HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xenocyon

2,460 karma · joined May 10, 2019

submissionscomments
xenocyon··on Policies that make the poor less poor
Long-time Seattle resident and transit rider here. Seattle's erstwhile "Ride Free Zone" was instituted with the aim of promoting tourist activity and applied solely to rides that began and ended within a tiny part of the city center; for example, if you were a homeless person in the U District making a trip downtown, you would still have to pay, each way. So - except for very short trips - it was not necessarily something that meaningfully benefited poor people nor low-income people.

More recently Seattle's Transit Riders Union (among other groups) has advocated for more substantial free transit. Some baby steps in this direction have been realized with such things as free transit for high school students.

xenocyon··on The Electrification of Everything
It's important to remember that electricity isn't an energy source, it's an energy medium. This seems trivial, but seems to be a blind spot for people who, for instance, try to set up comparison between electricity and fossil fuels. The comparison doesn't make sense when one is an energy source and the other merely a medium.

Generating electricity is a bit of a misnomer, because it's more about repackaging energy than creating it. Again, this is trivial but easy to lose sight of. The important question is: what's the energy source?

xenocyon··on A US socialite who gave it all up to become a Carmelite nun
It may be shocking, but this is often what happens when people discover their monastic calling in adulthood. Buddha famously abandoned his wife and infant son when he decided to pursue his path.

Furthermore, some people have little contact with their children for even weaker reasons. The fact is that we are inclined to judge women harshly for actions which would hardly seem remarkable for, say, a male rock star.

xenocyon··on TC Energy scraps Keystone XL pipeline project after Biden revokes key permit
Your comment is interesting given that some of the strongest voices against the Keystone XL pipeline are the indigenous tribes whose lands and water would be jeopardized by it.
xenocyon··on Resistor Noise Can Be Deafening, and Hard to Reduce (2007)
Electrical engineer here. Thermal noise is the same for all resistors with a given R, regardless of their method of manufacture. You cannot have thermal noise either less or more than this, so it's not a Johnson "limit" but rather a definite value. You are correct that there are other sources of noise such as 1/f noise. But more importantly, the manner in which noise manifests in the end result has to do with the circuit as a whole.

For noise critical applications you should do a noise analysis of the circuit as a whole rather than make ad hoc selections of components.

xenocyon··on There are no results for tank man
> I usually trust HN to be a bastion of free speech

You must have a remarkably selective definition of free speech then. Stuff gets flagged all the time, and users are suppressed via opaque and obfuscated methods.

To be clear, I'm not saying that moderation is a bad thing. But increasingly I notice that people use the term "free speech" to simply mean "speech I agree with".

xenocyon··on Franz Kafka: Manuscripts, drawings and personal letters go online
It's a little more complicated than that. Brod (who it would be more accurate to characterize as Kafka's close friend than a purely professional publisher) did not promise to destroy the works; on the contrary he made clear that he would do no such thing. It has been suggested that by leaving his works to Brod, Kafka intended that they should not be destroyed, despite his words contradicting this. (Kafka had a complex relationship with his own writing and so this ambivalence was not out of character.)
xenocyon··on Than Average
That's certainly an interesting point. The questions have ~9K responses at this time; I wonder how many of those can be attributed to an hour of being posted on HN.
xenocyon··on Steve Jobs Never Wanted Us to Use Our iPhones Like This (2019)
Bizarre that this is (at this time) the top comment with numerous replies and nobody has yet pointed out that this is not a NYTimes journalism piece; it is an opinion piece by Cal Newport.
xenocyon··on Google AI leader has defected to Apple
Proving defamation is actually quite hard. You have to prove both the untruthfulness of the statement made and prove that you have sustained monetary damages from it. If you manage to win, you will still likely be on the hook for your own legal fees. Finally, you will never recover the time sunk into this endeavor. For most people, it's simply not worth it.
xenocyon··on Film Restoration Today: The Elusive Perfect Viewing Experience
One of the tragedies of Indian film is that (outside of the Bollywood world) many of the master reels of past films have been ignored/lost/destroyed. According to one archivist [1]:

