HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

yomritoyj

1,351 karma · joined May 20, 2013

I teach economics at Ambedkar University, New Delhi. Personal website: http://www.jyotirmoy.net
submissionscomments
yomritoyj··on Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi University admission problem
But then you are asking students to collectively act out an algorithm. Why not leave it to a machine?
yomritoyj··on Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi University admission problem
Hakyll, which is a static site generator written in Haskell http://jaspervdj.be/hakyll/
yomritoyj··on Request to econ and math people: solve the Delhi University admission problem
To know more about them, read Leijonhufvud's "Life Among the Econ" http://www.econ.ucla.edu/alleras/teaching/life_among_the_eco...
yomritoyj··on “Hello World” in assembly language on Linux
OP here. You are right. Fixed now.
yomritoyj··on Ask HN: What are specific tangible benefits of learning Haskell?
Yes to the first. For the second, it is worthwhile enough for some people and I think it is a net benefit to society. Whether it is worth your time depends on your tastes and priorities.
yomritoyj··on Ask HN: What are specific tangible benefits of learning Haskell?
To me the value of Haskell comes from its being an extreme point in the language design space: that of a pure, lazy, strictly-typed language. I think that Haskell provides a very nice syntax and GHC a very nice implementation for exploring this extreme point. The primary benefit of this exploration is that it enriches our understanding as a community regarding language design and program design. I think that is a worthwhile enough contribution.

I think that Haskell's strangeness harms it in two ways. One it puts off people because the superficial strangeness takes some getting used to. More dangerously it makes a small fraction of Haskell programmers dangerously arrogant. They feel that just because they are now familiar with this strange jargon they have become superior to the users of other languages. Depending on temperament this turns them into snobs or evangelists.

I don't think there is any concrete evidence of Haskell's superiority as a practical tool. Programs like pandoc, darcs or xmonad are great but there is no proof (and as far as I know neither have their authors claimed) that they were easier to develop than comparable programs in imperative languages (TeX, git?).

Much better is the attitude of Haskell leaders like Simon Peyton Jones who present Haskell as a ongoing research project with its set of successes and unsolved problems: http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/um/people/simonpj/papers... http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/um/people/simonpj/papers...

yomritoyj··on Is Quantum Entanglement Real?
J.S. Bell addresses this in the paper https://cds.cern.ch/record/142461/files/198009299.pdf with the following example: "Dr. Bertlmann likes to wear two socks of different colours. What colour he will have on a given foot on a given day is quite unpredictable. But when you see that the first sock is pink you can already be sure that the second sock will not be pink... " But it turns out that the quantum situation is much spookier.
yomritoyj··on Arrow's Theorem
Interestingly, the theorem is false if the number of voters is infinite http://blog.jyotirmoy.net/2013/10/arrows-impossibility-theor...
yomritoyj··on Stalin: a global optimizing compiler for Scheme
Stalin is not a surname. It is a nom de guerre that means “man of steel”.
yomritoyj··on Letter to a Young Haskell Enthusiast
You presume that reevaluation of your position is an expensive operation that we must economise on. But sometimes it is just keeping your eyes open. For this particular question, I see lots of very good and beautiful written in imperative and dynamically-typed languages. There are many problems for which the most natural program is imperative or object-oriented. So to me at least looking at the programming language world with the presumption that Haskell-like languages are always superior seems cultish indeed.
yomritoyj··on Beginner's guide to OCaml beginner's guides
I found 'Learn You a Haskell's' treatment to be very good. After it, you have have some taste for mathematics, is Moggi's paper http://www.disi.unige.it/person/MoggiE/ftp/ic91.pdf
yomritoyj··on Coder's High – The Intense Feeling of Absorption
This is very much my experience too. Binge programming can give you a false satisfaction of having done intellectual work without too great an intellectual effort. I find myself itching to write up some code precisely at those times when I am feeling frustrated that I am not working on something “deep” but when the really “deep” things seem too hard and their rewards too far away in the future.
yomritoyj··on Anti-Tesla sentiment and the death of optimism
It is not necessarily a contradiction as long as you accept the existence of two different ways of ranking outcomes: one for desirability and one for decision-making. When a cake is being shared I may want to eat the whole cake alone, but I may still offer you half the cake out of a sense of fairness. For the predictions of game theory it is the decision-making ranking and not the desirability one which enters into payoffs.

If you deny the meaningfulness of talking about different ways of ranking then of course any notion of altruism becomes self-contradictory: "He gains enjoyment by starving himself to feed the poor, that's why he does it." But in practice we distinguish between masochists and saints.

