HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xxxxxxx12

35 karma · joined April 7, 2021

submissionscomments
xxxxxxx12··on Excess Deaths in 2020
> "lockdowns had no impact on people's behavior and therefore had no benefit" and "lockdowns had massive negative costs"

I think you're overlooking the idea that "lockdowns", as we know them, do little other than impose massive costs and anxieties on society, while failing to achieve their main objective i.e. complete immobilization and eradication.

So you end up with all the costs of the policy with little upside because the dynamics of spread seem very heterogeneous, mass-spread seems to happen in relatively few people in very particular scenarios (crowded indoor areas - notice that lockdown ends up pushing the entire society, especially the least healthy and most vulnerable, indoors).

xxxxxxx12··on Excess Deaths in 2020
They've got a fundamentally different society and lockdown is a luxury policy that only rich nations (and people) can afford.
xxxxxxx12··on Excess Deaths in 2020
> and then happy that their assumptions where validated by their models

This was done in the pro-lockdown measures camp all the time, epidemiologists, etc. love using models based on assumptions that are used to show scenarios as evidence of the original assumptions.

xxxxxxx12··on Excess Deaths in 2020
> I thought that the purpose of lockdown (in the UK at least) was to prevent health care from being overwhelmed

Which never really pans out (field hospitals, hospital ship sent to NYC, etc.) - they got strained and perhaps local spots overwhelmed, but never doomsday scenarios we hear bandied about without any evidence. His point is that lockdown doesn't really change behavior and places that don't have strong mandates end up largely practicing safer behavior anyway.

I think there's also a strong argument that lockdown ends up decreasing the time spent outdoors, which promotes spread.

xxxxxxx12··on Excess Deaths in 2020
Look up Hope-Simpson's work on influenza epidemiology, he observed seasonality like you say, but there are certain regimes that correspond to latitudes.
xxxxxxx12··on Excess Deaths in 2020
FWIW, an economist published this paper recently estimating "the cost/benefit ratio of lockdowns in Canada, in terms of life-years saved, is between 3.6–282":

> Generally speaking, the ineffectiveness of lockdown stems from voluntary changes in behavior. Lockdown jurisdictions were not able to prevent noncompliance, and non-lockdown jurisdictions benefited from voluntary changes in behavior that mimicked lockdowns. The limited effectiveness of lockdowns explains why, after one year, the unconditional cumulative deaths per million, and the pattern of daily deaths per million, is not negatively correlated with the stringency of lockdown across countries. Using a cost/benefit method proposed by Professor Bryan Caplan, and using two extreme assumptions of lockdown effectiveness, the cost/benefit ratio of lockdowns in Canada, in terms of life-years saved, is between 3.6–282. That is, it is possible that lockdown will go down as one of the greatest peacetime policy failures in Canada’s history.

http://www.sfu.ca/~allen/LockdownReport.pdf

xxxxxxx12··on Cryptocurrency Is an Abject Disaster
> yet it shows no similar characteristics to preexisting inflation hedges

Is that because, so far, if you were to measure since its inception, it's outperformed any other hedge against inflation?

xxxxxxx12··on CDC says many Americans can now go outside without a mask
It's funny how people act like the CDC is setting important rules here when people generally laugh off their advice as absurd when it comes to alcohol, food consumption, etc.
xxxxxxx12··on On Social Media, American-Style Free Speech Is Dead
I think it's worth recognizing that there is systemic liberal bias in most of the media and cultural institutions.

And liberals have been trending towards authoritarianism, no doubt.

So it's not all that surprising that lowercase-L liberal attitudes, which can be described as essentially based in protection of individuals from the arbitrary will of majorities, are falling to the wayside in a lot of cultural spheres.

xxxxxxx12··on India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists
> so it's mysterious to me why people are so vehemently against one with no downsides

Humans have millions of years of evolution searing into their DNA the impulse to socialize with other humans.

I think you're underestimating the effect of completely obscuring the face - how people indicate subtle social cues, emote, and communicate.

This ignores that masking is a nuisance, I don't care what other people say: they're virtue-signalling, Stockholm syndrome victims in my opinion.

Breathing fresh air, unabated, is one of the greatest pleasures in life.

xxxxxxx12··on Cryptocurrency Is an Abject Disaster
The ceiling of BTC is infinite cause USD is always falling (due to the simple dynamics of virtually every fiat system) towards a floor of 0.
xxxxxxx12··on Cryptocurrency Is an Abject Disaster
> It's created an obsession of quick wealth among a lot of otherwise normal people

It's showing a demand for an asset that isn't linked to the central planning of government where they continually and arbitrarily inject as much extra currency as they want whenever they catastrophically mess up sovereign budgets.

That's not greed. It's an interest in safety from a drug-addict-like government that opens the floodgates on a whim.

xxxxxxx12··on India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists
> I don't see how New Jersey, for example, materially differs in a relevant way in terms of population statistics from Santa Clara.

Yea clearly a science-minded person wouldn't be able to find a plethora of different variables between populations on opposite sides of the country.

Let's just assume they're homogeneous. /s

xxxxxxx12··on Bitcoin Continues to Fall
It's funny how this type of FUD is practically on a trigger (when derivative of BTC price < 0 then post FUD).

And what do you know? Less than 24 hours later and we're back into mid-50k territory.

xxxxxxx12··on MIT researchers say you’re no safer from Covid indoors at 6 feet or 60 feet
> As for social distancing outdoors, Bazant says it makes almost no sense and that doing so with masks on is “kind of crazy.”

> “If you look at the air flow outside, the infected air would be swept away and very unlikely to cause transmission. There are very few recorded instances of outdoor transmission.” he said. “Crowded spaces outdoor could be an issue, but if people are keeping a reasonable distance of like 3 feet outside, I feel pretty comfortable with that even without masks frankly.”

^ The important thing that no one seems to be mentioning in the comments here. I'm surrounded with "informed" hyper-concerned liberals in a city and the amount of people wearing masks outdoors quite far away from anyone is making me question their sanity.

xxxxxxx12··on [dead]
> Yes, men’s overall brain size is about 11% bigger than women’s, but unlike some songbirds, no specific brain areas are disproportionately larger in men or women. Brain size is proportional to body size, and the brain difference between sexes is actually smaller than other internal organs, such as the heart, lungs and kidneys, which range from 17% to 25% larger in men.

So they want to "dump the dimorphism" but then go on to say that the entire human body is sexually dimorphic.

The obvious motivation for this is to reduce every aspect of humanity into purely social constructs - those can be manipulated to advance a political order.

xxxxxxx12··on India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists
What I'm pointing out it is that, whether people acknowledge it or not, they're treating everyone as though they're infected.

So something like masking is required even if someone seems healthy. It's a regime of constant anxiety and latching onto any and every doom scenario.

So with the same logic, we should be assuming every sex partner has an incurable STI. Especially with the emerging threat of antibiotic-resistant strains, the most risk-avoidant with respect to SARS-CoV-2 would only be consistent by likewise being in favor of extreme measures like mandated condoms, quarantining, forced testing, etc. with something like STIs.

I don't agree with this at all - but it's clear that there's a fixation with COVID that doesn't get applied to other large aspects of society.

If we care about people's health - why don't we lock up fat people and force feed them a strict diet until they're a healthy weight? It's hard for me to see anything under the current public health/political regime that wouldn't justify this.

xxxxxxx12··on India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists
> Your freedom stops when you are a potential asymptomatic/symptomatic spreader of a potentially deadly disease to others.

I guess condoms must be mandated since antibiotic-resistant STIs are almost inevitable right now.

I guess we have to outlaw unprotected sex.

xxxxxxx12··on [dead]
I personally think lockdown measures and mandates increase spread - the more people are discouraged from participating in public life, the worse. People are better off outside out of their homes and living their lives.

This would also jibe with nursing homes and hospitals being perhaps the worst places to be.

If the idea that normal functioning of society involves less long-term clustering in buildings & therefore less disease spread, the surprising conclusion would be that the most important thing to do would be for a country to continue acting normal, and avoid devolving into panic and implement strict measures.

Aside from that - I think it's telling that Fauci really never answered this question during the hearing. He claimed he couldn't hear or see the stuff that was being asked.

The only thing he responded was that he thinks the difference could be explained by the idea that mandates and behavior are different.

But it's quite a stretch that simultaneously all the strict-measure states are disobeying the measures while all the lax-measure states are behaving as though there were strict measures.

xxxxxxx12··on [dead]
If the numbers drop in "Neanderthal" Texas, and practically every other supposed "good" state numbers rise - guess what?

The "good" guys are the Neanderthals.

xxxxxxx12··on India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists
> I have the right to participate in society without catching a dangerous disease from you.

You're essentially saying that the disabled (illness is a disability) should be excluded from society.

Shun the unclean and diseased?

You have the option of staying inside if you're afraid of mingling with certain people.

xxxxxxx12··on India's massive COVID surge puzzles scientists
Ah ok!

The esteemed internet silhouette Gibbon1 informs us that the credentialed expert John Ioannidis is not credible.

xxxxxxx12··on Facebook Said It’d Stop Covid Anti-Vaxxers, but It’s Letting Them Run Wild
Exactly, YouTube censored the panel of academics speaking with Gov. DeSantis.

You can disagree with them politically or even just substantively, but holy smokes is it infuriating to see credentialed and serious academics being deplatformed for being perceived to have broken with supposed orthodoxy.

xxxxxxx12··on We need to know the origin of Covid-19
> I don't think anything is, including engineering a plague.

People seem to forget that China was claiming for a long while that the virus wasn't transmissible (I'm sure people will equivocate that they really claimed there was no evidence of transmission, but it's tantamount), only shortly after for all the videos to surface with people passing out in the streets and the police welding people in their houses, etc.

xxxxxxx12··on We need to know the origin of Covid-19
This has been my guiding heuristic - China has acted unmistakably suspect.

They've got a political and ideological character that requires controlling narratives and erasing any trace of incompetence(this threatens the illusion of supreme power).

xxxxxxx12··on CEO of a top Bitcoin exchange warns: crackdown on cryptocurrencies may be coming
There is a (seemingly growing) number of people that openly say that the budget doesn't matter. You just print and spend.

Fortunately this incentivizes finding ways to circumvent that regime and point out how absurd it is.

xxxxxxx12··on CEO of a top Bitcoin exchange warns: crackdown on cryptocurrencies may be coming
> They dont want competition

Which is another way of saying they want absolute control, which in this case is the absurd charade where "inflation" measures that they claim represent life on the ground exclude the essentials like education, healthcare, and housing.

xxxxxxx12··on We Must Start Planning for a Permanent Pandemic
> knowing that our health care systems will be overwhelmed

I don't think we know that, and frankly I'm reminded of all the counterfactual ranting we get in economic arguments from establishment figures and orthodox, uncritical thinkers (we didn't spend enough, it would have been worse).

In both the US and UK, emergency set-ups (nightingale hospitals, the ship sent to NYC, nevermind Javitts center, etc.) went largely unused. It seems these things are highly localized, and in many places never really pan out. Of course, many people over-weight the power of human agency.

xxxxxxx12··on Sweden's Pandemic Experiment
> As an example, John Oliver ran a very cringe-worthy segment about Narendra Modi (the Prime Minister of India), without any introspection about how it looks for a British white man to mock the democratically elected leader of a country freed from British colonization only recently (in 1947).

It's funny how the US left frequently argues they're advocating in favor of X group, but if any member of X group diverges in opinion from upper-class urban whites and the broader liberal elite social class, they're quickly ignored or condemned.

This is even more apparent now when, in context of BLM stuff particularly, minority people are said to be embodying "whiteness" if they diverge from the BLM narrative.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2