Are there legitimate uses for password cracking or is this about getting access to other people's accounts?
517 karma · joined February 22, 2009
https://ryanxcharles.com
Are there legitimate uses for password cracking or is this about getting access to other people's accounts?
You merely require them to use longer passwords, and require them to change them every year. My university does this. They require a minimum of 8 characters, and they require that we change our password every 3 months or we can't log in.
If computing power doubles every 2 years, then every two years we should bump up the required password length to match. If each character is randomly chosen from amongst 2^6=64 possibilities, then every 6 years we add 1 to the number of characters required.
For instance, if today we require 12 character passwords, which are clearly uncrackable even with Amazon's fancy new GPU instances, then in 2016 we require everyone update their password to a minimum of 13 characters. Every six years we bump it up again.
I think people vastly underestimate their ability to memorize passwords (just think how many phone numbers you probably had memorized back in the day). You could probably memorize passwords thousands of characters long if you bothered, and the only problem is that it would take too long to type them in.
You only need one long password, and all others can be stored in an encrypted file. This is not much to ask.
Bcrypt and scrypt look great, but not fundamentally any better than longer passwords.
But this only works for small numbers of characters. You cannot inverse-hash a book length document. You also still can't inverse-hash a 16 character or probably even 12 character password.
This fast hashing stuff is only a problem because people use ridiculously short passwords. The examples in the article are a lazy, pathetic 6 characters. I think people vastly underestimate their ability to memorize passwords. For instance, I am able to memorize a 16 character password by just writing it down a few times and then testing myself. And since I can remember many such passwords, I could easily memorize 32 character passwords, which are probably impossible to crack for the next 50 years or so. And you really only need to remember one such password, because all your other passwords can be put in an encrypted file.
But the reason why being behind schedule is bad is because you are behind your opponent. They don't count twice.
The only way this makes sense is if you actually regress during your missed practices. That way, not only do you miss 2 practices, but it takes you 2 more practices just to get back to where you were before. Then it's like 4 missed practices total.
However, there is a point when you shrink the page where the number of words is about twice, but probably few devices actually have that width.
The only problem would be ensuring the clothes are clean and in good condition. You would probably have to have some automated way of cleaning the clothes if the system is to be efficient. Checking that the clothes are not torn up would be harder, but you can have the customers do that for you. They'll just send it back if there is a problem.
So almost every program is "wrong" then. This is pretty pessimistic. Every glass is empty unless it is 100% full.
I think the better approach is just to not fool ourselves. If a large application works, but has a few bugs, then it's OK to say that it's 90% working (or 10% broken--have your pick).
I call this project Project Asymmetry because a lot of people live symmetric lives where they are born, climb up until they reach a peak, then decline until they die. The end of their lives are mirror images of the beginning. In Project Asymmetry, we reject that, and aim to get better at everything until we suddenly die in an accident.
Here is an image to illustrate: http://ryandickherber.com/images/project-asymmetry.png
Right now I'm researching all the components of the human body that can be trained and will be putting up a wiki with more information on this. I will catalog standard activities, like weight lifting, taking physics qualifying exams, etc., and seeing what parts of the body they train (muscles, bones, brain, etc.). This will take about a week probably.
Then I will design programs that train every component of yourself. The idea is that you will become stronger, funnier, more intelligent, more knowledgeable, etc., in a very rigorous way. Everything will be tracked so you can know you're really making progress. The program never ends, and you will always follow it (until you suddenly die in an accident).
Here is the latest reddit thread:
http://www.reddit.com/r/Fitness/comments/cu0qp/we_want_to_be...
Keep track on my blog:
Yes, I think that's right. It's more accurate to say that there was no first moment rather than that t=0 was the first moment. Reconciling that with the fact that time is nevertheless finite is an important part of understanding the big bang.
To put it mathematically, the set of points of time is open on the left end. The set of times is this: (0,\infty). And not this: [0,\infty)
Edit: By the way, when I say that time is "finite", I mean finite from now into the past. Not finite from "start" to "finish". The standard cosmological model with dark energy have time being infinite from "start" to "finish"
Consider the function 1/x. For all positive x, 1/x is defined. As you approach x=0 from the right, 1/x approaches infinity. Same thing for the density of the universe. But the point 1/0 itself is undefined, even though the limit is well defined from the right. Likewise, t=0 itself is undefined, even though the density is well defined for all times greater than t=0.
I wouldn't really consider this an "assumption." It is actually a consequence of assuming that the universe is expanding in accordance with the law of gravity and that energy is conserved. The only way to do it is to construct a "metric" ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedmann%E2%80%93Lema%C3%AEtre... ) where a bunch of parameters are undefined at t=0, but well-defined thereafter.
The universe did not come from nothing. Consider the following two claims:
* The universe has a finite age.
* The universe has always existed.
Both of these claims are true. It might seem that if something has always existed, it must have existed for infinitely long. No so. At every time in history, the universe has existed, even though the age is finite.
Your intuition might disagree. But recognize your intuition has been developed under very peculiar circumstances on the surface of the Earth. You should be skeptical of your own intuition when studying things outside of your usual experience. In this case, human intuition says two things:
* There was always something before.
* There was always something 5 minutes before.
In ordinary human life, both claims are true. That's what your intuition says. But for the universe as a whole, only the first claim is true, and the second claim is false. Even though it is true that there was always something "before" (for any time you give me, I can divide that time in two and give you an earlier time), it is nevertheless not true that there was always something 5 minutes before (pick 4 minutes after the big bang, and 5 minutes earlier than that is simply undefined [1]).
Big Bang theory is a self-consistent, meaningful mathematical theory. It does not fly in the face of logical reasoning. Rather, it is a spectacular case-in-point of the power of logical reasoning to describe and explain the universe.
Your second point is that the Big Bang disobeys the first law of thermodynamics, which is the conservation of energy. False. You are assuming there was a period of time when there was no energy, and then suddenly energy came into being. That's not what happened. The energy has always been around, for all time, and thus the first law is not violated.
[1] It so happens that "negative time", or even time t=0, is equally as meaningless as Elephant Time or Verb Time. They are all undefined.
What's the probability that this lady will win four lotteries?
Before the first lottery, insanely low, say 10^20 to one. (I haven't actually computed this, but you get the point.)
After the first one, it becomes a little more probable; say 10^15 to one.
After the second, 10^10 to one.
After the third, 10^5 to one.
After the fourth, 100%.
And for that reason, therefore men are more common in science and engineering (STEM).
But there's a link here he never established, unless I missed it. Is it really true that the brightest of the bright go into STEM? Because I was under the impression that they don't; at least not more often than, say, Wall Street, or something else.
What if we established that the intelligence of people who go into STEM is on the right side of the distribution, but not the far right? Then there would be as many females as males at that intelligence level. And then how to we explain why there are fewer women than men go into STEM?
Something invented by humans is invented by natural selection. Just as new organic species can wipe out (or live harmoniously) with old species, a new inorganic species could do the same.
> This type of thing [faith] would not stick around within our societies were it not useful.
Cancer sticks around but it's not useful.
> If I were in Nazi Germany, the rational thing would be to not help any jew.
This is absurd. Depending on what you knew at the time, it may have been by far the rational thing to help jews. Because then when it's over, you could claim you were one of the few who helped, and wouldn't be as guilty as all the rest.
> People who have faith have one absolute advantage over those who do not - their path is always clear. They know what they are doing, they know why they are doing it, and even when they doubt, they can always fall back in blind trust in some invisible thing.
I fail to see how this is an advantage. Suppose you had a well-defined, crystal-clear path walking off a cliff. That's good just because it's clear? Also I'm not convinced that faithful actually have clear paths; they're just as confused as the rest of us, but they don't like to think about that.
> And they are happier, because as each step along their route unfolds and turns out to be right, their faith increases and their belief that the problems will always be overcome with more faith grows.
And this is where I suspect this author is simply a troll. Is it really the case that the faithful are happier than other people? This contradicts my experience. I think the faithful are probably no more or less happy than anyone else. Indeed, frequently faith is a source of unhappiness, like any time they are faced with something that contradicts their faith.
This statements also claims "as each step along their route unfolds and turns out to be right", but actually they are right less often than rational people! And the author has ignored all the times when they turn out to be wrong. Being wrong more often than rational people isn't a bad thing?
> Don't dismiss blind belief in something. It's an extra-ordinary tool. It's fundamentally human, and when you rationalize it away, you are are taking away one of those quirks that make us human - those strange things like love and laughter and revenge that should not be there, but are, and separate us from machines.
Personally, I see faith as a meme, and we are seeing its tricks in action here. It's taking something that's not extraordinary or useful and making it sound extraordinary and useful. It's not, but it needs you to think it is to survive.
Are we moving away from scavenging digital stuff too, or is that just me?
http://funnylogic.com/times/txt/2009-11-infinite-curiosity-l...
And for what it's worth, the definition of intelligence has been on my mind a lot.
How is Rand's "liberty" supposed to be provided?
It seems to me we already live in a universe where people have as much free will as we ever will. Some people use this free will to restrict the free will of others. Sometimes this is a government, sometimes it's a corporation, or sometimes it's a kidnapper.
But what hypothetical external agent could ever ensure that no one's free will will be restricted? To have such a system would necessitate restricting people's free will so that they couldn't restrict each other's free will; it would be a self-defeating situation.
This is analogous to the set of all sets in mathematics, or other paradoxes that arise by having "all powerful" objects. Humans are so free, that we are free to kill ourselves (for instance), and remove our freedom. Likewise, we are free to disable our own free will.
How could Rand change things so that this is not the case?
In my view, governments are the result of the utter freedom we have as humans. It is simply absurd to think of getting rid of the systems that restrict freedom; if we did, the freedoms granted would simply create new systems, like corporations, or another government, that would replace all the functions of the system we got rid of.
Let me put it another way: It seems we already have maximal liberty. How are things ever going to be better in that respect?
But the market does give points for effort. How else do you explain the bonuses awarded to bankers who damaged the economy? They were rewarded despite their antisuccess.