.
xantronix··on UBI as a productivity dividend
I don't think we should worry about the advent of AGI deciding to get rid of us; I'm more worried about the people who own the AI current AI infrastructure, as well as the current US regime, who don't see the value in the pesky humans beyond revenue and votes, respectively.
xantronix··on Wired headphone sales are exploding
Yes, this is a trend, but it doesn't seem like just a fad; a lot of people are choosing to return to "outmoded" things to embrace ritual and intentionality. As others have commented, it doesn't have to make sense to you; having options hurts nobody.
xantronix··on Shall I implement it? No
"You're holding it wrong" is not going anywhere anytime soon, is it?
xantronix··on Is legal the same as legitimate: AI reimplementation and the erosion of copyleft
So not only are we moving goalposts here, but we've decided the GNU team should join the other team? I don't understand how GNU would see mass model LLM training as anything but the most flagrant violations of their ethos. LLM labs, in their view, would be among the most evil software corporations to have ever existed.
xantronix··on Verification debt: the hidden cost of AI-generated code
I can't help but think that the logical conclusion of spec-first development is a return to Waterfall methodology. The amount of rigour required almost entirely negates the speed advantages of LLMs, even in the hands of seasoned developers. Unless the stakeholders are external, there will always be that necessary organisational bottleneck; of course, the C-suite could always decide to foist project management entirely on individual contributors, or take it on themselves, but I see that ending either in burnout or eventual neglect. All in the service of being on the forefront of adoption, and for what end?
xantronix··on Tell HN: I'm 60 years old. Claude Code has re-ignited a passion

    > (i.e. paying for third-party solutions)
My experiences are not universal but apart from hardware and maybe $10 for a VPS for hosting, I do not find the need to pay for third-party solutions; I quite like this situation, and I do not find myself particularly constrained taking a little extra time or having to think a bit harder. But, my friend, I must ask, what are LLMs if not third-party solutions with sizable expenditures?
xantronix··on My spicy take on vibe coding for PMs
I cannot tell if this is a genuine sentiment or parody; in this space, the two coincide with one another so frequently these days that it's hard to tell.

Please don't give up. This too shall pass. The bill for the worst excesses in this great experiment will come due. I can imagine the need to reckon with the growing technical and cognitive debt in a responsible way will be an existential issue for some enterprises. Somebody will need to step in and be the adults in the room.

xantronix··on OpenClaw surpasses React to become the most-starred software project on GitHub
Nobody has the _time_, that's for goddamned sure. The business model sounds very similar to that of Philip Morris International.
xantronix··on OpenClaw surpasses React to become the most-starred software project on GitHub
It's bizarre to me how Microsoft somehow owns two of the largest social networks for software developers.
xantronix··on You don't have to
I feel this article genuinely represents the gold standard for all such posts in this current genre and zeitgeist. It really does feel like a Spirit Bomb that Goku asked the entire planet to lend their energy to build, a collection of all the hopes and dreams against a mind-rending and incalculable opponent that seeks to eradicate the last remaining few shreds of the craft of software development that feel noble and decent.

I find myself wondering what to do with this article and the incredibly well-condensed collection of sentiments therein. Do I drop a furtive link in that #ai-enthusiasts Slack channel, in full view of everybody, including that CTO of mine who is REALLY excited about this stuff, and isn't quite ready to issue an AI usage mandate? Or do I keep this secreted away, like a bible in my left jacket pocket in case one of "their" sharpshooters attempts to assassinate me with an AI silver bullet, as though I were some wild and reckless heathen that seeks to abandon all good sense in the selfish pursuit of personal pride?

I don't mean to be hyperbolic, but I never envisioned this moment of feeling bizarre, feckless and iconoclast for wanting to do what feels like the reasonable thing. The circular finances propping this stuff up don't add up. Do I really want to be left dependent on a thing that only really feels like it just flashed into precarious existence, that will almost without a doubt be propped up, classed as "too big to fail" by one particular nation-state, whose actual intent and interests are to subjugate its subjects into a quivering oblivion when it's finally acknowledged the whole thing is in arrears? No, goddammit, I shouldn't have to accept this barrage against and wholesale weakening of my strongest assets: My mind and my discipline. At least that's how I feel about it anyway.

xantronix··on The happiest I've ever been
When the definition is presupposed by somebody else without qualification.
xantronix··on The happiest I've ever been
That's for us to decide as individuals.
xantronix··on The happiest I've ever been
The notion that one's economic output is equal to one's worth as a person seems pretty wrong-headed, when considering what the purpose of life is.
xantronix··on What AI coding costs you
How do we maintain best practices when the compiler outputs a different result for the spec at any given time? How do we obtain reproducible builds? Do we pin to a specific version of our compiler (ie, snapshot of the model; is this possible anywhere except local currently?), and vigorously test changes after any updates in our "toolchain"? How do we have control over our "toolchain" (again, apart from local), especially when said "toolchain" can, for all its users simultaneously, fold to political pressure from state regimes? And, if the code generated by LLMs is the build artifact, why is it now okay to check the build artifact into source control?

There may come a day when we, as an industry, decide that simply doing it by hand is more expedient when it comes to resolving urgent production issues. We may not know the pain we are causing ourselves until well into the future when it has become too much to bear without a visit to the proverbial doctor.

xantronix··on What AI coding costs you
Writing code by hand and managing the mental model of its execution and architecture is one of the few remaining joys of my day job, apart from delivering a good product people want and use and being helpful. Even the small things, the tedious chores of refactoring or scaffolding that initial bit of CRUD boilerplate are steps that matter to me. The callouses matter. The tedium matters. These moments of pain and drudgery inform me on what to do differently next time in a way I worry I would not appreciate otherwise, were specific tools thrust upon me.

I remain because I remain hopeful the pendulum will swing the other way someday.

← PreviousPage 4 of 7Next →