HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xphilter

534 karma · joined June 28, 2011

submissionscomments
xphilter··on I'm resigning from my job at Facebook
Where am I calling for suppression? I’m saying I don’t want it promoted via FB’s algorithms. The internet is open, just like the ol’ public square. As much as I hate 4chan, those idiots can still post. But FB is not the internet and never has been. It has been letting hate run amok and then promoting it. Imagine if every time I went online Comcast kept track of all the sites I went to then would recommend sites it thinks I would like. You get how that Comcast is different than the Comcast today? (Ignoring the fact that Comcast does keep track of what I visit).
xphilter··on I'm resigning from my job at Facebook
That’s not true at all. The content is filtered out according to their algorithms. They ditched the “see everything your friends are doing” feed a long time ago. Even the group and friend suggestions are tailored.

https://about.fb.com/news/2018/01/news-feed-fyi-bringing-peo...

xphilter··on I'm resigning from my job at Facebook
I honestly don’t understand how this ignorant of a comment still gets on HN. What y’all are talking about is “The Internet” where all the trash and racist are free to make whatever content they want. What everyone else is talking about is private companies that publish trash based on recommendation engines, timeline visibility algorithms, sharing functions, and whole other bunch of programmed ways to “increase engagement.” If Facebook just wants to be the internet where you publish trash then I have to go find it on my own accord then manually share it to a list of other people, or where I can make a page with no special boosting to parrot that trash, then go right ahead. But that’s not what FB is doing, so don’t pretend that is.
xphilter··on De-Escalation Keeps Protesters and Police Safer
It reads to be that you’re being purposely obtuse. Any security is going to take into account the appearance of a person. Undoubtedly you understand what that means in practice in America—-that appearance has been boiled down to just race: “be on the lookout for a black man.” It’s lazy and should be called out so that police are forced to do work and learn the difference between a non-violent angry person and a violent angry person in a crowd.
xphilter··on De-Escalation Keeps Protesters and Police Safer
Absolutely. But part of the problem seems to be that black people all look the same to cops.
xphilter··on How to Safely and Ethically Film Police Misconduct
That is a possibility, and one I think you need in a complex society. If police have a real threat of harm coming from inside a private home, they might need to enter the home before they can get a valid warrant. The problem is, police—-by doing the things in this video and though mistreatment of minorities—-are losing credibility (if they had any). Society needs to hold bad actors in police accountable so that we can be protected when they’re actually needed.
xphilter··on How to Safely and Ethically Film Police Misconduct
No, I was arguing against the parent comment. In this situation there were no exigent circumstances and so no expansion of what the law enforcement can do. I wanted to clarify that in special circumstances it is possible for a LE to order someone to move inside their house. You need consequences for this bad action so that the police have credibility to use the action in the proper situation.
xphilter··on How to Safely and Ethically Film Police Misconduct
I agree; but it is possible to have a lawful order to control someone on private property. An example was the Boston bombing manhunt where police were doing door to door searches because there was a specific, articulated threat in a defined geographic area (note, I don’t know that’s the real legal test, but I’m sure it considers factors like that).
xphilter··on How to Safely and Ethically Film Police Misconduct
Wow, thanks for posting. That’s really unfortunate and I hope they find who murdered the guard.
xphilter··on How to Safely and Ethically Film Police Misconduct
Where? Do you have a link? Let’s assume that’s true, that a crime was committed across the country. Does that give this group of law enforcement to shoot ltl rounds at unarmed people on private property and in compliance with the law? I don’t understand your reasoning.
xphilter··on How to Safely and Ethically Film Police Misconduct
But again, that’s not the law (the executive order here). They can’t go enforce things not the law. It’s not like there are armed folks running around that street making exigent circumstances. Why do you feel the need to defend something obviously indefensible?

Edit: just to be clear, given all the huff and puff by police of needing riot gear, armored trucks, giant guns, I haven’t seen any report in Minneapolis of any armed protestors or any cops coming under fire. But that doesn’t stop the cops from shooting (less than lethal) rounds.

xphilter··on In NY major crime complaints fell when cops stopped ‘proactive policing’ (2017)
Those areas are everywhere; they’re only selectively enforced in neighborhoods of color. White people don’t smoke weed, for instance? The huge rush of white folks into “legal” weed business suggests that’s not the case. But how many teenage boys in the suburbs are harassed and arrested and need to be bailed out? Imagine if all white people were stopped when they’re out in their neighborhood and actually had all those “petty” crimes enforced. (1) the policy would change overnight and (2) the arrest rate and mistrust of police would skyrocket.
xphilter··on IBM confirms layoffs are happening, but won’t provide details
I wonder how many times they try hiring consultants to do it for them. I tried consulting and it was mostly bs. I imagine if they hired good people internally they could do it. (But finding good people I probably the biggest problem...)
xphilter··on University of California Will Stop Using SAT, ACT
You can pay for tutoring that will improve your ability to answer those types of questions rather than increase your intelligence. If the standardized tests were good tests of general knowledge then paying $4,000 for a prep course shouldn’t be able to materially increase your score. You’re basically learning how to solve the SAT/ACT/LSAT puzzle, not suddenly learning a few years of school in 2 weeks.
xphilter··on Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR
It would be a terrible solution if they did that I hope they don’t). I imagine they have specified what the legal basis is for collecting and using the photos and have an exemption outlined for when they receive a deletion request.
xphilter··on YouTube removes interview with professor of medicine on Covid stats and policy
I don’t follow. When you protest at Walmart you aren’t guaranteed an audience either (people can ignore you and walk away). And when you make a video you don’t get granted an audience either. Why should YouTube have to help you out?
xphilter··on Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR
That’s why I put in the disclaimer. I don’t think you would rely on consent in that instance. Probably would have to use the “legitimate interest” and have some rules around how photos are taken and used (e.g., people in the background where the soccer player is the target of the photo vs taking a photo of a single fan in attendance).
xphilter··on Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR
Not to be a stickler, but if you’re at an NBA game you contractually agree to allow that photo to be taken and displayed (under US law). Obviously it’d be different under EU law though.
xphilter··on YouTube removes interview with professor of medicine on Covid stats and policy
Thanks! That’s what I was trying to refer to. But that seems different in a few ways. First, there’s actually physical open spaces in malls where the public is invited—you don’t have to shop. Second, the protest in a mall is ephemeral. Youtube is like a store in the mall, not the open forum (I don’t think Macy’s would be required to have a protest in its store); the internet is like that open space. Second, extending this to YouTube would require YouTube to proactively host a video on its servers, pay for costs to play it, and host it forever (until the protestor takes it down).
xphilter··on YouTube removes interview with professor of medicine on Covid stats and policy
According to what though? Walmart is ubiquitous; do they have to let people protest inside stores? No. Do they have to sell antivax books? No. You could maybe argue youtube is closer to a pseudo public place like a mall, but even there you couldn’t force a mall to protest on behalf of someone else or sell something. What exactly is your end game? Create a new type of forum (like physical forum) where private companies are compelled to act according to someone else’s standards?
xphilter··on Google bans Podcast Addict app over non-approved Covid-19 content
That’s impossible. Congress exempted the entire internet from court on something like this. Look at the communications decency act.
xphilter··on A small restaurant owner on Google, DoorDash, and Grubhub
I investigated a case similar to this a few years ago (as an attorney). The problem is that most of these restaurants already signed contracts with the tech company that gave away a lot, including rights like this. And because it’s B2B, it’s hard to play the “unsophisticated consumer” card.
xphilter··on Economists who defend disaster profiteers are wrong
Right. And there’s no way to have an exception just like there is today. I can’t tell if you’re all be obtuse on purpose. Is this some sort of political movement to equate minimum wage to eugenics? As is now conservatives care about the poor, disabled, and minorities? What’s crazy is that I agree with OP of this thread that economists should refrain from saying what’s moral. But that’s because most economists are just old white men, and I doubt they’re able to judge what’s moral better than others.
xphilter··on Economists who defend disaster profiteers are wrong
You are comparing adjudicating the worth of a non changeable attribute of a human to the minimum cost of labor. If you can’t see the difference between the two then I don’t know what to do. There slippery slope arguments then there are just silly arguments.
xphilter··on If nearly all Airbnb reviews are positive, does that make them meaningless?
I wish reviews would change to “would you stay/use this again?” Just yes or no. I’m sure I could get more usefulness out of an aggregation of that. Anyone have an idea of why that would or wouldn’t work?
xphilter··on Uber stops upfront ride pricing in response to California worker law
That doesn’t make any sense. Unless something else has changed, there’s no concrete way of knowing or estimating the cost of a ride. The price per mile/min is not regulated or posted like taxis. So what, you just hope surge pricing or per-rider-price-discrimination is not suddenly in play?
xphilter··on Samsung TVs May Upload Screenshots for Automatic Content Recognition
This is not new. It’s been embedded in tvs for years. You can thank judges who don’t care about consumer privacy and mandatory arbitration clauses for the spreading of this junk. If consumers could sue these companies none of this would be happening.
xphilter··on Google Gives Feds 1,500 Phone Locations in Unprecedented ‘Geofence’ Search
I am a lawyer but I still don’t understand how these warrants can be constitutional (or legal). Doesn’t it have to be specific in its request, “identifying the person or property”? First, google would have to search its entire systems for the specific location, then narrow down to the specific time. (I know it’s probably the same search. But wouldn’t that be too broad and not “identifying” enough for the warrant?
xphilter··on Ten-Hour Time-Restricted Eating Benefits Patients with Metabolic Syndrome
Maybe, but my feeling is that they are trying to attribute the benefit to intermittent fasting (which may be the mechanism! I have no ideas (and neither do they!))
xphilter··on Ten-Hour Time-Restricted Eating Benefits Patients with Metabolic Syndrome
Isn’t it just as likely that the 8% reduction in calories gave all the benefits? I briefly read the study and it didn’t seem like they had a reduced calorie group without time restrictions. Thoughts anyone?
← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →