HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xenophanes

3,793 karma · joined January 7, 2009

https://criticalfallibilism.com
submissionscomments
xenophanes··on Israel live-tweets assault on Gaza
The best (relatively) short, online history of Israel:

http://www.settingtheworldtorights.com/node/74

xenophanes··on Israel live-tweets assault on Gaza
Actually we can deny Israel has committed atrocities or done anything else bad or worse than other countries. in fact it has not.

you're now making factual assertions, which are false, and which you have never researched, you've only heard them from biased unscholarly sources like CNN. and you just believed them, without adequate questioning of them.

is it a coincidence that you believe false factual statements condemning israel, but not ones condemning france? or what?

and that you're so damn sure israel is guilty that you insist no one could even dispute it, even though you're highly ignorant on the topic and do not provide any factual arguments documenting any atrocities. (there are many purported documentations of such things. i've seen them before. they are not exactly high quality or persuasive. they only convince biased people or people who don't look too closely.)

xenophanes··on Israel live-tweets assault on Gaza
Dude, you called them nazis and then you assume i'm mad about any kind of criticism? you can't figure out it's actually that specific statement that's a problem?

the excuse that "i am only criticizing israel (which just happens to be the jewish state, what a coincidence), not jews" is an extremely common statement of anti-semites. using it without further elaboration only makes you look more anti-semitic.

xenophanes··on Israel live-tweets assault on Gaza
Dude, he played the fucking nazi card before i said a word. And you're defending him, and saying I'm super PC b/c i think calling israelis "nazis" is not ok. wtf is your problem.
xenophanes··on Israel live-tweets assault on Gaza
What is awful?

Israel defends themselves -- not enough (if some Israeli innocents still get murdered and Israel still attacked in the future, how can that be enough defense?) -- and you call it "awful"? Explain yourself!

xenophanes··on Israel live-tweets assault on Gaza
What dehumanizing? You give no examples. I go to the twitter feed and see tweets like this:

> Over 50 rockets fired from #Gaza hit Israel since yesterday -- more than 800 rockets in 2012 alone. RT this. #Hamas

> 1 million citizens in #Israel slept in bomb shelters tonight, barraged by dozens of rockets from #Gaza. pic.twitter.com/LqPfjaTj

Seems like they are explaining things in simple terms so more humans can understand what's happening. I don't get how communicating so more humans will understand is dehumanizing.

xenophanes··on Israel live-tweets assault on Gaza
And you believe posting anti-semitic remarks in public is appropriate.

We should care about your opinion why?

Flagged.

xenophanes··on Israel live-tweets assault on Gaza
The justification for settlements is as follows: buying land, and living there, is legal. Describing this process is "unilaterally moving into land where 2/3 of them live" is false. A way to stop being split on the issue is to stop believing false factual claims.

Palestine will have moderate leadership sometime after the majority of Palestinians are decent people who will vote for decent leaders. Blaming Israel for the hatred of its extremist enemies is nasty.

xenophanes··on Low-End iPad mini Carries $188 Bill of Materials, Teardown Analysis Reveals
That was only materials and manufacturing costs. The real margin is lower. Subtract advertising, software development, hardware design, etc
xenophanes··on Amazon EC2 currently down. Affecting Heroku, Reddit, Others
It's easy to understand shooting a leg with a shotgun. That's a simple thing.

The Amazon thing in question is far more complicated, and far harder to understand.

Thinking they are "akin" is a mistake. It shows you're thinking about it wrong and failing to recognize how completely different they are.

One isn't going to confuse anyone or be misunderstood, the other will confuse most of the population and be misunderstood by most people.

One, if someone misunderstood, only involves one individual being an idiot. The other involves a large company being evil and thus can help feed conspiracy theories.

I'm not sure if you are aware of the difficulty of Amazon doing this. Suppose Jeff Bezos wants to do it. He can't simply order people to do it because they will refuse and leak it to the media and he'll look really bad and then he'll definitely have to make sure to try super hard for there to be no outages anytime soon.

Shooting yourself in the foot is stupid but easy. Doing this is stupid and essentially impossible. To think it's possible requires thinking that Amazon has a culture of unthinking obedience, or has an evil culture that all new hires are told about and don't leak to the media. Totally different.

Casually talking about impossible, evil conspiracies by big business, as if they are even possible, is a serious slander against those businesses, capitalism, and logic. Slandering a bunch of really good things -- especially ones that approximately 50% of US voters want to harm -- and then saying "it's just a joke, it's funny" is bad.

xenophanes··on Amazon EC2 currently down. Affecting Heroku, Reddit, Others
He knows you were joking. It's a bad joke. "It's a joke" is not a magic bullet that means you can do no wrong.

Poisonous ideas spread as jokes. That is one of the ways they spread. A person thinking well about the issue wouldn't find the joke funny because it doesn't make sense. The joke relies on some poisonous, bad thinking to be understood. It has bad assumptions, and a bad way of looking at the world, built in.

xenophanes··on Want to be successful? Be inconsistent
Your comment obviously adds nothing to the discussion, having no explanation.

You obviously didn't get the same kind of education that some of us did.

:)

xenophanes··on Want to be successful? Be inconsistent
Changing your mind and being inconsistent are not the same thing. Stupid article.
xenophanes··on Surprisingly undervalued books
Wittgenstein is the guy who got fired as a schoolteacher for violence against his students, and threatened a philosopher with violence when he was losing an argument.

To be thought of merely as an eccentric is lucky for him, given his history. He was a thug.

xenophanes··on Outwitters Is a Financial Disaster
Title is pretty linkbait: Apple didn't mess up in any way.

But article is still interesting. Summary:

Free to play game. Millions of dollars in free advertising from Apple. Over half a million "sales" (downloads). But the idiots only had a total of $4 maximum of in-app purchases in the game. So they made it impossible for their best fans to pay them much, while also not taking any money at all from the masses. So they didn't get paid much by anyone.

xenophanes··on Mysterious Algorithm Was 4% of Trading Activity Last Week
I don't think you understand how email works.

Or the post office for that matter. There's actually one single organization that all those stamped envelopes get sent through, it's not decentralized.

xenophanes··on Mysterious Algorithm Was 4% of Trading Activity Last Week
How does charging me somewhere vaguely in the ballpark of $36.50 per year qualify as "no impact"?

And I'm just an individual. What about when I send to an email list and it goes to 100 people? Should Google Groups pay a dollar to send out those 100 emails? What about MailChimp, do they have pay $200 when they send out a newsletter to 20,000 people?

I'm also concerned about how this money will be collected and how, from a technical perspective, all emails will be monitored. Every SMTP server will now have to be registered with the central oversight organization? VPNs and rogue email installations will be the enemy or blocked from communicating with anyone "on the grid"?

xenophanes··on LinkedIn Mobile Moved from Rails to Node: 27 Servers Cut and Up to 20x Faster
It means repeat it a thousand times for emphasis.
xenophanes··on Turn your 404s into lost children alerts
Which is why I suggested raising less gullible, passive, compliant people. Gullibility is a problem, here and elsewhere.

I think raising people to be good, independent non-gullible people is a better approach than sticking trackers on them.

xenophanes··on Turn your 404s into lost children alerts
If they won't, he knows something is up. Did they never let him outside in public, never go to school, never have contact with anyone who could help?

If so, he was basically just locked in the basement, the whole thing about saying he was sent there didn't actually matter.

xenophanes··on Turn your 404s into lost children alerts
Or how about raising children self-confident enough to make a phone call home and demand to talk to their mother directly after a couple weeks.
xenophanes··on Learning to Learn
Epistemology explains how learning (aka creating knowledge) happens and what sorts of methods are capable of learning or not, and what sort are more or less effective at learning (aka at getting knowledge). This is useful to actually learning (anything) effectively.

Note again that most work in the field is terrible, so it doesn't actually do this. But the stuff I recommended does.

xenophanes··on Learning to Learn
Learn epistemology (the philosophy of learning).

Most stuff in the field is bad (worse than useless). Start with this book:

http://beginningofinfinity.com/

Karl Popper's books are good too.

