HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ygjb

2,394 karma · joined September 8, 2011

Yvan Boily Founding Security Engineer Co-founder, Oghmere parentsguidetoai.ca https://nimblemyth.ca
submissionscomments
ygjb··on Ask HN: Hacker claimed ownership and then deleted my Facebook Page of 50k users
Yeah, I am talking about Crown Corporations like MTS, Petro-Canada, BC Ferries, and such that were taken private, not the telecoms protectionism that is currently screwing over consumers in Canada, they are quite different.

I don't object to open markets, but I also think there is a space for crown corporations with a mandate to operate competitively (which strong oversight) for the benefit of Canadians (or citizens of $your_nation)

ygjb··on Ask HN: Hacker claimed ownership and then deleted my Facebook Page of 50k users
Yep, vaccine passports suck, and I say that as a supporter of them. I am not going to argue the merits or flaws of them with a throwaway account, but they have not been found to violate laws, and no jurisdiction in Canada that I am aware of has had to use exception powers (not withstanding clause, or reasonable limits under Section 1 of the Charter).

As for not being discussed in the latest elections, "if we are elected, we will implement vaccine passports" was largely the premise for the last Federal election in Canada, and while they didn't win in a landslide, Canadians voted in a government to implement them.

I don't think "most of the world" is a functioning democracy, but in Canada, our democracy is functioning, if continuing to be undermined by our political parties. Democracy around the world is at risk, and spreading misinformation about actual election outcomes and unpopular, but legal policies doesn't really help.

ygjb··on Ask HN: Hacker claimed ownership and then deleted my Facebook Page of 50k users
I don't know what to tell you. The people of the United States have continuously ceded power to their government, and the corporations that wield influence over it, while being spoonfed lies about what freedom actually means by government and media.

The right to bear arms supercedes the right to live in safe communities (and as a former infantry man, I can assert that more weapons in the hands of untrained civilians does not make communities more safe).

The right to an health care (abortion) is superceded by so called "religious freedoms".

The right to vote is superceded by politicians who rewrite election laws and electoral districts to choose their constituents.

Freedom to discriminate is beginning to supercede the right to freedom from discrimination.

These problems aren't unique to the United States, and in Canada we have our own issues.

> Private corporations don’t have the power of the state to coerce me to do anything.

* blinks in private law enforcement, the radical expansion of surveillance by private corporations, and lack of accountability of tech companies *

Uh, yeah, that's by design, but on a global basis, the design is breaking. There are more and more exceptionally wealthy individuals and corporations that are wielding power and working in domains that have typically been the purview of states and governments.

We need stronger regulation of corporations globally, and strong treaties that unify global regulation and information sharing of how that regulation occurs, or we will continue to cede freedom and governance to the whims of corporations that will wield significant influence over elected officials. One thing going for unelected government, they generally DGAF about the whims of corporations, and we have seen what some countries are willing to do in order to preserve influence over corporations (I would love to hear an honest, unbiased tell all from Jack Ma for example).

ygjb··on Ask HN: Hacker claimed ownership and then deleted my Facebook Page of 50k users
Some of us still live in functioning democracies. Also, it's worth pointing out that relying on privately owned or publicly traded corporations is not an effective strategy for preserving freedom; those businesses will only do that as long as they can justify it to their shareholders (private or public), and are subject to whatever laws apply in the jurisdictions they reside in (kind of the reason alot of 'western' companies prefer to either not do business, or conduct business via arms length entities in countries like Russia, China, and other places).
ygjb··on Ask HN: Hacker claimed ownership and then deleted my Facebook Page of 50k users
I will point out that in Canada, many of our telecoms were run by privately operated, publicly owned organizations (Crown Corporations) that operated at arms length. Until they were sold for pennies on the dollar by governments looking to score a quick win for "fiscal responsibility" and "small government", these organizations operated with a high degree of public scrutiny, and had the goal of offering low cost, reliable services.

By most accounts the quality of service in relation to the price has been awful in most places in Canada, and the few places that still have Crown Corp delivered telecoms are among the happiest customers in that sector.

This same scenario has played out across multiple sectors including oil & gas, electricity and hydroelectric services, and here in BC, transportation services (BC Ferries).

Everyone likes to take a dump on public run services, but practically speaking, they have more oversight and accountability than privately run services.

ygjb··on Pfizer and BioNTech launch trial of Omicron-targeted Covid vaccine
Your first two sentences are at odds. It is not mild for everyone if it's dangerous for people who have not been vaccinated.
ygjb··on Pfizer and BioNTech launch trial of Omicron-targeted Covid vaccine
Not really.

Natural immunity is what anyone who gets vaccinated or infected acquires, assuming that the immune response is successful.

