HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xenophanes

3,793 karma · joined January 7, 2009

https://criticalfallibilism.com
submissionscomments
xenophanes··on IPhone 5: Customers in the Big Apple camp out 8 days early
What the heck are you talking about? Apple does not lower iPhone prices a few months after launch.

Apple frequently doesn't lower prices on anything until the next model comes out.

And I think day 1 lines have a lot to do with the stores being crowded with limited space and staff, not just supply.

Also, ramping up factories to build this is hard. And you don't want to have an extra factory just for launch day, you want supply/demand balance longer term. You can build up some supply before launch but you don't want to delay launch for a long time to build up aging supply.

xenophanes··on So long, Retina
I had burn in on my apple cinema display. got the screen replaced in warranty, happened again mildly on the new one later (warranty has ended).

my 27" imac had serious burn in problems. got the screen replaced in warranty. hasn't repeated yet.

neither a cinema display nor an imac is cheap.

burn in problems are common. shrug. if it's completely unacceptable, there are a lot more completely unacceptable screens, and have been for a long time, yet no one seems to be complaining.

a sibling to your comment says 1st gen ipads can get burn in issues and this is expected by apple and not considered a serious defect when it isn't too strong.

xenophanes··on IPhone 5 Price Breakdown (UK Only)
The issue for GBs is value to the consumer, not cost of components.

It's Apple's form of price discrimination. Everyone else does get away with price discrimination in one form or another. Apple uses a simple and straightforward type which I think is a positive thing, even though it ends up connecting significant price changes to small component changes.

Also if you look at the % more you pay over 2 years for more GBs, it isn't that bad since the contract price is way higher than the phone or GB upgrade prices. (Even looking at the unsubsidized phone prices, the increased cost for more GBs is a lower %. Subsidizing each phone model for the same approx $450 in the US makes the GB upgrade price differences seem larger).

xenophanes··on Elon Musk: "I would like to die on Mars"
I am a huge fan of SENS too.

Here is another place with high value per dollar:

http://industrialprogress.net

Industrial Progress is a very important and practical cause, and this group has a very effective leader who is actually having some effect at persuading people (particularly people in industry) and providing them with better ideas. And it's cheap. SENS needs a billion. A few hundred thousand would be huge here.

xenophanes··on A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma to post
I post less too.

But: move on to where?

xenophanes··on Joyent ending "lifetime" hosting accounts
Reminds me of Google Fiber offering free internet forever for a $300 install fee. I would trust that more if they would charge $5/month.
xenophanes··on Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud Account
Some of the people dying on roads are suicides.

Very few are murders. Murders and accidents are not the same thing and not equally bad.

One difference: if you don't do anything about accidents, the rate stays the same. If you don't do anything about murder and just let it happen, the rate goes up as more people realize they can get away with it and serial killers or terrorists get more bold.

xenophanes··on Why I Turned Down $160,000
People overestimate the opportunities for lawyers.

If you go to Yale Law you're OK. Maybe even top 3. If you "only" go top a top 14 law school, you need to beat a lot of your classmates, there are quite large numbers of losers. If you do not go to a top 14 law school, it gets a lot worse, fast. And there's 200 law schools...

People assume it works less strictly than that, but the legal job market recently changed so just doing well at a top school isn't enough anymore.

In other words, the "particular type" of student is a narrower category than people think.

xenophanes··on Google Fiber Plans & Pricing
Why own a game system?

Ping.

You may have a point with the rest, but response time is a really big deal with many games and a large amount of bandwidth doesn't actually mean a super amazing ping. And actually the speed of light presents ping issues that are meaningful to games so you will never ever be able to just locate computers anywhere and connect to them to play.

xenophanes··on Don’t Jump to Conclusions About the Killer
You missed the point. Szasz explained why these modern "treatments" and ways of looking at and dealing with people, which the OP talked about, are bad. Until Szasz's explanation is both understood and refuted -- instead of neither -- then it's both stupid and harmful to just go on talking about these things like they are OK and endorsing them because they are popular.
xenophanes··on Don’t Jump to Conclusions About the Killer
Wake me up when "the majority view of modern psychology" provides a refutation of Szasz.
xenophanes··on Google+ grows 43% in June
Let me know when Google+ actually works with my google apps email address. It says you have to enable it but I did enable it (terrible documentation/help to do so) and still could never get it to work with no useful error about what's wrong.

