HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ygjb

2,393 karma · joined September 8, 2011

Yvan Boily Founding Security Engineer Co-founder, Oghmere parentsguidetoai.ca https://nimblemyth.ca
submissionscomments
ygjb··on Influential women's tech network shuts down unexpectedly
> How about a promoting vision of tech where people who can actually code well instead of virtue signal are promoted, whether they be male or female, instead of promoting this intersectional garbage?

I don't know, it probably has something to do with the fact that, despite a rich history of successful women in the industry, they are notoriously under-represented in leadership roles, continue to be passed over for promotion, and face cultural challenges all over the world. But don't take my word for it, go educate yourself?

ygjb··on VASA-1: Lifelike audio-driven talking faces generated in real time
yeah, teeth, tongue movement and lack of tongue shape and the "stretching" of the skin around the cheeks in the images pushed the videos right into the uncanny valley for me.
ygjb··on Inside Amazon’s Secret Operation to Gather Intel on Rivals
It goes further than "not unheard of". Clean room design (one team reverse engineers a product, then writes product specifications, then a new team implements a compatible product) is an established business practice to replicate a product while avoiding liability for copyright infringement.
ygjb··on How to stop losing 17,500 kidneys
Because when you remove the financial incentive that leads to outright exploitation, there still remains the case where self-harm can be a moral action.

Donating a kidney, for example, or bone marrow, is harmful to the donor, but the trade-off is that it may save the life of another person. People make trade-offs that result in self-harm as part of a moral decision all the time. Firefighters are a great example of this.

We (humans and societies in general, because this comment applies to all societies) generally block or allow moral and immoral activity based on the ability of those with power to regulate things. Some things are simple, like murder - generally, killing people is considered immoral, but even then, there is flexibility (for example, measures taken to stop an attacker from causing harm). Some things like organ donation are considered moral complex, and demand extra focus to prevent exploitation.

ygjb··on How to stop losing 17,500 kidneys
I think that any country that wants to consider legalizing the sale of body parts from living people should probably illustrate how they have effectively eliminated human trafficking for other forms of exploitation first.

Generally speaking, it is not a moral act to reward people for harming themselves, or allowing themselves to be harmed. Most society overlook this in the name of sport, or in the name of freedom (e.g. drugs, alcohol, driving, and other massively harmful, but shockingly profitable ventures), but the balance of respecting freedom while preventing exploitation is generally a complete shit show as evidenced by the rampant human trafficking, and the ongoing exploitation of addiction that the illicit drug trade represents.

The moral arguments also set aside the fact that the overall quality of "ethically sold" organs are likely to be lower due to the overall impact that a life of poverty on individual health has, and that selling an organ is most likely going to be an option of last resort for most people.

Personally profiting from an act of self harm doesn't stop it being an act of predation or exploitation.

ygjb··on The legal rule that computers are presumed to be operating correctly (2022) [pdf]
We are paid exorbitantly to work hard to maintain the illusion that the computers are operating correctly.

Any reasonably competent software developer or engineer should know that just because the customer dashboard is green and everything is working as expected doesn't mean that there isn't an absolute dumpster fire raging in the background (at least, having worked in tech for 20 years across many different verticals, that has been my experience).

ygjb··on Llm.c – LLM training in simple, pure C/CUDA
If you are starting from scratch?

https://karpathy.ai/zero-to-hero.html

Do those, then come back to this and it will make more sense.

ygjb··on Ask HN: How does my new ISP "leak" my geolocation?
Note that this may not, and probably does not include customer location data in most jurisdictions. They sell the locations of the equipment they own, which more or less effectively correlate with customer location as I described in my previous comment.
ygjb··on Ask HN: How does my new ISP "leak" my geolocation?
ISPs routinely sell/share geolocation data for fixed infrastructure; there are many factors that could impact why this is more accurate.

In a sparesly populated area, using microwave, point-to-point radios? You very well may be the only subscriber on that first hop from your home network, and that first hop is likely in a geolocation database (this is certainly the case for my cousins farm).

In a densely populated area? Like a residential tower with 100 units? Your next hop off your home network might be on-prem equipment from your ISP that resides in the telecoms closet in your building, which is also in a geolocation database.

There is a broad spectrum of accuracy between these, and it's big business to effectively geolocate users, mostly for advertising, sometimes for compliance, and generally not to the benefit of users :P

ygjb··on U.S. sues Apple, accusing it of maintaining an iPhone monopoly
Sure, I consider calling users lazy and incompetent very hostile because I have spent nearly 22 years building, testing and securing systems starting with ecommerce apps in the early 2000s, through government, finance, browsers and supporting services (Mozilla), internet scale infrastructure at OpenDNS, Cisco, And Fastly, and now at Amazon.

All along the way people routinely attack users for making poor decisions when they are simply using defaults, or the easiest to use and most compatible technologies.

* Pffft... Of course they got hacked, they used IE * Of course they got hacked, they opened an email attachment * Of course they got hacked, they clicked that homoglyph

In this particular case, SMS and MMS are baked into the phone, and delivered by the wireless provider, and for better or worse on the UX front, work with just a phone number and across all mobile OS. For anything other than that, if users have peers using other device or services, the alternative is to use multiple services to communicate with different groups based on which services they use. That means repeating messages across multiple providers, and/or missing folks because all the platform services have actively silo'd their platforms to prevent interoperability.

Yeah, SMS and MMS suck, but they suck less for the simple use case of messaging folks with cell phones, because the barrier to messaging those folks is having their phone number.

It's lazy and incompetent to attack users when users actually have very little control over the actual security or usability of the services and systems they use, especially as everything is hosted in cloud platforms.

ygjb··on U.S. sues Apple, accusing it of maintaining an iPhone monopoly
That is a shockingly user hostile take, especially considering you call out the reason why so many people still use it: it is the only solution for most users that consistently works.

The main reason people still use it is despite the issues with MMS (and SMS in general) the reality is that every vendor wants to own the messaging stack to build or strengthen moat, and the regulators who are in a position to enforce standard protocols have incentives in many or all countries to weaken the security of messaging protocols to meet surveillance objectives (whether those objectives are well scrutinized methods with judicial oversight, or blanket surveillance requirements).

Blaming the user as lazy or incompetent completely overlooks the significant financial incentives that platform owners and network providers have to maintain the status quo, or force the new status quo to strengthen their moats.

ygjb··on Epic says Apple will reinstate developer account
Ideally, as a consumer, in a market where commodity computer hardware is not arbitrarily restricted to extract the maximum attainable profit from consumers? It has been shown time and again that both volunteers and competitors can quickly and easily build and ship software, including entire OS's that run on the hardware, the only thing preventing them from doing so is anti-consumer and anti-competitive controls.

It's asinine that I, as a consumer, can pay over $1000 for a device and not be able to choose which software I can run on it because the developer of that device locks out access. It's even worse that the company I bought it from can arbitrarily disable the device, features, and services that I have paid for, and I have little to no recourse.

ygjb··on Inflection-2.5: meet the best personal AI
They are not being censored. I just think they suck and, imho are need of a rough education of why we got rid of Nazis a long time ago.

What exactly are you complaining about?

ygjb··on Inflection-2.5: meet the best personal AI
There is nothing stopping someone from training and using a model that impersonates whichever historical person you want it to impersonate - except for resources and skill.

That is always the huge differentiator in the availability of tech without guardrails. Do you want a reasonably priced thing? Accept the limitations of it and the fact that it will meet safety standards (whatever those might be). Don't like the limitations? Build your own. Too hard, or too expensive? shrug wait until the price comes down, or it becomes fully commodotized.

ygjb··on Inflection-2.5: meet the best personal AI
No one is stopping you from making your own decision. The only roadblock is that you need the resources and skills to train your own model.

If you lack either the resources, or the skills, you are absolutely entitled to complain about the lack of availability, but there should be no expectation that some other individual or business should bear the public relations, social, or real financial cost of building a tool to satisfy whatever interests you might have in using an uncensored AI.

The fact that one of the few businesses willing to do it is Gab says a great deal about the primary reasons folks want these.

ygjb··on Cloudflare Announces Firewall for AI
Aside from conventional rate limiting and bot protection technologies, how would you propose protecting a site from being scraped for a specific purpose through technology?

I would argue that there isn't an effective technology to prevent scraping for AI training, only legal measures such as a EULA or TOS that forbids that use case, or offensive technology like Nightshade that implement data poisoning to negatively impact the training stage; those tools wouldn't prevent scraping though.

ygjb··on To Lose Weight, Eating Less Is Far More Important Than Exercising More (2015)
I don't usually do 100g portions for these, but below are some recipes that are super easy and delicious. I make each of these quite regularly, and make it a few times and you will be able to eyeball it so you don't have to precisely measure all the time.

1. 400g Carrots (full size peeled, or "baby carrots") tossed with 1tsp olive oil and black pepper, then roasted at 425F for 20 minutes is approximately two 100 calorie servings.

2. 400g Butternut squash (i use frozen - but thawed before roasting, so less of a PITA to prep) tossed with 1tsp olive oil, and 1 tsp of taco seasoning (store bought or home made). 425 for 20 minutes. Again, 2 servings of ~100 calories.

3. 400g of cauliflower tossed with 2 tsp of olive oil, 1/2 tsp of turmeric, 1/2 tsp of cumin. 425 for 1 hour, again, 2 servings of ~100 calories

4. 4 cups of cherry tomatoes (~100 calories), 2 English cucumbers (~80 calories), 200g of chickpeas (~320 calories), 1/2 tbsp olive oil (120 calories), 1 tbsp balsamic vinegar (14 calories), 6 servings of ~100 calories

5. 50g of sun-dried tomatoes (cut in strips), 100g of oil packed roasted red peppers (cut in strips, drained), medium avocado (cut into cubes), 50g of dried, unsweetened mango (diced) - 5 servings of ~110 calories)

ygjb··on Netlify just sent me a $104k bill for a simple static site
That's a level of responsiveness that doesn't exist for the vast majority of organizations.