Immunity acquired from infection is more regularly referred to as convalescent or infection-induced immunity; moreover the messaging has consistently been that while there have been some studies that convalescent immunity can potentially be as or even more effective than vaccine induced immunity, it comes at a significant increase of complications, ranging from organ damage to the fairly nebulously defined long covid, and most of the studies that are credible in the field that have endorsed the effectiveness of convalescent immunity still recommend vaccination to avoid the potential impacts of even "mild" infections.

The rampant claims about so-called natural immunity by people may be drowning out correct or rational voices, but that shouldn't indicate that the messaging has changed, just that the messengers are spreading misinformation.

ygjb··on Pfizer and BioNTech launch trial of Omicron-targeted Covid vaccine
There is an ocean of difference between "it's mild because I am vaccinated" and "it's mild", and the bridge across it is being built on the mental and physical well being of our health care providers around the world.
ygjb··on Pfizer and BioNTech launch trial of Omicron-targeted Covid vaccine
It doesn't.

The refrain that Omicron is "mild" is being parroted by people who don't understand what they are talking about. In fact, the Omicron variant (like other COVID variants) is relatively mild among individuals who have been vaccinated.

That hasn't stopped the vast majority of folks yeeting themselves off a dunning-kruger cliff and assuming that they are competent to discuss the topic because they read a medical journal or an opinion piece that aligns well with their own perceptions of COVID and the broad spectrum of economic, political, and medical topics (myself included sometimes).

ygjb··on Roblox October Outage Postmortem
And that's a reasonable decision for an adult to make, and if they were targeting an adult developer community.

I don't think anyone objects to adults making that choice over say, using Unity or Unreal, and targeting other platforms.

In practice, explaining to my son who is growing into an avid developer why I won't a) help him build on Roblox, or b) fund his objectives of advertising and promoting his work in Roblox (by spending Roblox company scrip) on the platform has necessitated helping him to learn and understand what exploitation means and how to recognize it.

It's a learning experience for him, and a challenging issue for me as a technically proficient and financially literate parent who actually owns and run businesses related to intellectual property. It's got to be much more painful for parents who lack in any of those three areas.

ygjb··on Loopy Pro
That's a fair assessment, but I can tell you that if you run an Acrobat from 7 years ago, you are gonna have a bad time from a security perspective :)

I hate subscription models too, but maintaining software takes time and money.

ygjb··on Ask HN: Are Cybersecurity Workers Ok?
Congratulations! log4j is to feature rich to satisfy the requirements of your limited experience!

The JNDI string expansion and lookups was a pants on head stupid feature, but having highly configurable logging is super helpful when building and debugging systems at scale, both when you building and testing, and when you are scaling up so that you can granularly tune what is logging and where. This is true whether it's written in python, golang, rust, c, or any other language. If you don't know that, then perhaps you should try branching out in your experience.

ygjb··on Dungeons and Dragons Is a Case Study in How Capitalism Kills Art
I think you are probably misremembering the ease of play with older editions. I have been playing D&D in various iterations, and have older books going back to the original AD&D 1st edition and BECMI box sets and 5e was far easier to pick up and play, and is way more accessible to young children than previous editions.
ygjb··on Dungeons and Dragons Is a Case Study in How Capitalism Kills Art
As a D&D player i don't mind paying for physical media, and I don't mind paying for electronic versions of the media that are integrated with D&D Beyond or Roll20.

What I find galling is that I have to buy the same content on different platforms instead of buying my digital content from WotC, and logging into Roll20 or D&D Beyond with a WotC account with my entitlements.

Both D&D Beyond and Roll20 can negotiate with WotC on how payments would be split up, or whatever. The current model is hostile to me as a consumer, and I don't like it :P

ygjb··on Smartphones Are a New Tax on the Poor
2-3 days labour to buy an outdated device that will stop receiving updates most likely in 2022.

Sounds alot like Captain Vimes' boots theory of socioeconomic unfairness. Some people are just too poor to be able to buy a pair of good boots.

ygjb··on Hex-rays is moving to a subscription model
You do realize that is a win from a customer service and reputation perspective? Jetbrains listened to their customers, and amended their model. That is the kind of responsiveness I would appreciate in a vendor, especially if it's a vendor that produces tools that I enjoy using or help me make money.

Anyone who has worked on customer facing projects or tools know there is always overwhelmingly negative feedback to billing increases. What is less common is vendors being responsive to that in a way that is actually beneficial to customers. That is doubly the case when you are dealing with high quality, specialty tools that have free or open source competitors that are good enough to get by, but not great (Adobe suite vs various free and open tools, for example).

ygjb··on Ask HN: Are Cybersecurity Workers Ok?
Depends on how the organization grew, and if they have unified processes across department.

AFAIK the IT security folks at a financial institution that I used to work at are living in hell at the moment. That organization grew internationally through acquisitions across more than 80 countries, and lacks unified structure across the entire organization due to legal and compliance constraints unique to each jurisdiction.

A web development shop I provide security guidance to (owned by one my TTRPG buddies) had to do a couple of searches in github and update some hardware as patches became available. We made sure he was sorted out over a couple of drinks before we played board games.

It varies.

ygjb··on Ask HN: Are Cybersecurity Workers Ok?
It doesn't hurt actually. During major incidents in my non-remote roles I was expected to be in the office and available for the duration of the active incident, even if I wasn't able to actively contribute (contrary to what folks may have seen on NCIS, having two people typing on the same keyboard is not actually helpful when fighting hackers :P )

As a remote worker I can be at home and present with my family, with short breaks for actual activity, and longer periods for active response. This is not speculation - I have been active on incident response in the last month while helping my kids with homework, side by side at my home office desk).

ygjb··on Ask HN: Are Cybersecurity Workers Ok?
> 99% of these people running around with their hair on fire could have just wrote to a log file with three lines of code. Instead they mvn a whole fucking library for no reason

The fact that you think there is "no reason" to address the issue of logging through a method other than writing three additional lines of code shows that you really have no comprehension of how or why logging frameworks provide benefits (even if some of the inclusions like JNDI are ludicrous and should been defaulted off, or even behind a build flag, with big red warning labels).

ygjb··on Ask HN: Are Cybersecurity Workers Ok?
> With so many large scale hacks, 0-days, and breaches happening these days, are cybersecurity professionals ok?

As an industry? We are getting better. Better recognition for neurodiversity, and the needs and capabilities for each other. Better at calling out the bad actors who can be poison pills in our teams, companies, and communities. Better at mentoring folks who are coming up in the industry.

None of that changes the disastrous toll that the security industry can take on individuals. Incident responders and investigators often have to deal with many of the psychological issues that police officers have to (exposure to CSAM, graphic imagery, deep knowledge of cybercrime and the relationship to real world crime, including human trafficking, drug trafficking, etc). The stress of often working in sensitive roles where you can't share or talk about things, and in the case of many colleagues (at least in Canada and the United States), having access to work approved "counselling services" as opposed to actual mental health professionals with a direct clinician-patient relationship.

Many IT Security folks work in teams that are under resourced, function in "Teams" of one, and are often expected to fulfill the roles of SRE, IT Support, Architecture, Engineering, and Compliance for any technologies or tools they use to do their jobs, in addition to actually doing their jobs.

It gets to be a bit much at times :)

> Have studies about the mental health and anxiety levels of this group of professionals been conducted?

I don't know if there are any formal, rigorous, academic studies, but mental health in the cybersecurity space has been a long discussion, with the earliest significant discussions I remember being back in 2008-2009 at some conferences.

Depending on the role and the organization it can be a high stress job. I often tell a story at talks and conferences about my 72 hour work day, which was my first incident response activity early in my career. It involved life critical and personal safety systems affecting thousands of people, and ended up working with the team for literally 3 days straight with no sleep because there was no one else in our team that had the perspective on how to address the issues. There was serious physical fallout, as well as mental issues (I developed aphasia for a short period of time, amongst other things) Many of the folks I know in the industry have similar (but not as grim as a full 72 hours), and that's setting aside the toll of building a career on telling people that there are big issues, and having to be helpful and constructive instead of saying "I told you so..." when things go poorly.

ygjb··on CISA Director on Log4j Vulnerability
No, they are managing the teams patching things and helping with prioritization.

If the stakeholders participating in the call on Monday are not the people working on patching, managing, or prioritizing, then having the call earlier than that is pointless, because those stakeholders are too removed from the situation, and getting that information will detract from getting work done.

It's pretty simple really, having a status or coordination call while the work is being done is roughly analogous to a photo-op by a politician during an emergency. It looks good for the voters, but it takes away resources from the folks who are actually doing the work.

ygjb··on [dead]
First, the employees don't subsidize shit. If employees have to do extra work to accommodate a colleague who is on leave, whether that leave is due to vacation time, medical leave, parental leave, bereavement leave, or any other reason, the employees have to do extra work because the leadership of the organization has chosen to prioritize the bottom line over properly resourcing the team. That is not the fault of the individual who is on leave, or the employees who are doing extra work to make up for it.

Second, the company has to subsidize that because of hard fought labour rights legislation. Enough people thought it was important enough that they had strikes and participated in elections until the laws were changed. American labour rights in relation to time off and parental leave are among the most pathetic in developed or "1st world" countries. Employees should not be thankful to their employers for the rights they have, they should be thankful for the blood shed and work done by workers and labour activists that earned them those rights.

