HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ygjb

2,394 karma · joined September 8, 2011

Yvan Boily Founding Security Engineer Co-founder, Oghmere parentsguidetoai.ca https://nimblemyth.ca
submissionscomments
ygjb··on Piracy release group EVO ‘blames’ movie industry for its popularity
We know it's a distributor/rights problem, but the core of that problem is the drive to extract as much value as possible. Casual piracy of content drops off a cliff when there is an opportunity to cheaply, and easily access content. We saw this with the emergence of early streaming service with broad catalogues.

Now each distributor, or sufficiently large rightsholder wants to capture as much of that value as possible by both restricting catalog access and demanding ownership of the relationship with the end user, without any sort of federation across services (with a few exceptions like Apple TV that have used market dominance to assert the ability to search across content subscriptions). The end result has been a rapidly accellerating decline in the quality of the user experience for accessing streaming content. Couple that with a shift away from series releases to weekly releases (better for customer retention as customers won't subscribe for a month to binge a series when it drops, and increasing 'user engagement' on platforms for however each platform collects those metrics)

The response has been an increase in piracy, and vilification of users who are frustrated because we had an awesome era of rich content libraries, but a bunch of accountants and MBAs focused on short term profit increases have destroyed the good will that the entire industry built with the emergence of streaming.

ygjb··on There is currently no way to drive between Vancouver and the rest of Canada
you might want to loosen that tinfoil hat.

Private sector does really well in a lot of spaces, but despite being public infrastructure, most highways and roadworks built in Canada are already built by private sector employees working under contract.

Those public sector employees foaming at the mouth? Those are the ones who are responsible for making sure that the roads, highways and infrastructure are fit for purpose, including safety. But hey, why would we want anyone providing oversight of private corporations right?

You want emergency, purpose built solutions built by a mission oriented team? May I point you in the direction of the Canadian Military Engineers (you know, government workers?).

ygjb··on There is currently no way to drive between Vancouver and the rest of Canada
I'm sorry, I didn't realize that the EU was impacted by a massive critical infrastructure failure induced by a natural disaster.

Like I said, this isn't a discussion or debate about COVID restrictions, and while it sucks that you might be temporarily inconvenienced in relation to your travel plans, as a person who lives and works in the lower mainland and has several friends and family members who are either homeless or temporarily stranded, temporary travel inconveniences rank somewhere between "oh well", and "could you please not, while we clean up?".

ygjb··on There is currently no way to drive between Vancouver and the rest of Canada
The overall tone of the thread is about logistics in a port city that is the main port of entry to Canada. Individually, the testing requirements are very disruptive, but it's one less issue that may have impacted supply chains within the BC lower mainland, and an avenue to ship goods out, albeit more expensively.

This isn't (generally speaking) a thread about COVID restrictions, but if you want to sound off about that more, feel free, but it shouldn't be a shock that in a) a global pandemic, and b) a series of natural disasters, that no one really gives a fuck about how inconvenient travel has become for non-essential activities.

ygjb··on There is currently no way to drive between Vancouver and the rest of Canada
Unless you are exempt, like truck drivers. https://travel.gc.ca/travel-covid/travel-restrictions/exempt...
ygjb··on There is currently no way to drive between Vancouver and the rest of Canada
Clearly you don't know folks working in the industry; Trade and Transportation drivers have been and are exempt from testing requirements. My brother has been driving to and from the area around Winnipeg through North and South Dakota as a truck driver during the entire pandemic, and was vaccinated early by the US. (also, non-anecdotal source -> https://travel.gc.ca/travel-covid/travel-restrictions/exempt... )
ygjb··on There is currently no way to drive between Vancouver and the rest of Canada
Less The Dark Knight because there are fewer bad guys with squeaky voices running around, and more like this... https://imgur.com/gallery/U5up5RT
ygjb··on Blacksmith – Rowhammer bit flips on all DRAM devices today despite mitigations
> In other words, the whole industry sits on a bed of lies at this point and it's only because government is technically incompetent that we haven't seen the world's biggest class-action.

That's a pretty bold claim - if it's accurate, can you point at the government regulation that precludes a class action lawsuit? I would assume it's something in the T&C or EULA for the hardware rather than a regulation?

ygjb··on ProctorU is dystopian spyware
> White supremacy, to me, implies explicit, militant, proactive racism. People who might very well be proud of the fact they're racists.

