HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xrisk

1,092 karma · joined January 20, 2016

rk@rishav.io
submissionscomments
xrisk··on India protests: Internet cut to hunger-striking farmers in Delhi
From [1]:

> Bharti Airtel Services Limited (BASL) engages mainly in selling of hardware for internet and satellite business.

Also please do elaborate on what sources of revenue that Airtel has that cause its 300M in loss while (as you claim) it makes profits in their telecom?

xrisk··on India protests: Internet cut to hunger-striking farmers in Delhi
You've linked me to a subsidiary [1] (that too one that sells telecom hardware)? Airtel the co has made 300M INR in losses for 2019-2020 [2]

[1]: https://www.emis.com/php/company-profile/IN/Bharti_Airtel_Se...

[2]: https://assets.airtel.in/teams/simplycms/web/docs/Airtel-Int...

xrisk··on India protests: Internet cut to hunger-striking farmers in Delhi
... You realize that it set pricing across operators forcing literally every single one of them into losses?
xrisk··on India protests: Internet cut to hunger-striking farmers in Delhi
Because the APMC has to pay the cess and they supply India's PDS and various important things? Or would you have them do away with those too?
xrisk··on India protests: Internet cut to hunger-striking farmers in Delhi
I never claimed that they always work as expected. That is not an excuse to do away with them.

As for the shtick that they will not abolish mandis, that is already demonstrably untrue [1]. It is trivial to observe that big corp will utterly destroy them and then coerce farmers into bad contracts when they have no alternative.

As for your argument that the "free market" will improve the situation, for the record, it has been done before and has miserably failed. [2]

For posterity, I would recommend that you don't cite sources that are essentially blog posts with zero data or theory. I might as well cite the Communist Manifesto then. There is actual serious work on this matter.

[1]: https://www.newsclick.in/Fallout-Farm-Laws-New-Laws-Paralyse...

[2]: https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/agriculture/bihar-scrapp...

xrisk··on India protests: Internet cut to hunger-striking farmers in Delhi
> Where are the mandis going? If they are non-competitive, they are out.

They would be non-competitive because of the no taxation clause that the bill has -- allowing big corp to undercut the mandis. Not to mention that corps are known to take losses just to establish market monopoly (see Jio).

> But in Punjab where they are there, no one is allowed.

I don't understand why you cite the mandi as a monopoly, when in the existing system a farmer can choose to sell anywhere they want?

Let the big corps procure from the farmers, at a "competitive price" as you say. Why should they deserve tax breaks?

The fact of the matter is that the mandi is desirable and has contributed to the material success of Punjab's farmers. There is no doubt that there are inefficiencies and leakages, but to do away with them in deference to the gods of the "free market" is a bit questionable. Unrelated quote: "the quality of public education might not be very good, but that doesn't mean we do away with it".

As for your comparison with other states, I would recommend you check out this article: https://www.hindustantimes.com/opinion/why-punjab-should-not...

xrisk··on India protests: Internet cut to hunger-striking farmers in Delhi
The Indian government actively colludes with big corp; forget about breaking up monopolies (see: Jio).

As for the claim that the new laws allow anybody to approach a farmer with a better deal; sure that works in theory -- but notice that 1) that only works if there isn't a monopoly that drives prices (consider Jio that successfully monopolized telecom in India and now effectively sets prices throughout the industry) 2) farmers would be contractually obligated to sell produce (which would be a long-term deal).

The issue might be alleviated if the government promises to enforce a minimum price on all contracts made, but it will do nothing of that sort.

As for selling directly to end customers, in my limited knowledge, that is not a thing in India.

xrisk··on India protests: Internet cut to hunger-striking farmers in Delhi
> There was monopolies of mandis(farmer are restricted only to sell here) now government allows them to make contract or sell anywhere.

This is factually incorrect [1]. Only about 30% [2] of produce is sold in mandis.

Any anti-mandi law is essentially an anti-farmer law; because mandis act as a safety net for farmers. No farmer can negotiate good deals with big corp, and once the buyer side is monopolized (ala Jio); the farmer is forced into bad contracts. What the government should do is implement mandi reforms.

[1]: https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/opinion/can-free-trade-...

[2]: https://www.downtoearth.org.in/blog/agriculture/by-pushing-f...

xrisk··on India protests: Internet cut to hunger-striking farmers in Delhi
Once the mandis are gone, what prevents a monopolized market from then strong-arming farmers into bad deals? Farmers do not have leverage to negotiate good deals with big corps, and when the mandis eventually die away (simply due to this bill); they will be forced to enter into exploitative deals.

EDIT

> But can ONLY sell the produce to the local Mandi.

This is factually incorrect. Only about 30% of produce is sold in mandis. [1] [2]

[1] https://www.downtoearth.org.in/blog/agriculture/by-pushing-f...

[2] https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/opinion/can-free-trade-...

xrisk··on India protests: Internet cut to hunger-striking farmers in Delhi
He's talking about the fact that the RSS did not raise the Indian flag till about 2002. And that their historical opposition to the flag is well documented.
xrisk··on India protests: Internet cut to hunger-striking farmers in Delhi
> It's also true that existing power nexus like these farmer brokers who are spearheading the protest. You may ask where they get their money from go continue the protest? Basically from the existing network of exporters of fruits, vegetables, grains etc... These farmering group head ask for bribes and favours and then sell government subsidized produce to select companies who rendered those favours.

Can you please address the issues highlighted by the farmers instead of speculating on where they obtain funding from? In particular how will the passage of the farm bills prevent this practice that you claim exists? As I see it, it would just allow large players to gobble up the competition (ala Jio).

xrisk··on WhatsApp loses millions of users after terms update
I wouldn't conflate privacy with encryption necessarily.
xrisk··on This Anime Does Not Exist
What do you mean by autogenerated content? Nothing comes to mind that's also not super niche (stuff like generated music etc)
xrisk··on We can do better than Signal
Yes, the solution is … allow the protocol to let people run their own servers?
xrisk··on We can do better than Signal
Sure it does, but I'm more inclined to trust my own server than trust Signal's server (thus reducing the need for that verification to happen in the first place)
xrisk··on We can do better than Signal
Yeah, TLS solves that right? So we can agree that a decentralized system effectively removes the need to ever trust any third party system?
xrisk··on We can do better than Signal
Not if it's targeted towards a particular pair of people.
xrisk··on We can do better than Signal
> An attack would only be invisible if it happened from the first communication.

This is the scenario I'm talking about.

xrisk··on We can do better than Signal
Yes, but I can get all the parties I want to talk to on my own server (if the need arises).

About your point the connection itself being MITMed, I don't exactly understand how an active attacker sitting on my connection would undermine the connection? Presumably I have a way to verify the identify of my server. Please do elaborate if I'm missing something. Regardless an interesting thought.

xrisk··on We can do better than Signal
Copy pasting my comment:

Consider this paragraph from the Signal protocol

> ...For example, they may compare public key fingerprints manually, or by scanning a QR code. Methods for doing this are outside the scope of this document.

> If authentication is not performed, the parties receive no cryptographic guarantee as to who they are communicating with.

Nobody I know in practice does this authentication. If an active attack is carried out, I'm reasonably sure people would not notice.

xrisk··on We can do better than Signal
Why? I trust that my own server is not backdoored (thus reducing the need for off-channel fingerprint verification), I have no such guarantee about Signal's server.
xrisk··on We can do better than Signal
> If we could do better, we would have done better by now.

We should have given up on Linux UIs way back then. They're still garbage when it compares to the alternatives.

xrisk··on We can do better than Signal
So one of the things that feels the most damning to me about Signal-like protocols is that you have to inherently trust their server.

Consider this paragraph from the Signal protocol

> ...For example, they may compare public key fingerprints manually, or by scanning a QR code. Methods for doing this are outside the scope of this document.

> If authentication is not performed, the parties receive no cryptographic guarantee as to who they are communicating with.

I have not known anybody that actually does this. If an active attack does happen on somebody, I'm pretty sure they would not notice.

As far as I understand, a decentralized model solves this problem. Don't trust the server? Run your own instance or have some other way of validating clients (via your own PKI infra or similar).

xrisk··on Signal Is Back
Why would they blacklist IPs? The bans I've seen (in India) are based on sniffing SNI. Using AWS doesn't help at all in that case.
xrisk··on Ask HN: What are you working on?
Reading a bunch of computational social science papers and trying to figure out whether pivoting into social science halfway through a CS degree was a wise choice :)

In general: trying to figure out if academia is worth it or whether I should go join a startup afterwards :P

xrisk··on WhatsApp whitepaper removed sentence about never having access to private keys
Somehow I don’t buy it. Care to explain? One would think that being hosted on US soil makes it more likely to get backdoored by NSA type agencies.
xrisk··on Signal WhatsApp Chats Import
So is the model similar to that of WhatsApp web? can you receive messages on the desktop app if your phone is switched off?
xrisk··on Signal WhatsApp Chats Import
Off-topic but does Signal support independent multi-device yet? Sorry I can’t find reliable information about it online!
xrisk··on WhatsApp whitepaper removed sentence about never having access to private keys
I’d rather take the service which is not hosted on US servers over one that is, given that I can verify neither of their server code.
xrisk··on Rocky Linux: A CentOS replacement by the CentOS founder
This… is not the place to rant about Linux? Desktop compatibility is not the goal of CentOS style distros.
← PreviousPage 7 of 14Next →