HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xkfm

103 karma · joined June 27, 2018

submissionscomments
xkfm··on Incremental note-taking
I've used it for about a decade or so. It's really good, but the entire program is tightly coupled with old MS APIs/IE, so importing material is a pain.

Roughly the process goes: Import article -> read section (create extract/readpoint (a bookmark of where you were in the article) -> review extracts/articles -> create cloze deletion/card (if necessary).

I can't use any other app for this process because you can't really schedule material like that in Anki/Polar Bookshelf/RemNote. Supermemo is unique in that the material you want to make cards of eventually gets scheduled itself, so you don't have to remember to read something. I would use Polar Bookshelf, but every time I've checked in on it, they haven't added that feature. In Supermemo can import dozens of articles at a time, assign them priorities, and know I'll eventually be shown them to read.

I have a couple thousand articles imported at this point, and I never need to remember to read them. This is the most important feature for me, and why I've continued use Supermemo for so many years rather than switch to Anki or Polar Bookshelf.

Not needing to remember to read something you found interesting, rather than just save it as a bookmark somewhere (every bookmarking app) is a killer feature for me, but apparently is not very useful to other people. I've tried explaining it to several people (including the developer of Polar Bookshelf), and they just don't really care.

The longer I've used Supermemo, the fewer cards I end up making from material (most things aren't really worth memorizing/remembering or even reading once you step away from it for a few days/weeks). But, I still import a lot of articles/comment threads from HN etc I eventually want to read.

Often times I'll create extracts, and not actually make cards of them, because I just like rereading that particular paragraph.

I have tasklists of business/programming/etc ideas, that also get shown during my daily reviews. I can add to them, or generally get reminded that I was thinking about X at some point. Very underrated feature.

If you don't want to see something again, you can dismiss it from the review process so it doesn't show up in your reviews. However, the information is still in your collection, so you can still search for it.

Most people take notes and then never look at them again (this comes up in every note taking thread on HN). Supermemo continuously shows me my notes over days/months/years. It also shows me interesting articles I want to read on a daily basis. It also helps me remember whatever I want. All I have to do is open the app once a day and hit next repetition.

xkfm··on Plover is a free, open-source stenography engine
This project got me to buy a full NKRO keyboard.

I dislike how every system/theory has their own dictionary for words and in addition to that, it's heavily encouraged to customize your dictionary for the work you're doing. The customization makes it much harder to learn. Think extensive emacs/vim shortcut customization but worse (in my opinion) and much, much more common.

It is fun essentially typing syllables instead of individual letters. When I was learning, I found a lot of mismatches between how I thought a word sounded, and what the dictionary thought. It felt like relearning English.

Other downsides (at the time), was that there's no real slowing down. You're either typing syllables quickly, or you're not writing anything. There's a way to type individual letters but it's pretty slow, and you have to stop plover (toggle it off), to type normally (which is slightly faster).

xkfm··on Mighty Makes Google Chrome Faster
If it works well, I wouldn't be opposed to using it. $30 is kind of steep, but a web browser is something I spend the vast majority of my computing time using. Depends on how good the tab management is, and how fast it starts up locally on my computer. Some websites are so shitty I don't even want to open them on my own computer.
xkfm··on Spaced Repetition (2019)
One feature I wish SR software had was a tool to let you know if you were going to make a "bad card". There's a definite skill curve in making material at first. You can't tell until you've repeated a card a few times though that it was a bad card. By that time it's easily been a month.
xkfm··on Luna – Cloud gaming service
I wonder how this one will go. I wish I lived closer to most of these companies data centers. It'd be great living in Spookville, Virginia right about now if you were into these game streaming services.
xkfm··on Art of chording
I dislike how there are so many theories and it's heavily encouraged to modify your own dictionary. Makes it somewhat more difficult to learn.
xkfm··on Shady Numbers and Bad Business: Inside the Esports Bubble
I wonder if the bubble is mostly an issue with franchising coming out of Acti-Blizzard and Riot Games? The CGS (championship gaming series, mentioned in article) crushed CS in North America and it didn't pick back up until CS:GO came out. It was also franchised.

