HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

yokaze

1,003 karma · joined September 12, 2016

submissionscomments
yokaze··on Linux Networking: MAC VLANs and Virtual Ethernets
So, we are in agreement in that point: if you are going that way, you are relying on the physical switches.

I'm not sure about the problem being solved, depending on the scale.

If you are with your use-case (number of rules, macs, five-tuples, ...) outside the capabilities of the hardware, then, in my experience, it breaks down quickly. (I.e. flooding, or becoming unresponsive to configuration commands and needed to be _power cycled_, ...).

And those are switches costing easily five figures, and from two different well known vendors.

If you have practical experience with a setup, which scales more gracefully, please share.

But I'm sceptical that it exists, considering Google, Facebook, AWS all went with custom hardware.

I'm wondering, if at a certain scale of virtual NICs/flows per port, you are not better off with a hybrid approach, where software is part of a decision hierarchy. E.g Openflow.

No practical experience though.

yokaze··on Linux Networking: MAC VLANs and Virtual Ethernets
In my experience with said expensive hardware, it greatly depends on your use-case / scale.

You have to pay attention to stay within the limits of the hardware the switches (TCAM, etc...). And correct me, if I am wrong, but most NICs are fairly constrained in their hardware support on the numbers of MACs they can filter for. And those two combined, you might end up with a lot of flooding, which needs to be handled by the CPU again.

You also have to rely on the implementation of your vendor. And at least with one major vendor, who shall remain nameless, it is a major effort just to get acknowledged that there is a bug.

yokaze··on Why doesn’t natural immunity count in the US?
With a vaccine, you get a standardised dosis of an agent resembling the disease or just a part of it. The remaining variability is the response to that standardised input.

With an infection, you have no control over the degree of exposure, so on top of the variability of the response comes the variability of the exposure.

Additionally, in case of exposure of the full pathogen, there is some variability to what part of the pathogen the immune system will respond. That part can actually be a good thing in total.

yokaze··on Salesforce Will Help Relocate Employees from Texas After Abortion Law
I think, the main point here is not the delay, but the time you have to take out of your schedule, and you have to explain to your environment (I.e. work, taking care of family members).
yokaze··on Ivermectin for the Treatment of Covid-19: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis
It's not one or the other. Vaccines work great, but the prevention is not 100% effective.

It seems now doubtful, that we can achieve herd immunity, so we still need something to treat people for which the vaccine doesn't work.

I wouldn't hold my breath on ivermectin though either.

yokaze··on Every euro invested in nuclear power makes the climate crisis worse
Because the price of energy generation is only a small part of the cost: https://www.cleanenergywire.org/factsheets/what-german-house...

50% are levies, fees and taxes, which partly pay for the built up of the renewable energy generation.

yokaze··on Notes on Living in Los Angeles
I can't speak about Bangkok, or Chicago.

On Tokyo, Barcelona, and to a lesser extend LA, SF, I feel more confident to say something.

It is greatly a question what you are looking for, and the author quite apparently appreciates the variety.

And I have to give it to them, I do not think that Tokyo or Barcelona are in the same league there.

That is not to disparage the quality of the food. I hold Tokyo in high regard, and would say it is the place I would most likely feel confident to go to a blindly chosen random Japanese restaurant. In Barcelona, you already have to filter out the tourist traps. (Hint: Paella & Sangria)

But in both places, it felt to me more dicey if would like some non-local food. It always seemed to be heavily adopted to the local preferences. But maybe my experience is outdated.

My armchair theory is, that both cities "suffer" from the fact of having a great culture of own cuisine. Not sure, if their customers do not appreciate the otherness, or the cooks are preemptively trying to "fit in".