That is only half of the story of white supremacy though. The other half is the entrenched systems and biases baked into those systems that largely benefit white people, and that train people, through experience, to prioritize preserving the existing systems and status quo.

Not considering the fact that there is a well documented history over the last 20 years of tech companies and business in general prioritizing the experiences of the white majority, at the expense of people of colour, is largely the reason why you can "wouldn't be surprised if training data and/or testing were filmed in an office setting with the amount of light you expect there, and they never ran across the issues with dark skin interacting poorly with the amount of lighting a student would have a home.", and not consider that being the norm, or even acceptable as being indicative of white supremacy.

Those biases may not always, and only impact people of colour, but they do overwhelmingly benefit white people. That's the entire point of the article that OP shared, and the references the author of that post uses to back their claims.

ygjb··on ProctorU is dystopian spyware
> White supremacy is the idea that white people are inherently better and more capable and therefore more deserving.

That's a common dictionary or encyclopedia definition of the white supremacy. More broadly, white supremacy also refers to the systems and structures of power that are built into most of "western" (a better term might be post-colonial) societies that favor both white people, and people who support or uphold the balance of power in those post-colonial societies.

> Racist systems that have encoded societies biases are generally not white supremacist

I agree, however I think that those racist systems that are not inherently white supremacist in nature are largely rooted in non-colonial countries (basically countries other than the European colonial powers, and the countries that grew out of those colonies).

> It also pushes people who unintentionally did something racist way into the defensive if you tell them they are white supremacist. And pushing people who unintentionally did racist things into defending their actions is not going to make things better.

That is just not true. If someone does or says something racist, they can and should be challenged on it. If they become defensive, there are multiple reasons that could happen, but if the reason is that they simply didn't know better, it's just the way their society is, or if the reason is that they are opposed to "wokeness" (which is a catch-all for intersectionality, critical race theory, and many other modern perspectives and ideologies that are largely centered on dismantling power structures and reducing bias and discrimination), then it's likely that they are supporting white supremacy out of ignorance (whether that ignorance is from being uninformed or uneducated, or the more malicious willful ignorance of people who choose to use or engage in racist norms because they are opposed to "wokeness" from an ideological or other perspective).

Pushing people who do things that could be cast as unintentionally racist is the only way to a) educate them, so they can do better, or b) determine if it was an intentional act. I know this from practical experience, and it was only from going through the hard and painful experience of being called out on harmful "unintentionally" racist jokes and behaviour that I learned to do better after being raised by a family that had (and for the most part, still has) some pretty racist and discriminatory views.

ygjb··on ProctorU is dystopian spyware
Yes, I totally get that, unfortunately I accidentally left out part of the first question in an edit :(
ygjb··on ProctorU is dystopian spyware
I mean, it's an article about how a technology is negatively impacting marginalized groups, and cites research that backs those claims. It makes sense to cite the groups and practices most impacted by it.

You could read the research and refute it, or you could just bluster about things. I know you tried to expand on it in your comment below, but minimizing the specific concerns raised to "isms" and ignoring that at least two of the references in the articles linked and their references for the actual research addressed at least the socioeconomic portion of it, illustrates that you only applied your surface level perspective and criticism.

ygjb··on Pfizer's oral Covid-19 antiviral cuts hospitalization, death by 85%
As an alternative, you could have a single payer, public health care option that would be significantly cheaper than the current shit show that the US system has (modulo the small percentage of Americans who have had a genuinely positive experience with the syst as opposed to the Kafkaesque nightmares that are the more common take.)
ygjb··on Genshin Impact made more money in its first year than any other game
Optimizing for player base is at odds with optimizing for paying player base. I am a "whale" as a consumer - I really enjoy video games, but my time is at a premium. I have more money than time, and I am happy to use it to accelerate my access to free to play games, especially for cases where I am playing games with my family, who generally have more free time than me.

Unfortunately in many of the games that my kids enjoy, I have noticed that the optimization path for the freemium model includes increasing the time sink required for access to game mechanics and content, and increasing the rewards for paying actual money for access to mechanics and contents.

There are some free to play games that find a good tension between this early on, but longer term, I find that the games because less enjoyable because it is too time consuming for others to keep up with my "pay to play" approach to skipping the time intensive portions of the games.

> Saying Fortnite is “optimized for profit” makes very little sense, since nothing you can do in the game requires purchases at all.

Sure, from a mechanical perspective. My son uses a portion of his allowance to keep current on his emotes and skins because his friends apply social pressure by teasing the kids that don't have them. It's been a great opportunity to teach him about peer pressure, and the relatively harmless of this version of it, in contrast to more harmful ones related to drugs, alcohol, or risky behavior for teenagers.

ygjb··on Google's infamous internal 2010 “I just want to serve 5TB” video now public
I want to say that based on your response, I don't believe that you are arguing in good faith, but I will give you the benefit of the doubt.

I didn't change the subject. I rejected your claim that touching someone without permission is a microagression. It's not, it falls on a spectrum of harassment to assault, depending on who you touch, where you touch them, and where you are when you do it. That's not a microagression.

> "microrape"

Unless we are talking about moths, please provide a serious academic or published document that actually proposes this as a generally accepted term. I confess that the first time I saw it, I thought you being flippant, but it appears that you actually think this is a commonly used or generally accepted term.

I spent some time reading about the term, and asking about it among the D&I folks that I know, and based on that, it's not really a thing that people are concerned with, and aside from some fringe groups on the edges of D&I activism. Most references are related to some shitty humour on reddit and other sites meant to mock folks rather than engage in actual discourse.

Aside from your use of the term, I think the question you are really asking is "Does a 'dirty look' count as sexual harassment?", and the answer is, yes, depending on the jurisdiction. I already said that.

> "intent doesn't matter"

Yeah, intent doesn't matter. This isn't a new concept - look up the etymology of the phrase "The Road to hell is paved with good intentions."; it's a well understood concept and proverb that dates back at least 500 years, farther if you torture some of the translations and transliterations. This isn't to say that intent doesn't actually matter, its a slogan that illustrates that even well intentioned actions that have a negative outcome are still the responsibility of the person who took the action, and that positive intent doesn't balance out negative outcomes.

That said, it doesn't really matter what your opinion is on D&I activism, or your thoughts on the role they play in business. I fall back to my original statement that the vast majority of D&I training and related activities are risk mitigation activities.

If you don't want to change your beliefs, that's fine. Just act like a decent human being, and treat others with respect while you are operating in a professional context.

As for the rest of your claims, it is obvious to me that you are more concerned with your perceived harms to your own freedoms than you are with considering the perspectives of others - unless you have something more meaningful and evidence based to add to the conversation, there isn't much point to continuing it.

ygjb··on Google's infamous internal 2010 “I just want to serve 5TB” video now public
First, touching someone without permission isn't a micro-aggression. Depending on the jurisdiction, the location of the unwanted touching, and the age or power disparity between the two, it can range from harassment to assault.

The fact that this discussion is even happening in the context of Black people and their hair is frustrating because the implicit bias is that somehow individual curiosity overrides another persons expectation of freedom from interference or right to not be fondled. If we were talking about a casual grope of a woman's breast because people are naturally curious, I would expect that most people would be moderately outraged.

Also, while a "dirty look" is subjective, "leering" is a form of sexual harassment in many jurisdictions.

While I appreciate that your perspective that microagressions, silence is violence, and words are violence are Orwellian, your perspective also reveals a pretty clear ignorance of the nuance and impact that these slogans capture. I don't know if it's an ignorance that stems from a lack of knowledge and experience, or a more insidious and willful ignorance that stems from the type of thinking that allows for or encourages "marketplaces of ideas" that tolerate and debate some of the most awful and toxic values, but it doesn't really matter. Up in the thread I stated, and I stand by it, workplace inclusiveness and diversity training is intended to reach those who can be taught, and inform those who can't of the consequences of failing to at least act in a baseline socially acceptable fashion for the duration of the work day.

It would be a better world if more people cared about the impact of what they do and say, but in the absence of that, most of us will settle for people who can at least act like they care.

ygjb··on Google's infamous internal 2010 “I just want to serve 5TB” video now public
> People like to feel puffy hair, black person or not. > ... > In Japan, people like to feel my arm hair, which is blonde and almost invisible and completely foreign to East Asians. It's harmless.

Do you extend this perspective on unwanted touching to other parts of the body without consent? People like to do things to and with other people. The thing that makes doing that a form of aggression is doing those things without consent.

> Ask a white person with dreds if anyone has ever felt their hair.

Please point to the cultural and historical legacy of white people being stripped of their freedom, dignity and agency when comparing the experiences of white folks to Black folks. That sets aside the entire discussion of cultural appropriation related dreadlocks which is related to, but not at the core of the point I am trying to make.

> Now, you can obviously say or do something racist or mean while touching that hair, but the act of touching hair cannot itself be deemed aggressive without knowing the context. You would have to understand the social context of black people (apparently) being tired of being touched all the time in order to know that you should avoid doing this specific thing, which makes this a "faux pas".

The fact that you dismiss the documented experience of Black people as "apparently" being tired of being touched all the time says pretty much everything anyone in the audience needs to know about whether you are arguing in good or bad faith. The point is further driven home by the fact that you are contrasting your own anecdotal experience with an awareness of the social context of why this is an issue.

ygjb··on Google's infamous internal 2010 “I just want to serve 5TB” video now public
From a practical business perspective, performing a diversity and inclusiveness review is a risk management activity.

It doesn't really matter if the business strongly supports or opposes a particular set of diversity and inclusiveness goals from a fiduciary perspective, but it sure does matter if the business keeps losing money or missing targets because it is embroiled in scandals, paying out settlements to staff that have suffered discrimination, or being hauled in front of regulators to air their dirty laundry.

One would hope that being a decent place to work, and treating people fairly would be enough of an incentive, but for everyone else, there are risk management processes designed to have repeatable processes to identify business risks, escalate them to leadership, and presumably either accept the risk, or steer the project towards a solution that has a more acceptable risk profile.

ygjb··on Google's infamous internal 2010 “I just want to serve 5TB” video now public
Yes.

The expectation isn't that you actually adopt or accept the values. The expectation is that you know that if you fail to do so (and you lack sufficient privilege in your organization), then you will be held accountable.

Practically speaking "woke" people would prefer to work with people who share values, but most of us will settle for people who can at least emulate a decent human being while interacting with other people at work.

ygjb··on Wacom drawing tablets track the name of every application that you open
Well, or as an alternative, we could regulate the collection, retention, and use of data by applications.

Consumers can't meaningfully consent isn't meaningful when businesses don't have an obligation to disclose what data is being collected especially when it is described as

“[including] aggregate usage data, technical session information and information about [my] hardware device.”

Far more consumers would be outraged if each application or license agreement had to: a) provide a detailed list of information collected and transmitted to the vendor b) acknowledge each time that list of data changed c) had to do this for each business they dealt with on a regular basis

ygjb··on Seeding oceans with volcanic ash could be new tool to tackle climate change
No, just countries building stronger borders to prevent ecological and economic migrants from escaping the countries that don't have enormous wealth as a buffer against change.

:(

ygjb··on Private keys used to sign EU Digital Covid Certificate might have been leaked
One would assume, but unfortunately as another comment in this thread illustrated, there is no bottom when probing the depth of the depravity inspired by ignorant hatred.
ygjb··on GitHub degraded performance – resolved
I wish I had your confidence in the financial system, but it's not the financial services I am concerned about.

Financial services are important for moving money around, and processing electronic payments, but it doesn't matter how effectively you can process a wire if there are significant supply chain disruptions, and systems failures that take down the platforms that major retailers and distributors use for logistics.

Even if ATMs and bank networks remain up, what about the encashment and physical security services that those institutions rely on to move around actual physical money?

The economy is more than just financial services, and all of those financial services are just proxies for the real world goods that people need to survive for more than a few days in most urban centres.

ygjb··on North and West Africa: Interpol report on human trafficking for organ removal
puts on sanitation engineer outfit

> Men are 20% of human trafficking. The idea that's not a massive part of the asset is garbage.

Yes, that's what I said. 20% of human trafficking is the minority. Not irrelevant, and I never said that. I said that when you want to prevent attacks you start with the asset you want to protect that is most frequently attacked.

> The reason men are left out is because the UN is a political tool used to promote careers over good policy. And from your two comments it works.

Huh? My comments have nothing to do with the UN, my comments are based on the notion that I have worked for more than 20 years in various information security roles, including government, finance, open source companies, cutting edge technology firms. Before that I was a soldier. I am very open about who I am. What expertise do you have besides shitposting on social media sites?

> The reason you would target women and children, is men are generally labour which is generally less harmful to the individual. (Ignoring the complexity of boys trafficked as soldiers)

The reason I would protect, not target women and children as a priority is because they make up the largest community of vulnerable people. As I said in my original comment, raising the standards of protection and care for vulnerable populations has the effect of raising the bar for every group of vulnerable people. Finally, trafficking in child soldiers is a different issue entirely, and is the reason that I make donations to organizations like https://dallaireinstitute.org/ What actual good work have you done in your life, by donation, or by actual work?

> Of course for organ transplants that makes no sense. But that's back to the bureaucrats and the commentary on OP question. People are not good. They are in this to feel good about themselves. Hence white knight the women and children.

No, you are not a good person, and you are projecting your awful perspectives and assumptions about people onto others actions. I have seen some shit people over my careers and generally they come in with attitudes like yours calling people liars and assuming that everyone who takes a positive position is virtue signalling or white knighting, or whatever language of the day is used to hide the fact that your cynical views of people are largely based on your own inadequacies.

Be well, and stop stinking up the neighbourhood.

ygjb··on GitHub degraded performance – resolved
Yes.

It's worth noting that you can take almost any software from before the late 90s to early 2000s, depending on the vendor, that is still available, and with a layer of emulation get it running in minutes.

The vast majority of software that is being built today for end users simply will not function in a short time frame because of aggressively built in dependencies on cloud based services, often with those dependencies designed to encourage customer lock-in and prevent piracy by forcing users to have active accounts and shift core logic from endpoints to cloud services.

Even moving past licensing servers and account capabilities, tools like Grammarly ship much of their analysis to the cloud, same for most translation services. Many modern text to speech services are cloud based as well (just look at how useless a modern cell phone becomes when you are without a data connection, for example).

I don't know what the statistics would look like, but I shudder to think how much of the world economy would grind to a halt if Amazon or another significant cloud provider had a sustained, multi-region outage (say 24-48 hours).

It's a god-damn mess, and we did it to ourselves.

ygjb··on U.S. tightens export controls on items used in surveillance of private citizens
To detect cosmic rays? I doubt it; detecting them would be possible, but pointless since you couldn't reasonably act on the information - any such solution would probably need Heisenberg compensators since the tools to detect the radiation would most interfere with the radiation you are trying to detect. It's probably better to just shield all the things, or add integrity checks everywhere.

To detect bitflipping errors? Yes. Use cryptographically secure algorithms and protocols that ensure that messages have integrity checks in transit and in memory.

To detect crashes? Probably not - if a bit flips in memory without hardware level error correction that reports the error, there isn't really a way to detect what caused the error.

ygjb··on North and West Africa: Interpol report on human trafficking for organ removal
Sibling comment already addressed this, but for the simple reason that when you are working to protect any asset or resource, including people, you invest where attackers are targeting those assets first.

Most frequently focusing on improving the safety and security of the most vulnerable has a knock-on effect of dragging the level of safety up to a simple baseline.

The frustrating thing about writing an answer like this is that it's necessary because based on your comment history you aren't asking that question in good faith, but others need to respond to it because leaving garbage comments like yours unaddressed is like leaving litter in the neighbourhood park. It's not my job or responsibility to take out the trash, but I like living in a clean neighbourhood.

ygjb··on Does “skipping meals make you live longer”?
I mean, parent post literally wrote that. Cutting carbohydrates and sugars will reduce calories (unless ones diet consists of psyllium husks and sugar alcohols as the carbohydrates and sugars).
ygjb··on U.S. tightens export controls on items used in surveillance of private citizens
Yeah, it's a battle that China may not be able to win, but the United States government continuing to permit SpaceX to deploy satellites that are used to circumvent Chinese policy would be a clear act of aggression, especially if China had taken action to assert control over it's domestic communications.

I mean, it's entirely possible that some elements of the US government might prefer that, but generally speaking, I don't think that's a winning strategy for SpaceX. I think that even the most ardent Musk fans should anticipate how quickly tolerance for Musk's cavalier attitude dries up once missiles start flying.

ygjb··on U.S. tightens export controls on items used in surveillance of private citizens
So that perspective is largely a risk management failure. Yes, it's possible and probably likely, that at some point a rogue cosmic ray might flip a bit on your phone (or a bit in transit between a tower and your phone).

No, it is exceedingly unlikely that such a bit flip will have a real world impact beyond an unexpected error that manifests as an application crash or device reboot in the worst scenario, and most likely a temporary failure such as an image not loading or rendering, or a decryption operation that fails because the flipped bit makes is treated as an error.

Is it something to be concerned about? Generally not - if you are in an environment that has sufficient radiation that it has a practical impact on your phone, one would hope that your actual concern is more heavily focused on protecting your physical self, and one would hope that your personal threat model increases in scope to justify spending on electronics that are more resilient if you have budget left over after buying protective gear.

← PreviousPage 15 of 24Next →