HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xvolter

359 karma · joined August 30, 2011

Professional geek. Genius in training.

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/hutchins; my proof: https://keybase.io/hutchins/sigs/9adwbA0i3yDExaLm5lRR_cqYPitsjnHxSZMreBUyHDU ]

submissionscomments
xvolter··on VPNs Are Absolutely a Solution to a Policy Problem
I had to write a more extensive response to the OP, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13998898 https://medium.com/@ben.hutchins/what-youre-revealing-to-you...

I think this ignores article too much about what is actually at risk, regardless of whether a VPN is a viable solution for some.

xvolter··on Show HN: IsTempMail – Detect and block disposable email addresses
As people already pointed out that your product isn't free, if you require knowledge about a person then they're giving you their information. Facebook doesn't cost a user money, but it costs them plenty else.

For a product with a "free tier" that doesn't work where a user needs to sign up several times, the product itself is flawed.

However, disposable emails again are not the problem, as there are tons of ways to get valid, working emails to bypass any unique email requirements. Blocking disposable emails aren't going to help you with that. The only thing you're removing it a user's access to better privacy. Again, if you require knowing who your users are then you are not a free service.

If you don't care about having users unless you know their real email addresses then you should consider validating their identity in other means, besides an email address. Many services use a text message to validate you also have a phone number that works, which is much harder to anonymize (although I personally have four different numbers for this very reason, based on the trust I give a service I decide which number I want to provide them - since to me, my privacy is worth something, I don't share it for free).

xvolter··on Show HN: IsTempMail – Detect and block disposable email addresses
This is completely ignoring the useful use cases of "disposable" emails like privacy. I have a domain that I specifically use as a catch all, so anytime I sign up for a website I use the domain as the username, like news.ycombinator.com@forward.to.me.com

This helps protect me in many ways. If my email is sold or leaked, not a big issue, I can just add that specific email to a blacklist and I never need to get spam from it again. Or if I cancel and keep getting spam about rejoining, blacklisted. It makes it easy to keep my spam and newsletters to a minimal.

It has the built in advantage that I can always sign up for new trials if I want, just do thatdomain.com1@ thatdomain.com2@ and so on. Although I don't do this often, I have had to do it for various reasons.

I've hit on occasion websites that block their domain from being in the email address, likely a poorly implemented security check because their software might say anyone with a "@service.com" email is an admin or something. In that case, I enter some random crap. I never have to remember the emails, since I can just search my email history for the address the service sent the registration confirmation to.

However, the downside is privacy. I use my own domain, which contains my full name, so when I sign up to some services and want to do so without giving my name, I still rely on a disposable email service such as hidemyass.com; and I do this for many online services. I am not a believer that everything I sign up for needs to know my full name, address, and email - often services ask for this information for no reason.

So attempting to block these types of services, that have valid and useful benefits to users, simply harms your users. You can avoid spam users with a captcha, and for trail abusers you already can't do much because @gmail.com already allows for a lot of aliases to work like @googlemail.com, or user.@gmail.com or u.s.e.r@gmail.com etc, or user+whatevertheywant@gmail.com

Don't harm your users with useless validations.

xvolter··on Ask HN: Is S3 down?
Seeing the same here
xvolter··on Filecoin – A Cryptocurrency Operated File Storage Network
Seems really annoying to get setup with Sia though. You need to have at least 50,000 SC to begin hosting, and you can't earn SC until you start hosting. You even need SC to announce your host (15 SC), and the apps don't explain if the software deals with dynamic IPs or if it supports hostnames instead of just IPv4 addresses. Also, it seems like it is only using IPv4 addresses, kind of short minded for modern technology.

How are you even supposed to get started using Sia if there's no way to do it except to go and spend money. The point of being able to host files is that I'll offer up some storage on my NAS, earn coins, then be able to backup some of my own important documents on the network. Seems like if I have to dish out money to get started I doubt I'd ever be able to maintain the service without continuously spending money. So many other syncing technologies seem easier than this.

xvolter··on Time to Encrypt the Cloud
I definitely think that cryptpad.fr doesn't know the meaning.

Keybase's entire purpose is to make a public database of people. They know who you are, therefore, they have some knowledge.

Not that complicated. If you store user profile data and therefore link the data they store to that profile, it is not zero knowledge.

Arguably, if you have to charge money for a service, you might need a way to do that, but then you're not zero knowledge. Or you just a flat rate with unlimited of whatever your service provides.

I don't think it makes a lot of sense to trust a company that claims to be secure when they don't understand even the terminology, let along the complexities, of providing security and privacy.

xvolter··on “Sonicwall products are not returnable”
This is irrelevant if you use a proper business account like American Express. You have return protection, are able to return anything within 90 days, if ymthe merchant won't accept it then the payment processor does a charge back and returns your money.
xvolter··on Fixing JSON
I'd see a trailing or leading comma as a potentially null, or undefined. It's intentionally against spec. I personally see the concatenation an issue in particular with streaming. Streaming JSON objects and parsing them on the fly is a pain, usually requiring a SAX parser. To concat two objects though, I feel like you could just merge the two, if you are okay with appending two arrays, if you had to merge two JSON objects you could. Numbers I seen issues with, I've had to store numbers as strings before, there is guidance however, the official ECMA-404 spec for JSON says there can be any number of digits following a "." in numbers, then optionally followed by an "e", "+" or "-" and more digits. For parsing then, it would be limited by the data types available to the parser. Since JavaScript itself is 17, so that would be the default maximum for JSON IMHO. However, different libraries for different languages may not have 17 for the native decimal types.
xvolter··on Fixing JSON
I don't believe the original purpose of JSON was to eval untrusted objects, since that would always have posed a security risk. It did however offer a very easy standard way to share and parse data back in 1999. In 2016, I believe continued backwards compatibility is a necessity; otherwise you are just creating a new data storage format. So removing commas doesn't seem like an acceptable improvement, especially when the recommendation comes out of a necessity due to human error while hand-editing. JSON is incredibly easy to read and write by hand, in comparison with XML it is far easier to parse and traverse through code do its significantly simplified structure. If however, you need more functionality, switch to a different format; why bother trying to mangle or force JSON to work where it doesn't. There are other technologies and standards out there, use them.
xvolter··on Fixing JSON
I think if breaking changes are made, there is no point, it would not be called JSON 2.0; it is an entirely new data format. When there are hundreds to thousands of alternatives, trying to "fix JSON" isn't the solution. JSON works because it is simple and easy to follow, it is robust and flexible, and has no restrictions. There is no good way to store dates in XML or many other formats, without the use of Schemas, and the syntax changes are minimally beneficial. It wouldn't save a lot of bandwidth with gzip, and the text data likely doesn't add up to a lot of disk space when compared to the data being stored; so removing commas which make parsing JSON easy and increases its adoption and usage, just so some people can have less linting errors doesn't seem like a large benefit.
xvolter··on Fixing JSON
Yes, that would be a strongly recommended way. I could see using a unix timestamp as a numeric field as another way.
xvolter··on Fixing JSON
I was thinking along very similar lines when reading the article by Tim Bray. JSON is designed for JavaScript compatibility, I almost stopped reading when he said:

> They’re inessen­tial to the gram­mar, just there for JavaScript com­pat­i­bil­i­ty.

The entire article goes on to suggest extremely terrible solutions to the problems he is pointing out.

In order:

Commas: If comma's are an annoyance, is that to mean there is no annoyance with XML markup? You can forget a closing tag just as easily, probably more easily. Just get a JavaScript or JSON linter. Fixed. If you are really annoyed by commas, move to YAML or another format.

Datetimes: Just store your dates in a standardized timezone and format, how about [ISO 8601](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_8601). You can also use a [JSON-Schema](http://json-schema.org/) if you really want.

Schemas: There's lots of potentials here. However, again, if you're going to change JSON so much, why not just pick another data format that has better schema support.

xvolter··on A Password Manager That Doesn't Store Passwords
I've seen many implementations of this exact thing, the basic ones are just sha1 or sha2(master + website domain) which generates a unique "password" for each site. This is just another implementation of the same idea. I've seen a few releases of simple scripts that do this for you as well, some work as bookmarklets, browser extensions, or single-page app websites.

Visionary being a Python script I think makes it less portable, harder to use for average users, and definitely not mobile-device friendly.

xvolter··on For anyone who has been turned down by 38 companies
I've seen articles about technical interviews too many times to count, and while I personally don't believe whiteboarding is a good tool for interviewing and don't use it when I perform interviews, I do believe that any good engineer should be able to whiteboard answers with relative ease. The gripe really is dependent on the specific questions, however if you've worked with a technology stack you should be able to recall the function names, parameter order, and basic pseudo code syntax to write answers to questions. If a developer is dependent on their IDE or Google to do absolutely anything, I wouldn't hire that person. Even developers directly out of college have done enough programming to do the basics, and if a developer can't they should be honest about their abilities and rather than stumble through a wrong or incomplete answer. Often the interviewer will still ask you to try your best, but it's important to be honest about your capabilities.

I've interviewed at dozens of technology companies, many that do whiteboarding, and I've always done well. I've gotten offers significantly more times than I've ever been rejected, this isn't because I interview well, but because the things I claim to know and be an expert at, I know better than the back of my hand. If a software developer has been writing code and working with a set of technologies on a daily basis for years, I'd expect the same of any of them.

From what I've seen of the modern software engineers isn't that they interview poorly, or that whiteboarding is the blocking issue. It's that they're actually poor engineers. Lots of people are taking 8 to 10 week crash courses on programming and think they are near the same level as someone who went to college for four years, even tend to expect the same pay. I actually don't think college is generally useful for software engineers either, but it's about the time spent. The best programmers by far are those who started young and even program personal projects as a hobby, who actually love to write software. I love writing software, getting wrapped up and losing track of time, creating amazing software that solves difficult problems and is a delight to use. I hire developers who are the same.

xvolter··on Here Are Google, Amazon and Facebook’s Secrets to Hiring the Best People
I've seen dozens of articles about how Google, Amazon and other large tech companies hire the best. It's a terrible assumption that these tech giants hire the best, they simply can't be picky with their hiring, they need to grow teams to keep up with progress, and replace the members who are leaving. They need to hire quickly, so they refine their hiring process to get qualified candidates, but not the best candidates out there. Sure, they might eventually hire some really good people, but the majority can't be held to a hire standard.
xvolter··on How and Why I Taught My Toddler to Read (2010)
I'd be interested to learn about parents who continued focused eductions throughout childhood. While I can see that entering a public school and knowing to read won't give a lot of benefit since the child would be held back by the other students catching up, if the parent homeschooled or similar, the child may be able to continue accelerating. I'd also be interested to know if children who learn early develop better habits for learning, and therefore can learn new subjects more easily. Even an increased interest level in reading has benefit though, and I suspect a child who can read can find entertainment in books and that seems like it may help them as well.
xvolter··on What I Learned From Blowing An Interview
Agreed. My bad, probably didn't help. Was in a mood of sharing.
xvolter··on Why we moved away from GitHub
Gitlab EE (Enterprise Edition) is also open source, you can grab it and use it without an enterprise license if you really want, it's more of a trust-based system. Which I support 100%. https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ee
xvolter··on Why we moved away from GitHub
That seems like an issue for Jira, not Github IMO. Atlasssian owning both Jira and Bitbucket though, seems like they'd prefer to keep it the way it is for this very reason.
xvolter··on Why we moved away from GitHub
Agreed. This immediately shot up to the top too, suggests to me their team might have heightened it. Either way, if you want to go for cheap, use Gitlab.com which is also free to use, but can host it yourself so can be far more secure and private, and has great integration with Jira as well. Along with a ton of other issue trackers, since I personally don't like Jira.
xvolter··on What I Learned From Blowing An Interview
Statistically, regardless of what the video is, most people haven't seen it. I always find it fun when someone is surprised someone else hasn't seen a specific movie or a popular video on youtube. I believe we're well past the point where even if you wanted to spend 24/7 watching videos, you couldn't possibly see everything that exists. Kind of out of the scope of this topic, but just a fun point to make.

I definitely enjoy seeing Malcom's father give advice, or is it a drug lord giving advice... hmm...

xvolter··on Ask HN: I was hired and unhired in 2 weeks, for no reason
You've had many past ideas, such as:

http://www.scatter.fm/ (and a mobile app) - a location based deal site and mobile app for hunting deals from nearby shops.

Or https://yenbe-beta.appspot.com/

Seems like your ideas are generally around finding good deals, price hutning, so my guess is that the YCombinator startup that hired you is around the same idea. There are a few YCombinator startups that deal with simialr things; I don't have the time to find the entire list. Maybe someone else can do that and the HN community can figure out which company did this.

xvolter··on Is “Yo” Stupid Brilliant or Stupid Stupid? Let’s explore, shall we
Pet rocks could hypothetically teach someone responsibility. Yo is closer to the eye ball used on that pet rock, useless by itself.
xvolter··on Is “Yo” Stupid Brilliant or Stupid Stupid? Let’s explore, shall we
I agree. It's stupid stupid, hands down.
xvolter··on Heroku locked down
Notice they haven't mentioned what the issue is caused by, just that they consider it resolved.
xvolter··on Heroku locked down
Light purple text on dark purple on black? How about try and consider accessibility and make it readable. Terrible palette, as Heoku has always had.
xvolter··on Ask HN: Who wants to be hired? (June 2014)
Boston, MA. Local or remote preferred. Full-time, contact or part-time.

Stack: Full-stack developer; JavaScript, jQuery, CSS3, HTML5, Python, PHP, Perl, Java, native Android, Mongodb, MySQL, Amazon AWS, Ruby, C#, ASP.net, C++

Resume: https://www.linkedin.com/in/benjaminhutchins

Contact: ben(a)hutchins.co

I've worked primarily as a font-end web developer for the past several years, however in the past I've worked as a security consultant working to add encryption and privacy practices to software and as a junior-level systems admin and database admin. I've created several native Android apps on the side of my main projects and work on several open source projects to expand my knowledge https://github.com/benhutchins/

I'm a level 2 Sr. Software Engineer at my current company and am looking to join a company I can be passionate about, building a great product or service. I am not interested in moving at this point, but if the offer is reasonable enough I'd consider it. Prefer to work for a smaller company or startup where I can put to use my full stack of skills and to join a great team or a growing team.

xvolter··on Ways to avoid using the word 'very'
The article describes ways to avoid using very, not that you should replace every instance of very with another synonym. There are instances when you can easily replace "very XXX" with a more descriptive term.
xvolter··on Ways to avoid using the word 'very'
Have you ever read 1984. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newspeak

I'm of the opinion we should dispose of useless words. Why even have the word terrified in the dictionary when you can use very afraid?

Very good and you'd use superb? Over the dozens of other words that can be used to replace good? I say get rid of them all. I'd also go with the idea of removing antonyms in exchange for un- prefixed words because you do have the issue that antonyms are not exact opposite.

You also have the issue with the comparisons that very can be less intensive. Very wet does not mean soaked. Additionally, being anxious modernly implies a mixture of stress, worry, possibly fright. Potentially changing your meaning is not usually desired.

However, this article only describes how to avoid using very, and that may be a good goal. There are many times when you can better describe your meaning without using very. However, you cannot do it in every instance.

xvolter··on Electric Car owner charged for stealing electricity from school
This sounds like a situation that was just blown out of partition. An officer who cares about the theft of five cents on a single occasion is an officer with too much free time. Does he realize how much his five minutes cost tax payers when he was telling this guy about how he stole? And seriously? Stole! Five cents of electricity from a public school? The guy's a tax payer (assumption), therefore, if you follow the money, somehow he paid for the electricity to begin with. If you take that aside even more, it's better for him to steal five cents of electricity than drive a gasoline car, I'd gladly allow random strangers to charge from my parking lot outlets if it encouraged more people to go green. Considering tax money also gives free electricity to people who cannot afford it, hypothetically, if this guy was on a financial assistance program to pay for his utilities would it still be stealing considering the money is coming from the same place? It's not like five cents would hold either, the moment this is disputed it'd be dropped.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →