HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xorfish

857 karma · joined December 30, 2016

submissionscomments
xorfish··on Wild mammal biomass has declined by 85% since the rise of humans
So eating humans is only wrong, because other people think it is wrong and there are laws against it?

I find that really shortsighted. Slavery isn't bad because we as a society have decided it so. It always has been bad.

xorfish··on Private Prisons Are Behind the Push for Homeless Criminalization
I don't think it is a good idea to reduce the supply over time. It may make sense in some cases, but some addicts are better of by having a constant supply. Pharmaceutical grade opioids are pretty safe. Far safer than legal drugs like tobacco or alcohol.
xorfish··on Inflation is at a 40 year high. What can history teach us?
Fixing infrastructure is not always useful.

Infrastructure for low density suburbs is a money pit that bankrupts cities.

Here is a good playlist that explains why this is the case:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y_SXXTBypIg&list=PLJp5q-R0lZ...

xorfish··on Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlier for everyone else
Ideally cities would function without cars.
xorfish··on ‘Effective Altruism’ Is Neither
> "I don't like these people and these people support EA, so EA is bad. Also I think trickle down economics is an accurate model."

This would have been a much shorter article without losing substance.

xorfish··on After weight-loss surgery, a year of joys and disappointments (2016)
Taking a break every few weeks is a really good idea, it is also how most bodybuilders go about achieving ~5% body fat.

I'd also recommend measuring weight loss as percentage of body weight.

xorfish··on After weight-loss surgery, a year of joys and disappointments (2016)
Being "off diet" (at roughly maintenance) for a week or two every few weeks seems to make a diet easier to stick to and keep your target weight once yo reach it.

This goes into a bit more detail:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8HVdLMnr40M

xorfish··on The Uber leak exposes the global war on workers
> Everything related to transportation sucks.

That is not the case everywhere. There are plenty of walkable places with good public transport systems.

As the saying goes:

"A developed country is not a place where the poor have cars. It's where the rich use public transportation."

xorfish··on Why America can’t build
Have you been to Switzerland?

Going on a hike where you don't need to go back to the place you started is pretty convenient.

xorfish··on Why America can’t build
There is this thing called trains and public transport.

I don't live in a city. I don't have or need a car. I can do nearly everything with a 10 minute walk. There are two city centers available to me within a 20 minute train ride and many more with a 1.5h train ride.

You don't need cars to have "access" to cities.

xorfish··on A Response
People in richer nations report to be happier and a higher life satisfaction than people from poorer nations. Most countries now have higher self reported life satisfaction and happiness than in the past.

Rates of mental health disorders haven't changed much during the last 30 years.

https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/gdp-vs-happiness

https://ourworldindata.org/happiness-and-life-satisfaction

https://ourworldindata.org/global-mental-health

xorfish··on ‘Anti-hunger’ molecule forms after exercise, scientists discover
That is not a good rate to lose weight. A rate of ~1% per week for 3-4 months followed by 1-2 months of maintenance before the next weight loss phase is much more sustainable and you are more likely to not gain back the weight after the target weight is achieved.
xorfish··on Ranked-Choice Voting Is More Democratic, Not Less
Proportional voting for congress per state would solve this.

If the 27 seats from New York would be distributed via proportional voting, then a party with just a few percent of votes can get some political power.

xorfish··on Current guidelines for sun exposure are unhealthy and unscientific – research (2019)
Is there solid evidence, not just theorizing, for this?

Our bodies can deal with damaged DNA.

Proving that low rates of DNA damage increase cancer risk proportionaly to the risk asociated with high rates of damage seems nearly impossible.

So I don't understand the absolute certanty with which it gets proclaimed as fact.

xorfish··on Current guidelines for sun exposure are unhealthy and unscientific – research (2019)
I find the advice 'all sun exposure is bad' pretty unhelpful. It is on the same level as teaching abstinence as sex education.

Our bodies deal with some form of damage all the time.

Is there really evidence that someone that slowly builds up a tan during spring has a higher risk of skin cancer than someone who doesn't?

I can't really imagine how you could study that in a controlled way.

xorfish··on Where are the articles asking why men don't want to have children?
You can have a baby with protected sex. No birth control except abstinence is 100% effective. It is much worse if you look only at methods that men have control over.

Birth control for men is still quite limited. There is not a single non-permanent method that has a effectiveness of over 90% per year per couple. The closest to that is the condom:

https://www.plannedparenthood.org/learn/birth-control/condom

Giving men equal rights in the decision to become a parent would mean giving them the right to legal parental surrender.

xorfish··on My Life as a Mentalist
Because the other players will react differently to the same moves and you get different boards after the first few moves.
xorfish··on My Life as a Mentalist
> After the masters are duly impressed, he makes it clear that all he did was play the first master’s move against the second, the second against the third, and so on. It’s an ibvious trick but he does it so well, no one seems to notice at the time.

That strategy doesn't work.

xorfish··on No news is good news
There is also the pandemic that killed around 1 in 400 worldwide and is still causing around 15'000 deaths per day.
xorfish··on Covid and the Heart: It Spares No One – Johns Hopkins
You have no way of knowing if the increased risk materializes for you.

Saying that playing russian roulette doesn't affect you if you don't get the bullet is nonsensical.

xorfish··on Covid and the Heart: It Spares No One – Johns Hopkins
The increased risk affects everyone, even if the risk doesn't materialize for everyone.
xorfish··on The Future is Vast: Long-term perspective on humanitys past, present and future
No, halve of the people that ever died, did so in the last two thousand years.

Less than 9 billion people lived before the agricultural revolution.

xorfish··on How to Prepare for a Recession
The number of shares sold and bought are always exactly the same.
xorfish··on I'm Too Risk-Averse for Index Investing
1) is only true if the average active investor that switches to index funds is better informed than the average active investor. If a less informed investor switches from active to passive, then price discovery is improved.

2) is only an issue if the underlying assets don't have any value or you need to sell at the worst possible moment. ETFs generally improve the liquidity of in a liquidity crisis.

xorfish··on Russia Cannot Win The War
Putin doesn't win when a tank is at a specific place in Kyiv.

Putin doesn't have the economy, the material nor the young men for a prolonged occupation of Ukraine.

Without a prolonged occupation, there is no win for Putin. He may install a puppet regime, but that will fall as soon as Russian forces leave the country.

xorfish··on Tell HN: If You Are in Russia
Except the explicit words of the dictator of Russia.

There is nothing to contradict the view, that Putin doesn't want to restore the old Tsar or Soviet borders.

xorfish··on Defensive tactics from the modern history of urban warfare
Putin doesn't have the time for a siege.

The propaganda machine still speaks of a special operation to liberate Ukraine.

You can't keep up this picture for long. There are too many communication channels between Ukranians and Russians that will chip away at this warped image of reality.

xorfish··on Russian-manufactured armored vehicle vulnerability in urban combat (1997)
There are multiple pro European parties, but only one pro Russian party.

Here is the map that shows the support for the pro Russian party.

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/56/%D0%95%D...

There are very few districts, that have more than 50% support for the pro-Russian party. You also can't assume that the voters that voted for a pro Russian party want to be part of Russia and support the invasion.

xorfish··on Russian-manufactured armored vehicle vulnerability in urban combat (1997)
Pro-Russia parties got less than 10% of the vote in the last election. It is hard to imagine that the sentiment moved in Putins favor since then.

Putin is invading a country that nearly unanimously opposes him with troops that thought that they were just there for an exercise and don't really want to invade their brother country.

xorfish··on Russian forces invade Ukraine after Putin orders attack
The voice of the people always matters to some degree. Especially if said dictator wants you to risk your life or the life of your loved ones for his conquests.
← PreviousPage 2 of 14Next →