As the author writes, LA is a melting pot, and I have eaten there great food from all over the place, especially when the menu was only half-translated. But then, it may be a prejudice, I am less confident that I can pick a random place, and receive the same quality as in Tokyo.

yokaze··on 5G and Beyond for Contact Tracing
That's very general and generally known (at least in this community). How do you see that not addressed in the article? which means are you missing?
yokaze··on 5G and Beyond for Contact Tracing
Not sure, if you are trolling, but assuming good faith: That's not what privacy means. That's secrecy.
yokaze··on 5G and Beyond for Contact Tracing
Care to elaborate?

From your short sentence, I can only guess what you mean, and it is at odds of what I get from the article, which says:

> Privacy is a key requirement of any contact tracing systems

yokaze··on Europe's all-time heat record set in Sicily at nearly 120 degrees
> Global warming is about average temperature increases. Individual one-off high temperatures only gives ammunition to climate deniers when they see a record low temperature somewhere in the world.

That is why it got rebranded to climate change. Yes, it is about the global average temperature, but that is too abstract for people to understand, and exactly gets discussed when "they see a record low temperature somewhere in the world."

> Individual one-off high temperatures only gives ammunition to climate deniers when they see a record low temperature somewhere in the world.

Everything and anything gives climate change deniers ammunition. I think, it doesn't make sense to try to placate people, which are essentially inaccessible to decades of scientific reports, and more and more news like this one. No need to self-censure here.

> It does more harm than good to raise the climate change alarm for these events, and requires some statistical gymnastics to conclusively tie it to global warming

You do not have to conclusively tie individual events to global warming. The point here is, that those news come in more and more often. It is something people directly experience. And that is very much a real alarm.

yokaze··on Long-term studies of Covid vaccines hurt by placebo recipients getting immunized
To add to that: Gibraltar isn't isolated, but has a lot of people coming and going from neighbouring Spain. Vaccination rate raising, but still far from 99%
yokaze··on Measuring Mutexes, Spinlocks and How Bad the Linux Scheduler Is
(2019) and the discussion from the first post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21919988
yokaze··on How AstraZeneca threw away its shot
The next sentence right after the one you chose to quote in your last paragraph: "This is close to 8%. However this number shouldn’t be taken at face value."

Why? TLDR: Too small group and too few cases in groups (one each) to be statistical significant.

yokaze··on Australia: 82K tests, 111 cases, 1 death, 900.000 people locked down
Yeah, it is odd how those discussions always seem to frame it as disproportionate.

The alternative has been exemplified in Europe, you can wait longer to have more cases and deaths, and a longer lock-down to get out of the mess.

yokaze··on Are there flaws in some ARM64 instructions?
> What are the applications where someone would require floating point math AND both extreme speed and extreme accuracy?

Scientific computation.

I'm not even sure, it is a trade-off between (computational) speed and accuracy.

In my experience, error-analysis was a mandatory course for physics, but not in robotics. The error analysis was manual and time-consuming.

In robotics, no one cared why it occasionally produced NaNs, etc.. people just added a small number here and there.

That's faster to program.

To put it more positively, I think, the view here is more having an application, which is robust in the face of errors / edge cases. What counts is the output (action).

While in science the correct model is part of the output. Edge cases are an important part of it.

yokaze··on EU draft exempts private jets, cargo from jet fuel tax
I would say the main deciding factor for that was the rejection of the Treaty for Establishing a Constitution for Europe (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_establishing_a_Constitu...), which would have given the European Parliament far more power, in plebiscites in Belgium and France, causing other countries to bail on theirs.
yokaze··on U.S. to add ‘X’ gender marker on passports
The X comes from a pre-existing standard from the ICAO, which gives the options F,M,X. X standing for unspecified.
yokaze··on Jeff Bezos: Work-Life Balance Is 'Debilitating Phrase'
I would say, almost the opposite: It is much easier if you essentially do not have to work anymore and you can do it just for the kick of it. Like starting a space race.
yokaze··on EU startup fund overwhelmed by high demand
> Companies can't use equity as compensation (which is a big lure for talent)

What? Where do you get that? Then I better return all the equity I got.

> and it's extremely hard to fire people

I would say that is hyperbolic, unless you find anything but at-will employment "extremely hard". Small companies (<20?) in Germany, can fire people without reason. I do not know any country (Edit: in the EU), where restructuring is not a valid reason to fire someone (with a severance of 0.5-1.1 monthly salaries per year of employment).

(Edit: But then, I cannot claim to know all the labour laws in the EU)

yokaze··on Cuba′s Covid vaccine rivals Pfizer, Moderna
> Ask the many Cubans in exile, how often they have to send life saving medication to their families on the island.

Well, not to excuse the dictatorship in Cuba, but there is the small issue with embargo and trade restrictions the US places on that particular one. Theoretically, medicine is exempt, but in practice it isn't: https://medicc.org/ns/documents/The_impact_of_the_U.S._Embar...

yokaze··on The EU’s disputed system of geographical indications is taking over the planet (2017)
Not quite, as the geographical indication not only only means that it was produced there, but also has other constraints on how it is produced, etc... So it is very much a brand, in the very same meaning, that it doesn't necessarily guarantee quality, but that the brand of the region is a means of ensuring some quality standards.

E.g. there are wines from certain regions, but they do not have the geographic indication, as they have not been produced according to the regional standards.

And going with food it is even more important so, as it is close to impossible to reproduce the climate and terroir somewhere half around the world.

That doesn't mean, that it is worse, just that it is not the same.

Take Lambrusco as an example, they do have (or had?) a bad reputation and suffer for it. It's a good motivation for regional producers to keep each others in check.

yokaze··on Why do recipe writers lie about how long it takes to caramelize onions? (2012)
Here you go: https://www.thespruceeats.com/how-to-brown-onions-913397

There is browning and there is caramelisation.

yokaze··on What's Inside the EU Green Pass QR Code?
Reflecting on it, it doesn't solve anything, as I still have to give my name and date-of-birth to the person validating it anyway.

Otherwise, there is a large degree of normalisation in the id documents in the EU, and you could simply hash each variation.

yokaze··on What's Inside the EU Green Pass QR Code?
It is the same way necessary as having your passwords stored in plain-text to verify your password.

Name and DOB could be hashed and compared to the hash inside the QR code.

yokaze··on Wuhan Lab Leak Theory
That sounds reasonable if you ignore priors...

The location of the lab was not chosen arbitrarily either.

https://angry-chef.com/blog/do-hares-lay-eggs

yokaze··on North Carolina tells retired engineer he can't talk about engineering
You can read the letter linked in the article: https://ij.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/NC_Engineering_051...

It looks to me more the latter: he "helping his son" by "speaking about engineering" is a written report in a court case.

Quite a bit of framing

yokaze··on Shocked to find smart thermostats raised remotely by “Smart Savers Texas” progrm
There are ACs which have a dehumidifier mode, which according to the manual had less energy consumption.
yokaze··on Show HN: fcp – A significantly faster alternative to cp(1), written in Rust
> Traditionally the reason to use threads in small-requests i/o is to get multiple outstanding requests in flight in the hardware io stack which some hardware can use to get you more IOPS throughput

I would assume that is the case here too. The threads are likely hiding the latency of the IOPS. I can't see any CPU load statistics, so it is hard to say, if it is indeed CPU bound or not.

A quick run with time shows user+sys being only slightly higher than real, so with 6 threads for my 6 cpus, it uses a single cpu. (and practically no time in user-space)

yokaze··on Linux with “memory folios”: a 7% performance boost when compiling the kernel
Counterexamples:

Running your DB with the default parameters.

Not running Linux kernel parameters depending on your workload. (+10Gbit NICs, lots of connections...)

There are reasons, why those knobs are there, as there are always trade-off, and having them automatically adjust is very hard.

But maybe that was what you're referring to.

← PreviousPage 3 of 13Next →