2,392 karma · joined September 8, 2011
This has been a recurring problem for me - as a security engineer catasrophization is a fundamental skill to finding vulnerabilities in complex systems, but makes me to conservative when building. For some of my leaders they are much better at saying 'good enough, ship it, and fix it later'.
The collapse of the massive overvaluation and circular investments will be the undoing of several major tech investors and companies that have a serious contribution to the things in tech we don't like. It will be bad for the economy, but it will also weaken the abhorrent control that those companies have over regulation in the United States.
It's gonna be a rough time, but it's pretty clearly necessary.
The only big problem is that if that collapse happens under the current administration in the US, they will be utterly incompetent to respond to a real domestic crisis, since they have been virtually unable to do anything without creating more problems.
I do agree on the fly by night agents, especially since so much is actually just agents acting on behalf of folks who just spam whatever permissions are requested in Claude/Codex.
You might be right that they can't do that now. The simple path forward is to have these companies simply make a public commitment to publish the data when the copyright expires. I also think there is a space to be carved out, probably through regulation, to ensure that there is a clear path for these scans to enter the public domain, at the very least.
This is not just important for these specific books, I have written on other platforms and in other spaces about the importance of media companies and those who benefit from strong copyright laws to protect and generate profits and revenues to repay the public for the cost of that enforcement over time by ensuring that at the appropriate time, those works fully enter the public domain. That could mean a restructuring of the Library of Congress in the United States to become a modern Library of Alexandria to host data, and shifting to a registered copyright model where to gain the protections of the court, you need to upload/submit your copyrighted works for storage and eventual release. I doubt it would ever happen there because of the amount of money invested in tying up IP in the United States, but perhaps a more amenable location like the EU could help with that.
However it might work, part of the promise of the Internet was that information would be liberated, but we see every day how much information gets sent down the memory hole when businesses, sites or services shut down, or how regularly companies abuse IP related regulations to attempt to strangle competition. It would be expensive now, but it would create an incredibly valuable legacy of information for the future, and it will only get more expensive to build such a thing as time goes on.
IMO that would go a long way to resolve any concerns about losing books. I still don't like the idea of extremely hard to find or last prints being actually destroyed for this, but it certainly makes it more palatable.
I personally don't like or use most Apple products outside of my work MacBook pro, but I recognize the value and innovations there.
In addition I have virtually unconstrained usage at work (for now).
Tasks that I do on my personal account: - building stuff for my wife's business - analyzing and experimentation and building harnesses to test other models/services - processing interesting research papers that publish without code or sufficient data to replicate the work
And that's besides simple stuff like exploring new topics I am interested in, and building learning assistants and personal tooling, and eliminating technical chores.
If gives me a pretty solid map of what is working well, and aids in driving through security testing.
Still not a replacement for manual testing. Us meatbags still have a knack for royally messing up the expected use cases :P
I don't care much about the 2nd amendment absolutists, and the myth of the American heroes who will stand up to tyranny, because so far the only thing they appear to have stood up for in the last hundred years are gun rights, religious fundamentalism, and in 2020, a demagogue.
American exceptionalism and gun culture are important to Americans, but are pretty much viewed as narcissism and with skepticism outside of the US. YMMV, but like another comment I made recently, this isn't an anti-American sentiment, it's just a perspective from one of your neighbours to the north who has lots of Canadian and American friends and family living in the US.
In the absence of effective laws to align people in the direction of the society they want, and constant effort to realign in response to pressure, we will fall back to tribalism and all of the attendant forms of feudalism and government that came before it. Ownership then reverts to might (or those with the resources to buy might) makes right.
This isn't an anti-American sentiment. It is an anti-corporate/regulatory capture/embrace and extinguish sentiment (which probably reads the same to many people these days).
It's probably not what you want to hear, but are you sure you were holding the tool correctly? At least with this tool, you can actually ask it :D
You haven't even provided enough information for us to know if you are using the right tool. Saying "the model" in relation to an LLM provider that offers several is like asking for help with using a Dewalt or Milwaukee to help assemble an cabinet. Are you cutting, drilling, hammering, screwing?
As hardware specs get better, and model providers keep making different classes of mistakes that alienate users, more people will opt for or support local models. I tend to take Schneiers' "Attacks only improve" philosophy and apply it to damn near everything like this. Inference will get more expensive, but IMO cloud based inference is at or near the maximum that users can tolerate, across multiple spectra. There may be a marginal increase in cost, but as the different metrics between what is affordable for rapidly scalable, cloud based inference and the lag of local inference with open models and expensive hardware converge, prices will come down.
I am not the right person to say what the peak is going to look at, but when the companies with (practically speaking) unlimited compute resources and money are starting to take a good hard look, there is going to be a drive towards efficiency. I hear grumbling at work, and the appreciation from my leaders when I show up with a tool that shows how I reduced my token costs, or I keep asking the questions of what the token cost (real, and internal billing) are for tools my peers write are.
I also have absolutely eye-watering personal AI bills that are starting to make buying a better tier of local inference gear look more affordable, even with inflated hardware prices. The current generation of open models are very effective, and paying for multiple $200 dollar a month subs is not feasible longer term, and as one example, in one month, if I was paying enterprise token rates, I would have burned through $8000+ token budgets on one of those accounts, doing actual, practical useful work, it makes more sense to buy some much better hardware than to pay for one-time inference costs.
That's democratization - shifting power and skills away from those with the wealth to purchase vulns and run offensive security teams. It's still not simple, but it's one of the reasons bigger vendors want to lock down the capabilities of models that present a threat to the wealthy and powerful.
Current AI isn't super effective at making the breakthroughs, but it sure is effective at democratizing the ones you can point it at.
Same thing for stuff at work. Oh, the tables/schema changed and my queries broke? I could dork around with spark and cypher for an hour, or I can tell claude to update the queries for the new schema. At the rate I am paid, spending on Claude tokens is generally a better use of my resources.
Building a net new solution? Coding tools take a back seat until I get the core logic right, then I let automation handle web page and UI scaffolding.
The US likes to flex it's muscle by pushing other governments around on behalf of its commercial interests.
I think it's well past time for Canada to either formally pursue toes with the EU or pursue alignment with EU consumer protection legislation.
Middle powers unite!
I would be interested to see a formal study of this. I say this not out of anything other than a observation that I think the only real blockers are a) judgement, and b) physical reflexes/strength. As a kid I was certainly aware of ice,snow, and rain, because I road my bike year round and had low confidence in my own ability to control my bike on snowy or wet terrain, especially during season changes. That translated into learning to drive in northern Canada in the winter and applying those lessons to driving.
In an environment devoid of consequences, I have seen kids operate driving simulations (both real simulations, and video games) with a degree of precision that is shocking, including seeing several 9-11 year olds play the simulations and games with a much higher degree of confidence than adult drivers. Children have an awareness that the simulations are consequence free, unless given other motivation. Adults that are consistent drivers have muscle memory and preconceived expectations that govern the decisions they make when playing the game. I am curious about the level of training and exposure required for children to overcome their lack of awareness of the hard limits and consequences of driving and driver error, versus the amount of training and exposure required for expert drivers that are novice gamers to stop applying their learned experience to consequence free simulations.
I spend all day working on AI related stuff at my day job, but more recently I have been getting lots of questions about AI from friends and family and that ramped up when the Vancouver school board announced they were rolling out Copilot across high schools.
I put together the guide, made a few iterations and published it and now I am getting more questions than ever and it's turned into a blog too.
I'm having fun but it definitely feels like a topic that is underserved. A solid example, lots of resources for when your kid is the victim of a deepfake, but what if you as a parent know your kid is getting into trouble and escalating. Where do you go for help to make sure they don't escalate from unfriendly behavior to abusive or even criminal.
It's a big challenge!