It should just work by default.

And if it's disabled, they should stop sending me emails asking me to sign up when they know perfectly well that they won't let me.

xenophanes··on The Challenge of Making Friends as an Adult
Or his goal in this discussion isn't to win friends and influence people.

Maybe he's trying to gain entertainment.

Just because someone isn't getting X now doesn't mean he doesn't know how to. Maybe he's after Y.

xenophanes··on Louis C.K. sees ticket scalping drop over 96% by selling tickets himself
It's not scalpers who are constraining supply.

If a show has 1000 seats, and 900 fans buy the first 900, and never consider reselling at any price, then they are the ones constraining supply relative to an efficient market. (And there's nothing wrong with that, shrug.) The scalpers, by reselling tickets instead of just holding them and ignoring the market price, actually are increasing the amount of tickets available on the market, not lowering it.

Imagine if there were zero scalpers. Then it sells out and price goes to infinity. How can price go to infinity? Because supply is being constrained to zero because people refuse to consider reselling. Scalpers delay that some and keep the market more robust, while also making a profit from underpriced tickets.

And you can never ever sell a ticket to someone for more than the value of the show to them, so the buyers never lose.

All they are "losing" is the ability to get underpriced tickets (tickets for less than they are willing to pay) from the original seller who could have charged more (since he controlled all the tickets) but, for whatever reason, preferred to leave some money on the table for scalpers.

xenophanes··on Why Your McD's Burger Doesn't Look Like the One in the Ad
From the video:

1) they stack up all pickles/onions/etc in the front for ads.

2) the real burger goes in a box and the steam makes the bun shrink a little

Also, they didn't say it but they showed it:

The burger is cooked differently for the ad. I got the impression they were just grilling it to make it look good but with minimal cooking (I wonder if it's even safe to eat the ad one). If you've ever cooked a burger, you'll know they shrink when you cook them.

xenophanes··on Why philosophy is largely ignored by science
If you're interested in Popper, please let me invite you to the best Popperian discussion group on the internet:

http://beginningofinfinity.com/discussion

I'm aware of that Feynman quote. But he apparently had in mind typical philosophers as he did read and understand Popper.

Here's a quote from David Deutsch (correcting someone who claimed that Feynman had never heard of Popper):

> For what it's worth, I happened to mention Popper in the one conversation I had with Feynman, sometime in the 80s, and he did not say "who's that?" but replied meaningfully to the point.

I know Deutsch and have heard the full story. Feynman showed substantial understanding of Popper. Plus avoided all the usual epistemological errors.

Feynman may have been introduced to Popper by Wheeler. Here is Deutsch on Wheeler:

> Wheeler ... (my boss and Feynman's thesis advisor and subsequently his collaborator), knew a lot about Popper and was honoured and delighted when Popper quoted one of Wheeler's aphorisms as a chapter epigraph. Wheeler and I discussed Popper in detail on several occasions and I tried to persuade him to become a Popperian -- ultimately without success, because he preferred Polanyi (!). Nevertheless there were specific aspects of Popperian philosophy of science that he very much agreed with, especially that scientific theories are not derived from anywhere, that they are conjectural and full of errors, and that science makes progress by correcting these errors.

xenophanes··on Why philosophy is largely ignored by science
So he says at the start he dismissed the best philosopher in the field, Karl Popper, without reading him.

Maybe most scientists ignore Popper's philosophy of science (the only worthwhile one) because they are ignorant and judge which philosophy to read by inaccurate reputation rather than merit.

Though bear in mind, quite a few scientists, big and small, did not ignore Popper and actually liked his ideas and found them helpful. E.g. Richard Feynman, David Deutsch, and Albert Einstein.

xenophanes··on In Math You Have to Remember, In Other Subjects You Can Think About It
Thank you. That helps me understand matrices better!
xenophanes··on NCombinator
Benefits no one except the participants?

