HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ygjb

2,394 karma · joined September 8, 2011

Yvan Boily Founding Security Engineer Co-founder, Oghmere parentsguidetoai.ca https://nimblemyth.ca
submissionscomments
ygjb··on U.S. tightens export controls on items used in surveillance of private citizens
I would like to challenge the notion that the executives at businesses at this scale are unwilling to communicate a numerical cost.

I can't say which organization it was, or when it was, because I maintain enough of a public profile that it could leak specific information, but while doing a security consulting gig for a major global financial organization between 2001 and 2011, the team I was working with identified numerous serious concerns. The client company agreed that they were real risks, and even likely risks, but the financial impact, even if those risks were realized multiple times, were far below their documented thresholds for risk tolerance. In other words, the individual risks would have had to exceed $10M in impact per year, for multiple years before the financial impact of those issues would justify the massive cost of investment to remediate the risks. It's not that they didn't take them seriously, but the cost of the new system in development, which included addressing those risks, was so high that starting separate remediation efforts that would detract from those in progress changes introduced risk of the main replacement project failing. It was easier and lower risk and lower cost to just accept the impact of fraud, including compensating victims, than to try to fix it.

Whether or not those "self-insuring" risk tolerance figures are public are a different matter.

I do agree on the value and efficacy of capability-based systems, however the cost and effort to deploy and manage them, even in life critical environments, is so high that they are only practically effective in centrally planned environments where the funding for systems security is strongly decoupled from how that funding is acquired. In other words, capability based systems are, and will only be effective, at scale, in environments such as government (and even then, only military) or publicly funded, single payer, centrally managed health care systems (which don't really actually exist - most public funded healthcare in the world is centrally and publicly funded, but delivered by private service providers who bill the public funder).

It's an effective model where the cost of reliably deploying and managing capability based security can be externalized from the line of business that requires that level of security.

ygjb··on U.S. tightens export controls on items used in surveillance of private citizens
Are you trying to hold up the autocratic client state that failed to stop 50,000 people from escaping in it's 45 year duration as an example? The one that was facing the prospect of economic ruin when it's controlling state had to withdraw economic and military support due to it's own policies of perestroika that sought to address the impending economic collapse of Soviet Russia?

The fascist client state that collapsed due to an increasingly hostile domestic population who were angered by the growing economic challenges, and were tired of the continued state violence?

The same German Democratic Republic that has been consigned to the historical scrap heap of failed totalitarian regimes?

One might even consider holding North Korea up as a current example, since they have outlasted the GDR by 31 years so far, but they are also a client state, and their economy has been in relatively steady decline. The only thing keeping North Korea a functioning country is military and economic support from China, with even Russia's central bank continuing to push back against further economic development with North Korea.

ygjb··on U.S. tightens export controls on items used in surveillance of private citizens
This is such a ridiculous comment. It has never been in the technical capabilities to seal off any land border in the history of humanity, because any controls that you can put in place, including all of the technology that currently exists that you could throw at it are still designed by humans, require absolutely no collaboration on the part of the operators of those defenses, and are immediately upon deployment subject to attack by your adversaries.

Assuming you are referring to the United States, even if you deployed all of those sensors at all crossings, it would not be sufficient to deter crossings; those only provide detective capabilities. Yes, you would radically increase the number of people guarding the border, but that would also require a radical investment in enforcement, and such an investment would bankrupt the country for no real practical effect. Even if you did fund and build it, the maintenance costs of preserving the effectiveness of such a land border along the northern border with Canada means protecting a nearly 9,000 km border that about 200 km from the West Coast turns into extremely inhospitable to hostile terrain and climate for a minimum of three to four months out of the year. This terrain is absolutely awful to stalk and patrol in, but is a pleasure to sneak through (at least I really enjoyed it back in my hunting and military training days :D)

It is not feasible to scale the navy to the point where it would be practical to prevent access to the continental United States, for example, let alone the island territories. Attempting to do so would bankrupt the nation. Hell, modern technology can't even reliably prevent folks from bobbing over from Cuba despite the relatively small attack surface there.

Even if you managed to invest more than the current percentage of GDP (which is already ridiculous), you would also have to confront an increasingly hostile domestic population who is used to freedom of movement, is already paying punishingly high taxes in contrast to the value and benefit they receive for them, and rapidly diminishing quality of life.

Good luck with that!

Oh, and one last note about capability based security - it works great in lab and somewhat small environments, but I would appreciate a practical explanation of how you would scale up capability based security to an environments operating in 87 distinct countries (with disparate regulatory requirements that preclude centralized management), 3600 offices, and 800,000 employees, with approximately one third of those employees having employer managed devices, notebooks, and managing a total of 2,300 distinct software applications (granted it's been about 14 years since I worked in that environment, but that company has grown substantially since then).

I'm listening for a real, practical suggestion here, not being facetious.

ygjb··on $1M bounty for details on Tether’s backing
I am curious about how that type of activity doesn't constitute insider trading? Presumably having "bad news" would constitute material nonpublic information?
ygjb··on The FDA wants you to be able to buy a hearing aid without a prescription
Check out nuraphones; I don't know enough about hearing and audio to know what voodoo they are doing, but as a person with significant hearing loss, the hearing customization they perform during set up allows the device to emit the right frequencies at the right volume that I can hear a significant portion of the left audio channel (which is impressive, given that I am "profoundly deaf" in that ear).
ygjb··on Expensify S-1
> Which isn't to say that one should avoid political advocacy, just that the costs should be evaluated before deciding to do it or to not do it.

It is pretty clear that the decision to write the email was written with business impacts in mind. Two of the longer paragraphs are essentially business justifications for why he wrote the email.

ygjb··on Expensify S-1
Why?

Is it because you disagree with the political leanings of the CEO?

Is it because you don't think that corporations should express political biases?

If so, do you maintain a list of companies that you won't do business with based on corporate donations?

Is it because you disagree with a founder or CEO using the platform that their company provides them to amplify their voice?

Your comment is a condemnation of the action of the CEO without any specific concern raised about the action taken, and leaves one to conclude that you are a Trump supporter. That is also fine - the whole point of democracy is to allow people to choose who they vote for.

ygjb··on Eidos-Montréal Offices shifting to the 4 day work week
Competent managers in technical companies managing highly skilled professionals do. The rapidly growing corporate surveillance market says that incompetent managers and companies that grind people until they burn out are still a a major force out there.
ygjb··on GitHub Advisory Database now powers NPM audit
Then, if you build a successful product, you get:

* ransomware

* free PR from haveibeenpwned (but not the kind you want)

* a burning desire to put my (or one of my AppSec/IR peers) kids through college.

That said, YMMV.

ygjb··on Firefox Suggest (address bar based ads, currently limited to US)
I personally think that Firefox Pro could offer a shiny icon that says "Pro" in it, and the satisfaction of knowing that I supported a project I care about.

For an annual license, perhaps a sheet of stickers?

ygjb··on Firefox Suggest (address bar based ads, currently limited to US)
No it's not. Advertising is natural, from pretty flowers, to peacock and spider dances, to animals marking territory and making whatever mating noises they care to.

The advertising industry, which generally means the corporate owned, mass surveillance apparatus that is every authoritarians wet dream is malicious.

ygjb··on Firefox Suggest (address bar based ads, currently limited to US)
I know this has been posted before, but it seems to be getting some traction and outrage on twitter and other social media today.

Props to Mozilla for finding revenue diversification opportunities, but this still doesn't feel quite right since it's enabled by default.

ygjb··on New York Public Library ends all late fees
We live in the same neck of the woods, based on your HN profile; there is a balance tracked at Vancouver Public Libraries that is based on late fees. It's also worth noting that VPL wants to get rid of late fees as well, based on this article from a few months ago. https://bc.ctvnews.ca/vancouver-libraries-offering-fine-forg...
ygjb··on New York Public Library ends all late fees
Wait, so now, in order to provide public library services, that are generally free, you want libraries to essentially function as banks and carry account balances and pay out interest?

My dude, I don't think you really understand the goals or objectives of public libraries.

ygjb··on New York Public Library ends all late fees
That would preclude the significant majority of use of public libraries; a $200 deposit is absolutely crippling to someone living in poverty, and unattainable for almost all children and students.
ygjb··on Man can change his pupil size on command
Same. I always lumped it in with "can't curl my tongue" and "cilantro tastes like soap" types of genetic differences...
ygjb··on Second IC
But the model for it to be accessible to the general public is readily available, it's just not evenly distributed.

I can go to several local fed-ex offices here in Vancouver and they will print on demand a file that I provide them, for a very reasonable cost (given that they eat the cost of misprints and supervision of the process).

There are a number of fairly successful print on demand businesses that are niche specialized as well, heroforge is a great example.

ygjb··on Climate change: IPCC report is 'code red for humanity'
This argument is the problem. If we stopped producing fossil fuels right now, there would be an economic collapse, and starvation, and probably a few wars.

In 50-75 years we will probably be looking back in horror at the missed opportunity to avoid the ongoing economic collapse, the massive famine, starvation, and plagues that will follow on COVID, and the continuous wars as refugees flood from the front lines of climate collapse to places where the impacts aren't as severe and immediate.

ygjb··on Climate change: IPCC report is 'code red for humanity'
No, you are underestimating the fact that people already understand how average temperature works, especially folks they have ever lived in a modest home with no AC.

If someone's home is 24-26C, and they turn on their oven to cook something for dinner, it will warm up their home, depending on the size of their home and ventilation.

Overall the average temperature increase won't be that much, but they localized temperature increase is very dramatic. Your apartment might not be hot, but that small area that is 200C is having a dramatic impact on everything else in your apartment.

Bonus points for extra comprehension if they have a basement or ground floor that has a substantially lower temperature. Again, the average temperature might be high, but it doesn't mean that it's hot everywhere in the house.

Understanding this isn't rocket science, and the only reason people are ignoring it is because people in power have a vested interest in keeping people ignorant of it by outright lying, obfuscating, or denying it.

ygjb··on The historical accuracy of medieval city-builder video games
In one of my campaign worlds the assassins guild was run by a church; you had to pay once to kill them, and again to make sure they stayed dead :P

Introducing magic, or any kind of efficient machine or analog for modern medicine that might appear as magic in a fantasy setting means you get to throw out most of the rules that are learned from historical observations, except where you base those lessons learned on post-industrial revolution studies where the availability of electricity and modern industrial tools haven't been made readily available to developing communities and countries.

ygjb··on Room C, where my little ballerina danced
I absolutely love it when I am present for when my kids start learning something. It's delightful to watch them learn and figure things out and take their first steps. Sometimes whatever they are learning is something they enjoy, and sometimes it's not. For my son the first time he realized he was consistently hitting the ball in baseball was great. For my daughter it was getting control of the ball in soccer. The novelty is delightful.

One thing I learned over time though, is that when I am present is that my presence is a distraction. It wasn't something I figured out - my son straight up told me. When I am there at a practice, he is constantly checking if I am watching, because he wants to make sure he is doing well (not because I am a crazy perfectionist parent - I hope... ) because he wants to show off. By not being fully engaged and present I give him the freedom to practice and make the mistakes that are necessary for bridging a basic skill to mastery.

I enjoy watching them learn, but not at the cost of my children being distracted from the task at hand. I will be present for every performance, and every game, but if I am going to a practice, I will generally drop the kids off and take a walk to give them space to mess up without being concerned what I am going to think or how I might respond.

ygjb··on Toyota is quietly pushing Congress to slow the shift to electric vehicles
For Canada

https://www.nrcan.gc.ca/science-and-data/data-and-analysis/e...

Specifically for BC, where I live: https://www.cer-rec.gc.ca/en/data-analysis/energy-commoditie...

ygjb··on Toyota is quietly pushing Congress to slow the shift to electric vehicles
> I live in a condo so charging at home isn't an option. Why not? Why not join your strata or hmo board and change that?

Why not lobby your local jurisdiction to add these kind of requirements to new construction, or pass by-laws or laws at the right level to require condo buildings to allow individuals to install chargers?

All of these complaints are passive and indicate that you don't have agency in this situation. These types of changes don't happen unless people push back against the status quo.

I am always shocked when I see so many people participating on a message board that is designed for people who want to move fast and break things just... accept... the way the world around them is.

ygjb··on Toyota is quietly pushing Congress to slow the shift to electric vehicles
Your concerns are basically straight up range anxiety. Anecdotally speaking, my previous vehicle was the only one out of 4 vehicles on camping trips for several years that had mechanical issues.

The simple reality is that in most of North America you are less than 2 hours away from help in case of mechanical defect. Inside the United States, with few exceptions, it's must closer. You are just as vulnerable to mechanical failure with a gas vehicle as you are with an electric vehicle.

That said, it's currently a consumer choice, but as a tax payer and a consumer I desperately want my (Canadian) government to end all subsidies for fossil fuel industries, and introduce additional taxes with a direct path to those taxes being used to subsidize and invest in electric alternatives.

ygjb··on Toyota is quietly pushing Congress to slow the shift to electric vehicles
No one is arguing any of these points. The problem is that currently the increased efficiency of ICEs are externalized from the people who are profiting from it.

Pollution, noise, power distribution (fuel vs electric) and the toll on public infrastructure are all externalized costs for these businesses.

The detail that is really exciting is that as EV technology is improving and people are becoming more aware of the realities of climate change and our complete inability to practically affect change as individuals, more and more people are starting to look to sustainable choices, and ICEs based on fossil fuels simply aren't one of them. AFAIK hydrogen fuel cells still aren't simply because the cheapest source of hydrogen is still fossil fuels, by a long shot (unless there is a more recent study that shows otherwise).

ygjb··on Toyota is quietly pushing Congress to slow the shift to electric vehicles
Is this just your opinion, or do you actually have data to back up your claims here?

I ask because there was a 5 year old study that illustrated that in 2016 87% of trips were within range for an electric vehicle with overnight charging. https://www.nature.com/articles/nenergy2016112

Range anxiety is a real thing, but we settled on a PHEV SUV with a 40km range last year due to not finding the right mix of towing capacity and range in an electric vehicle (we need to routinely use a trailer that can haul >1500 lbs for business reasons). That 40km range covers approximately 3/4 quarters (74.38) of our routine driving (I actually have this data, we were surprised that it came out to such a round number!)

We expect to sell our current vehicle and switch to a full electric SUV with similar capabilities once they are available in 2021/2022.

ygjb··on TC Energy scraps Keystone XL pipeline project after Biden revokes key permit
It's not possible to both maximize the safety and efficacy of using oil while externalizing the long term economic and environmental impact of using oil. The proposed efficiency and safety are entirety predicated on the externalized impact of pollution, climate change, and oil sand fracking.
ygjb··on Making JavaScript run fast on WebAssembly
While there will always be the case that highly optimized javascript code will be more performant, the flexibility and performance of WASM on the web and in browsers means that a significant number of high impact products and services have already made the jump to using WASM in part or in full.

https://madewithwebassembly.com/all-projects

ygjb··on Google says Rowhammer attacks are gaining range as RAM is getting denser
You don't need to have a practical attack for something to be a credible threat that needs to be addressed in a multi-tenant system (like say, cloud providers).
ygjb··on MDN Plus
A premium chat room or forum doesn't make more sense because the people Mozilla would be paying to staff that channel are already on several open forums and most are willing to answer questions (even if that answer is RTFM and a redirect to an MDN page).

Yes, they got rid of most of the team, bu the remaining team members that are there and pretty much all of the community contributors would quit if they were suddenly transitioned into paid tech support roles.

← PreviousPage 16 of 24Next →