HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xorfish

857 karma · joined December 30, 2016

submissionscomments
xorfish··on Coronavirus protein treatment trial 'a breakthrough'
The price of a stock doesn't matter. A company with 100'000 shares that are worth $100 isn't worth more than a company that has 10 million shares that are worth $1.
xorfish··on Swiss Political System: More Than You Ever Wanted to Know
That is not what is happening in Switzerland. There isn't reallya reason why ot would play out differently in the USA.

The beginning might be turbulent, but that should cha.ge after a few years

xorfish··on Swiss Political System: More Than You Ever Wanted to Know
How is this connected to the post?
xorfish··on Swiss Political System: More Than You Ever Wanted to Know
How would the country destroy itself?
xorfish··on Swiss Political System: More Than You Ever Wanted to Know
Note that there were was significant civil unrest at that time.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1918_Swiss_general_strike

xorfish··on Swiss Political System: More Than You Ever Wanted to Know
Concordance is more or less a consequence of referenda.

An opposition party with enough support could force a referendum on every law. Giving them power prevents this tactic.

xorfish··on Research database explores racial bias in police shootings (2019)
You know, the US is the only developed country where police officers that are called on an unarmed drunk person, end up killing him. You can find excuses for nearly every instance all day, but in the end you can't expect model behaviour from a drunk person. You can however expect two well trained sober offers to handle something like this without an escalation to deadly force.

I mean 40 times higher than the developed world. Do you agree, that this is an unacceptable level of violence?

xorfish··on Research database explores racial bias in police shootings (2019)
Police with bad training kill more and are killed more, not really a surprise there. A better trained police would reduce the number of violent encounters and be less likely to be killed in a violent encounter.

I mean it is factor 40. This are third world numbers. I don' really think there is a valid excuse for that.

It may be that the majority of prisoners are there for violent crimes. But how many of them were in prison for a non-violent offence the first time?

The percentage of innocent people in prison is probably below 10%. But the number of exonerations of the innocent project and the difficulties and issues they uncover, make it hard to believe, that it is in the lower single digit range. Most of the time it is just pure luck that a false conviction is overturned. So there must be many more.

Today we know just how unreliable eye-witness testimony is, especially of a different ethnicity, yet it has been a major way criminals are identified.

xorfish··on Research database explores racial bias in police shootings (2019)
So the taser is deadly? Why was it pulled in the first place? How many times can a taser be fired? Brooks is running away, are you seriously suggesting that he posed a serious thread to the officers?

Nevertheless, the incident shows at best how grossly incompetent the police in the US are,however manslaughter is certainly also a reasonable interpretation.

Alcohol is the most dangerous drug. Are merchants responsible if they sell alcohol?

xorfish··on Research database explores racial bias in police shootings (2019)
Police killings in the US are around 40 times higher per capita than in the rest of the developed world. Murder Rate is also around 5 times higher than in the rest of the developed world.

Clearly this are problems that needs to be addressed.

My opinion is, that the first step to solve this issue are good safety nets for everyone.

Sentence lengths need to be reduced and victimless crimes should not be punished.

The prison system must be rebuild from the ground up to reintegrate offenders to reduce the risk of re-offending.

Police training needs to be improved as well. It can't be that two sober cops end up shooting a drunk that is sobering up in his car in the back because they are unable to handle such a ordinary situation.

xorfish··on The possible disappearance of a massive star in the galaxy PHL 293B
Wouldn't that be a slow process?
xorfish··on Show HN: Antimander – Optimize Congressional Districts with Genetic Algorithms
Usually each party would provide a list with their preferred representatives that can be modified.

Where I life, you can give up to 2 votes per representative. You don't need to choose 54 different politicians because "empty" votes will still count for the party.

Most people will just use the list of their party and maybe remove some that they don't like or vote double for someone they like.

xorfish··on Show HN: Antimander – Optimize Congressional Districts with Genetic Algorithms
How hard would it be to change the congressional election system to proportional voting by party?

In California you would vote for 53 representatives, each representative would be part of a party. First the seats are divided among all parties based on some system. Then within each party the seats are given to the representatives that have the most votes within the party.

This would introduce new parties to the system, no party would be able to govern alone.

xorfish··on Covid-19: The T Cell Story
I have seen that "infection level off after 10-20%" multiple times.

It is simply not true. Some areas level off at 1-2%, some at 5%, 10, 20% or whatever else. It all depends on when strong social distancing measures were taken.

There were only a few places such as NYC or Bergamo, where measures were taken too late and infections went over 20%.

xorfish··on Source code of Germany’s official covid-19 contact tracing app
https://github.com/DP-3T/documents

Here is the protocol it is based on.

xorfish··on George Floyd Protest – police brutality videos on Twitter
Extreme left. I don't think this sentiment is popular on the left as a whole.
xorfish··on George Floyd Protest – police brutality videos on Twitter
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_killings_by_law_enforc...

The US looks more like a third world country than a developed nation.

xorfish··on Wuhan hospital traffic, search engine data indicate virus activity in Fall 2019
Seems like 28-Oct-2019 was the early limit of the confidence interval.

https://virological.org/t/phylodynamic-analysis-176-genomes-...

xorfish··on Wuhan hospital traffic, search engine data indicate virus activity in Fall 2019
I'm taking about genetic diversity over time. From there you can extrapolate back to when to common ancestor existed. To within a limited number of generations.

This calculation shows this common ancestor existed between mid November to December.

xorfish··on Wuhan hospital traffic, search engine data indicate virus activity in Fall 2019
Wouldn't there be higher genetic diversity of the virus if this were the case?

There doesn't seem to be any real evidence for this theory in the genetic data we have.

xorfish··on Anders Tegnell defends Sweden's virus approach
What is the basis for this best estimate?
xorfish··on Anders Tegnell defends Sweden's virus approach
Seems highly unlikely, excess mortality is nearly 0.3% of NYC. You would need 150% of NYC to be infected to get to 0.2%.

Many seroprevalence studies with prevalence >5% also show that the IFR is in the region of 1%.

xorfish··on Anders Tegnell defends Sweden's virus approach
Scientists and the WHO estimated the IFR to be around 1% in February. Most models that estimate fatalities use that number as well.

That estimate has hardly changed.

xorfish··on Anders Tegnell defends Sweden's virus approach
Who exactly promised an apocalypse?

The early estimates for the IFR from February turned ouf to be quite accurate.

xorfish··on Me on Covid-19 contact tracing apps
Average life expectancy based on age and comorbidities of the people who die is around 10-13 years. That is not an insignificant lifetime reduction.

0.5%-2% of the people who get it, die. That is much worse than the flu that kills 0.04-0.1% of the infected. The flu itself is already pretty deadly and this is much deadlier.

xorfish··on Me on Covid-19 contact tracing apps
The Swiss COVID-19 Science Task force recommends a test at the beginning and the end of the Quarantine and if someone shows symptoms.

https://ncs-tf.ch/en/policy-briefs --> Contact Tracing

xorfish··on Me on Covid-19 contact tracing apps
But it is more 5-40% of infected that don't show any symptoms. It is also not clear how infectious people that don't show symptoms are.
xorfish··on Me on Covid-19 contact tracing apps
Any contact tracing will produce false positives and false negatives. You will notify 20-50 people per infected person, most of them will not be infected. We only have a problem if the number of false positives is in the 200+ range and the rate of infections is relatively high.

It is important to not that a short encounter will not put you into an at risk status. You need 15 minutes or whatever the health authority is long enough to make the tradeof between false negatives and false positives.

If people follow the app or not will be mostly legal protection. Countries with weak worker protection will have a harder time getting people to comply voluntarily.

I find slippery slope arguments weak. They can be used on anything to make the outcome much worse.

xorfish··on Zoom corrects usage numbers: says it has 300M daily meeting participants
Is it really that much better than it's open source alternative jitsi-meet?
xorfish··on Google Play has been spreading advanced Android malware for years
Why haven't antitrust lawsuits made it mandatory that you can chose your app store after first use like it happened with browsers?
← PreviousPage 7 of 14Next →