4,152 karma · joined January 1, 2016
Nothing like a good ad hominem to prove how right you are.
> Militants and terrorists being captured for specific acts of terrorism or from the battlefield
Yes, thats why they are kept without a trial indefinitely on "Administrative detention". 14 year old terrorists, how dare they throw rocks.
> also fed and get medical treatment
And raped, but hey at least they get fed and treated afterwards.
When Gilad Shalit was taken hostage Operation Summer Rains followed. That was one soldier. You really think if Hamas took hundreds of soldiers hostage, they wouldn't go bomb Gaza?
What might those be? What other types of resistance hasn't already been tried and failed there?
1) As long as Israel treats Palestinians the way they current do, there will always be another Hamas. That or completely remove Palestinians from the area, which seems to be the current goal. So no, completely destroying hamas is not the only way to get to a real permanent peace.
2) How Israel is going about things is the exact issue at hand. You can't just hand wave it away.
3) Let's say for the sake of argument destroying Hamas IS the only way to achieve long lasting peace, how much death and destruction does it justify? 10% of the population? 20%? 50%?. So again just because it's an armed conflict, doesn't mean anything goes.
Putting the debate of who started what aside, does someone starting a war justify war crimes against them?
- who started what
- specific conditions to end things
- who agrees to what
All of these are distractions. The core issues are, are there war crimes being committed or not? Is the population of Gaza starving or not? If so, is Israel actively contributing or deliberately causing the situation or not?
EDIT: this is a good example of how collective punishment is being justified, to blame the population of Gaza for the actions (or inaction) of Hamas. "Well, if they just do X, then they wouldn't have to starve".
um, yes? How many palestinian prisoners are they keeping without a trial?
2. Even if a country's government starts a war, that doesn't not justify war crimes. This is why they're called war crimes.
3. Pointing to what allies did 70+ years ago doesn't mean anything.
For 1 we should be looking at results and the situation on the ground, not the guidelines for what's "the proper way to do things". Were people in Germany starving or not, are people in Gaza starving or not? If the answer to either is yes, then it is / was a problem.
Secondly, what we consider ok changes over time. Go back far enough and killing prisoners, taking civilians as slaves etc were all considered ok. We frown on those now.
Secondarily, just because there was a guideline during WW2 that was deemed "the right way", it's the result that counts. Were people starving in Germany post WW2? If so that was wrong then too.
Are you referring to something like the current private security patrol or an actual police? If it's the former it already is there, if it's the latter I'm not sure how that'd cut down on the amount of bad things police do today.
I don’t hear anyone (well some, but very few and usually not taken seriously) suggest police and fire departments should be for profit, so clearly it’s understood that some services should not be profit driven.
But apparently it’s a huge leap to extend that to healthcare.