HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xyzzy21

1,100 karma · joined March 17, 2021

submissionscomments
xyzzy21··on Why Is It So Expensive to Save Lives?
Reality is complicated. That's why. Silver Bullet solutions presume reality is simple and simplistic. Reality is nonlinear and has feedback loops.
xyzzy21··on Single mom sues coding boot camp over job placement rates
Good. 99% of coding boot camps are frauds making promises they can never keep and they know it. Most people can NOT code well ever. The economy can't possibly absorb having much more than 5% of the population being coders and that's unrealistically optimistic.
xyzzy21··on Shirky.com is gone
NOTHING on the web can be trusted to last very long. It's the deep flaw of digitalization of paper.
xyzzy21··on Twitter board adopts poison pill after Musk’s $43B bid to buy company
The literal value is their share price x total shares.

The notional value is at best the NPV of future profit streams. However Twitter's track record on profits are dismal so the claim is dubious legally.

xyzzy21··on Twitter board adopts poison pill after Musk’s $43B bid to buy company
And then the board and executive get sued for failing to maximize shareholder value. It's literally a violation of federal law.
xyzzy21··on The Irrelevance of Porter’s Five Forces for the B2B Software Industry
Ah, NO...

I'm in B2B and Porter is central to our product design and marketing strategy.

I'll just put it out there: the author has NEVER started a company!

xyzzy21··on Ask HN: Why isn't there a standard network audio protocol?
Firewire was supposed to be an AV standard that allowed connecting anything to anything and completely eliminate the RCA cables etc.

And then the RIAA and MPAA discovered the plan and killed it good.

xyzzy21··on Abandoned railroad routes in North America
There's definitely a whole lot more than listed - easily 10x.

The half dozen I know about in each CA and NY aren't listed at all.

xyzzy21··on Why is selling software so weird?
Ditto! B2B is alive and well. I absolutely prefer it because it's a far more rational interaction and sales process. Margins can be higher and it's a better class of customers most of the time.
xyzzy21··on Ask HN: How to keep coding while moving up the ladder?
It's simply not realistic to expect or want this. You have only a final amount of time in a day so you can't have it both ways and still do EITHER well enough to be competitive with people who focus.

You simply have to let go and minimize programming or you have to minimize management/strategy.

xyzzy21··on Van life (cancer edition) finale
You can think all you want. It won't matter. We are not remotely getting closer (my sister is a VP ops at a major biotech/pharma firm - she provides me with sober sanity about such things). Cancer is not one thing - it's like saying "food is just one thing; how do we replace/control food". Well the goal is far too complex to even have meaning. The easier path is "How do we accept death?"

You WILL DIE. I WILL DIE. And it might be cancer or it might be stroke or heart attack. No one gets out alive.

My SIL dies of MM metastasis - dead within 1 month of discover of this after 10 years of "successful" experimental treatments. My father died of SSC metastasis within one week of discovery.

xyzzy21··on Van life (cancer edition) finale
Indeed.

My SIL was diagnosed with MM. At that time, the life expectancy was 6 mo - 2 years. And then thanks to being at the right place at the right time, she went into 5 separate clinical trials and lived 10 years. But then very suddenly, it returned and she was dead in a matter of weeks.

xyzzy21··on San Francisco cops pull over a Cruise driverless car for no lights on
The police should have shot the tires out and boxed in the vehicle to stop it from escaping.
xyzzy21··on San Francisco cops pull over a Cruise driverless car for no lights on
In fact, liability has been limited in this case by California laws...
xyzzy21··on San Francisco cops pull over a Cruise driverless car for no lights on
Except safety has only ever been improved for either aircraft or drugs by people dying from exactly this kind of failure.

Apparently there is ZERO learning or forethought about risks that can be anticipated or suggested from other technologies!

xyzzy21··on A story about planning for Desert Storm
This is what war is all about.

This is why many want cooler heads to prevail in the Russia-Ukraine war now!

Those who have lived through war know how horrific and uncontrollable it is and how sociopathic you need to become to wage it successfully.

Intelligence is the first problem. Then the model to fit it to. Then the conclusions to take from it. Each layer is HIGHLY prone to error.

Just an example: precision munitions largely eliminate the odds of NOT killing to zero but then it's the intelligence and interpretation that becomes the weak link: are you really hitting the right target for the larger purpose, or are you doing everything wrong hitting the wrong target because you are measuring success wrongly (e.g. body count - as we did in Vietnam and then returned to in Iraq and Afghanistan - simply because it was the only thing we could measure; classic "streetlight fallacy")

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streetlight_effect

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McNamara_fallacy

xyzzy21··on A story about planning for Desert Storm
Just google "gorbachev saddam 1991"

The answer is "pretty much true".

xyzzy21··on Why a Slide Rule Works
I was probably the last generation in the US in the 1970s to willingly learn slide rules - the HP-35 had been out a few years and new scientific calculators already made the demise of slide rules pretty obvious to even us nerdlets.

One of my prized inheritances from my engineer father is his slide rule (complete with leather case).

xyzzy21··on Why a Slide Rule Works
Mathologer has a nice video about this via "log wheels".

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZIQQvxSXLhI

xyzzy21··on Taking Pictures the Hard Way
Except you have to consider inflation has been galloping since the 1980s. So even these may be cheaper than back in the day...
xyzzy21··on Taking Pictures the Hard Way
Well, back in the day, when California still had "extras" in public schools like photography with real 135 and 120 cameras complete with darkrooms, I learned photography "the hard way" like this and that included processing B&W film and printing it. There's a lot to be said for such a learning experience.

Reading this article I decided to see how much a C41 color film (Kodacolor/Fujicolor) processing system sells for - well, turns out they are not cheap but also not bizarrely expensive either. With some extra cash and time, you could set up a service for C41 processing using one of these machines. Sadly I don't have enough lifetimes for it but...

I'd still love to do Kodachrome though - I grew up with magazines shot in Kodachrome and I still like the look.

xyzzy21··on Etsy Strike
Honestly, it might be easier to pivot your business model and/or use a different channel. This seems too much like "some one else do the work to make my life easier again!!"
xyzzy21··on Middle managers fear they've become irrelevant with work from home
I hope you don't believe that "things will just happen on their own". Because they don't and won't. It's the same with selling products that generate company revenue - in general products DO NOT SELL THEMSELVES. Ever. And "worse" - even the best designed product that "flies off the shelf" will usually only do that for the first 3-9 months - after that, the lack of awareness for product or problem, the mismatch of buyer/seller knowledge, product features to market need, etc. is large enough that nothing will be an obvious match. All these things are why there are sales people with commissions et al.
xyzzy21··on Middle managers fear they've become irrelevant with work from home
LOL

If they truly believe that, then they do NOT understand their roll and thus they are probably ALREADY obsolete and irrelevant.

If they understand - it should not be a problem of need but of methods and skills.

xyzzy21··on What If Europe Loses Russian Natural Gas?
The problem with "electric heaters" is that electricity for ANYTHING can NEVER be better that 50% efficient and often is worse. Natural gas heating can EASILY attain 70%-80% efficiency in heating.

Green Energy is generally contrary to the laws of physics in this sense. It's one step forward and three-to-five steps backward.

xyzzy21··on The Backdoor That Keeps Russian Oil Flowing into Europe
There's a FAR LARGER backdoor that allows oil, minerals, etc. to flow in far larger quantities to the USA.
xyzzy21··on What science says: Could humans survive a nuclear war between NATO and Russia?
The central error in this question which is ill-formed: what do you mean by "Humans".

Can humans as a species survive? Absolutely no question: yes.

Can humans as any individuals survive? Absolutely no question: no. Not statistically.

Can humans as some cultural or nation-state survive? Can humans in some particular geography/demography survive?

Honestly that's where the gray area starts.

xyzzy21··on The Huge Endeavor to Produce a Tiny Microchip
Nice article.

Hopefully the complexity of fabs and their operations makes it obvious why chip shortages can easily take 3-5 years to address if creating new fab capacity is the problem. It also costs between $30B-$50B to create a new "mega/ultra/super fab" operating at volumes typical of TSMC, Intel, Samsung, etc.

Even then, the small corner of a fab my business operates in isn't even mentioned in the article because it's far "too small" - all the businesses combined into our segment has total market revenue ranges in the $5B-$10B/year range. We are essential but small money-wise for most people to care.

The other part of the story with water - some of the most advanced water purification and recycling development is happening in this realm as well. Another company product line unrelated to ours is able to detect 10-nanometer-sized contaminants in water at volume both to assure incoming water purity as well as outgoing. Much of the total volume of water is recycled.

There are also surprising ways seemingly unrelated parts contribute. For example our product operates on clean-room floors but we put a ton of effort to reduce the floor footprint (we're 30% smaller than the de facto competitor). That directly reduces the amount of water consumed as a multiplier effect because it means you get more productive output per square foot of HVAC air processing capacity. That HVAC is primarily chilled water based. It also reduced energy consumption or increases productive output per unit kW.

Whenever you have high capital investment, you get the most innovation in basic technologies required for the business and the most spin-offs as well. Whenever you have low investment, you get zero innovation.

xyzzy21··on The Huge Endeavor to Produce a Tiny Microchip
It's because photoresist is sensitive to deep blue out to UV so you want to avoid that kind of light as wafers with photoresist applied but not-yet-exposed are running around in their robotic FOUPs through the facility.

It's exactly analogous to red safe lights used for film print photography.

xyzzy21··on How Intelligent Are Cats? (2004)
One of my dogs used to "lie" - he knew he wasn't suppose to be on the sofa. But he'd always push boundaries and try anyway like a human child. As soon as he'd hear you approaching the room, he'd just off (he was a no-fur dog).

What gave away his game was that sometimes his hind leg didn't quite get off the sofa. It was like a kid that took cookies for the cookie jar, even managed to get it back where it was supposed to be but then left obvious crumbs.

← PreviousPage 3 of 28Next →