HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xorfish

857 karma · joined December 30, 2016

submissionscomments
xorfish··on Why obsessively following successful people online is dangerous
I think the world would be a better place if we accepted that we do not really have controll.

Poverty and Crime are not moral failings.

Presumably we would make the lives of such people far better if we attribute their missfortune to just bad luck.

Redistributing wealth from people that got lucky is also simpler than if we'd attribute their success to their goodness.

xorfish··on Why obsessively following successful people online is dangerous
> Except maybe in how we think about justice perhaps. But that's not useful now.

This is a big one.

Income and wealth inequality is another one.

The only reason why someone should have more than someone else is to incentivize to increase the total cake. But you probably can redistribute far more without reducing the total cake too much.

xorfish··on Why obsessively following successful people online is dangerous
> you yourself are no more meaningful and it's thus appropriate to assign you responsibility for your actions.

I don't follow this.

We don't blame people for actions when we think that they don't have control over these actions.

If someone has their first epileptic episode while driving a car and they kill someone because of it, we understand that they had no control and don't hold them responsible for the accident. Why should it be different if the causes are more complex and harder to trace back?

xorfish··on Why obsessively following successful people online is dangerous
Thanks for correcting the judge study. It seems that cases with a higher chance of success are also scheduled earlier as the time it takes is less certain.

My understanding is that a portion of the remaining 95% are responsible for turning genes and whole chains of them on and off or something in between.

There is no place in the physical world where this control could come from.

The factors that influence are hugely complex and very hard to separate. Just because we do not understand how certain factors interact and influence our behavior doesn't mean we have control.

xorfish··on Why obsessively following successful people online is dangerous
Biology and especially neurobiology has made huge steps to understanding the brain and how human behavior comes to be. DNA (Genes are only a very small portion of our DNA, the interesting stuff happens in the other 95% of our DNA) interacts with the prenatal environment, the culture you grow up, the relationship with your parents, the levels of hormones in your blood, how warm you feel, how long ago your last meal was and many more factors to form human behavior.

> And it leaves us with as much control over our ability to act as any other control

No, there is no fundamental ability to control. We have some illusion of control. Don't mistake this for saying that humans can't change, we just have no control over how we change.

Judges that decide over parole won't attribute their decision on the last time they ate, even if it is the single most important factor to their decision.

It will be interesting to observe how society will react to this in the next 50 years when the science will become harder and harder to deny.

xorfish··on Why obsessively following successful people online is dangerous
DNA is just one puzzle piece that explains human behavior, together with many other factors.

Those factors are not yours to control. Even if you are able to influence some of them, the ability to do so is dependent on factors you do not control.

xorfish··on Why obsessively following successful people online is dangerous
> The truth is that probably most successful people can't tell luck, serendipity and hard-work from wisdom. Times change, opportunities change etc. so how much is advice really worth?

The ability to work hard is also always 100% luck.

Humans do not control their DNA or what environment shaped them to be able and have the desire to work hard.

xorfish··on A World Without Sci-Hub
That outdated view in your comment is exactly what I mean.

There might be an argument if the US actually had lower crime or recidivism rates than European countries, but it does not have that.

Yes, it takes some effort to overcome that primal view on justice, but it leads to a more humane society with less crime.

xorfish··on A World Without Sci-Hub
The US has the highest prison population per capita in the world.

Mostly because of an outdated view on justice and crime.

xorfish··on The Science of the Benefits of Religion
Religion isn't that easily defined.

Are Confucianism and American Civil Religion religions?

God, Gods or even believe in the supernatural are not necessary parts of religion, some religions place much higher importance on rituals than on their believe systems.

xorfish··on Lab-grown meat may never be cost-competitive enough to displace traditional meat
For market forces to work, we need to attribute some monetary value to the quality of life of animals.

Eggs from chicken that have more space and can go outside suffer less but are more expensive to produce.

Ignorance or questionable ethics should not be rewarded by monetary gain. That is why relying on consumers to "vote with their wallet" is a fundamentally broken design.

External costs should always be included in the price of a product.

xorfish··on Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic containers starting 2023
How big is the problem with plastic in developed countries with functioning waste management?

Does the use of plastic reduce food waste?

xorfish··on Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic containers starting 2023
Kurzgesagt uploaded a video two days ago about climate change: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yiw6_JakZFc

Fighting plastic packaging is one of the environmental issues that get an unreasonable amount of attention.

It is more "look we did something" than "look we actually make an impact"

xorfish··on Lab-grown meat may never be cost-competitive enough to displace traditional meat
No, if you implement a efficient system to transfer wealth, you don't subsidize meat as meat and plant based food are treated equally.

If a less lucky person (or what you call poor) receives money, they are still incentivized to spend the money efficiently. With the money they have available now, they can buy less meat but more plant based food than before.

xorfish··on Lab-grown meat may never be cost-competitive enough to displace traditional meat
If you include external costs, how much should suffering of mammals cost?
xorfish··on Lab-grown meat may never be cost-competitive enough to displace traditional meat
I hear this statement all the time, it is never sourced.

If Jews can grow tomatoes in the desert, then what land could possibly not used for agriculture?

Besides, the majority of the land use that is used for growing animals or growing animal feed is in the lather category.

So as it is a statement that is always asserted without evidence, it can also be dismissed without evidence.

xorfish··on Lab-grown meat may never be cost-competitive enough to displace traditional meat
Demand for food is pretty inelastic.

If the external costs were included, consumer would simply be forced to pay for their consumption.

This would give a fair advantage for food that has less external costs.

External costs are also hard to estimate, especially if they is burdened on another species. How much is the suffering of a chicken worth?

xorfish··on The Psychology of Betting Big and Losing It All
> Similarly Hugh Hefner has lived a more fulfilling life than Charlie Munger.

How could you possibly know that?

xorfish··on Steam Top 50 Games: Over 70% now work on Linux
It seems to be 4 out of the top 10.
xorfish··on Robert Sapolsky on Depression (2009)
Nobody is really responsible for their behavior, their success or their misfortune.

This changes quite a lot about justice. There is no such thing as a just punishment. Criminals should be viewed more like we view a broken car. If someone can't be "fixed", then it is reasonable to seperate them from society. But it should be done as humanely as possible. They are not "evil".

Similarly, anyone that becomes successful should be viewed the same as a lottery winner: Just lucky. Bacause money has marginal utility for individual, redistribution of wealth becomes an optimizing game to maximize the average well beeing. There is a good Two Minute Papers that explores somthing like that:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sr2ga3BBMTc

Last poverty is not a moral failing. Just bad luck.

xorfish··on Robert Sapolsky on Depression (2009)
Especially if they want to discuss Free Will.
xorfish··on Robert Sapolsky on Depression (2009)
I read his newer book, "Behave: The Biology of Humans at Our Best and Worst".

The book changed my view of the world quite a bit. Especially about wealth, poverty, crime and justice.

xorfish··on The uncanny absence of nihilism
Humans live like animals. Homo Sapiens is part of the group animals.
xorfish··on The death of the ‘Millionaire Next Door’ dream
The average real return of equities is 5.3%.

https://www.credit-suisse.com/about-us-news/en/articles/medi...

xorfish··on Climate change: IPCC report is 'code red for humanity'
That is exactly what happens with a redistributed carbon tax.
xorfish··on Climate change: IPCC report is 'code red for humanity'
Yes, I think the point still stands. A carbon tax is an efficient measure that will reduce emissions and not harm poor demographics.

However there are other things we can do as well to reduce emissions as well as increase life quality at the same time (improve public transport and bicycle infrastructure) where poor people benefit especially.

xorfish··on Climate change: IPCC report is 'code red for humanity'
Investments into public transport and bike infrastructure is relatively cheap and improves streets for everyone.

Taking a car lane and/or parking and making a dedicated bus and bike lane out of it will reduce congestion and increase the mobility of nearly everyone.

xorfish··on Climate change: IPCC report is 'code red for humanity'
They still have the incentive, they would gain more money if they have a smaller carbon footprint.
xorfish··on Climate change: IPCC report is 'code red for humanity'
Only if the tax isn't redistributed.

Most poorer people would get money in such a system.

xorfish··on The first two hours of MTV (1981) [video]
Look at this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=48bfKs5p4Ik

Not that bad, but then you realize that there isn't a single cut in the video.

← PreviousPage 4 of 14Next →