Epistemology is the long term route. No instant results, but useful for everything and very efficient in the long run. That's the best way if you plan to learn about many things to be a polymath.

And for discussion of autodidact stuff, ask your questions on this email list:

https://groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups#!forum/taking-ch...

I've already done this stuff. Feel free to email me curi@curi.us

xenophanes··on With More Than 20M Gamers Tuning In, Twitch Raises $15M
Kripp has 2500 viewers right now streaming google docs while he does math to optimize his hero.

Another big factor for twitch viewership is that you can view it while not paying much attention and doing other stuff like reading HN. I have his stream on mute currently, and have it muted for hours sometimes. Gaming takes a lot more dedicated attention than having a stream on.

xenophanes··on With More Than 20M Gamers Tuning In, Twitch Raises $15M
Watching someone else play has some large advantages over playing yourself.

1) he has more skill at the game than you

2) he can put in the hours to get gear, friends to join his party, and other resources you don't have that let him do things you couldn't do

3) playing alone can be lonely. a streamer talking about the game provides some discussion about it. and streamers can be on audio chat with their friends, so you can be listening to a discussion between several people while they are playing. whereas if you play yourself maybe you don't have several friends at the same place in the game chatting with you about what you're doing

4) you can watch a stream on a computer that can't play the game

5) save money on buying the game (I often watch some gameplay footage of games i don't have to see if i'd like to play them or not)

So for example I watch http://www.twitch.tv/nl_kripp sometimes. He is in a WoW guild that I couldn't get accepted in, doing things in WoW I couldn't do. I want to see what high end WoW is like but I don't want to spend a year to catch up. So it's great to get a taste of gameplay that has a very high barrier to entry. I also save the $15/month for a WoW sub.

And for what it's worth, I bought guildwars 2 because of Kripp (for $60). It was fun to play the game while having his stream on. Why not do both in some cases!? I got tips from his stream and understood what he was doing better because I was doing similar things.

xenophanes··on The Apple Reaper
Don't remove the feature, just figure out how to resubmit in such a way that it gets reviewed by a different person. Then you have a high chance to be approved.
xenophanes··on Google Bans Online Anonymity While Patenting It
There are other rectangular phones which Apple is not suing. Why is that? By investigating this question, you may shed light on whether rectangles alone is the issue or not.
xenophanes··on Google Bans Online Anonymity While Patenting It
You're right but you also allowed them excuses to complain about you (which is very hard to avoid) and I don't see what you hope to accomplish. Someone is wrong on the internet ... so you corrected them and expressed how annoyed you get when someone is wrong on the internet about this? It's not your problem if they are wrong.

I think you rightly recognize anti-Apple non-argued insults as being as uncivil as your own comments. So it's quite unfair you get complained at for being uncivil while people don't acknowledge the stupid, insulting-to-Apple comment as already departing from civilized and productive discussion. But still, you aren't fixing any of this.

If your goal was merely to educated other people who read the comments, I don't think your comment was well written to accomplish that. It'd be more effective for educating third parties if it was 100% impersonal and only talked about the issue in a serious way. I think you were trying to persuade the guy you replied to, not third parties, but I think you already knew that wasn't going to work when writing your comment. So there's a bit of a contradiction there.

xenophanes··on Why the iPhone 5 is a good thing
I don't disagree. I agree it's hard to know what "the public" thinks. I do think the public is uneducated about the details of the iPhone 5, but I don't think that makes them not buy it.

I actually think most of the public is so uneducated they don't really know the difference between and incremental or large improvements in most cases, so the incremental thing becomes irrelevant because they are uneducated. They only know when a handful of major using facing features come out (e.g. siri, iphoto app release, retina display, new shape, maybe the earpods).

And they know that Apple says "new and better" and they put some trust in that since they don't know how to evaluate it themselves (a lot of the public would have difficulty telling the difference between an iPhone 5 and a samsung phone or a 4s).

xenophanes··on Why the iPhone 5 is a good thing
> Unfortunately there’s a downside to doing this – small incremental changes that uneducated consumers won’t appreciate.

It's the "educated" tech press and bloggers who have a problem with incremental improvement. The public is buying it.

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →