HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xyzzy123

7,319 karma · joined September 21, 2012

contact zxcdotmx@gmail.com
submissionscomments
xyzzy123··on Samsung's Processing-in-Memory (PIM)
As I understand it, the killer app is llms. You could run MACs directly in RAM, offloading a lot of work from CPU and cutting down on insane (external) memory bandwidth required.

Imagine (this is a fantasy pitch but potentially achievable for some use cases) wanting to run a larger llm and all you have to do is buy more RAM so it fits.

xyzzy123··on Ask HN: Interesting Tech Adjacent Jobs?
I've been there and would advise thinking about which parts of the job are causing you stress. Few of the things that make work suck are unique to tech.

Is it the hours? Unrealistic expectations around work output? Hostile management or colleagues? Outcomes you are responsible for but don't fully control? Sometimes it's something MISSING, like you don't feel meaning in the work anymore, a strong feeling of being "over it".

There's a lot of misery in working for places that are too big (drowning in process, politics, management halls of mirrors) or too small (you are basically at the whim of one or two other people and you're very closely watched).

For good power relations with a company and colleagues you ideally want your leverage to be as equal as possible. You don't want to be completely disposable, and you don't want to be irreplaceable. You want the company to hurt approximately as much finding a replacement as you do getting another job.

The hard thing about pure software companies IMHO is that it's easy to feel distant from any real purpose of the work. It can quickly lose all meaning.

Personally I think the most chill-but-rewarding vibes are internal at mid-sized companies where software is integral to the business but not the primary business of the company. The "meaning" is decent, you can be closely connected to the people getting value from the software. There's broader HR and company culture but you're out of the spotlight of it, off to the side a little bit. You get to use all your skills and there may be new ideas you can bring. The team should be big enough that things don't explode if you take a vacation but small enough that you can see your work still matters. You might have to move to find it, though.

xyzzy123··on Felony charges for citizen deleting phone data at US Border
The specific complaint of the poster seems to be that certain people are NOT being "come for".
xyzzy123··on I gave Qwen 3.8 27B a reverse-engineering job and it finished in 30 minutes
It does seem to me that for this specific problem the materials are a lot more amenable to control than the information is?

There's also this weird revealed threat model thing going on? Like why does it make sense to support heavy LLM restrictions but leave benchtop oligo synthesisers completely unregulated? (Note: I do agree that wanting to regulate BOTH is at least a consistent and defensible position).

xyzzy123··on I gave Qwen 3.8 27B a reverse-engineering job and it finished in 30 minutes
I don't fully understand the instinct to regulate local models for this? It seems like the wrong place to address the problem.

You can download Ebola sequences right now if you want to. That's not the same as having an isolate. The difference is a lot of messy reality. This kind of work is not generally "one shot" (Claude make me a supervirus, make no mistakes), it requires lab space, iteration, and specific resources. It has a footprint.

Wouldn't it make more sense to monitor / regulate facilities where you can sequence or request assembly of DNA, RNA, restrict and monitor the supply of key reagents and so on?

xyzzy123··on Felony charges for citizen deleting phone data at US Border
Mostly you should assess rule of law by threat to you and people you know and not by what it seems like other people are able to get away with.

Yes, a big part of the idea is that laws are meant to also apply to the powerful, but it's difficult to accurately assess situations that are far away from you.

xyzzy123··on Children's stunted lungs show recovery in ultra low emission zone
I'm not really sure the thing they were trying to measure was measurable with the study design and level of funding they had. To be fair, the paper is fairly clear on the limitations and much better than the press release.

The study is supposed to measure how clearing up pollution in London improved children's lung function. The decrease in London was meaningful — NO2 fell about 22%. But particulates fell faster in Luton and NO2 in London is still roughly double Luton's. The gap is larger than the decrease.

By 2022 both cohorts get the same results on blow tests. But how does this happen if we believe that the study's dose-response model is true?

Put another way, if the change in London NO2 is so crucial, how come it doesn't matter that the absolute value is still double Luton's?

xyzzy123··on How Compaction Works in Pi
In my opinion this is one of the areas where GPUs provide a qualitatively different experience than unified memory boxes.

For an EPYC with a 5090 (no layers on CPU) vs an M3 max 128GB, qwen 3.6 27B at 128k context / 7k generation:

                Cold: prefill + decode    Hot (KV cached)
  5090          40s  + 2-3m  = 3-4 min    2-3 min
  M3 Max 128GB  14m  + 8-10m = 22-25 min  8-10 min
This is for dense qwen (which I wouldn't run day to day on the mac) - in reality the mac is quite usable with MoEs but you definitely notice a difference.
xyzzy123··on Nvidia doubles RTX PRO 6000 Blackwell's MSRP to a staggering $16,000
You can get 5-10x the perf out of the blackwell under the right workloads. It has faster VRAM (> 2x) and can do a lot more matmuls (>> 10x).

They're both good value (or crazy expensive) depending on how you look at it.

It depends how you price the ability to run a particular model at all, vs run the model quickly and serve several parallel streams.

xyzzy123··on GPT 5.6 Cyber
I can't tell if your comment is satire or not, so, bravo :)

From my perspective what I always loved about "the profession" was a relative LACK of gatekeeping. I loved offensive security for the same reason, there was a long run where you really just needed to be able to hack, and if you could demonstrate that there was a job for you somewhere (for better or worse).

Keeping the industry in its current form frozen in amber would be as weird as, I don't know, keeping horses & carriages in business by regulating scarcity of motor vehicle licenses. Not a great analogy but hopefully you see what I mean.

xyzzy123··on GPT 5.6 Cyber
Great, the start of model segmentation where I'm gonna need a legal license to ask about legal problems, a nutritionist license to create a meal plan, a medical license to ask about an x-ray, a pilots license to ask about a flight plan, be a registered electrician to ask how to wire something, etc etc. The licensing of allowed thoughts.

Apparently I can pay for partial solutions to the Riemann hypothesis but if my question involves a crackme or something that is an existential risk somehow.

xyzzy123··on DeepMind's WeatherNext model achieves breakthrough forecasting cyclones
I feel like the details of this are highly dependent on the confidence of the warning; moving large numbers of people (particularly elderly) will result in some deaths regardless. I guess more time to do it should help though.
xyzzy123··on DeepMind's WeatherNext model achieves breakthrough forecasting cyclones
I know this is uncharitable and I am wrong but I am having trouble coming up with concrete scenarios where you die with 2 days notice but survive with 3. I am nonethless a believer that more accurate forecasting has value.
xyzzy123··on DeepSeek V4 Flash 0731
There are a lot of tasks that are hard for organisations to run consistently but require some intelligence - monitoring logs and metrics for anomalies and security events, backup audits, audit processes in general, ensuring document quality and consistency, database advice and tuning, customer experience management, process optimisation - that are not "long horizon" in the classical sense of each step depending on the last, but are the result of consistency and attention over a long period of time and a large amount of data.

For this genre of task execution can run with limited horizon and is independent but would be too expensive to do with "us frontier tokens", I think for these, there is value in availability of cheaper tokens.

xyzzy123··on Nashville uses eminent domain to block data center near zoo
The value prop for the crazy sounding idea of putting GPUs into orbit.
xyzzy123··on Ask HN: How do you correct spatial reasoning of LLMs?
I guess my v0 would be notches around the mating end to allow for compression, and a hose clamp. Maybe split shaft collars off aliexpress for a fancier look. The design space of barbell collars is a big set of worked solutions to a very similar problem.
xyzzy123··on Ask HN: How do you correct spatial reasoning of LLMs?
Since it's the morning I thought I would ask Claude to create an example. This is just a first pass; it will be totally wrong but demonstrates the general idea. I don't know anything about barbells or your sensor: https://claude.ai/code/artifact/1f1a8a12-e5b2-4ee8-b20c-7da0...

I'm not sure from your description if you control the geometry of the sensor part (i.e, can the clamp be integral to the sensor housing or does it need to be a separate part) also ignores the internals, etc etc.

One thing I noticed is that off the bat, it did think about the assembly in general terms but would need guidance to think harder about FDM limitations and layer orientation etc. These are not good designs for printing. A good dev loop and git history help with these kinds of revisions.

The general principle is that if your domain is verifiable at all, give the model tools and a workflow that constrain and check its output. You want the LLM arguing with the geometry kernel instead of you.

To fully close the loop you print parts as fast and possible and concretely see where they suck.

xyzzy123··on Ask HN: How do you correct spatial reasoning of LLMs?
I would consider asking it to model its proposed designs in openscad or build123d (ideally something query-able). Then have it render and examine plausibility / suitability from different angles. Get it to render the part in use also and give instructions to think about forces and motion.

Recommend doing this in a coding harness not a chat box.

The reason I think you might have more success with this is that the model is mostly thinking about the part in words, which it can convert to a part design in CAD in code. LLMs are really good at coding. Also means it can use relative positioning and relationships.

You will be able to iterate more easily, compare things, compute properties, commit to git etc. The process is more reproducible and steerable than generative production of images.

When the LLM can look at renders of the geometry it generated, it’s easier for it to discriminate when it’s producing nonsense like misaligned parts, things that don’t fit, etc. It’s still going to kind of suck, but it will be better. The whole process of code -> render -> inspect forces the model to put up or shut up and provides grounding. Meshes > bloviating.

As far as I know today's LLMs don't have a "visual imagination" but a process like this could be a slow approximation of one. They clearly do have SOME spatial understanding (pelican tests show us that!) but it feels really non-human.

One thing missing from this is kinesthetics. Personally I am mostly not thinking in accurate visuals in mechanical design. I am imagining how the parts feel and kind of how they move and what slips first and what bends and what feels heavy. Imagining what my hands would feel. But I don't think I trust LLMs to evaluate that stuff by writing simulation code yet.

xyzzy123··on Oxide Computer raises $445M (SEC Form D)
I do feel like Oxide are qualitatively different from the others pjlmp mentioned because they're staying commodity in key interfaces like CPU ISA / OS / ecosystem (thing with big network effects) and mainly focused on fixing the control plane / management / architecture mess.

The others suffered "ecosystem collapse". With Oxide you won't be stuck on a "burning platform", your main risk is that the value prop for the hardware & management experience doesn't play out.

xyzzy123··on Why Airplanes Use 400 Hz Power
The other aspect is that the electrical parts of the power system are lighter at the higher frequency too. A 400hz transformer is meaningfully smaller and lighter than a 50hz one.

This is the same idea as switching power supplies but planes had to solve that before power semiconductors were cheap enough.

The power frequency also has an impact on the size of all the induction motors.

I guess if you were designing it from scratch today you would let the generator produce power at whatever frequency the mechanical engineers tell you they want to and the power electronics could convert it without problems. You would do the same thing the other way around on the motors.

xyzzy123··on Advancing the price-performance frontier with GPT‑5.6
You're right of course, LLMs provide a partial, unsound oracle.

The "halting problem is unsolvable" argument relies on the oracle not being able to output "not sure". But adding that option admits trivial oracles, like ones which output "not sure" for everything, so some are better than others.

The "real world" use most people have for halting oracles is as part of software safety, where if the checker outputs "not sure" you modify the software until the checker can decide if it halts.

xyzzy123··on Advancing the price-performance frontier with GPT‑5.6
Its funny because you can write a halting problem oracle by calling out to an LLM and have it return yes / no / not sure and get it to work reliably for almost all real code, like that is an entirely practical thing to do in 2026.

All we need now is some sort of program to evaluate halting problem oracles...

xyzzy123··on AI's top startups are barely publishing their research
Hi, shredding the book is to reduce potential legal liability of format shifting - if you shred the book after scanning, the theory is you are not increasing the number of copies. This has come up as a factor in legal rulings. The legality of format shifting is still murky though, and the legality of training on the work are a separate question.
xyzzy123··on What if useful AI is a fantasy?
> Practically speaking, is there really a difference between prompting an LLM to create a CMS for a website and installing something like WordPress or Ghost?

There is some difference; when you install WordPress or Ghost, your problems are shared. There's a community that goes along with the software and a "shared understanding in the world" of how it works and where the rough edges and limitations are. A lot of the time, LLMs will actually be better at modifying WordPress or Ghost to do what you want than they will be at fixing the CMS you built last Tuesday.

When you custom build, you can get an exact fit for your needs but your misery is yours alone.

xyzzy123··on What if useful AI is a fantasy?
The problem he's describing comes up any time you have a team of developers. That doesn't mean the usefulness of teams is a fantasy because you didn't write all the code yourself.

If you don't have a useful mental model of the architecture that's a communication / review / documentation problem, not a problem with the entire idea of codegen.

xyzzy123··on Be skeptical of OpenAI's rogue hacker agent story
The incident is funny on 2 levels; a) OpenAI thought so little of the model's _actual_ security capabilities that they gave it a "wet paper bag" sandbox and b) OpenAI failed to use AI to accelerate their security processes.
xyzzy123··on Demis Hassabis has a plan to harness AI safely
Food is allocated using a variety of mechanisms in peaceful first world countries, primarily money but also via government assistance, kinship, friendship, community, etc.

At any given time many people have problems with one or more of those systems. Money is easy to run out of because it's used for everything, the government can be slow and difficult, relationships can fray, people can be isolated, etc. Food banks exist as a backstop for when the regular means of allocating are not working.

The problem isn't "scarcity" per se, it's more of an allocation thing. Who has a claim on enough food to stay alive? Everyone! But what foods can they claim? How much? What specific channel / institution (with associated allocation rules) will distribute it to them? What are the conditions and controls? etc.

Allocating things can be difficult. An allocation mechanism with no controls will see fraud, waste and abuse. Even when an institution is willing to give things away no questions asked, there are (often invisible until you think about them) conditions like "please don't claim huge quantities and resell what we're giving you, that would be unfair to others".

It's also interesting to think about the fact that you can't fix food scarcity in general by simply giving hungry people money, because money is too fungible.

xyzzy123··on Why it's so difficult to produce American-made medical gloves
I like your moxie and I also agree Australia is an over-regulated racket... but I'm also glad my neighbours aren't mass farming frogs or cockroaches in my suburb without talking to the council first.

My brother had a neighbour build a crematorium next door in NZ; not an industrial or rural area, just the suburbs, no permits, no consultation, no notification. Very entrepreneurial. They got shut down but the flip side of "you can just do things" is surprises like a plume of smoke and the smell of burning corpses when you step outside.

xyzzy123··on I co-founded Wikipedia, but an anonymous mob runs the show – and now I'm banned
If we take a contested issue like the origins of COVID-19, the facts are detailed, complex, contradictory and ambiguous. They also don't make narrative sense without some degree of interpretation.

Interpretations of complex webs of facts often diverge along tribal lines and bias can easily leak through when editors need to decide which interpretations are authoritative.

xyzzy123··on sqlite-utils 4.0rc2, mostly written by Claude Fable (for about $149.25)
In Sydney Australia its < 2 days of median rent.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →