HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

youarentrightjr

252 karma · joined December 7, 2025

We're probably all wrong
submissionscomments
youarentrightjr··on Sugar industry influenced researchers and blamed fat for CVD (2016)
> He's an absolute goddamn nutjob

> He is a vaccine-denier

> Anything he says has no validity

Huh?

Yeah, he's wrong about many things. But hurling epithets and constructing an argument via ad hominem isn't necessary. You can defeat his claims directly.

And FWIW, the claim that eating unprocessed "whole" foods is healthy is almost certainly true.

youarentrightjr··on Tesla’s 4680 battery supply chain collapses as partner writes down deal by 99%
> get ready to ramp up cyber cab production lines

The word on the street is this is only 2 weeks out.

Right after fulfilling the roadster orders.

And right before the Dyson sphere that will power Grok AI is deployed.

youarentrightjr··on 62 years in the making: NYC's newest water tunnel nears the finish line
> Desalination will be a West Coast thing. The East Coast has abundant fresh water.

It's not entirely accurate to say that the West Coast doesn't have enough fresh water. Oregon and Washington have a lot of rain, and many groundwater resources.

California kneecaps itself with perpetual deeded water rights and mismanagement/closure/lack of improvement to reservoirs and related infrastructure. There's a long history of this kind of stuff in the state (see the watering LA desert, the Salton Sea experiment, and many others).

youarentrightjr··on State regulators vote to keep utility profits high angering customers across CA
Not to pile on, but this is a similar vibe to people telling others to stop complaining about gas prices and just get an EV.

Some people can't afford a $38k car, heck, for some even $10k for a car is out of reach. There are people who have no choice but to buy a 20 year old ICE vehicle and pray it doesn't die. These same folks suffer due to the regressive nature of fuel tax.

youarentrightjr··on State regulators vote to keep utility profits high angering customers across CA
> The median bill is estimated to be $135 – $165/month

I have a hard time believing this; in the Bay Area, the privilege of simply having a 200A connection is $130/month.

youarentrightjr··on The Deviancy Signal: Having "Nothing to Hide" Is a Threat to Us All
> He's running for governor of California. He's apparently having trouble getting 6,000 signatures or $5000 to get on the ballot, so he's probably not a serious candidate.

The popular, well funded politicians haven't exactly served their constituents well in the privacy domain...

youarentrightjr··on UNC System President Peter Hans confirms all syllabuses will be public records
> I’ll take the bait. I’m guessing you don’t pay state tax in Kansas, so you don’t pay my salary. I’m totally down with anyone in the state reading my stuff, though.

With all the federal education grants/aid/what have you, it's hard to imagine that your institution is purely jayhawker funded.

youarentrightjr··on Tesla reports another Robotaxi crash
Sorry, what's the claim here? That electrek has a financial incentive in Tesla's failure? Or that they are reporting inaccurately?
youarentrightjr··on If AI replaces workers, should it also pay taxes?
The top 1% of earners aren't the capital owners, not even close.
youarentrightjr··on Stanford Medicine study shows mRNA-based Covid-19 vaccines can cause myocarditis
> The lead "researcher" on that paper is a climate change denier who also claims covid didn't exist. He also used racial slurs against a former colleague.

I invite you to read another important Wikipedia article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poisoning_the_well

No doubt Denis Rancourt holds false and reprehensible beliefs. But you can defeat his claims without attacking his person.

youarentrightjr··on Stanford Medicine study shows mRNA-based Covid-19 vaccines can cause myocarditis
> There are countless things that are fundamental to day to day life that can be abused but are vital in their non-abusive form.

Great. Waiting for your argument on why this is one of them.

> If you are making a claim based on information you know to be incorrect, this is a known falsehood. This isn't anti-science, we're not talking about people making arguments against the scientific consensus in good-faith with some framework behind their reasoning.

I'm curious, how did you come to know that everyone who is asking questions not in line with the consensus belief is a bad faith operator? And what makes you able to assess the framework behind their questions?

> Trying to frame this discussion as being a matter of people performing science and not people taking a politically or financially motivated stance (or people that have been conned by people that did that) is also fundamentally dishonest.

This is exactly the problem. You're equating the small minority of folks who are using their speech to defraud with the remainder of the "dissent group" (for lack of a better term) who is trying to get to the truth. Then, by claiming the existence of the minority's speech is incredibly dangerous, attempt to ban anything not in line with the orthodoxy.

I'm not defending people using their speech to profit politically or financially. I'm saying the benefit of getting rid of that speech is not worth the collateral damage that would inflict.

How did the folks that questioned the early "masks aren't effective" claim stand to profit? Or the claim that the virus definitely 100% had zoonotic origin? Maybe you believe they were heavily invested in mask manufacturing companies and were imminently about to launch a political campaign on a Sinophobic platform?

> Free speech isn't absolute, and private companies are allowed to moderate the speech that happens on their property.

There's a lot to unpack here, and I'm not sure how much you've gone into the details of what you're saying, but: - "free speech is not absolute" is not normative, but descriptive (not really relevant to our discussion) - "private companies are allowed to moderate the speech that happens on their property" Wrong. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pruneyard_Shopping_Center_v._R.... Whether this applies to social media is currently being tested in our court system. - SCOTUS saying "not much came of this" doesn't mean nobody was wronged, or that much couldn't have come of it. Also, doesn't this (govt intervention in speech) directly contradict your claim that it was just private companies acting in their own domain?

> This isn't a societal priest class.

You're literally advocating for a priest class, who is blessed to discuss "science", because they are doing it in the way that you interpret as "good faithed" and have the right "framework" behind their discourse. Which is exactly what qualified the religious leaders of old times.

I'm incredibly grateful to not live in a time where only certain people could speak on particular topics. I wish more people were.

youarentrightjr··on Stanford Medicine study shows mRNA-based Covid-19 vaccines can cause myocarditis
Don't take this the wrong way, but the run on sentences are quite hard to parse.

> That’s a vague hypothetical

Not at all. I'm simply asking whether you can see how speech restrictions can be abused. Nothing vague here.

> I saw a number examples of people asking questions which were obviously based on known falsehoods or presupposed answers

This is an anti-scientific perspective. There is no such thing as "known falsehoods". There is only "current best understanding", which is the thing that most aligns with observations of reality.

Questioning existing axioms or intermediate conclusions is a great technique to advance understanding of reality. If everyone simply referred back to the previous "foregone conclusions", we'd still be trying to discover fire.

> it wasn’t surprising that they encountered forum policies for acting in bad faith. I saw many people acting in good faith who had no negative consequences for exploring questions like this, too, so it’s really doesn’t seem like there was a problem here and the people who lied about why they suffered consequences only had their speech suppressed to the extent that they had to go somewhere else so the consequences were minimal.

The problem here is the gatekeeping of discussion. Humanity has spent thousands of years trying to escape the power of the societal priest class, and we are in a better place than ever.

Yes, people are going to say wrong things, and mislead other people. But the cost to suppress this speech is far, far more detrimental than letting it be.

youarentrightjr··on Stanford Medicine study shows mRNA-based Covid-19 vaccines can cause myocarditis
> the people who engaged in it scientifically had nothing to fear

Similar to the question of criminalizing "hate speech" - who gets to decide whether an engagement reaches the scientific threshold?

Is it not obvious how policies like this can be weaponized to quell valid dissent?

youarentrightjr··on Stanford Medicine study shows mRNA-based Covid-19 vaccines can cause myocarditis
> Instead you had political figures, “experts” and tech sites suppress any and all discussion.

What's ironic here is the other responses - vehemently defending this authoritarian thought control; while for the last two weeks, we get daily posts reaching the HN front page criticizing EU chat control/age verification/VPN ban/etc.

It's true what they say - "you don't oppose the boot, you just want to be the one wearing it".

youarentrightjr··on EFF launches Age Verification Hub
You're conflating protecting children with "protect the children!".

Required reading: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Horsemen_of_the_Infocalyp...

youarentrightjr··on 30 Year Anniversary of WarCraft II: Tides of Darkness
Factorio is a clear exception here, not at all representative of the average experience.
youarentrightjr··on Dollar-stores overcharge customers while promising low prices
Man, it's horrible people have such an emotional connection to art and businesses that keep their pets alive. If only we could transform these into an asset that extracted wealth, now that would be great for society! Think of all the externalities!
youarentrightjr··on Dollar-stores overcharge customers while promising low prices
You're operating insincerely by attacking low quality interpretations of what I'm saying, among other problems. For example:

> You said "there is a legal requirement for directors of public companies to act in the financial interests of all shareholders." That is wrong. It's doubly wrong in the context of public versus private companies, given it applies to all business corporations.

Wouldn't that mean my statement is incomplete, not "doubly wrong", if it applies to all businesses, not just public ones?

Similarly, cherry picking sources that support narrow scenarios tangential to the discussion (Revlon) is not sincere.

By this point it's clear your religious grasp on the distinction between public and private companies will not be shaken. I'll continue living in reality, where in fact directors of private companies do act against the interests of the company itself (and in practice are still in accordance with the law), paying themselves off and leaving an insolvent heap. I'm honestly shocked regarding your insistence that public and private companies are the same in this matter; I can only assume that you already have, or stand to, gain from such a private endeavor, and this is causing a cognitive dissonance that is at fault for the vomit you've spewed above. Good day.

youarentrightjr··on Dollar-stores overcharge customers while promising low prices
> All that means is that controlling shareholders can't use the company as a piggy bank and raid it to fund their other ventures

Yes, you're getting it now.

> It doesn't mean the business has to be "sustainable" or whatever. In fact, it's perfectly legal for the board to sell to a "vulture" PE firm that will sell the business off for parts, as long as the sale price is good enough.

As discussed elsewhere in this thread - the sale itself is required to maximally benefit the shareholders.

youarentrightjr··on Dollar-stores overcharge customers while promising low prices
> Where are you getting this from?

I seriously doubt you're operating sincerely in this thread, given your ability to cite Revlon. But on the off chance, start here:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodge_v._Ford_Motor_Co.

> And nothing about public companies says they can’t be structured in a way that sometimes undermines some shareholders.

See above.

youarentrightjr··on Dollar-stores overcharge customers while promising low prices
Why bring up Revlon duties when as you say, their relevance is only during company acquisition or restructuring?

It's well established over hundreds of years of case law that directors of public companies have to act in good faith to benefit the company (and therefore, the shareholders).

Weird cherry pick.

youarentrightjr··on Dollar-stores overcharge customers while promising low prices
Zing! Gotem! Reddit moment xD
youarentrightjr··on Dollar-stores overcharge customers while promising low prices
> despite your best efforts

Citation needed.

youarentrightjr··on Dollar-stores overcharge customers while promising low prices
I see these private equity takes on HN frequently and am really baffled by the ignorance. There's a very clear difference between a public and private company - the fiduciary duty to shareholders.

There is a legal requirement for directors of public companies to act in the financial interests of all shareholders. In practice, and according to precedent, this means long term viability of the company, in other words, a sustained profitable business.

There is no such requirement for a private company. In practice (esp. recent history), this means private equity firms acquire successful businesses to "mine them" of their wealth - capitalizing their assets for personal gain, and leaving nothing left.

The question for public companies isn't how many retail vs institutional investors they have, it's whether an investor can make a claim about a breach of fiduciary duty. It's patently false to say that the institutional investors (who yes, do have more sway) aren't interested in the company acting in their financial interests.

← PreviousPage 4 of 4