Population density/internet quality may have something to do with it as well. Europe and South Korea seem to have stronger esports scenes for just about every game. The players from those regions tend to be better, and they have more tournaments located there.

xkfm··on Using Anki and Spaced Repetition
Can you make cloze deletions from the material? I watched the video haphazardly, and was unable to tell.
xkfm··on Ultra-Time-Efficient Exercise Lowers Blood Pressure, Boosts Brain Function
Interestingly enough I bought this what I thought was a scam/sham/illegitimately represented product from Bas Rutten (the O2 Trainer) awhile ago on a lark. It seems like it actually has some merit (at least the idea, most likely not the product).
xkfm··on Incremental Learning – A continuous learning approach (2018)
You can do this in Supermemo quite easily. It does have interleaving (mixing multiple "decks") by default, although you can do reviews from one deck if you want to.

You'd be losing FOSS, Linux, and IMHO my favorite feature, the mobile support by switching to Supermemo.

When I was using Anki in school I just used multiple decks. Usually one per class.

xkfm··on NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out about concussions
That would make sense. The app was working fairly well, and you could guess what the offense was going to do on each play. It's going to be interesting to see where the league goes.
xkfm··on NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out about concussions
I've recently started getting into watching football. There's a great amount of tactical depth, and I really appreciate that it's one of the few sports where the coach has a very noticeable impact on the outcome of the game.

It's essentially like watching a physical version of chess.

In light of the whole concussion thing, it's somewhat interesting that there are two new football leagues launching in the US soon. The AAF (aaf.com) recently launched this past weekend and is positioning itself as sort of a minor league to the NFL. There's also the XFL, which is a relaunch of sorts (it existed briefly in the early 2000s), and seems to be setting itself up to be a faster version of the NFL. Both of these new leagues do have rule changes that are there to speed up the game, and marginally improve player safety.

Eventually, I would suspect that NFL teams will be able to send some of their practice team players, and players they want to get another look at before cutting, to the AAF for more development.

The AAF seems to have had a moderately successful weekend launch. At least to the extent that there were no catastrophic failures.

A lot of the players who like playing football seem to really like playing football (i.e. they had opportunities to go pro (getting paid actual money) or semi-pro (college in the US) in other sports, and still chose football over them), so I don't think it'll go away entirely unless middle and high schools stop offering the game completely.

xkfm··on Ask HN: Did offering a money-back guarantee help your business?
I can't believe Quest Nutrition was founded in 2010. I started exercising regularly around then, and I remember people talking about it being the only bar worth buying in like 2011-2012. Based off how people talked about the company, I thought it would have been around since 2003-2005.
xkfm··on The Spacing Effect: How to Improve Learning and Maximize Retention
There's a few decks I've seen for math/CS, but I haven't had much luck myself, and have resorted to making my own. I've been trying to figure out the best way to do it.

It's pretty easy to do with Supermemo. But, it's still not as easy/simple as making cards for vocab.

For a specific math/CS topic it's not too hard, just in general.

xkfm··on Addicted to vaped nicotine, teenagers have no clear path to quitting
It's fairly easy to taper your nicotine usage (as well as make your own juice), but I wouldn't expect teenagers to care that much, or use less nicotine even if they were making their own.

I had a few incidents with caffeine/energy drinks, but they were arguably a less harmful and definitely cheaper habit.

xkfm··on The Spacing Effect: How to Improve Learning and Maximize Retention
You can with Supermemo's incremental reading feature. There is a plugin for YouTube if you can find your podcast there. I'd recommend converting your ebook to html first though.
xkfm··on Improvisational theater can reduce anxiety in teens who struggle socially
I've found improv to be frustrating (but not anxiety inducing) in the sense that you can "yes and" a topic to a place that's difficult for someone else to pick up.

Almost like you're playing catch, but you tossed the ball to a place that makes it too hard for your friend to catch. Another example would be writing a comment (even this one) and consciously making sure it's easy to reply to, rather than just expressing myself.

I suppose it's like having a binary tree, and trying to pick a node that's not too far down the tree.

I find myself having to take a step back and consider what I'm going to say and if it makes sense (in general) for someone else to continue off of rather than just talking.

xkfm··on Whether to Use Anki or SuperMemo
You can import entire articles into Supermemo and break them down into flashcards without leaving the program. Anki just gives you flashcards. There's an incremental reading plugin for Anki, but it doesn't work very well.

Incremental reading works by breaking down an article into flashcards. Basically, you go: article -> paragraph -> sentences -> flashcards (usually with cloze deletions). But, because the algo manages when you see everything, I don't have to worry about doing all of that in one step.

Polar Bookshelf (getpolarized.io) is more of an open source solution for archiving documents at the moment. You can export annotations/extracts from Polar into Anki, but you don't get the spaced repetition with the actual reading of articles like you do with Supermemo.

I read a bit of the article, decide if making an extract of that portion is worth it, and then click next repetition when I'm done/bored reading it. I'll then get another article/flashcard/extract (of another article).

You also have tools for marking up articles and saving your place.

Every day I review around 30-50 flashcards, and 30-50 articles/extracts of articles.

With Supermemo, I don't have to decide (or rather, I give up the ability to decide) what I'm going to read next; in favor of having everything scheduled by the algo.

I go through about 800-1000 items in my RSS feeds once a day, save them into read it later/polar/bookmarks, and once a week, I throw the ones that still seem interesting into Supermemo.

I probably spend 30min to an hour going through everything once a day, and another hour or so on Supermemo. Most of the items in my RSS feeds are admittedly junk around 95-98% or so (HN and HN comments, reddit rss feeds and comments, lobste.rs and comments, some news sites, a few personal blogs, and some forums), but I do get a few gems throughout the week.

The newer Supermemo algorithm also tolerates breaks better than Anki (the last time I checked). So, for example, not using Supermemo while on holiday isn't an issue.

I also keep aha moments from programming and some documentation in there as well.

Edit:

Here's a demo of incremental reading in Supermemo. He marks up articles much more than I typically do. There's a lot of features and functionality in the program.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DoQoeK53bP8&

xkfm··on Whether to Use Anki or SuperMemo
There's an actual program, and a saas version. The saas version isn't worth paying for (imo) over using AnkiWeb unless you wanted preformatted decks, and the most up to date version of the algorithm.

I've experimented with using the website (mostly because I'm a fan of the software). It's mostly okay. I've been using Supermemo (the actual app) for a few years now on a daily basis. The app itself has a trial if you can find a download link somewhere, and I believe the site might be free if you import your own decks.

As far as lock in, I believe you are also locked in unfortunately. This would be another reason to go with Anki or another solution if you just want flashcards.

xkfm··on American Eating Habits Are Changing Faster than Fast Food Can Keep Up
Most major chains already have apps, at least I Know McDonalds and Burger King both do. The McD's app does have online ordering too, and you can pick it up at the restaurant. Less chance of confusion when dealing with a screen or mobile device if you don't have a standardish order.
xkfm··on Paint.net 4.1 is now available
One thing that's nice about the Windows store is you sometimes get more licenses to install it on multiple PCs than you would if you bought the program directly from the developer. I know photoshop elements is like that. In general, I have bought most of the software I use on windows through the MS store if it's available there. But, generally it isn't.
xkfm··on Anki: Memorization with Spaced Learning
It works well. I recommend not making too many flashcards at once, and using the mobile Anki apps to get repetitions in throughout the day.
xkfm··on Anki: Memorization with Spaced Learning
Supermemo has the best implementation of incremental reading and somewhat pioneered it. It's only downside is it's heavily tied into windows. [1]

[1] https://www.supermemo.com/help/read.htm

xkfm··on Anki: Memorization with Spaced Learning
I tried it awhile ago, and it didn't work well, but I'll try it again. Incremental reading is kind of finicky to get right. Incremental reading is the real draw of these programs for me, and Supermemo (despite it's flaws) is kind of the only one that has a decent implementation of it.
xkfm··on Anki: Memorization with Spaced Learning
Other than Anki, clozemaster and supermemo.com are two good paid options. I'm currently paying for supermemo.com*, and the two decks I'm using for Spanish seem to be pretty good.

Clozemaster uses word frequency lists and sentences. Honestly it's (clozemaster) one of the best free SRS products I've seen for multiple languages.

I'd avoid memrise (too many horrible quality decks). Duolingo isn't bad but certainly isn't comprehensive by any means.

