What I actually want is a different approach that rejects authority.
3,793 karma · joined January 7, 2009
What I actually want is a different approach that rejects authority.
And who decides who qualifies as a "scientific expert"? Isn't that problematic?
Also that some similar groups dislike each other does not imply that all groups which dislike each other are similar.
The word has multiple meanings. He used a different one. How is that relevant? It's like you cited the first use of the word "mouse" (animal) when we were talking about computer mice.
And your comments don't make sense. Rand strongly criticized anarcho-capitalism, you say libertarians today are largely anarcho-capitalists, and yet you seem to be disagreeing with the Objectivism/libertarianism divide (though it's hard to tell what your position is).
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Belsham
> [Belshan] used the term libertarian in a discussion of free will and in opposition to "necessitarian" (or determinist) views
The use of the word "libertarian" in free will debates is separate from political libertarianism.
But it's worse than that:
http://www.informationphilosopher.com/solutions/philosophers...
> This essay is cited as the first to use the term "Libertarian." For Belsham it was a term of abuse. Liberty was nearly synonymous with libertine, a description of a person with no responsibility.
> Belsham dismisses the ideas of the Libertarians, citing the foreknowledge of God, as did Hobbes and the religious leaders Luther and Calvin before him.
> Belsham is a Necessarian, as he describes his fellow determinists.
So, what are you talking about?
> What was Ayn Rand’s view of the libertarian movement?
> Ayn Rand was opposed to the libertarian movement of her time.
Details follow.
There is no such thing as an objectivist libertarian. Maybe you should learn what you're talking about before hating. Objectivism and libertarianism are separate opposing things. The Objectivist position on libertarians is very negative.
> 2. Social context is irrelevant to mental health.
> 3. Therefore mental health is an individual issue.
None of those are positions Szasz holds. The first two are just kind or ridiculous – he said contrary things, a lot. They are pretty opposite to his actual positions. For the third, he is pro-individualist but the "therefore" is wrong, and also the topic "mental health" includes things like the insanity defense which aren't just an individual issue.
Your supposed anti-libertarian insights are basically correct – but Szasz already knew them and wrote about them.
Of course what is labelled "mentally ill" depends on the social context, rather than being objective. That was a major point Szasz made. Have you read his books?
> Obviously there are times when this is needed.
Here, where you advocate coercion, you have an actual disagreement with me and Szasz. This, not your points 1-3, is your basic disagreement with Szasz. It's the standard disagreement most people have: they favor coercion, he and I do not.
Also, Szasz and Laing are closer to opposites than counterparts. See for example:
http://www.amazon.com/Antipsychiatry-Quackery-Squared-Thomas...
Quote from the book, by Szasz:
> In the late 1960s, a group of psychiatrists, led by David Cooper (1931-86) and Ronald D. Laing (1927-89), began to criticize conventional psychiatry, especially so-called somatic treatments. But instead of advocating the abolition of Institutional Psychiatry, they sought to replace it with their own brand, which they called "Anti-psychiatry." By means of this dramatic misnomer, they attracted attention to themselves and deflected attention from what they did, which continued to include coercions and excuses based on psychiatric authority and power. Thus, antipsychiatry is a type of psychiatry. The psychiatrist qua health-care professional is a fraud, and so too is the antipsychiatrist. In Psychiatry.The Science of Lies, I showed that psychiatry-an imitation of medicine-is a form of quackery. In this volume, I show that antipsychiatry-a form of alternative psychiatry-is quackery squared.
> For more than a half century, I have consistently asserted two simple but fundamental propositions: mental illnesses do not exist, and coercions justified by them are wrong. Anyone who seeks to help others must eschew the use of force. Not a single antipsychiatrist has ever agreed with these principles or abided by these practices. Subsuming my work under the rubric of antipsychiatry betrays and negates it just as effectively and surely as subsuming it under the rubric of psychiatry. My writings form no part of either psychiatry or antipsychiatry and belong to neither. They belong to conceptual analysis, social-political criticism, and common sense. This is why I rejected, and continue to reject, psychiatry and antipsychiatry with equal vigor.
> how about you go fuck yourself?
Who is the one ranting?
Sometimes people who escape criminal justice via psychiatry get similar levels of freedom. Sometimes significantly less freedom! It can be a way to imprison people for an indeterminate sentence which may last longer than the maximum prison term for their offense. And, sometimes it's quite a lot like they are turned loose. All of these happen.
You seem to be implying that Szasz and I hold our positions due to scientific ignorance, which is demonstrably false, and insulting. But maybe you didn't mean it that way.
If you wish to change my mind, tell me where Szasz was mistaken. If you are not familiar with Szasz, perhaps you should try reading both sides of the issue before passing judgment.
For example, you might try reading literature with multiple different perspectives on the issue. Then try to figure out which ideas are right and why. (If you've already done this, forgive me, and please please inform me why Szasz is mistaken, I would love to learn something.)
People labelled mentally ill can be imprisoned without a trial.
People labelled mentally ill can avoid prison when another person who did the same actions would go to jail.
People labelled mentally ill can be drugged by force.
This is bad for basic human rights, isn't it?
How? People are labelled mentally ill IFF they do things that have a stigma attached.
So in other words, conventional psychiatry failed. And the author's solution seems to be to spread it more.
Maybe after a failure like this, where we see that the care providers, hospital and "highly-respected treatment program" don't work, it's time to stop respecting that treatment program so much and consider different approaches.
1) did something good 2) seems to care what you think and is defensive
Shame on you.
you also can't count the soldiers because you don't have unlimited memory (states), so you might run out of memory (states) to count in.
Those discussions often do attract some level of drama, but I don't particularly care. HN has stuff I don't want to read including some drama and some non-drama, and my solution is to ignore it.