1,092 karma · joined January 20, 2016
Sure, I don’t deny it. However, just adding a ton of space doesn’t make a design good. Especially when you actively harm functionality while doing that.
From my limited experience doing design, I’ve realized that good contrast and active visual demarcations go a long way towards that goal (both things which the new UI is sorely missing).
See the old Mail UI: https://support.apple.com/library/content/dam/edam/applecare...
Notice the breadcrumbs that you could use to conveniently use as favorite inboxes. Those are gone now, which means that you have to keep the left sidebar always exposed (thus taking up significantly more horizontal space). This was what I think is really good design, thoughtful and non-intrusive.
Not everyone is working on large screens. Adding a ton of padding to all UI elements doesn’t improve usability in the slightest, regardless of what you might say.
This difference is more noticeable when I’m looking up a word in the dictionary, looking up a contact etc, or searching for an email/file. Why do I have to press another key?!
Look at the Mail app for example, you could previously view “inboxes” at the top of the app (useful because you could then resize the app to take up far lesser horizontal space); and now you can’t – just because, … no reason really?
Why would you actively degrade usability?
1. uBlock Origin - the content-based blockers on Safari are not nearly as good 2. Zotero connector - for my academic work 3. Session Buddy - for saving sessions 4. Proxy switcher - for selectively using my uni proxy for academic resources
and so on...
But are you seriously gonna blame people looking for free swag? How many of us haven’t done something for swag before?
[1] https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/parliament-attac...