And just to be clear, I say this as a business owner, and an employee of another business. I choose to hustle for 60-80 hours a week because of the things I want to achieve. I don't, and shouldn't, have the right to grind others into the gears of my business because they don't want to.

ygjb··on CISA Director on Log4j Vulnerability
No. The stakeholders are busy patching their shit. Pulling folks into meetings shouldn't be the priority when teams around the world in virtually every tech organizations are in firefighting mode.

This type of a call would likely be focused on assessing current state at that point.

ygjb··on The Microsoft paradox: Contributing to cyber threats and monetizing the cure
> The fact is that Microsoft has continuously improved its process for the past fifteen years while being the most exposed company in IT.

It's not just that they have continuously improved process, they have also made enormous contributions to the security space in terms of building and sharing repeatable processes, and providing a platform to socialize some of those practices (for example, bug bounty programs, threat modelling, SDL practices, tons of documentation and guidance around how to improve processes).

I am not a Microsoft shill - my main use for Windows and Microsoft products are video games, and Microsoft Office, but they have made tremendous progress and shared several tools and learnings along the way.

ygjb··on Bjarne Stroustrup: “I Did It for You All” (2007)
Uh, using Adobe as an argument in favour of C++ as a reliable programming language from a memory safety perspective is not a good argument. Just looking at the CVE count tells a story that cuts across their entire product line, and then we have the long and storied history of Flash and Acrobat vulnerabilities.

Any non-trivial code base in any language will have security issues, but the argument that these security vulnerabilities are a result of using C++ poorly doesn't change the fact that C and C++ have tons of footguns and pitfalls based on both modern and legacy code.

ygjb··on Hacked Cryptocurrency Platform Begs Hacker to Please Return $119M
I mean, it's been a minute (well, actually a bit more than a decade) since I worked in finance, but I don't think I would characterize banks as having top grade security.

More like 'barely meets the threshold for compliance with regulations and laws if you glance sideways at it through a foggy pane of glass' security.

While most do have adequate security, many banks are self-insuring for several classes of risk, including several that self-insure for cybersecurity issues. They depend heavily on support from LEOs, centralization of clearing operations, and established norms on how to interact with each other through ISACs and other industry associations - something that cryptocurrency and decentralized finance currently lack.

ygjb··on Stripe hiring issues make some lose job offers
I can't speak specifically to IBM as a whole, but in my experience, there are parts of IBM that are old and stodgy (professional services around finance and government that I interacted with when I worked in those industries). There are other parts (around security and research that I worked with in other roles) that are pretty cool and innovative that are much more approachable and fun to work with.

IBM (and Microsoft, and Google, and others) are huge and it makes sense that there are pockets of awesome and awful distributed throughout them.

ygjb··on Firefox is the alternative to a Chrome hegemony
In a walled garden, the ability to for the user to do what they want, where they want is perceived as innovation.
ygjb··on Piracy release group EVO ‘blames’ movie industry for its popularity
Now I know Amazon is more stable that most other streaming services, but so far, my Canadian experience has been to have digital purchases of movies I have made be shuffled from one service to another as they fold, or are acquired, with differences in quality, or "expirations", etc.

Renting I don't mind, but as a consumer my preference is to buy Blu-ray movies in the highest quality available, and then rip them. I am a huge screen buff, and have boxes of physical media (blu-ray, dvd, VHS, and even a couple of beta tapes in storage), but it's endlessly frustrating that a large number of classic movies are only available in "remastered" editions, that destroy the fidelity and classic feel of the original movies by updating special effects, or committing the sins that George Lucas did of adding entirely new scenes to movies that undermine the overall quality of the movies ("Jabba, you're a wonderful human being."), let alone re-cutting the movies from full-screen to pan and scan. I recognize that the recuts have broader mass market appeal, but some of the history of how classic cinematic masterpieces were made, and how film making changed over time is lost to new audiences when those changes are made.

ygjb··on Piracy release group EVO ‘blames’ movie industry for its popularity
We know it's a distributor/rights problem, but the core of that problem is the drive to extract as much value as possible. Casual piracy of content drops off a cliff when there is an opportunity to cheaply, and easily access content. We saw this with the emergence of early streaming service with broad catalogues.

Now each distributor, or sufficiently large rightsholder wants to capture as much of that value as possible by both restricting catalog access and demanding ownership of the relationship with the end user, without any sort of federation across services (with a few exceptions like Apple TV that have used market dominance to assert the ability to search across content subscriptions). The end result has been a rapidly accellerating decline in the quality of the user experience for accessing streaming content. Couple that with a shift away from series releases to weekly releases (better for customer retention as customers won't subscribe for a month to binge a series when it drops, and increasing 'user engagement' on platforms for however each platform collects those metrics)

The response has been an increase in piracy, and vilification of users who are frustrated because we had an awesome era of rich content libraries, but a bunch of accountants and MBAs focused on short term profit increases have destroyed the good will that the entire industry built with the emergence of streaming.

← PreviousPage 14 of 24Next →