Also their customers, future business partners, spouses, etc... Don't sell yourself short.

xenophanes··on NCombinator
Better to be actually good.
xenophanes··on Why I'm thrilled Mark Zuckerberg is annoying the bankers
I underdressed to my programming interviews in the bay area (I generally wear what I like). I can't really say if it helped or hurt but I did fine and doubt it mattered much.
xenophanes··on Merchants of Despair: ...Environmentalists...Pseudo-Scientists...Antihumanism
Book has fact checking problems:

http://curi.us/1561-bad-scholarship-merchants-of-despair-by-...

xenophanes··on Merchants of Despair: ...Environmentalists...Pseudo-Scientists...Antihumanism
The real title is:

Merchants of Despair: Radical Environmentalists, Criminal Pseudo-Scientists, and the Fatal Cult of Antihumanism

The 80 character limit on titles is lame.

xenophanes··on Andreessen Horowitz to give half their earnings to charity
She does provide various arguments. There's no shortage there. Whether you find them convincing is up to you but please don't mix that up with her not publishing stuff to argue her point. For example, not living in a second-handed way is a main theme of The Fountainhead, and that's closely related to the altruism issue.

> Her answer wasn't the consequentialist one that Adam Smith and other market-economy defenders proposed: that self-interest produces the best overall outcome.

Correct.

One thing that might be helpful is to understand Rand's view on compromise. She said you can compromise on concretes when you agree on a principle, but you must never compromise your fundamental principles.

For example, if you agree on the principle of trade, you can compromise (haggle) on the exact price or contract terms, and you're still both following a good principle and can both benefit.

But you must never compromise between collectivism and individualism, capitalism and socialism, life and death, freedom and slavery, rationality and irrationality. Those sorts of compromises between opposite principles amount to sacrificing some good that one shouldn't give up, and allowing in some unacceptable evil. Nor should you compromise your values in order to get something that you don't value or value less. That isn't a reasonable compromise, it is surrendering your values and principles for the benefit of others.

Given this sort of view of compromise, it's no good to ever compromise your own life, no good to ever sacrifice yourself. Anything that asks you to do that is evil. If there is a rational trade to make, then make the exchange and benefit, but don't sacrifice yourself for unspecified or vague future benefits which no one is accountable for providing to you.

xenophanes··on Andreessen Horowitz to give half their earnings to charity
You neglect to mention why Rand opposed altruism and considered it inherently immoral: because it means putting other people above oneself and therefore self-sacrificing for others.
xenophanes··on Andreessen Horowitz to give half their earnings to charity
By giving half their profit to charity, one could take them as implying that profit is bad, that they don't deserve everything they earned, and that they are appeasing the irrational anti-capitalists (if not siding with them).

I don't know anything about this particular case, but in general many businessmen are complicit in bad philosophy, and sometimes even pay to promote it. That's shameful and harmful.

Business people trade for mutual benefit. That provides value to society even if they never give a dime to charity. And even if they do give a dime to charity, their actual business activities provide more value, both for themselves and others. Businessmen should be proud.

You can find this sort of opinion in the Ayn Rand book _Why Businessmen Need Philosophy_. You might want to read it, and make some effort to reply to its arguments, before dismissing it as wrong enough to dismissively insult in passing.

xenophanes··on How I attacked myself using Google and I ramped up a $1000 bandwidth bill
One factor is: Amazon charges for actual bandwidth used. Most buyvm users only use a tiny fraction of what they are allowed to.
xenophanes··on Google Drive detailed: 5 GB of free space, launching next week
Dropbox doesn't want to sell. Apple already tried.
xenophanes··on How Apple iPads are Manufactured At Foxconn Factory in China [video]
There's much worse going on in China that isn't exposed to Western eyes much, that's why Foxconn jobs are popular and desirable -- they are better than the alternatives.
xenophanes··on Minicamps on Rationality and Awesomeness: May 11-13, June 22-24, and July 21-28
A good one is Why Businessmen Need Philosophy

http://www.amazon.com/Why-Businessmen-Need-Philosophy-AtlasS...

← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →