HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ygjb

2,393 karma · joined September 8, 2011

Yvan Boily Founding Security Engineer Co-founder, Oghmere parentsguidetoai.ca https://nimblemyth.ca
submissionscomments
ygjb··on Meta's news ban in Canada remains as Online News Act goes into effect
> My fellow Canadians need to feel the impact to remind them of how awful this government is.

That is a pretty general blanket statement. I don't agree with alot of the choices the current government has made, but I also don't believe there is an effective, credible alternative in Canada at the moment. The current front-runner's biggest claim to fame is that he is the last sock-puppet standing from the previous Harper administration, and has not yet released a substantial platform or initiative that should galvanize people besides "Trudeau bad" and "wokeness bad".

ygjb··on Meta's news ban in Canada remains as Online News Act goes into effect
I don't know the solution, but if there was going to be a committee formed to evaluate acceptable media organizations, I don't think the committee should be staffed by the government - there should be an appointed ombudsman who has responsibility for transparency, and it should be radically open.

Beyond that, I would assume that there should be a method of identifying people who have actually studied journalism and it's role in society, for example, with a masters or doctorate in journalism and who have been actively engaged in the industry should be suitable.

ygjb··on Meta's news ban in Canada remains as Online News Act goes into effect
I think there are trade-offs. Small local media is vitally important, but the problem implicit there is that biasing towards small, local media also means diverting funding to small teams that may or may not be high quality. For every Indiegraf, Tyee, or even small town papers like the Flin Flon Reminder, there is a Rebel Media that is just a microcosm of everything wrong with the media.
ygjb··on Law enforcement took more stuff from people than burglars did last year (2015)
Ending Civil Asset Forfeiture is an absolute mess for legislators because while it makes sense to end it based on past abuses, the reality is that it is a political grenade. Want to end CAF? Why are you soft on crime? Why are you supporting criminal activity? Why do you want law abiding citizens to pay higher taxes to offset the revenue lost from CAF?

It really does seem to be a thing that is best handled by a ballot measure or referendum.

ygjb··on Animate Anyone: Image-to-video synthesis for character animation
Text to movement is highly desirable. There is a long way to go before tools like this are used in AAA games, and blockbuster films, but as much money as is tied up in those areas, even more is tied up in advertising and lower tier content production pipelines.

Look at tools like Adobe Animate and Character Animator, these tools are absolutely capable of doing interpolation between frames while giving the person operating the tools a fine degree of control. When you can use text to movement to quickly create tens or hundreds of sample scenes quickly, then manually iterate on and edit them, instead of hand drawing and compositing, the value proposition is pretty crazy for time and budget constrained production where tradeoffs on quality and fidelity are acceptable.

ygjb··on The Seamless Communication models
These are models specially tuned and sized for near real-time, instant translation. It would be naive to think that there aren't technical creatives building and training models tuned for expressiveness and nuance in a more controlled environment.
ygjb··on Reasonable expectation of effectiveness for large dog lifespan extension
Because of the long history of snake-oil salescreeps, and the ongoing degree of utter bullshit of people selling crystals, essential oils, and other shams to separate desperate and hopeful people from their money?

Regulators and regulations have problems, but the entire reason we have them is due to unregulated corruption that caused massive harm before the regulators were created.

ygjb··on OpenAI approached Anthropic about merger
First time having the curtain pulled back?
ygjb··on Moving from AWS to Bare-Metal saved us $230k per year
I mean, aside from my current role in Amazon, my last several roles have been at Mozilla, OpenDNS/Cisco, and Fastly; each of those used a combination of cloud, colo and on-prem services, depending on use cases. All of them worked at scale.

I specifically said "if it is designed well", and that phrase does alot of heavy lifting in that sentence. It's not easy, and you don't always put your A-team on a project when the B or C team can get the job done.

The article outlines a case where a business saw a solid justification for moving to bare metal, and saved approximately 1-3 SDE (depending on market) salary in doing so.

That amount of money can be hugely meaningful in a bootstrapped business (for example, for one of the businesses my partner owns, saving that much money over COVID shut-downs meant keeping the business afloat rather than shuttering the business permanently).

ygjb··on Moving from AWS to Bare-Metal saved us $230k per year
Yeah, that's part of it. The other part is that you can move stuff that is working, and working well, into on-prem (or colo) if it is designed well and portable. If everything is running in containers, and orchestration is already configured, and you aren't using AWS or cloud provider specific features, portability is not super painful (modulo the complexity of your app, and the volume of data you need to migrate). Clearly this team did the assessment, and the savings they achieved by moving to on-prem was worthwhile.

That doesn't preclude continuing to use AWS and other cloud service as a click-ops driven platform for experimentation, and requiring that anything that is targeting production to refactored to run in the bare-metal environment. At least two shops I worked at previously have used that as a recurring model (one focusing on AWS, the other on GCP) for stuff that was in prototyping or development.

ygjb··on A failed AI girlfriend product, and my lessons
> LLM's like GPT are just predicting the next token in a sequence of tokens. It's not magic. It's still just a computer program.

Frankly, that approach is problematic, since any computer software that might achieve consciousness or self-awareness, and should be accorded rights, could have their rights dismissed using the argument "it's just a computer program".

I know they are probably a long way off, but AGI, and other adjacent or related technologies, such as a human to machine copy of a consciousness are explicitly stated goals of both businesses and extremely wealthy tech oligarchs that will have fundamental rights issues attached. We are bad enough at recognizing those rights in humans, in most of the world that we shouldn't wait until abuses start piling up to consider them.

ygjb··on Is AI the next crypto? Insights from HN comments
The forms, delays, and fees are because what those financial institutions are doing is providing checks and balances, and de-risking, to the extent they can, performing that transfer.

The forms are for KYC activity, and agreements on what the limitations of liability are. The delays are to validate that the transfers are handled and secured, and ideally can't be charged back. The fees are to cover the costs of the people who do the work for that.

It's not perfect, but it's quite a bit better than the checks and balances that exist for folks who get hit by a scam and are convinced to go to a crypto kiosk and pay a scammer because they have been frightened by a threat to a loved one, or are taken in by a scammer about services being cut off, or desperately paying off a ransomware demand in the hopes that your business or personal records won't be leaked or published.

ygjb··on Open source is struggling and it's not big tech that is to blame
> For many people out there open source is a way to legally pirate stuff.

Huh?

In order to pirate open source products, assuming we are talking about copyright infringement, you have to release derivative products in a way that is not consistent with the licensing requirements.

Unless you are conflating open source code that is intentionally built for interoperable alternatives to commercial or closed products. In which case, that's not piracy, it's competition.

> They would be pirating those tools and libraries if they were commercial.

I think you are deeply confused about the role of open source tools and libraries. There is no shortage of cases where commercial tools have infringed on open source projects. There are also many cases where open source tools have infringed on patents or in some cases infringed on copyright, for example, where open source software is built based on reverse engineered or unlicensed access to source code. The preferred pattern is to have two teams, one responsible for reverse engineering a product and generating a specification, and another, separate team that implements the specification.

That is not piracy, and is a legitimate use of reverse engineering that has been litigated fairly extensively (at least, AFAIK, and IANAL, but I have worked with so, so many of them over the last two decades of my career).

> And on top of that they feel entitled to have their critical bugs fixed right away, again for free.

Well yeah. That's not unique to open source. There is a reason that "karen" as a description of certain behaviors has entered the pop culture lexicon. Hell hath no fury like an inconvenienced user of a free product.

ygjb··on EU data regulator bans personalised advertising on Facebook and Instagram
Are you kidding? Have you seen the way that big tech companies use and abuse the legal system to target people, for example, who come into possession of leaked hardware prototypes?

Where they could manage private licenses to enforce state powers over matters material to their business interests, you can bet they would in a heart beat.

ygjb··on The black market in GitHub stars
Genuinely curious, which jurisdictions is it actually illegal?
ygjb··on Microsoft in talks to sign on Amazon as customer in $1B cloud tools deal
https://www.statista.com/statistics/234488/number-of-amazon-...
ygjb··on Microsoft in talks to sign on Amazon as customer in $1B cloud tools deal
excel isn't just used by finance. I can use any number of command line tools, scripting languages, jupyter notebooks, etc, but sometimes is just faster to throw it in excel, do a little futzing around and send it over to the non-technical folks in a tool they know how to use.
ygjb··on Google Removes the Photo Sphere Mode from the Pixel 8 Camera
Do you switch ecosystems and products each time a new threat actor or malware toolkit shows up?

If your personal threat model warrants it, you might be better off with a feature phone instead - the attack surface on both Android and iOS are enormous.

ygjb··on Researchers tested AI watermarks and broke all of them
You are confusing a digital signature for evidence of anything other than an attestation.

If you create a digital record, then sign it, then that signature is only an attestation of may claim you make, not evidence of that claim. That is the problem with relying on technology to establish trust - the moment you attach an economic benefit to a technology you incentivize people to circumvent it, or to leverage it to commit fraud.

ygjb··on Opinion: The SEC wants to spy on your portfolio
Wealthy people might be held accountable (at least, that is my read on it :P).
ygjb··on I moved states just before the return-to-office order at Amazon, so I quit
Despite several rounds of layoffs and a general economic downturn, companies are still competing hard for talented people.

You know those nightmare hiring scenarios that keep getting posted on social media sites? Where companies ghost people at the offer stage, or retract offers? That's caused by incompetent talent management.

Companies that can't grow an retain talent, and the narrative that you need to job hop to grow in your career? Incompetent talent management.

This article is written from the POV of a person who was dealing with disabilities, and had challenges at work, but was still able to remain at Amazon despite several rounds of layoffs. That is a pretty solid indicator that her leadership team found her to be an effective employee.

It may not buy into the lean startup ethos, but contrary to popular belief, HR does a lot more than hiring & firing, and covering the companies butt on policy issues.

ygjb··on ‘Less than half’ fresh produce sold globally makes any profit
That's the point. As consumers we pay the cost of logistics and service, but we also pay for the waste. We aren't paying the cost of a head of lettuce, we are paying the cost of a head of lettuce, plus a fractional cost of waste produce. From an economic perspective we are paying for the risk the retailer takes in bringing a product with a short shelf life to market.

Grocers offset some of this risk by processing some of the food onsite, selling precooked meals, premade salads, etc.

If it was more profitable to further reduce costs, then they would, but there are diminishing returns on end of the line food processing, since the kitchens and packaging required are generalized for a broad range of foods instead of being a specialized operation that is more efficient.

It sucks, but it's the system that capital built, and pretty much the only thing we can do if we don't like it is to focus on buying local, or electing politicians who will target food waste as a policy.

ygjb··on Re-logic gives $100k to Godot and FNA
There will always be people who make those choices, but the majority of players don't shop on engine.
ygjb··on Chromebooks will get 10 years of automatic updates
ChromeOS and Google are super creepy because of how data hungry they are. That said, one of the advantages is that if they have committed to a 10 year lifecycle, and they have a new feature that is awful on an older device for performance reasons, they have an incentive to implement a feature that executes that slow function using cloud compute resources when the device is connected to maintain their lock on customers.

It really depends on how Google assesses the value prop of supporting older devices.

ygjb··on Launch HN: HyLight (YC S23) – Hydrogen airships to inspect energy infrastructure
The implication is that it's not a federal felony to fire a weapon at a flying aircraft? I know that there are different laws in different countries, but I can't imagine that would be legal, even in the United States!

Unfortunately it is also exceedingly likely that the folks who shoot at road signs as their particular outrage against government are most likely to think that surveillance drones are there to spy on them, and not inspect infrastructure. I don't think regulations or laws matter to those folks.

ygjb··on Ancient fires drove large mammals extinct, study suggests
Because rising sea levels doesn't get clicks anymore, but if you read actual literature on the topic, there are ongoing concerns and considerations. On a more practical level, it's not a major North American or European city, so it doesn't capture Western media's attention, but the Republic of Kiribati[1] has an estimated <80 years before it's primary land masses are completely submerged, with some being lost nearly 20 years ago.

Kiribati is a canary in a coal mine for climate change related activity in coastal regions. The government of that nation has very progressively purchased land in Fiji, and presumably in other places to aid with resettlement efforts. There have been legal tests (and denials of claims) for at least one person claiming to be a climate refugee from Kiribati. Even before the sea levels rise, the arable land and liveable areas will be wiped out.

This isn't theoretical, it just isn't directly affecting (yet) the exceedingly wealthy, major western cities, or white folks, so it doesn't get as much press.

Some other areas that are starting to recognize the impacts of rising sea levels include Kolkata, Guangzhou, Miami, New York, and more directly personally affecting me, Vancouver! Unfortunately the main point of recognition is that significant portions of these cities will be below sea level at some point in the next century, barring solutions like seawalls, and other methods to try to save them. It's been almost 20 years since the levees failed in NOLA, but it hasn't stopped people thinking we can hold back the ocean. Things are going to be crazy in the next couple of decades.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kiribati

ygjb··on 2024 Defense Bill Threatens Future of 3D-Printed Firearms and Basic Gun Rights
The comment I replied to dismissed another users comment as politically motivated with a call to "do better"; I made the essentially the same argument and at least presented data to back up my argument.

If an opposition to gun control and voicing that opposition is ideological warfare inappropriate for this site, I would expect to see this entire submission flagged.

That said, to bring it into context, HN is a tech focused website; the nature of this regulation is rooted in the fact that there is no practical way to regulate how a 3d-printer might be used, since they are trivial to build using off-the-shelf components and software, in many cases, for a skilled engineer, just using components salvaged from common household electronics and appliances.

This legislation is highly relevant to HN since it exemplifies how such an "unregulatable" technology might be regulated by imposing specific requirements on the outputs of that technology, and explicitly criminalizes the use of that technology to manufacture specific devices. A good example of how this contrasts with other technical regulations and laws, and their impacts on technology, consider modern printers - they are easily capable of scanning and printing at sufficient quality and low cost, paper currency that would pass at least casual inspection by observers, provided you can get the appropriate print medium for the currency in question (for some currencies). In response to this, there are several varieties of regulation that extend deeply into print and scan technologies as part of counterfeit deterrence.

This outcome for the manufacture of firearms is actually more desirable than more intrusive legislation that would mandate that 3d-printer firmware or other fabrication technologies attempt to discern what could be a firearm or munitions component, and refuse to print it. Strictly from a technologist perspective, without ideology, I would support this legislation on that front. In other words, as long as you don't use this tech to do crimes, you are ok. More restrictions on the proliferation of firearms is just a bonus :)

ygjb··on 2024 Defense Bill Threatens Future of 3D-Printed Firearms and Basic Gun Rights
Sure, perhaps I shouldn't have been so figurative. The level of endemic gun violence in the United States is deeply alarming to basically all of it's other peer nations and allies. The fact that the level of gun violence is "on the decline" doesn't change the fact that there is still a shocking amount of gun violence in the United States, or the fact that an increasing number of Americans want restrictions or some form of gun control.
ygjb··on 2024 Defense Bill Threatens Future of 3D-Printed Firearms and Basic Gun Rights
I mean, it's not perfect, but is graded poorly (32%, right, mixed quality, low quality sources, and moderately opinionated) by The Factual using their isthiscredible.com service.

Part of do better should at least be coming with a basis for your argument instead of just pointing at political leanings.

The epidemic of gun violence in the United States is blatantly obvious to every one of its allies, and 2nd Amendment rights one of the major political brain worms that is undermining US standing around the world (and don't get me started on Canadians and UK folks who argue about gun rights trying to use an American framing of the position).

ygjb··on OpenAI acquires Global Illumination
Maybe not, but frequently hiring a team that has accomplished a significant percentage of a goal is a better choice than trying to retask existing folks, or to grow a new product set outside of core competency.
← PreviousPage 10 of 24Next →