HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ygjb

2,393 karma · joined September 8, 2011

Yvan Boily Founding Security Engineer Co-founder, Oghmere parentsguidetoai.ca https://nimblemyth.ca
submissionscomments
ygjb··on Jellyfin: We're Good, Seriously
> Instead of asking to stop, they should do just what they suggest, without further ado - distribute the income to the ecosystem devs the way they see fit

Probably not. The amount of money they are taking in is very small, and if they start to ramp up revenue, then they actually need to start paying people for non-core work, like lawyers and accountants. Assuming that the money is received in Canada, by an Ontario registered non-profit, then it is really easy to do the accounting work for small dollar amounts (I ran several Manitoba and BC based non-profits previously for conferences and community work). If you start paying people who can't invoice you, then you need to sort out cross-jurisdictional payroll, and if you are making alot of purchases through other services.

Comments like this are unhelpful because it assumes that the developer of the project has a desire to run a business (and non-profits are businesses) rather than building and shipping an open source tool that scratches an itch. It's cool to speculate on what could be, but if you think that is the right approach, fork it, run the business transparently, and allocate a portion of revenue to be held in reserve the moment the core team for the project you forked asks for it.

ygjb··on It's not just CrowdStrike – the cyber sector is vulnerable
> This kind of logic only works if you ignore any kind of possible nuances in the problem and just insist on throwing the baby out with the bathwater. Just because someone let you do automatic updates (or let's be real, you probably didn't give them much or an option) that doesn't mean you should do use for everything.

Oh, I agree - automatic updates are nuanced in many cases. Generally speaking, automatic updates are a good thing, but they offer trade-offs; the main trade-off is rapidly receiving security updates, at the risk of encountering new features, which can include new bugs. This is kind of a big reason why folks who buy systems should be requiring that updates offer a distinction between Security/Long Term Support, and Feature updates. It allows the person who buys the product to make an effective decision about the level of risk they want to assume from those updates.

> Automatic update of data (like virus definitions) != automatic update of code (like kernel driver)

Yep, absolutely, except for the case where the virus definitions (or security checks) are written in a language that gets interpreted in a kernel driver, presumably in languages that don't necessarily have memory safety guarantees. It really depends on how the security technology implements it's checks, and the facilities that the operating system provides for instrumentation and monitoring.

ygjb··on It's not just CrowdStrike – the cyber sector is vulnerable
It's easy to make comments like this against automatic updates, but then you get popped because something that would have been automatically updated misses a patch because it was too critical to risk automatic updates.

In practice, failing closed (or crashing) is probably fine for most businesses, and lower cost than a breach, but the correct solution is automated testing across a broad spectrum of devices, staged and rolling updates to prevent entire fleets going down at once, and ensuring that there is an effective, tested rollback mechanism.

But that shit's expensive, so shrug :/

ygjb··on FTC finds 'dark patterns' used by a majority of subscription apps and websites
> This is a terrible piece. Whoever wrote it probably signed up for a subscription and forgot to cancel it.

The article specifically calls out that the issue investigated are applications that make it hard, and/or use otherwise bad UX patterns to discourage users from cancelling.

> Doesn't matter if you don't read the paper that's delivered to your house every morning, the service is still provided. Same thing with app services.

Newspapers are another area, like recurring apps, and gym memberships, where they are so hostile towards users unsubscribing that they have invited investigation and regulation in many jurisdictions.

> If you signed up for it, you signed up for it. Not my fault if you fail to cancel it if you're not using/reading it.

You want regulations? Because that's how you get regulations - which is likely the outcome given the number of countries investigating these practices individually, and through organizations like ICPEN.

ygjb··on Google Chrome has an API accesible only from *.google.com
Sigh. You don't prune threats you can't control from a threat model, you document them so that the consumers and maintainers of the target of assessment can intelligently reason about the threats as the product evolves.
ygjb··on Girls in Tech closes its doors after 17 years
That's a pretty bold claim to make without data to back it up.
ygjb··on Ask HN: How do browsers isolate internal audio from microphone input?
This is super common.

When I worked at Mozilla, most stuff was open, but I still couldn't talk about stuff publicly because I wasn't a spokesperson for Mozilla. Same at OpenDNS/Cisco, or at Fastly, and now at Amazon. Lots of stuff I can talk about, but I generally avoid threads and comments about Amazon, or if I do, it's strictly to reference public documentation, public releases, or that sort of thing.

It's easier to simply not participate, link a document, or say no comment than it is to cross reference what I might say against what's public, and what's not.

ygjb··on Electric Vehicle Batteries Surprising New Source of 'Forever Chemical' Pollution
You intended for them to be recycled, but just because you dropped it at a recycling depot or disposal doesn't mean they got recycled.

There are countless stories and studies showing that only a fraction of recyclable materials actually make it through recycling - it's kind of an E for Effort state for anything but glass and metal :(

ygjb··on Voice Isolator: Strip background noise for film, podcast, interview production
I mean, you don't have to?

Set up an audio source, for example, your phone, playing a reasonable length of talking, for example a youtube video, or a podcast on spotify. Then record from your computer or other recording device, and test with that?

ygjb··on Gassy cows and pigs will face a carbon tax in Denmark, a world first
Wow, you kind of went off the deep end there. I am not a vegetarian, nor do I promote a meat free lifestyle. You made an assumption because I said something you didn't like - a simple fact about the food production.

You see thousands of people on Reddit carrying on about being carnivores, I'll raise you 9% of India's population being vegan (that would be more than 125 million people), and another 40% of the population of India being some type of vegetarian. Find better data for your claims about the health impacts of not eating meat.

One other thing -

> Meat is clean of toxins as like in our own body

Uh huh. That's why farms routinely send meat to labs routinely to test for parasites and diseases, and mercury is a huge problem when consuming fish.

> Carnivores are strong, fit predators.

Eating meat does not make a predator; in the context of diet, if you are not hunting for your prey, you are a scavenger, consuming the remains of others kills (unless you think those Redditors you cited stalking the aisles of your local supermarket for the best deals counts as hunting).

The only reason I responded to this was because someone else might accidentally read your garbage post and be swayed by it.

ygjb··on Supreme Court blocks controversial Purdue Pharma opioid settlement
ok, so now you are just arguing percentages. What is an appropriate amount of the harm to be apportioned to the Sackler family?
ygjb··on Gassy cows and pigs will face a carbon tax in Denmark, a world first
> The aquaculture needed to produce seaweed has to be a net benefit now?

No. The concern is about the overall impact of the aquaculture required to scale this seaweed feed supplements production to have a meaningful impact on the methane production from livestock. If you ramp up seaweed production, and reduce methane, but the overall process (aquaculture, processing, distribution) produces anything but than a net negative in GHG emissions, then the only value of the process is greenwashing cattle ranching.

I am not hellbent on finding additional problems, the point is that a lab based solution doesn't solve the problem, and most of your comments have ignored the very real market realities. I would also wager that your opinions are not necessarily grounded in reality - I chatted with my brother, who was a pig farmer for nearly two decades and is still involved in agriculture in both farming and ranching, and my cousin who runs a very large ranch in Manitoba. Some of the concerns I brought up in my previous point about market pushback are summaries of the questions and concerns they raised, although they both thought it was really interesting because they are both especially interested in sustainable farming practices.

Switching gears because you moved the goalposts, nothing I have said has anything to do with starvation or hunger. Since you brought it up, it is almost absolutely certain that building technology that mitigates, partially or wholly, the environmental impact of cattle farms actually exacerbates world hunger. The simple reason that is that the labour and resources that go into producing meat for human consumption would produce significantly more human consumable calories if we shifted those to plant based alternatives (up to and including feeding people seaweed).

ygjb··on Gassy cows and pigs will face a carbon tax in Denmark, a world first
I haven't added or edited anything but spelling errors. It was another commenter who raised concern about scaling production, my point was that the viability of this as method for methane reduction also needed to determine if the aquaculture needed to produce the seaweed would be a net benefit from a climate change perspective.
ygjb··on Denmark to charge $100 per cow in first carbon tax on farming
Who said they cause climate change? Is the impact of domesticated cattle a measurable impact on global methane production? Yes. This has been measured, observed, and accepted science since at least 1995[1]. Does methane have an observable, measurable effect on climate? Yes[2], and agriculture is a major driver for anthropogenic climate change[3]. If you want to argue it doesn't or isn't, bring data, because there are too many articles, research papers, and studies arguing that it does that have for your unbacked opinion to be accepted.

Does this mean that cow farts (or burps) are the cause or driver of climate change? No. Is it something that we can meaningfully reduce the impact of? Well, probably, based on some of the resources linked to in other comments.

Does it mean that solving this for cattle is going to solve climate change? No, but incremental progress helps (insert 1.01% effort per day over a year = 37.8 meme).

You know what doesn't help? Clearly ignorant reductive comments that conflate a contributing factor with the entire problem while ignoring the preponderance of evidence contrary to your claims.

[1] https://academic.oup.com/jas/article-abstract/73/8/2483/4632... [2] http://repository.geologyscience.ru/bitstream/handle/1234567... [3] https://www.iea.org/reports/global-methane-tracker-2022/meth... [4] https://www.unep.org/news-and-stories/story/methane-emission... [5] https://climate.nasa.gov/vital-signs/methane/?intent=121

ygjb··on Gassy cows and pigs will face a carbon tax in Denmark, a world first
And I am sure that all of the fat people (myself included) are thrilled that a thermodynamic approach to weight loss is a proven solution, despite the fact that I have not had much success applying it.

I am also strongly reassured that XSS is a solved problem when using content security, and climate change has been solved by mass reforestation efforts.

The difficult part of a technical solution is not inventing it (although those are rightfully hard problems); the real challenge is in driving adoption of the solution.

The industry will push back on this solution for a broad range of reasons:

1. Cost - what is the cost of both the supplement and the labour required to administer it, or the differential on unfortified vs. fortified feeds.

2. Marketing - how will you communicate to folks that they should do this?

3. Customer Satisfication - does the supplement meaningfully affect any of the metrics for customer satisfaction (flavour, texture, etc of the meat).

4. Availability - retooling and spinning up the aquaculture required to produce the supplements

5. Viability - what is the ecological impact of the proposed seaweed solution, and is it a net positive.

I spent a chunk of my career as a researcher, developing protoypes and proof of concept stuff. One of the greatest things of that time in my career was developing something to 80% and throwing it over the fence, which let me ignore all of that hard work and call my project a win. One of the worst things is that out of that multi-year period of experimentation almost none of the work I did actually yielded unique products or improvements (although the tools I built did drive improvements to address issues and flaws found).

Assuming that you did the research, your work was definitely successful in finding a solution. You have not solved the problem, and the hard work is very much ahead.

ygjb··on Gassy cows and pigs will face a carbon tax in Denmark, a world first
That means absolutely nothing until the majority of cattle farms incorporate the supplement into their operations.

Knowing a potential solution is not the same as solving a problem, unless you are performing an academic exercise.

ygjb··on Denmark to charge $100 per cow in first carbon tax on farming
Sure, but you are only looking at one potential impact of this. I can think of at least 3 benefits that are seem pretty clear without doing a deeper analysis.

1. Adding an appropriate carbon tax for gassy cows offsets reduces or eliminates the externalization of the environmental impact of the cows, and provides justification for spending on the increased cost of feeds that drive down the amount of methane produced.

2. Driving a justification for increased spent on those feeds, especially novel feeds, drives investment in new aquaculture techniques that will create additional jobs and ensures that capital that might be otherwise be held as profits actually circulates through the economy (a key component that is actually required for capitalism to work).

3. The increased costs of beef and pork will drive lower consumption of animal based proteins. That lower consumption should be a factor in driving better health outcomes, longer term (note I said lower, not elimination of consumption). This is a net benefit for any nation that provides health care services to it's citizens (heart disease and cardiovascular illness are among leading causes of death in Denmark, like most developed nations).

ygjb··on Gassy cows and pigs will face a carbon tax in Denmark, a world first
This is a potential solution, but the problem isn't solved until the market actually adopts it.

Without a financial incentive to follow through (for example, a carbon tax on gassy animals) to offset the added cost of feed supplements, then most farms won't see the business justification (carbon footprint is largely externalized).

ygjb··on Drugmaker to testify on why weight-loss drugs cost 15x more in the US
This has "I could recreate twitter in a weekend" vibes. I am not out here rallying to lick corporate boots (I am in the 'hand the drug companies a cheque to recoup research costs, and make the drug generic' camp), but this is a really bad take.

The $3 billion comes from researching and demonstrating the role of GLP antagonists, determining how to use them as a medication, developing manufacturing and distribution processes, and dosing mechanisms, testing, documenting, and getting the appropriate certifications and approvals to ensure that the risks of using the medication are reasonably well understood and communicated. Then there is the cost of marketing and educating the medical services providers in various fragmented markets about the effects and efficacy of the drugs and presenting them as alternatives to existing medications.

$3B sounds like a lot of money, but when you consider that the efforts above take hundreds to thousands of people over 30[1] years to achieve, it's not alot.

As for the idea that people should or could manufacture or self-administer these drugs safely at home, yeah, that might be the case for a very limited number of people, but I am going to lean on the ghost of George Carlin for that “Think about how stupid the average person is, then realize that half of em’ are stupider than that”.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5707151/

ygjb··on Uncensor any LLM with abliteration
Who is being censored if an LLM is not able to generate inferences about a specific topic?

The information the user of the LLM is still available, just not through that particular interface. The interactions the user of the LLM is seeking are not available, but that interaction is not an original thought or idea of the user, since they are asking the LLM to infer or synthesize new content.

> How did a society that was established on free-speech just decided that the written word was so dangerous all of a sudden?

The written word has absolutely always been dangerous. This idea is captured succinctly in the expression "The pen is mightier than the sword."; ideas are dangerous to those with power, that is why freedom of expression is so important.

> The disdain one must have for free-speech to even think that danger enters into the equation.

This is asinine. You want dangerous text? Here is a fill in the blanks that someone can complete. f"I will pay ${amount} for {illegal_job} to do {illegal_thing} to {targeted_group} by or on {date} at {location}." Turning that into an actual sentence, with intent behind it would be a crime in many jurisdictions, and that is one of the most simple, contrived examples.

Speech, especially inciting speech, is a form of violence, and it runs head long into freedom of speech or freedom of expression, but it's important to for societies to find ways to hold the demagogues that rile people into harmful action accountable.

ygjb··on Uncensor any LLM with abliteration
> This is the standard 'just start your own microservice/server/isp' and now it includes llm. Where does it end really?

With people who aren't good enough to build it own pissing and moaning about it? >The generic point is that it shouldn't take more work. A knife shouldn't come with a safety mechanism that automatically detects you are not actually cutting porkchop. It is just bad design and a bad idea. It undermines what it means to be a conscious human being.

First, you are comparing rockets to rocks here. A knife is a primitive tool, literally one of the most basic we can make (like seriously, take a knapping class, it's really fun!). To make a knife you can range from finding two rocks and smacking them together, to the most advanced metallurgy and ceramics. To date, the only folks able to make LLMs work are those operating at the peak of (more or less) 80 centuries of scientific and industrial development. Little bit of a gap there.

Second, there are many knife manufacturers that refuse to sell or ship products to specific businesses or regions, for a range of reasons related to brand relationships, political beliefs, and export restrictions.

Third, knifes aren't smart; there is already an industry for smart guns, and if there is a credible safety reason to make a smart knife that includes a target control or activation control system, you can bet that it will be implemented somewhere.

Finally, you make the assumption that I believe humans must be kept under close scrutiny because I agree with LLM safety controls. That is absolutely not the case - I just don't believe that a bunch of hot garbage people (in this case the racists and bigots who want to use LLMs to proliferate hate, people who create deep fakes of kids and celebrities) or a bunch of horny folks (ranging from people who want sexy time chat bots to, or just 'normal' generated erotic content) should be able to compel individuals or businesses to release the tools to do that.

You are concerned about freedom of expression, and I am concerned about freedom from compulsion (since I have already stated that I don't believe that losing access to LLMs breaks freedom of expression).

ygjb··on Uncensor any LLM with abliteration
> Societies that value freedom of speech and thought shouldn't be like this.

There is nothing preventing an individual using a computer to generate hateful content, this is absolutely evidenced by the absolute glut of hateful content on the internet.

My freedom of movement is not practically limited by the fact that if my car breaks down, I don't have the knowledge or tools to repair my car effectively - I still have two feet and a heartbeat, and it might take longer to get there, but I can go where I want (modulo private property and national borders).

Societies that value freedom of speech and thought should also be equally opposed to compelled speech, while model censorship is frustrating and challenging to work with, expecting to, or forcing a researcher, or a business to publish uncensored models is a form of compelled speech.

There is absolutely nothing stopping a reasonably competent technologist from implementing simple models, and the only thing stopping a reasonably competent technologist from building an LLM is financial resources. There is a broad set of resources to learn how to train and use models, and while an individual researcher may be challenged to product the next model competitive with current OpenAI, Anthropic, or other models, that is again a resource issue. If your complaint is that resource issues are holding people back, I may want you to expand on your critique of capitalism in general :P

> This is good advice, given in bad faith. Even should the physical hardware be available to do that for any given person, the know-how's hard to come by.

It's absolutely not a bad faith argument. The know-how is hard to come by has been a compelling competitive advantage since the first proto-guilds sought to protect their skills and income in Mesopotamia (and probably before that, but they hadn't figured out a durable means of writing yet). In the modern parlance if someone can't Git Gud, that's not any researchers, or any businesses problem in terms of access to uncensored models.

Yeah, regulation is probably coming, but unless you're argument is that models are entities entitled to free speech, no ones freedom of expression is actually inhibited by not having access to tools to use generative AI technologies to generate content. People who can't create or jailbreak their own models to do it for them are still free to write their own manifestos, or make adult collages of the object of their fantasies. It just takes a bit more work.

ygjb··on Uncensor any LLM with abliteration
If your implication is that as a tool, LLMs shouldn't have safeties built in that is a pretty asinine take. We build and invest in safety in tools across every spectrum. In tech we focus on memory safety (among a host of other things) to make systems safe and secure to use. In automobiles we include seat belts, crumble zones, and governors to limit speed.

We put age and content restrictions on a variety media and resources, even if they are generally relaxed when it comes to factual or reference content (in some jurisdictions). We even include safety mechanisms in devices for which the only purpose is to cause harm, for example, firearms.

Yes, we are still figuring out what the right balance of safety mechanisms is for LLMs, and right now safety is a place holder for "don't get sued or piss off our business partners" in most corporate speak, but that doesn't undermine the legitimacy of the need for safety.

If you want a tool without a specific safety measure, then learn how to build them. It's not that hard, but it is expensive, but I kind of like the fact that there is at least a nominal attempt to make it harder to use advanced tools to harm oneself or others.

ygjb··on Launch HN: Overwatch (YC S22): OSINT platform for cyber and fraud risk
Meh. That is just the Blizzard trademark; there are several other Overwatch trademarks that are military and security related that are probably a more likely overlap.

Definitely something to consider, but more in the "send a note to a trademark lawyer and marketing folks" than "rename our entire product and brand".

ygjb··on Firefox 127
There is an article linked in the release notes that allows users to opt-in to a less secure option.

https://blog.mozilla.org/security/2024/06/05/firefox-will-up...

ygjb··on Google releases smart watch for kids
IDK, showed it to my 12 and 15 year old. It's a bit too "little kid" for them, but both of them would have liked it when they were younger.

You call it bullshit, but maybe you just aren't the target market?

ygjb··on Project Gameface launches on Android
Kill it? It's a local app, with the model included, and Apache 2.0 license. It might bit-rot, but you could fork and maintain it if you want to.
ygjb··on Project Gameface launches on Android
The model runs locally on device, you can find the mediapipe model in the repo.
ygjb··on Dear Europe, please wake up
It's amusing that you used Uber as an example as Bolt is a direct competitor to Uber that is founded and operated in Estonia, but other than that, your purported advantage is pretty meager.

Assuming you build a product custom tailored to Estonia's unique regulatory requirements that is targeting primarily business users, then you are targeting a maximum market of 324,000 businesses. It's realistic to assume, given Estonia's population of 1.32M people, that most of those businesses are sole proprietorships or small businesses that will not have any IT or service department to support them. Building a successful, competitive product in this fashion requires protectionist policies that favor a local product, and those policies will often run afoul of public tendering rules. At least with Germany, you are dealing with a much larger scale (~84M people, and ~5.3M businesses).

It is certainly possible to build and operate a service that would target Estonian, or other small countries, specific regulatory requirements, but the size of the potential market is extremely small, and the path forward to build a competitive service is to abstract away Estonia specific regulations so that you can build country/regional specific versions.

All that said, assuming you are successful in building a business that accomplishes an "X" product for "Y" market model, the entire success of the business is predicated on a market that is created by differentiation in regulation, and your product benefits from lobbying for eliminating those differentiation.

Optimizing for small, local markets is definitely a path to success for some businesses but it's not an easy one, and it doesn't seem like a reasonable investment for growth oriented startups that seek to compete in a global marketplace.

ygjb··on Influential women's tech network shuts down unexpectedly
shrug

Depends on which country and state you are in. It also depends on the history of the company you work for, the reputation and history as presented by women working in your organization (present and past).

People talk, and if your company is known in public or private discussion groups as hostile to people, or advertises itself with a laundry list of red flag terms, you might not have much luck recruiting women.

The great thing is that there are lots of resources for companies who want to change the culture at their company and who can work to make your company more attractive to women and other under-represented communities!

← PreviousPage 8 of 24Next →