The reason I'm paying for supermemo.com is because it has a good quality Chinese deck and those are hard to come by. I also want to use the updated SRS algos that it uses. SM-2 is really old and does not handle skipped days well at all. The newer versions of the sm algo are much better in that respect.

xkfm··on Anki: Memorization with Spaced Learning
I find it somewhat excessive (and I still make poor cards even my by own guidelines all the time), but I try optimize to make my flashcards as easy as possible to answer according to [1].

Especially in the long run once you get thousands of flashcards, and have a few breaks because of life. A general rule of thumb I go by is that my answer should be shorter than the question.

Even in your answer there's three or four separate parts to it. You have:

1. An abstract data type 2. collection of elements 3. Two principal operations 3a. Pop and push

[1] https://www.supermemo.com/en/articles/20rules

xkfm··on Anki: Memorization with Spaced Learning
It does, but many of the decks on memrise are horribly made, so I stopped using it. Clozemaster is much better in my opinion.
xkfm··on Anki: Memorization with Spaced Learning
For Anki, I'd grab the complete article from Wikipedia/textbook/[good source], and then write a few examples. The flashcards would be a number of cloze deletions, and then I'd have a separate deck with a practice question to recall from a blank state. For example [1], I'd take this Wikipedia article, and break it down like so:

In computer science, a stack is an abstract data type that serves as a collection of elements, with two principal operations: pop and push.

This sentence would become a number of flashcards that look like ([...] is a cloze deletion where you have to insert the missing word, each cloze is a flashcard):

In computer science, a [...] is an abstract data type that serves as a collection of elements, with two principal operations: pop and push.

In computer science, a stack is an abstract data type that serves as a [...] of elements, with two principal operations: pop and push.

In computer science, a stack is an abstract data type that serves as a collection of [...], with two principal operations: pop and push.

In computer science, a stack is an abstract data type that serves as a collection of elements, with [...] principal operations: pop and push.

In computer science, a stack is an abstract data type that serves as a collection of elements, with two principal operations: [...] and push.

In computer science, a stack is an abstract data type that serves as a collection of elements, with two principal operations: pop and [...].

You'd do that for most of the article. Find a few examples of a stack, do the same thing from cloze deletions, and then in a separate card, make a few questions to have you write from scratch, parts of a stack.

The separate deck would be so your regular reviews don't take forever, when you get a question asking you to write out a stack. The other deck would be done say 3-4 days a week, and have many fewer cards, because they're going to take awhile to answer. You could even use the index card method for this part as it's closer to actual practice than recall.

In another deck, I'd also have short answer questions. For example, what's the difference between a stack and a queue, or stack and array, etc. This would also be more for practice sessions, rather than daily repetitions, as the questions could take awhile to answer.

Note that you'll have a ton of flashcards this way for each algo, but they'll be extremely easy to answer (a good thing). Five flashcards you can answer in 2-10 seconds each, is much better than one flashcard that takes you a minute to answer.

Assuming five seconds to answer a flashcard, you could easily do 120 repetitions through the day. The nice thing about Anki is the mobile clients, so you can do a few cards while you have some downtime. When I was in school, I was usually doing flashcards while I was waiting for class to start or going to the bathroom etc.

xkfm··on Anki: Memorization with Spaced Learning
I use supermemo, and the vast majority of my collection isn't language related. For languages, something like clozemaster, supermemo.com, or premade anki decks/courses are fine.

I still find it odd that the only two groups of people who seem to use the software a lot are med students and language learning enthusiasts.

Supermemo is really buggy, and the website is extremely disorganized, but has a lot of useful information on it. The main reason I use it is its incremental reading function. Essentially, you can import articles, and turn them into flashcards in one swoop, while still having access to the full text via built in search (if you choose).

For example, I just finished importing most of the CSS reference [1]. And it only took me ~10 minutes to open the tabs and import them into Supermemo. Each page will get whittled down into flashcards over the next few weeks.

As others have stated, my srs usage is actually quite a small portion of my day, and extremely high leverage.

The hardest skill to learn is learning how to make flashcards properly [2]. I almost exclusively rely on cloze deletions now.

I do my repetitions in the morning when my memory is still fresh.

[1] https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/CSS/Reference

[2] https://www.supermemo.com/en/articles/20rules

xkfm··on To Remember Everything You Learn, Surrender to This Algorithm (2008)
Just emailed you the video, it's a little raw, mostly due to the length limit.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →