HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

xyzzy_plugh

10,008 karma · joined September 23, 2014

submissionscomments
xyzzy_plugh··on A low-carbon computing platform from your retired phones
I've worked with manufacturers who shipped us binary blobs for their hardware. They are often willing to customize the software for you, but they want to own the modifications, which they can use for other customers. A big part of many contracts is a services component where they provide features or advanced functionality, and this lets them mark up their bill substantially. They're existentially scared of their hardware being cloned or their customers building in-house solutions, so they have to stay competitive on that front.

It's also a huge pain in the ass for them to release software as open source. They would need to track all the different forks and modifications in an organized manner (they often do a lot of copy paste and one-off nonsense). They run pretty light staffing on a lot of these components and doing all of that is just another chore for their overworked devs.

Lastly, I've heard they sometimes use other commercial, closed-source software components which they can't easily relicense.

Is this all bullshit? Yes absolutely. I'm not defending them but these are the excuses they give.

xyzzy_plugh··on WASI 0.3
> Point being, if you rely on a non standard specification of developer defined wasi api subspec you might as well just go with freestanding.

Precisely this. The whole endeavor has been disappointing. I'd love to build support for WASI but realistically it's far simpler for all parties just to do something custom, which feels wrong. I get that it's only 0.3 but it's advancing far too slowly for my tastes. I just don't know who it's for right now.

xyzzy_plugh··on Petition to Withdraw Canada's Bill C-22
> while Canada is facing a number of very real challenges, the government in power is spending its time on internet censorship bills.

You could have said this at any point in the last ~15-20 years and it would apply. It's a problem certainly but not a new problem and has little to do with the current government nor current issues. They will try and try again until they succeed.

Instead of arguing over these semantics we should be focusing on a more permanent measure of preventing this garbage from getting inevitable shoved down our throats.

xyzzy_plugh··on PgDog is funded and coming to a database near you
The creator of pgdog is also the creator of pgcat, so I think they probably don't need to do this.
xyzzy_plugh··on AWS Bedrock to require sharing data with Anthropic for Mythos and future models
There are a significant number of extremely large companies that are wholly interested in such a sub-processor. The tier of data sensitivity is irrelevant.

Almost all companies are content to engage with data sub-processors with respect to customer data or some form of PII.

But there are many that will absolutely not let their IP visit or reside on systems they do not control.

This is absolutely a deal breaker for a ton of organizations and it's not going to trigger industry wide adoption like other comments here suggest. Instead another provider will offer a more appetizing deal and they will win market share.

xyzzy_plugh··on Dopamine Fracking
I'd like to agree but practically there are difficulties enforcing it. Anecdotally I know of some parents having a battle with their local school because their kids have been watching this sort of crap in kindergarten.

Fundamentally it seems like building products designed to target children with harmful content, or content that substitutes for educational material, should not be accepted by society.

So yes parents are responsible but maybe we should stop building The Torment Nexus but for children.

xyzzy_plugh··on Amazon Cognito now supports multi-Region replication
Probably meant KTLO: Keep The Lights On
xyzzy_plugh··on Google AI Edge Eloquent
The "Download for macOS" link is currently a 404:

https://dl.google.com/eloquent-mac/eloquent_mac.dmg

It's a shame there is not more information on how this app works beyond a textbox.

xyzzy_plugh··on Are You Enjoying Our Linguine? (2025)
If you're taking offence, then you might be missing the point:

> The American tourist used to be regarded as the most obnoxious creature in the world. Loud, naïve, ham fisted, needy. The reason I told you about the opening of this borghetto di merda is that it made me realize: Now we are all American tourists.

The author seems to agree with you.

xyzzy_plugh··on Are You Enjoying Our Linguine? (2025)
The homogenization, and subsequent impoverishment (at least with regards to the quality and diversity) of the world appears to be, sadly, inevitable. It takes real, constant effort to maintain "the old ways" while tradition is so easily erased through globalization and, ultimately, technology.

I don't think we'll lose _all_ diversity of culture, as there will always be stalwarts to uphold institutions (even espresso bars) but as generations transition I think we'll be shocked at how much we've lost just a few years from now.

This isn't strictly a bad thing, as there are many traditions which have been laid by the wayside over the centuries, but I have to admit: I am not impressed at the things we've been replacing them with. Phones, social media, selfies, a constant sense of connectedness, influencer tourism -- it all feels so terrible, and it feels like only now are people around me recognizing that we may have dug too deep.

It seems to me that 2020 was the turning point (do you remember what it was like to be a tourist before then?) and that we're deeply nestled in the jaws of the Balrog now.

I'm really not sure what it looks like to climb back out.

xyzzy_plugh··on Re: [PATCH] OOM_pardon, a.k.a. don't kill my xlock (2004)
I agree with your perspective. I certainly agree that swap can be invaluable at times, and is generally a mistake for your run-of-the-mill production services.

It's a nice approach particularly because all OOMs become actionable: there's a bug in a service or a limit is wrong or traffic is changing in an unexpected way.

Systems built this way end up being extremely reliable in my experience.

It's an uphill battle both ways though and not everyone is up for that experience.

xyzzy_plugh··on Shantell Sans (2023)
Wow somehow I've never come across this font, and I've done a lot with comic-sans-adjacent fonts.

This font, however, is by far the most beautiful one I've encountered yet.

xyzzy_plugh··on Canada losing top talent as workers head to the U.S.
The SF Bay Area has consistently been more bonkers, relatively and absolutely, so I don't think is a substantial contributing factor.
xyzzy_plugh··on Canada losing top talent as workers head to the U.S.
The not-so-top secret way to get rich as a Canadian new grad in tech is to get a job at a unicorn by way of TN status, hop around for ~5-10 years, possibly getting an H-1B, but never pursuing a greencard.

Accumulate wealth by any means necessary. If you find yourself with nice RSUs or options, hang on to them or exercise them, respectively.

When you're fed up move back to Canada and enjoy no exit tax and enjoy the step-up cost basis on all your assets. Sell all your RSUs and pay nearly zero capital gains. Use your imagination here.

(If you are unlucky and only have losses, well, you'll never really be able to use them tax-wise.)

xyzzy_plugh··on A fundamental principle of aeronautical engineering has been overturned
A key difference is that war planes occasionally want to be able to rapidly change their trajectories.

With sufficient thrust you can fly around in a cube.

xyzzy_plugh··on Search engines alternatives now that Google isn't Google anymore
I've encountered this as well. I'm pretty sure it is unable to produce answers involving some copyrighted works. For example, I was trying to find an old video and it filled in the gaps in my knowledge very accurately, however it absolutely could not provide an actual link to the video or any concrete content related to the video.

In my case I suspect the original uploader took down their videos from YouTube or there was some legal process involved. But it was very weird for the Gemini answer to confirm exactly what I was looking for but be unable to articulate in a way that helped me. Totally bizarre, as if the topic was ablated from the LLM.

I would much prefer getting a straight answer, "due to copyright I can't discuss this" or something.

xyzzy_plugh··on Migrating from Go to Rust
The Go standard library has learned to interpret path variables as well:

https://go.dev/blog/routing-enhancements

xyzzy_plugh··on Using HTTP/2 Cleartext for a server in Go 1.24
Has HTTP/2 performance improved as of Go 1.24? Last I checked forcing HTTP/1.1 everywhere was a massive improvement in throughout and latency for a very busy distributed system.
xyzzy_plugh··on BambuStudio has been violating PrusaSlicer AGPL license since their fork
Fundamentally I agree with you.

I'd love to see stats showing a material impact to their sales but I'm not optimistic. If I were to guess I'd reckon their sales are still climbing.

xyzzy_plugh··on BambuStudio has been violating PrusaSlicer AGPL license since their fork
Believe me the point is not lost on me. But it's certainly not a universal dick move. It's an opportunity in a society that does not care for the laws on the other side of the world.

If it's such a universal dick move, then why do Chinese companies keep doing it? Do you imagine they realize they are being unethical? Perhaps your morals and ethics are less universal than you believe. Do you think that perhaps it is the case that a society that prides itself on its communist integrity might not hold fond feelings about copyright

I see businesses make this mistake again and again. I don't know why they expected a different outcome. You don't anthropomorphize a lawn mower. Shaming does nothing to improve the situation.

xyzzy_plugh··on BambuStudio has been violating PrusaSlicer AGPL license since their fork
I understand, appreciate and respect copyleft but I'm no zealot.

Fundamentally this rubs me the same wrong way as others attempting to enforce social contracts do. It feels wrong to assume that western ethics should be universal and apply to a foreign entity such as a business in China. Perhaps they simply view this as a viable approach? And, surprise, it is, at least for them. Do I wish that weren't the case? Sure, that'd be grand. But I don't see how this post gets us any closer to that fantasy.

Put yourself in their shoes. Someone released some software under a license designed around a foreign legal framework that doesn't apply to you. You can make products using that software that people want and make money. Is it your fault you are immune from the license? Is it your government's? Is it wrong to do so? I don't think it's clear enough.

And yeah the call to action should be clear. It's not. I don't see why they can't pursue legal action and go for damages or at the very least prevent the sale of their printers in local jurisdictions. Perhaps that would still be performative but it at least creates precedence that others can use to strengthen their own cases, or allow governments to push for action. But it appears like they're doing nothing.

If the US or the EU are going to do nothing about Chinese companies pedaling wares derived from US/EU IP made possible only by dodging licensing requirements then perhaps it's simply not a viable approach to rely on copyleft to protect you. Or you can try and change that.

xyzzy_plugh··on BambuStudio has been violating PrusaSlicer AGPL license since their fork
I don't like all this shaming on social media. It feels performative and leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

If they're in violation of your copyright agreements, sue them. If you can't sue them because it's unenforceable, well, that sucks, but too bad.

I don't know what they expect to happen here. Is there even a clear call to action? Boycott? Do something.

xyzzy_plugh··on How to convert between wealth and income tax
I really like the way you framed it. I've never really been against a wealth tax but making it equivalent to income feels fair to me. I don't think the math works out with rates where they are today, though.

I guess the simplest approach is, if you're making money, it should be taxed fairly, regardless of how you're making it.

xyzzy_plugh··on GitHub faces a fight for its survival at Microsoft
Regardless of how we feel, GitHub has been swallowed by the bureaucracy and is being thoroughly digested and dismantled as talent and leadership flee elsewhere.

This kind of turmoil is dangerous for even the healthiest business, and yet GitHub has been shitting the bed left and right for years now, and the shitting is still accelerating. It's rather unbelievable.

Even if they had a solid plan and somehow could execute, I don't see how they can come back from this.

I think they're fully cooked.

xyzzy_plugh··on Saying goodbye to asm.js
I still maintain the notion we're in the wrong timeline, one where PNaCl died and instead of a worthy, timely successor we end up being boiled alive in a soup of Electron apps.

I really thought, for a time, that we'd be doing everything in the browser. And in a way that's increasingly true, but it all just feels worse than ever. I like WASM and I want to like WASM but the rate of maturity within the ecosystem is incredibly abysmal.

What's worse is that we should all be running our untrustworthy AI tools and their outputs in precisely such a sandbox, and companies are selling the reverse: hosted sandboxes, hosted JS-based VMs.

I guess that was always the problem: there was never any money in a client-side sandbox.

xyzzy_plugh··on Railway Blocked by Google Cloud
I've managed several accounts with GCP over the years and I've always maintained a great relationship with our contacts there. Some of these accounts were quite small, on the order of <$20k/mo, and even then we were kept abreast of anything that might be cause for concern. I always maintain a standing biweekly meeting with at least someone on the other side (account exec, technical staff, whatever) and I've yet to be blindsided by anything.

Is Google's communication good? No, not particularly. The only way something like TFA happens is if the relationship is neglected (by one or both parties). I'm not saying Railway did something wrong, but there are usually many flags and opportunities to correct long before drastic actions.

I get the impression that Railway plays fast and loose with a lot of their limits and resources and that Google may not be a fan of that.

Edit: would also like to say that if you put all your resources in one GCP project you are going to have a bad time. If you organize stuff over many projects it is very unlikely that they will ever take account wide action. I've had issues with, for example, a particular tenant's behavior, but it never jeopardized the other tenants.

xyzzy_plugh··on Show HN: Number Gacha, a gacha game distilled to its essence
This is very well done. Where are the microtransactions? You could be rich beyond your wildest dreams, dear author, if only you let me buy gems.
xyzzy_plugh··on Anthropic acquires Stainless
There are a tremendous number of Xtripes at both Anthropic and OpenAI.
xyzzy_plugh··on WinCE64 – Windows CE 2.11 for N64
Me? Conflating? I think not.

We all dumped Windows CE for Windows Mobile. It was a lot of work and in the end it was an inferior product for pretty much every use case imaginable. The certification was not difficult but costly. Porting practically every application was a huge waste of time and money when they already worked well enough on WinCE.

Windows Mobile, built on WinCE, effectively cannibalized itself. We had Microsoft PMs and engineers tell us WinCE was a dead end. I moved onto to greener pastures before WinCE 6 but my understanding is that it triggered a crisis of faith within at least a few engineering organizations.

There were a number of things Windows Mobile excelled at compared to its predecessor but in particular it excelled at wasting corporate resources.

xyzzy_plugh··on WinCE64 – Windows CE 2.11 for N64
Part of the reason CE 6 didn't get much love is that everyone had been burned so many times by all the previous CE releases -- not to mention that CE 6 was far too late!

In the end, though, it was better than Mobile, but hindsight is 20/20.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →