HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xlnt

602 karma · joined March 21, 2008

Want to discuss something I said? email me:

curi@curi.us

submissionscomments
xlnt··on Why I'm not using Lisp
it's not the same in any turing-complete language. lisp makes adding new "language level features" easy, and python makes it hard.

i'm not saying you should always use lisp for everything. but for this particular issue lisp has a major advantage.

xlnt··on Problems With Life Extension: The Brain
What do you propose a brain might be doing, other than computation?

We have an existing theory that our computers are universal (even a Turing Machine is), which means they can do any possible computation. If the brain does computations, then our computers could do the same computations.

xlnt··on Hello: Macs are about to get interesting again
as much as i like macs, this article doesn't really have any information in it. just hoping for new mac designs.
xlnt··on Why I'm not using Lisp
> unicode is an issue that should really be solved at language level

with lisp, you don't need anything to be built in "at the language level" because you can modify the language much better than with python or ruby. many "built-in" lisp features, that would be language-level in other languages, are just built-in macros, and you could have written them yourself exactly the same. for example, loops are done this way.

xlnt··on New longevity drug mimics caloric restriction in mice
It was Aubrey's theory first. It's also my theory, currently.

You are mistaken about evolution. There are random mutations, but those are not complex features, they are tiny changes. It takes many mutations to build up to a major feature.

Example of "lack of trait" winning by default: might humans have the ability to breath the air on Mars? no. why? there's no reason that feature would have been created. you don't have to be unsure whether they might or might not; unless there's an argument on the other side, the "no breathing on mars trait" wins by default.

xlnt··on Mac OS X market share surges 32% in one year
yay for capitalism
xlnt··on Stop blaming PowerPoint. Learn how to kick some arse with it
Summary: incompetent presenters use powerpoint badly. the incompetent event planners who hire them decided to blame powerpoint and make rules restricting its use. this is stupid and does not in fact solve the problem of having hired incompetent presenters.
xlnt··on New longevity drug mimics caloric restriction in mice
Evolution does not create features by accident. I'm not proposing a trait. I'm proposing a lack of a trait (built-in long term life extension feature in humans), which is very different than proposing a trait, and wins by the default unless someone has an argument to the contrary.
xlnt··on Why I'm not using Lisp
More powerful language -> shorter, DRYer code -> less maintenance.

(Plus a few other reasons. See PG's essays, PG's Lisp books, and SICP if you don't know the other reasons.)

If you don't believe this, don't use Lisp. The guy writing the article does seem to believe it. He likes and respects Lisp. So he ought to analyze in the way I said.

xlnt··on Why I'm not using Lisp
So, it would take W hours to get Lisp working well. He will spend X hours writing and maintaining his python over the next Y years. And if he used Lisp instead, after the initial W hour investment, he would save Z hours on less maintenance and coding time thanks to Lisp's power.

Is Z greater than W, or less than W? That's the critical question for him.

How can he decide which approach is best without estimating the hour values of each variable?

Edit: of course there's some other issues. maybe he'd spend 80 hours on python maintenance vs 100 writing lisp unicode support. the numbers are made up, but the point is that maintenance probably isn't much fun, so one might choose the lisp path even if it takes a bit more time. besides fun, one might learn more that way.

xlnt··on New longevity drug mimics caloric restriction in mice
Aubrey de Grey has argued that caloric restriction can probably only extend life in humans by ~2 years. The idea is that it's not a percentage of lifespan that you can gain, but rather a fixed amount of time. He says the data supports his interpretation, and that it makes sense evolutionarily because extending lifespan in response to low calories is mostly useful if you can get through a short famine and get a chance to mate that would have otherwise been lost. If it's a long famine that's a much harder problem for evolution to solve and there's no evidence it is solved.

Therefore caloric restriction probably isn't very important. Does anyone know otherwise?

xlnt··on Campuses getting less political as '60s professors retire
If you don't want to be a soldier, that isn't playing politics. But as you said, that wasn't the position of most protestors.

