602 karma · joined March 21, 2008
curi@curi.us
http://foohack.com/2007/10/required-reading-for-web-develope...
But +1 for quoting Popper.
I wanted to learn something. Why did you post?
(Plus, back then, science and industry had yet to give a stunning demonstration of the power of human reason over nature.)
I thought the waterfall development link basically answered the question about advanced planning. I'm mostly interested in the emotional fragility of parents and wanted to see what would happen if I pointed out that logic does not back up his reaction.
And, BTW, if you and other parents can't read it rationally, why should I believe you handle parenting matters rationally? Parenting matters are more difficult and more emotional than reading a simple forum post.
You said you were facing a certain problem "now", 2 months after the child was born.
You could have made your decision about how to handle it prior to the child being born. If you'd done that, you would not be facing the problem now, it would be decided. But you didn't.
He asked about why you didn't decide in advance. You got offended by the implication that you hadn't decided in advance. That was something you said yourself, so it's unreasonable to be offended by it, or to blame him for noticing you said it.
If you're talking about the halting problem now, humans also don't know whether the TM they are manually simulating will halt eventually.
And you still haven't said specifically what the thing is that the humans do and computers can't.
Are you really saying that a computer with too little memory can't do it, or something like that? because it seems blatantly obvious that a computer can simulate a turing machine.
there is no reason to believe that bringsjord can solve that problem and a computer can't. divide his method of solving it into very small steps. then answer which step did he do which a computer can't do?