HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

yanhangyhy

527 karma · joined February 14, 2015

submissionscomments
yanhangyhy··on China has added forest the size of Texas since 1990
at least on this topic, i agree with you
yanhangyhy··on China has added forest the size of Texas since 1990
China is a country that does not prohibit abortion at all. Maybe this could be a starting point…
yanhangyhy··on China has added forest the size of Texas since 1990
I probably often use that term in a neutral sense.
yanhangyhy··on China has added forest the size of Texas since 1990
So most people believe it was a mistake. We were misled by some so-called experts at the time. Conspiracy theorists claim that many of those experts weren’t Han Chinese, since the one-child policy only applied to the Han population.
yanhangyhy··on China has added forest the size of Texas since 1990
I’ve actually thought a lot about this issue. My conclusion is that it’s not feasible. China has never been good at integrating other ethnicities and races. Even managing the 56 recognized ethnic groups within mainland China hasn’t gone very well; it has copied many mistakes from the Soviet Union, which has now led to a certain degree of backlash.

So I’ve always felt that China’s ambition extends only to Taiwan, and Taiwan is the endpoint. After all, the people on Taiwan are Chinese too, sharing the same culture and ethnicity. Another point that people might overlook is that China’s approach to incorporating outsiders is based on cultural identity rather than racial identity, which is the opposite of the U.S. In the U.S., you can come in, bring your own culture, help reshape American culture, and still become an American. In China, you can only be considered Chinese if you adopt Chinese culture.

Of course, sometimes we discuss online hypotheticals like whether it would be good for China to annex Mongolia or Myanmar. From a purely military perspective, it would be very easy for China. But almost no one supports it, because our way of thinking dictates that it would require an enormous cost to transform those populations into Chinese culture, and that cost is simply not worth it. Trade and cooperation are the best approach.

yanhangyhy··on China has added forest the size of Texas since 1990
the government is trying to encourage more births through subsidies and other measures. In fact, experience from developed countries has already shown that this approach doesn’t work. Moreover, the subsidies the Chinese government provides are far lower than in developed countries and far below the actual cost of raising a child.

The most common nationwide subsidy is 3,600 RMB per child per year, which is basically ineffective. For a woman on maternity leave, the government will subsidize her based on her salary, which can be substantial—in places like Shanghai it could reach 200,000–300,000 RMB—but still not enough to stimulate population growth.

To put it in a darker perspective: the only way to truly boost birth rates would be to reduce women’s rights or compensation, which is unlikely in any civilized country. A historical example is Romania.

So in my understanding, China has only two viable paths: solve the cost of raising children through household robots or by means of coercion, the government could require state-owned enterprise employees and Communist Party members to have children. China has 100 million Party members and roughly tens of millions of SOE employees. SOE employees usually have stable benefits and income, so childbirth could be tied to salary, benefits, or promotion opportunities. To some extent, this could be argued as reasonable—after all, they are supported by taxpayers and arguably should contribute to society. But it still counts as a rather dark idea, and I imagine it would be a last-resort option.

yanhangyhy··on China has added forest the size of Texas since 1990
LOL. Probably no longer needed. China currently has no real solution for the low birth rate. I guess they are 99% relying on industrial robots and household robots(in the future).So China will desperately invest in the robotics sector. (The recently released 15th Five-Year Plan likely includes this). By then, language likely won’t be an issue—AI can replace everything.
yanhangyhy··on China has added forest the size of Texas since 1990
I don’t know how it is in other countries, but nearly thirty years ago when I was in elementary school, a Chinese propaganda slogan stuck with me: “If you want to get rich, build roads first; have fewer children, plant more trees.” Every part of that slogan has been put into action, continuously, for decades. Although low birth rates have now become a problem, back then it seemed like a solution.

Xi Jinping may be a rather dull person, but his most famous saying is “Lucid waters and lush mountains are invaluable assets.” As for building roads — the Belt and Road Initiative speaks for itself. We’ve built bridges in Croatia, in Bangladesh, in Mozambique, and roads and railways all over the world. That slogan is probably engraved in every Chinese person’s memory.

yanhangyhy··on China Can't Win
China people can buy Huawei and Apple phones, but the U.S. cannot buy Huawei phones. China people can buy BYD, Telsa and various other countries’ cars, but North America cannot buy BYD(and any other chinese brands).
yanhangyhy··on Huawei releases an open weight model trained on Huawei Ascend GPUs
huawei's Ascend GPUs is the only choice for many chinese company for now. Huge win for huawei.
yanhangyhy··on Why does the U.S. always run a trade deficit?
I mostly agree with your points. Social inequality in China is pretty serious, and it’s gonna take a lot of smart policy moves to fix it.

But when we compare China to other countries, we do have to consider some unique factors. The cost of living in China is really low, which means that even if people have similar income levels to places like Thailand, their actual quality of life can be better in some ways. For example, China’s “vegetable basket project” keeps food prices super low across the country. There’s no property tax, firefighting services are free, and rural healthcare is cheap—even if it's not on par with what you'd get in big cities.

That said, the government still needs to do more to boost domestic consumption. The current setup is okay, but it’s still nowhere near the living standards in developed countries.

yanhangyhy··on Why does the U.S. always run a trade deficit?
wow, China’s internal-external internet separation policy really makes it difficult for people outside the country to truly understand what’s going on inside.
yanhangyhy··on Bus stops here: Shanghai lets riders design their own routes
this is great. hope beijing will adopted this soon
yanhangyhy··on Ask HN: What device do you use to read academic papers with?
SONY DPT
← PreviousPage 11 of 11