If your customer is aware enough to notice they are being hit with a DOS or legit traffic while it is happening, then great! They can respond, and if needed, engage proserve to get support for scaling or defense depending on needs.

If your customer is not alert enough, then their site is offline, and they won't hear about it until their customers are screaming at them, which will result in a P1 ticket to look at a vendor who won't turn them off during an unexpected peak.

It's a catch 22, and if you have to choose between: a) a PR hit because you have to go on a forum and post about waiving the fee, or b) a PR hit because someone posted a blog post about how you killed their site during a moment of critical growth

any reasonable business will choose A every time because A is far more supportive of customer growth and has drastically better optics. Anyone who thinks A is worse is probably too inexperienced to have an opinion.

ygjb··on Court blocks $1B copyright ruling that punished ISP for its users' piracy
Why was it unethical? Did the activity violate the contract?
ygjb··on This is how cargo ships fight pirates without guns [video]
Well yeah, but that is not a new problem either. Piracy is a profession as old as sailing, and frankly has always been tolerated by states (piracy against our enemies? ok, don't bug us, pay your taxes, and we will ignore you), if not outright sponsored (privateers)

There is modern data on this, recorded history, and ancient literature going back to ancient greece (and in other societies) that cover this very well.

You can't eliminate piracy with violence under these circumstances, you need to make it too costly or too risky to undertake. As shown by the attack on the Israeli vessel, you also can't eliminate the threat posed by well funded, competent adversaries that are highly motivated.

ygjb··on This is how cargo ships fight pirates without guns [video]
I wonder why that solution hasn't solved piracy (or any other form of violent theft) in the history of humanity.

It's literally an arms race, and non-combat measures reduce the risk of loss of life, cargo, and vessels, which makes them much more economical than trying to train and arm crews.

Plain old escalation may work (modulo combat effectiveness of crew members) on an individual case, but there will always be more pirates, especially in the most desperate parts of the world.

ygjb··on Google slips as OpenAI said to be working on search product: report
There is a big difference between "logged out" and "private mode" - paid VPN services offer privacy by (purportedly) not tracking or logging traffic from their users. They still get paid using traceable payments systems.
ygjb··on Watching Ads on Amazon Prime Video Is a Deal Breaker for Some
https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/entertainment/prime-video-u...
ygjb··on Right to Repair: The Price Is Not Right
Not just closing the loopholes; specifically imposing consumer awardable penalties for failing to support a product - something like treble damages for willful infringement should do the trick.

Can't provide a part within a specific time frame at maximum cost of the appropriate fraction of the price, for a defined period of time after the product is sold? Great, the consumer is awarded an amount equal to 3 times the MSRP at product release to ensure they can acquire a replacement product!

ygjb··on NASA loses contact with Ingenuity Mars helicopter
Meh. I don't think your position makes sense.

Your assessment of the estimates is basically MBA talk.

They designed the helicopter for 5 flights. It is very likely the case that the requirements that a rotary wing aircraft can operate for 5 flights with minimal operator intervention, and only between missions, resulted in an helicopter that had a longer lifespan. Could they have done it cheaper? Maybe, probably, but most likely with a much higher risk of failure, and given the time, distance, and cost, and the organization doing the work, I am pretty confident that the team made the right choice.

ygjb··on Changes we're making to Google Assistant
The problem is that the current crop of google assistant devices (excluding current and upcoming gen cell phones) are woefully underpowered for local models, meaning that supporting the existing install base will be expensive.

I expect that a new assistant like product (Google Bard Home or something) will be announced and existing Assistant/Home devices will be deprecated.

ygjb··on Ask HN: Is there a global site rank API (like the old Alexa)?
It's not web specific, but when Alexa changed the pricing on the list, our team pushed for Cisco Umbrella to publish the top 1M domains here https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/umbrella-static/index.htm... - I don't know any details about how this is currently maintained as I left Cisco/OpenDNS about 3 months after this started!
ygjb··on Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use with LTE phones
I agree with you, with one proviso. I hope there is a proliferation of camp grounds and sites with rules forbidding things like projectors and speakers over a certain volume level.

The number of projectors I have seen in use at campgrounds in the last couple of years is just profoundly irritating.

ygjb··on NFTs died a slow, painful death in 2023 as most are now worthless
BTC ATMs are still wildly popular with scammers.
ygjb··on Meta's news ban in Canada remains as Online News Act goes into effect
Yep, except when was the last time the prime minister of Canada wasn't the party leader of the party invited to form a government after a federal election?

Saying that Pierre Poilievre isn't the CPC front runner when polling indicates that the LPC is down in the polls, and we have an as yet undeclared election coming up is disingenuous.

No, Canadians don't elect the Prime Minister, and yes it is most likely that one of Trudeau or Poilievre will form a government after the next election, unless Trudeau steps down before or during the campaign starts.

← PreviousPage 9 of 24Next →