If you say the war is immoral, illegal, or unwinnable, that is getting involved politics.

xlnt··on Campuses getting less political as '60s professors retire
If that was their argument, and it's a political argument, then they were "playing politics". That's all.
xlnt··on Campuses getting less political as '60s professors retire
You say "I offer no personal view of Vietnam." but you said it was an "illegal, immoral, and unwinnable war"

Are you really unaware that people disagree on all 3 of those points? They are political positions.

xlnt··on 37signals to Drop IE6 Support
If the company doesn't allow external internet access, it isn't relevant to anyone deciding what browsers their website should support.
xlnt··on Campuses getting less political as '60s professors retire
Are you really denying that your view on Vietname is a political position, on the basis that you think you're right really strongly?
xlnt··on 37signals to Drop IE6 Support
It's exactly this attitude that has given internet forums the black eye that they still haven't recovered from.

Stop being harsh with people, and don't tell them to die.

-----

Sorry for the mirroring; I know it's often done in spite; it's just irresistibly amusing; and seriously I don't think it's good to tell people to die.

xlnt··on 37signals to Drop IE6 Support
Clarify this?
xlnt··on 37signals to Drop IE6 Support
why can't they just let people install firefox, and use ie6 for internal apps, and firefox for external apps?
xlnt··on 37signals to Drop IE6 Support
Good points. However, the benefit of the supplier and customer can coincide. If it's easier for 37signals to make their products, they can lower prices or add extra features or add polish or something.

Maybe they consider ie6 support a feature, and they think their customers will prefer some other features instead.

xlnt··on The 1 way you need to attack shyness
"Everyone is equal" is not a solution to shyness. People are often shy to speak to someone they consider worse than themselves; shyness empirically does not function as implied.
xlnt··on The 1 way you need to attack shyness
> "everyone puts their pants on one leg at a time"

i put my pants into a device which holds them open, then i stand on a platform and jump into them.

BTW I'm thinking of starting a company to sell this device. Anyone interested in being a co-founder?

xlnt··on 20 Ways to Attack Shyness
Why do you go to the party or bar? I don't attend such things.
xlnt··on 20 Ways to Attack Shyness
If you're so shy, how'd you manage to post personal information in a public forum, like this?
xlnt··on 32 Sci-Fi novels that you should add to your reading list
Neither is Atlas Shrugged.

anyway, who wants to add 32 books to their reading list all at once? it's more useful to know which are the best 3.

xlnt··on Another Over Paid Google Exec: $4 Million
to demonstrate overpaid you must compare actual pay to actual value. so provide an estimate of his value, or you have no grounds to call him overpaid.
xlnt··on Re: Why Nerds are Unpopular
There are other problems with schools, such as the model of teacher who already knows the answer, and student who must learn the material without changing any of it (no attempts to improve the ideas).

Traditional knowledge has its place, but so does criticism and reasoned judgment and new ideas, and schools are not designed to facilitate the rationalist, liberal approach.

If the role of a teacher was seen as helping the student in ways the student prefers, as if the student were a customer, it would drastically improve the classroom aspect of schools.

There are also a wide variety of smaller problems. For example, many lessons focus on solutions to old problems without enough explanation of what the problem was or why it was important to people. For someone who doesn't understand the problem situation a solution attempts to address, that solution is uninteresting.

xlnt··on Some Proof that Marijuana is a Powerful Medicine
It's not so simple. Places that supply medical marijuana get raided.
xlnt··on Some Proof that Marijuana is a Powerful Medicine
Sure, evidence is good. But one shouldn't have to prove anything before it's legal to make my own decision. A proof that marijuana has medical value would not be very important if we already had freedom on the matter (especially since we already knew it did).
xlnt··on Some Proof that Marijuana is a Powerful Medicine
It shouldn't be a matter of what is proven. It should be a matter of my own judgment about what I want to use, or not.
← PreviousPage 5 of 20Next →