2,392 karma · joined September 8, 2011
That said, I think more lovecraftian horrors that have taken on their own life, aided by the human creation of corporations...
I don't recall where I first saw it, but this is fairly apt :P
---
Did anyone notice how quickly the internet turned into a Lovecraftian horror scenario?
Like we’ve got this dimension right next to ours, that extends across the entire planet, and it is just brimming with nightmares. We have spambots, viruses, ransomware, this endless legion of malevolent entities that are blindly probing us for weaknesses, seeking only to corrupt, to thieve, to destroy.
Add onto that the corrupted ones themselves, humans who’ve abandoned morality and given up faces to hunt other people, jeering them, lashing out, seeing how easy it is to kill something you can’t touch or see or smell. They’ll corrupt anything they think could be a vessel for their message and they’ll jabber madly at any who question them. Their chittering haunts every corner of the internet. They are not unlike the spambots in some ways.
Add on top of that the arcane magisters, who are forever working at the cracks between our world and the world we made. Some of them do it for fun, some of them do it for wealth, others do it for the power of nations unwise enough to trust them. There are mages who work to defend against this particular evil, but they are mad prophets, and their advice is almost never heeded, even by those who keep them as protection.
The team that built peerd had the good sense to consult with the author of Spegel before moving forward with their project. A simple note to their business line lawyer (or whatever they call them at Microsoft) at work to say "hey, we are going to use some of this code from this open source project, what do we need to do?" would have taken less time and effort than setting up the meeting with the Spegel person/folks. That is assuming there isn't an easy to find page on how to consume open source software on Microsoft intranet. Every major company I have worked for (HSBC, Mozilla, Amazon, Fastly, Cisco, to name some) has had this going back to 2005. This isn't rocket science.
You also don't need to be a legal expert to comply with most open source licenses, and the MIT license in particular is really easy to comply with. Just copy the code, and whatever file you copy the code into gets an attribution comment at the top.
Fair use allows for commentary, news reporting, criticism, teaching, research, and scholarship and there are guidelines. Most cases where fair use is sought as a defense requires litigation to clear it up. The other alternative when forking an extremely permissive MIT license is to just follow the license.
> Probably they should keep a copy of the original LICENSE file somewhere, sure. And if one asks politely, maybe they will do it.
They are required to do so by the original license of Spegel. Does Microsoft ask politely when people violate MS licensing by say, pirating their software, or do they work with 3 letter agencies and a massive enforcement team to ensure their licenses are followed?
> My point is that Peerd seems like it's loosely based on Spegel. Maybe a fork that was heavily modified. Not sure if they should track all the code that looks like it was not modified enough and attribute it everywhere.
Yes. Every other tech company I have worked at, including Mozilla, a company that publishes almost everything they do as open source, has had folks dedicated to ensuring license compliance.
> Again: they did credit the original project. So it feels a bit aggressive to say that they "stole it without giving any credit".
They didn't provide credit in the way that the license requires. This isn't a case where a new community member forked or copied code into their first open source project. This is one of the biggest companies in the world with a well-known history of taking and using OSS without proper attribution. I like and use many MS products, but they absolutely do not deserve the benefit of the doubt.
Forking and/or copying files from the Spegel code base into the Peerd code base is permitted, but since the Spegel code base had a single license file covering the entire repo, then the onus is on Microsofts engineers to update the code they copied and include the original license terms, for example, by including something like:
// Copyright (c) Microsoft Corporation.
// Licensed under the MIT License.
// Some code Copyright (c) 2024 The Spegel Authors, under MIT license
If your argument is that they aren't required to do this because the original code didn't have a license header in the file, then it would follow that you are arguing that the MIT license doesn't apply to the code that was copied, in which case Microsoft is using unlicensed code stolen from an open source project.
While I haven't worked at MS specifically, I would assume that like every other tech company I have worked at, they have a team or working group that specializes in adherence to open source licenses specifically to avoid both the legal implications and the bad PR implications of misusing open source software.
As an example, a CNA like Mozilla, Apple, or Microsoft is unlikely to disclose vulnerability data via CVE until they have remediated the issue or have public guidance, and their embargo processes are likely separate from CVE publication.
It's an easy word to say, and the implication that it would be peaceful or non-violent because of economic pressures ignores the fact that Canadians don't want it.
I have also set expectations with my leaders at work that even work travel to the US beyond previously booked trips (the last of which is next week) is off the table, and I would prefer to find a new job than continue to travel to a country that is treating it's allies so poorly.
You can argue the merits for or against, but more than 60% of Canadians support outright bans on firearms, and more than 80% support bans on 'assault' weapons.
This is not a hugely controversial topic in Canada; personally I support hunting, and recognize the utility of firearms as someone with a rural upbringing. I also support very strict gun controls and regulation, and I don't agree that there should be a right to bear arms - it's a privilege that should be earned, and well defended through testing and responsible ownership.
Yes, a tyrant could take over, but the only credible threat Canada has had of that since the second world war has been our most powerful ally 'joking' about annexing us. A well-armed militia wouldn't really help to stop that given the difference in equipment and headcount between the Canadian military, and the US military.
If Canadians decide that Canada needs one, we should implement a method to drive enrollment in the the Canadian Army Reserves, or implement a home defense militia that folks could enroll and participate in with a guarantee that they couldn't be deployed outside of Canada (I was in our armed forces, and would not join a volunteer unit that could be deployed overseas, but would immediately sign up for one that was only legally allowed to be deployed domestically for defense).
Canada did a lot to support US industry because it was working well for us as well as the Americans. If the US is going to disrespect us and threaten us, we might as well lean into our relationships with other trade partners.
Now it's because of advertising telling us to drink anything but water (or if we drink water to buy it in a bottle).
No one can control what will happen, but the simple reality is that allowing Russia to push a war of aggression out of fear of a nuclear attack endorses the idea that anyone with Nuclear capability can do what they want. China, India, etc can annex or invade and no one will stop them because it might trigger escalation. That reinforces the need for less powerful nations to pursue nuclear capability. Those smaller, less stable nations will be more likely to lose control of a nuclear weapon.
It's a catch 22 so we might as well try to err on the side of stopping wars of aggression. The other path is open for the cowards who would rather bend the knee or look the other way until aggression knocks on their front door.
The reasons he was elected are irrelevant, only his actions since being elected and taking power are.
Since then, Trump has proposed ethnic cleansing and gentrification of Ghaza, and proposed launching attacks into Mexico (putatively to take out cartel members). Anyone who thinks that Trump or his administration are looking for peace or peaceful solutions is clearly delusional.
https://x.com/tobi/status/1885906286950363546
Shopify has been very vocal of it's defense of free speech, most specifically when supporting the decision to platform some pretty awful organizations. There is a long history of this, but this recent article notes that they specifically removed restrictions on hateful content from their TOS.
https://finance.yahoo.com/news/holocaust-denial-merchandise-...
Lutke had previously denounced concerns about 'woke' ideology as destructive to teams, so it's pretty easy (for me at least) to see that Shopify would be eager to use the political cover of Trump's DOJ crackdown on businesses with DEI practices as cover to eliminate those teams.
Yes I do; it is a choice to profit by delivering services to different communities. Over and above being a good company and having lots of interesting technical challenges, one of the reasons I stayed at Fastly for nearly 5 years was because of the good neighbours practice, and the fact that the leaders at Fastly chose not to do business with companies that platform hate.
> Not sure what good you thought it was going to do to come into a thread about a US company, say they are defending free speech and then turn around and go "yea I don't believe in free speech".
Well, Shopify is a Canadian company, and I am Canadian, so I thought it might be useful to share a Canadian perspective.
> I would die for their right to free speech even if I don't agree with what they say. Are you prepared to do the same for your beliefs?
Yes. I enlisted in my countries military, and indicated my preference to join a peace keeping regiment because I believe that as someone who has the ability to stand up for and defend others, I should. I believe very strongly in Freedom of Expression, but when that expression turns to hate and advocating eugenics, genocide or any number of things that my country and my grand-parents fought against, well.. sometimes you have to punch Nazis... (or Hutu war criminals, or Bosnian war criminals, etc).
It's not enough to just depend on educating people - we can see that education hasn't been very effective, and education has been subverted in several countries, including the United States and Canada.
You are very quick to dismiss the establishment of Canadian identity, and disregard the history of the development of Canada. You are correct that the Canadian flag didn't exist then, but then again, the American flag didn't exist until close to the end of the American Revolution.
> Canadians do so because they have very little history to cling to. So they steal a bit of british history for themselves
Canadian military history includes British military history because we too were a colony of the British Empire. It turns out that there are a large number of Canadians who can trace their ancestry back to folks who settled in Canada well before Canada was a country. Their military service includes fighting for the French and the British before Canada was a country, including during the Revolutionary War. You could do some reading on this, there are many great books on the topic, and there is a ton of information on Wikipedia that outlines the history.
> Also, the british created the dominion of canada, not canadians. What do you think dominion means?
Specifically, in that era? It means a sovereign territory within the British Empire. The Dominion of Canada was established by the 1867 British North America act.
> Almost 3 whole generations. But even then you are off by more than a century (1982).
Yes. Change takes time - the American Revolution took almost 20 years, and didn't start with the Revolutionary War. Even after the Revolutionary War, there were additional rebellions and invasions into what would become Canada and it took time for things to settle down. Canada was established as a nation in 1867, and 1982 was absolutely a watershed moment where Canada established it's own Constitution and the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, but dismissing Canada's role as a nation prior to that is historically inaccurate.
> Other than having to kick out the british in the PNW in the 1840s/50s.
That didn't actually result in border changes that were different from what was established in 1818, it did however, lead to clarification that those borders were in place and would be defended.
> If you are curious about who won the war of 1812, go look into british land claims and american land claims prior to 1812.
I am not sure what you are on about here. The Treaty of Ghent included terms that dictated that the borders would return to the pre-war state. Neither the British nor the Americans won - that said, the US does have a history of failing in expansionism and labelling it a win, so I guess more power to you?
Beyond that, like I said, aside from some coastal island changes, and the Alaskan border, the majority of borders between United States and Canada have remained unchanged since 1818. The United States attempted to invade Upper and Lower Canada and take them over, and were repelled.
Yeah, lots of people say this, but the folks who fought the war were the people who lived in Upper and Lower Canada. The Boston Tea Party is considered by many historians to be an important turning point in American history, and is viewed as an American protest against taxation without representation. In much the same way, Canadians tend to consider the war of 1812 one of the watershed moments leading to the formation of the Dominion of Canada (even though that didn't happen for another 55 years).
Without British North America fighting back against American expansionism (among other things) that lead to the war of 1812, Canada would not have existed as it did then, and the borders have stayed mostly consistent (modulo some small disputes around Alaska and coastal islands) since 1818.
In the meantime, we are carefully and cautiously reminding the United States that we fought many of the same wars and learned the same lessons as the US military about how insurgencies are fought, and while many of our friends, family, and neighbours are American, we are not, and do not want to, and will not be American. Do with that what you will.