"The loss of India’s film heritage has been colossal. Around 1,700 silent films were made in India of which the National Film Archive of India (NFAI) have only five to six complete films and 15 to 20 films in fragments. The film industry in Madras made 124 films and 38 documentaries in the silent era. Only one film survives, Marthanda Verma (1931). By 1950, India had lost 70 to 80 per cent of our films. And we don’t have to go so far back. Gulzar Saheb could not find the original negative of Maachis, a 1995 film. Mani Ratnam has lost many of his original negatives, which people do not realise, still need to be preserved even if you have a digital copy. The only world-class restoration of Indian films have been the restoration of Satyajit Ray’s Apu Trilogy that was done by the Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences and the Criterion Collection, Uday Shankar’s Kalpana and Ritwik Ghatak’s Titas by Martin Scorsese’s The Film Foundation’s World Cinema Project."

In short, the only parallel cinema that has survived in high quality has been through the efforts of Western enthusiasts. It is consequently a struggle to find good or even passable copies of critically-acclaimed films by Shyam Benegal, Govind Nihalani, Buddhadeb Dasgupta, Adoor Gopalakrishnan, etc; though in the last couple of decades, NFDC's Cinemas of India [2] has attempted to rectify this somewhat.

[1] https://www.film-foundation.org/2018-kolkata-workshop-telegr...

[2] https://www.cinemasofindia.com/

xenocyon··on Study finds ride-sharing intensifies urban road congestion
So call it a taxi then. It's still not a rideshare (except for the actual shared ride services like UberPool).
xenocyon··on Pasco County’s Sheriff Must End Its Targeted Child Harassment Program
The EFF is very interested in surveillance and misuse of personal data so it seems well within its mission.
xenocyon··on A Brief History of the Hedge Fund
You must have a special deal. The price I see (USA, Kindle store, current pricing) is $9.99/mo after the first month.

That said, I agree that journalism deserves to be paid for, and even the price I mentioned above (about $2.30/issue) is very reasonable.

xenocyon··on Google’s FLoC Is a Terrible Idea
I'll admit I like some aspects of the internet of 20 years ago more than today's. I don't like our current world of targeted ads, SEO, overlays, scripts, autoplay videos, and a thousand trackers. But I don't think this makes me that different from today's average internet user - just different from today's average marketer. Indeed, noxious marketing-friendly/user-hostile devices existed in some form 20 years ago as well (intrusive banner ads, popups etc).
xenocyon··on Are You Trading or Gambling?
I agree that expected value (EV) is not necessarily a good metric for personal financial decisions. In fact, this applies both to EVs greater than and less than 1.

As you point out, insurance is a good example of a <1 EV; its purpose is to reduce volatility.

Another example: lottery tickets in the occasional case where the EV>1. This is supposed to, for instance, lead a rational economist to buy a lottery ticket (or many lottery tickets!) when the Powerball jackpot hits some particular threshold, say 500 million. However, money isn't linear in terms of value to individuals, and for most people the difference in life impact between winning a billion dollars vs 500 million is not anywhere close to 2x - indeed the two outcomes are more or less effectively identical.

tl;dr: because money is not linear in the value it adds, EV is not a good optimization metric for highly skewed outcomes.

xenocyon··on I heat my home by mining crypto currencies
1. At an individual/hobbyist level this is a fine thing to do, if one is already a cryptocurrency enthusiast.

2. At a social/planning level it is important to remember that opportunity costs matter, and this should not be recommended as public policy. One kWh of electricity could either be used for mining bitcoin (creating at most one kWh of indoor heat), or it could be used for running a heat pump[*], yielding multiple kWh of indoor heat due to the magic of heat pumps and their >100% "efficiency"[**].

[*] Yes, I realize the OP is already using a heat pump, but assisting it with preheat is inherently less efficient than plowing the same energy into running the heat pump itself.

[**] Yes, heat pumps aren't >100% efficient per a physics textbook, but what most people care about is that you can use them to get >1 joule of indoor heat from 1 joule of energy input, which feels magical when compared to electric heaters, gas furnaces etc.

xenocyon··on How and why I stopped buying new laptops
You're correct; my comment may have overstated the case. I reworded it to say "most tasks quite adequately".
xenocyon··on How and why I stopped buying new laptops
> me just being a person in the zoom era uses a combination of a windows gaming rig, an old mac for video conferencing, a new mac for xcode, and a linux laptop so I don't hate myself

I'm typing this comment on a Thinkpad X230 - not quite as old as the X60s, but still the better part of a decade old. It can perform most tasks quite adequately.

The real problem is getting spare parts for it; replacing the battery, for instance, was quite the fishing expedition, and I eventually had to settle for a bulky 9-cell instead of the smaller 6-cell I had previously enjoyed. So there are some downsides to be sure.

xenocyon··on TurboTax Tricked You into Paying to File Your Taxes (2019)
That's not what the article is about at all.

It's about their unethical reneging on the agreement they made, where they agreed to provide a free product in exchange for the government not providing one - but it's a free product carefully hidden with the darkest of dark patterns.

xenocyon··on The Lakota: A Human Story
I'm not sure what the "genuine spirit" is in celebrating a man whose incredible brutality towards indigenous people was astonishing even for his time. Here is merely one atrocity from amongst the many he committed:

"So Columbus tried again for gold, but this time he and his men didn’t go looking for it. They ordered all Taíno people 14 and older to deliver a certain amount of gold dust every three months. If they didn’t, their hands would be cut off.

At this point, the Taíno were refusing to grow crops, and those who didn’t bleed to death after their hands were removed began to die of famine and disease. When they fled into the mountains, they were hunted down by dogs. Many killed themselves with cassava poison."

(source: https://www.washingtonpost.com/history/2019/10/14/here-are-i...)

xenocyon··on Citing 'Censorship' Concerns, North Idaho ISP Blocks Facebook, Twitter
I can't speak to Idaho, but it appears this ISP also serves some areas in eastern Washington (which happens to be my state). As the article says, WA state net neutrality laws explicitly prohibit ISPs from selectively blocking websites so it is pretty slam-dunk illegal.
xenocyon··on Chemistry of Cast-Iron Seasoning (2010)
Yes. A well-used pan is quite non-stick. In my anecdotal experience, immediately after stripping/seasoning is not the best time; it gets better after a few weeks of use as more oil/fat bonds to the surface after repeated use.

If you find your pan is too sticky: use lots of oil/fat, cook at medium temperature (not too cool nor too hot), and be patient for a couple weeks; the problem will sort itself out, and eventually you'll be able to cook eggs with just a little oil.

xenocyon··on Peer-reviewed papers are getting increasingly boring
Yes, boring in the conventional sense is desirable from a scientific point of view (because the preference for surprising results leads to the biggest problem science has today: most published findings are incorrect). The linked article doesn't really do a very good job of explaining what "boring" means to the author, but my hope is he doesn't have a problem with boring in the sense of negative findings or unsurprising results.
xenocyon··on Self-driving vehicles against human drivers: Equal safety is far from enough
> However, the lives lost in autonomous accidents will be a different set of people than those that would have died in human driven accidents.

So far it seems that this is very much the case. Autonomous cars do relatively well in highway scenarios whereas they appear to do poorly recognizing bicycles, for instance. Reducing safety to one single metric would be a big mistake.

xenocyon··on Anonymously call out the bad behavior of “ghosting” by recruiters
I've been a hiring manager as well, and I've never failed to inform interviewees waiting for a response. Treat it as an important priority, not an afterthought.
xenocyon··on Domino’s Pizza drove increase in stock value by acting like a startup
> But what's the alternative to looking at examples of success?

Controlled experiments and/or causal analysis.

xenocyon··on Salmon spawning in the upper Columbia River, first in 80 years
There are different kinds of hydropower. At the risk of oversimplifying, "big" hydro (such as conventional dams) inflicts massive environmental damage, while "little" hydro doesn't.
xenocyon··on Ask HN: Why is making a good recommendation system for YouTube hard?
Start backwards: what metric of "goodness" are you using? Then, once you have a goal in mind, you can decide on the best way to get there.
xenocyon··on Philosophy of the GNU Project (2018)
> You’re probably using a free software browser from a corporation right now?

Free (as in 'free beer') is not the same as FOSS.

← PreviousPage 2 of 10Next →