Helping others may help you survive if selfish people are ostracized by others (as seem to happen in human societies) or if a good turn today entitles you to a good turn tomorrow. But the evolutionary theory of altruism is not something I understand very well. My only point was that contrary to what the OP suggests, the formal techniques of game theory such as Nash equilibrium are agnostic with respect to nature of payoffs. And both casual observation and systematic experiments in economics show that many humans act out of a sense of fairness and expect fairness from others even when interacting with strangers.

yomritoyj··on Anti-Tesla sentiment and the death of optimism
But if you really are a selfish player, and you have somehow persuaded the other player to trust you and play "deny" then you should definitely play "confess" to maximize your payoff. With selfish players there is no way to move to ("deny","deny") in a one-shot Prisoners' Dilemma. Cultural change cannot help unless it amounts to a change in payoffs.

[The story would have been different in a coordination game with multiple Pareto-ranked equilibria where a change in beliefs can move you from a bad equilibrium to a good equilibrium.]

yomritoyj··on Anti-Tesla sentiment and the death of optimism
The author is seriously mistaken about game theory. The Nash Equilibrium requires every player to be maximizing their payoffs given what the other players are doing. But game theory itself does not say what the nature of the payoffs are: there is no problem in modelling altruistic players who attach a high payoff to outcomes which are good for everyone and low payoffs to outcomes which benefit only themselves.

The Pareto Optimal is not an outcome which is best for both, since the whole point of this concept is to avoid giving a definition of "best for both". Rather it is an outcome from which no player can be made better off without making some other player worse off. So, for example, for two greedy people sharing a cake, any division of the cake, including one which gives the entire cake to one person, is Pareto optimal.

Anyone seriously interested in understanding what game theory really says and avoiding superficial mistakes in its interpretation should read at least the first chapter of Binmore's 'Playing for Real'.

yomritoyj··on Ask HN: Good books on Information Economics?
There is no standard definition of "Information economics". If you are interested in the economics of the IT industry then apart from Varian's "Information Rules" mentioned in another comment, there is

* Oz Shy, The Economics of Network Industries.

If you are interested in research at the interface of economics and theoretical computer science you have:

* Shoham, Leyton-Brown. Multiagent Systems.

* Nisan, Roughgarden, Tardos, Vazirani. Algorithmic Game Theory.

* Cramton, Shoham, Steinberg, Smith. Combinatorial Auctions.

For the traditional economic theory of asymmetric information among economic agents:

* Bikchandani, Riley and Hirshleifer. The Analytics of Uncertainty and Information.

yomritoyj··on Why I Never Hire Brilliant Men (1924)
This story is a cheap attempt to make people with an inferiority complex feel good. There is nothing great about mediocrity. Someone who fails to deliver on their work is not brilliant, appearances to the contrary. But at the top of the world are brilliant people who have delivered, and no amount of self-congratulation for stolid mediocrity can change that.
yomritoyj··on LHC Physics Center bans Powerpoint, switches to whiteboard-only forums
Having the speaker write out things on a board also has the advantage of giving the listeners time to think through what has gone before. In my experience this leads to more interesting discussion.

I'm a teacher of economics and the only time I use slides is when I have to present a lot of data or literal text like the statements of theorems. Even in these situations I think distributing printed handouts works much better. But that involves logistics and expense.

yomritoyj··on Mathematicians are chronically lost and confused
Mathematicians are indeed lost and confused but in a very different way from beginning students. One must put in one's dues in what Terence Tao calls the "rigorous" phase before one can become productively confused in the "post-rigorous" phase. http://terrytao.wordpress.com/career-advice/there%E2%80%99s-...
yomritoyj··on Where should I start learning Assembly?
I found it very useful to read the Intel software developer's manual to get an understanding of the instruction set. If doing this for the x86 architecture seems too daunting at first, a fun alternative is to read the manual for the AVR microcontroller which powers the Arduino and then program an Arduino in assembly.
yomritoyj··on Poll: What level of math is programming roughly analogous to?
I think programming even a CRUD application is much more congnitively demanding than any math that your son is likely to be taught before university. This is because math in school is taught mostly in terms of procedures that can be blindly followed. On the other hand in writing even the simplest programs one must deal with freedom: there are many ways in which a program can be structured, and many paths its execution can follow, and you must develop your abstract thinking skills in order to see the consequences. It is only at the university level that you begin to see this kind of freedom in doing math.
yomritoyj··on Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow
I agree with the OP's point that it is mostly the easy questions which get many answers on Stack Exchange. But I don't see that as a negative. Those working in dense communities can get a lot more done because they have the option to quickly ask a knowledgeable neighbour's opinion. Assured of this support everyone gains by specializing more. The Stack Exchange sites bring the same benefits to more isolated workers.
yomritoyj··on [dead]
It is strange that the author attributes the eight-hour workday to Henry Ford's business strategy. It had been a demand raised by workers themselves from much earlier: “Eight hours labour, Eight hours recreation, Eight hours rest.” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eight-hour_day
← PreviousPage 4 of 4